{ "recorded_at": "2026-10-13T14:18:08.573Z", "methodology": { "concurrency": 32, "duration_seconds": 60, "warmup_seconds": 10, "repetitions": 3, "seed_messages": 100000, "writes_per_repeat": 4096, "order": [ [ "baseline", "profile-join", "access-join", "striped" ], [ "striped", "access-join", "profile-join", "baseline" ], [ "profile-join", "striped", "baseline", "access-join" ] ], "requests": "Real loopback HTTP; shared read fixtures, separate write chats and cache prefixes", "resources": "Four idle/active API instances and HTTP generator share one Node process; only one workload active at a time", "sql": "pg.Client.query; transaction-control commands excluded; no changes to database pool size" }, "variants": [ { "name": "baseline", "modules": { "Auth/auth.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "86599b6e89cd66483cb10aff0d85cc29fe092ab24bbb849960079dcae347b8bf", "js_sha256": "70e4c149faff62a38f3009816994c349096a8300495ecd57128a07af2acfb78f" }, "User/user.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "de158e39c114c610cc7ea6c850108c8dd69c9bc3d643bac94557d272621f3cfb", "js_sha256": "e71c703979ae29963546f88602d4c98735562163749af06c966474e1670e4b7c" }, "User/user.guard.ts": { "source_sha256": "b84d95633fbd89b4fdbc505c51dd64e657611651b757bed1aea8eee3f0eac3d9", "js_sha256": "16bc70f6d4df0809637b16f569dda973085128775f29c29d6154aecf9a45be52" }, "Chat/chat.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "11b6b6d361d5599667318540b2c83a1b8e397db6d4d3665bbfa526e0b349d430", "js_sha256": "42cc729f6f8f6da1a4b6b66746d7ea8299c4a26cfc29f6cfcb436d865107dfad" }, "Chat/chat.controller.ts": { "source_sha256": "700becb64112538a6551c5775ccc09ff9d750755dcffe6ec916782afed1dae11", "js_sha256": "32ebfcf009fce603c8637da701e33756868a3a4b1dda3e93cf7007b3a8b14ec7" } }, "striped": false }, { "name": "profile-join", "modules": { "Auth/auth.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "63e6ad3117bf8adda51bab735ee7b975179e68a6af060aafe63416a8c9b90107", "js_sha256": "5da0f49def86501c34c2f8d02dbd86dde37b9b7d1d98b57df3e334fc557dcffd" }, "User/user.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "0737e88c408510bc17ec0597c3812be855c03499dfc2ad5ba6a4b1e85bb1c5e7", "js_sha256": "e71c703979ae29963546f88602d4c98735562163749af06c966474e1670e4b7c" }, "User/user.guard.ts": { "source_sha256": "b84d95633fbd89b4fdbc505c51dd64e657611651b757bed1aea8eee3f0eac3d9", "js_sha256": "16bc70f6d4df0809637b16f569dda973085128775f29c29d6154aecf9a45be52" }, "Chat/chat.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "11b6b6d361d5599667318540b2c83a1b8e397db6d4d3665bbfa526e0b349d430", "js_sha256": "42cc729f6f8f6da1a4b6b66746d7ea8299c4a26cfc29f6cfcb436d865107dfad" }, "Chat/chat.controller.ts": { "source_sha256": "700becb64112538a6551c5775ccc09ff9d750755dcffe6ec916782afed1dae11", "js_sha256": "32ebfcf009fce603c8637da701e33756868a3a4b1dda3e93cf7007b3a8b14ec7" } }, "striped": false }, { "name": "access-join", "modules": { "Auth/auth.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "c577b5c9d8ad52eae065359f1614de2d74b1bc7588ac2676d513f4aba2fc9c6f", "js_sha256": "8fc180339017f373771a1abeed9f6dc978ee8a1c051df9f6fb69f054ca45bf0f" }, "User/user.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "0737e88c408510bc17ec0597c3812be855c03499dfc2ad5ba6a4b1e85bb1c5e7", "js_sha256": "e71c703979ae29963546f88602d4c98735562163749af06c966474e1670e4b7c" }, "User/user.guard.ts": { "source_sha256": "20b05a0e5272a4ee1ccbddef83494e62621ffb0236e56a15c17e7f8f0083f6d7", "js_sha256": "a078cc3065d6f87ee441f2bc0ff43af25094e66db4bd661d74cf3cd1c501fc2a" }, "Chat/chat.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "11a44d19390d1e605fb72fabbc6111a25917e292a1aab4132e26390887128219", "js_sha256": "3759d025e679f2b1694e486c460361a96979f8b67a1a8e811e589c722e8fb55f" }, "Chat/chat.controller.ts": { "source_sha256": "1e3b1e0a5abc053625c5b1a6dc14f5b5b3e87676b1af0bdd73e78ad95d1eb325", "js_sha256": "6ac78b848b82f03a4134a9e19e2b802fef59d06b938f2e747fa361c2293fd5c7" } }, "striped": false }, { "name": "striped", "modules": { "Auth/auth.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "f99168697aa79d7c5c1fd9f35083448c97f68a0bfecdbfbca49fa279445d79b1", "js_sha256": "73fe21965e7f1fc421b501c5760ee8dfc4ca7edb606477db1682dd04a9c885d1" }, "User/user.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "0737e88c408510bc17ec0597c3812be855c03499dfc2ad5ba6a4b1e85bb1c5e7", "js_sha256": "e71c703979ae29963546f88602d4c98735562163749af06c966474e1670e4b7c" }, "User/user.guard.ts": { "source_sha