{ "stage": "after", "recorded_at": "2026-10-13T12:52:54.446Z", "node": "v24.20.0", "methodology": { "requests": "real loopback HTTP; instrumented API process in measured backend image", "sql": "pg.Client.query calls; transaction control counted separately", "concurrency": 16, "duration_seconds": 10, "warmup_seconds": 3, "repetitions": 3, "seed_messages": 10000, "cold_burst_requests": 32, "writes_per_repeat": 512, "resources": "process CPU/RSS includes HTTP generator and instrumentation; not container CPU", "limitations": "closed loop, client and API share process/CPU; other Docker workloads share host resources; no capacity/SLA claim; fixtures bypass password KDF", "comparison": { "modes": [ "redis", "no-redis" ], "no_redis": "API started without CACHE_URL; all application Redis caches disabled", "epochs": "PostgreSQL epochs and atomic CTE writes retained in both modes", "order": "redis first in repeats 1/3, no-redis first in repeat 2", "processes": "both API instances and HTTP generator share one measured Node process" } }, "dist_sha256": { "Chat/chat.service.js": "f0f8b0cd357dcbb2ba6f401e30dadfcf19ab0deb7c1a812b306126d0478289e2", "cache/cache.service.js": "ec7c09ef55f9054176ace8c62a3690df6e717b54c36db9ef66b91bc34a761693" }, "dependencies": { "@nestjs/core": "package metadata not exported", "@prisma/adapter-pg": "package metadata not exported", "pg": "8.23.1", "ioredis": "6.0.0", "fastify": "5.12.1" }, "samples": [ { "workload": "cold-history-burst:redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 1.837, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 17.42, "latency_ms": { "mean": 1530.045, "p50": 1546.818, "p95": 1755.189, "p99": 1770.661 }, "sql_queries": 71, "sql_per_request": 2.2188, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 5, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 2 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 86.19, "peak_process_rss_mib": 319.89 }, { "workload": "warm-history:redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.873, "successes": 191, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 17.566, "latency_ms": { "mean": 890.11, "p50": 663.435, "p95": 2777.896, "p99": 2907.685 }, "sql_queries": 414, "sql_per_request": 2.1675, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 191, "SELECT:chat_members": 191, "SELECT:messages": 14, "SELECT:users": 18 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 66.76, "peak_process_rss_mib": 315.13 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 17.874, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 28.645, "latency_ms": { "mean": 555.497, "p50": 399.725, "p95": 1666.381, "p99": 2243.938 }, "sql_queries": 1080, "sql_per_request": 2.1094, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "WITH:messages": 512, "SELECT:users": 56 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 81.97, "peak_process_rss_mib": 336.75 }, { "workload": "cold-history-burst:no-redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 0.841, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 38.059, "latency_ms": { "mean": 763.242, "p50": 770.663, "p95": 829.822, "p99": 830.022 }, "sql_queries": 128, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 32, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 32 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 91.64, "peak_process_rss_mib": 337 }, { "workload": "warm-history:no-redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.345, "successes": 381, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 36.828, "latency_ms": { "mean": 430.415, "p50": 421.069, "p95": 734.11, "p99": 820.689 }, "sql_queries": 1524, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 381, "SELECT:users": 381, "SELECT:chat_members": 381, "SELECT:messages": 381 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 85.89, "peak_process_rss_mib": 337.75 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:no-redis", "repeat": 1, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 4.754, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 107.691, "latency_ms": { "mean": 147.905, "p50": 100.917, "p95": 466.346, "p99": 610.975 }, "sql_queries": 1536, "sql_per_request": 3, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "SELECT:users": 512, "WITH:messages": 512 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 128.47, "peak_process_rss_mib": 338.37 }, { "workload": "cold-history-burst:no-redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 0.286, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 112.082, "latency_ms": { "mean": 205.996, "p50": 195.439, "p95": 280.506, "p99": 281.494 }, "sql_queries": 128, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 32, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 32 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 90.64, "peak_process_rss_mib": 338.5 }, { "workload": "warm-history:no-redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.489, "successes": 393, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 37.468, "latency_ms": { "mean": 425.185, "p50": 392.661, "p95": 791.784, "p99": 958.484 }, "sql_queries": 1572, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 393, "SELECT:users": 393, "SELECT:chat_members": 393, "SELECT:messages": 393 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 89.12, "peak_process_rss_mib": 338.5 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:no-redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 5.905, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 86.709, "latency_ms": { "mean": 182.799, "p50": 137.282, "p95": 388.273, "p99": 791.35 }, "sql_queries": 1536, "sql_per_request": 3, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "SELECT:users": 512, "WITH:messages": 512 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 82.53, "peak_process_rss_mib": 338.75 }, { "workload": "cold-history-burst:redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 1.029, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 31.09, "latency_ms": { "mean": 918.771, "p50": 972.749, "p95": 1025.929, "p99": 1026.358 }, "sql_queries": 92, "sql_per_request": 2.875, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 5, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 23 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 61.08, "peak_process_rss_mib": 338.75 }, { "workload": "warm-history:redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.105, "successes": 1978, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 195.742, "latency_ms": { "mean": 81.312, "p50": 65.517, "p95": 165.58, "p99": 255.442 }, "sql_queries": 3956, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 1978, "SELECT:chat_members": 1978 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 117.29, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.5 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:redis", "repeat": 2, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 2.802, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 182.731, "latency_ms": { "mean": 86.914, "p50": 72.205, "p95": 174.511, "p99": 249.039 }, "sql_queries": 1024, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "WITH:messages": 512 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 116.33, "peak_process_rss_mib": 339.81 }, { "workload": "cold-history-burst:redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 0.145, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 220.143, "latency_ms": { "mean": 135.024, "p50": 137.463, "p95": 143.455, "p99": 143.876 }, "sql_queries": 86, "sql_per_request": 2.6875, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 2, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 20 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 167.65, "peak_process_rss_mib": 339.81 }, { "workload": "warm-history:redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.028, "successes": 1620, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 161.555, "latency_ms": { "mean": 98.91, "p50": 76.732, "p95": 213.951, "p99": 404.794 }, "sql_queries": 3240, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 1620, "SELECT:chat_members": 1620 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 102.71, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.31 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 3.011, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 170.063, "latency_ms": { "mean": 93.676, "p50": 67.99, "p95": 224.796, "p99": 264.354 }, "sql_queries": 1024, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "WITH:messages": 512 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 99.05, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.43 }, { "workload": "cold-history-burst:no-redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 32, "elapsed_seconds": 0.215, "successes": 32, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 149.175, "latency_ms": { "mean": 204.462, "p50": 206.7, "p95": 213.436, "p99": 213.79 }, "sql_queries": 128, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 32, "SELECT:users": 32, "SELECT:chat_members": 32, "SELECT:messages": 32 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 121.65, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.43 }, { "workload": "warm-history:no-redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 10.072, "successes": 937, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 93.032, "latency_ms": { "mean": 171.384, "p50": 154.642, "p95": 341.443, "p99": 697.848 }, "sql_queries": 3748, "sql_per_request": 4, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 937, "SELECT:users": 937, "SELECT:chat_members": 937, "SELECT:messages": 937 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 99.34, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.93 }, { "workload": "writes-single-chat:no-redis", "repeat": 3, "concurrency": 16, "elapsed_seconds": 6.298, "successes": 512, "errors": 0, "error_ratio": 0, "successful_rps": 81.295, "latency_ms": { "mean": 191.411, "p50": 155.363, "p95": 410.542, "p99": 517.121 }, "sql_queries": 1536, "sql_per_request": 3, "sql_calls": { "SELECT:sessions": 512, "SELECT:users": 512, "WITH:messages": 512 }, "process_cpu_percent_one_core": 100.74, "peak_process_rss_mib": 340.93 } ], "correctness": { "read_after_write": { "redis:1": true, "no-redis:1": true, "no-redis:2": true, "redis:2": true, "redis:3": true, "no-redis:3": true } }, "completed": true, "cleanup": "only experiment chats/user/cache prefix removed" }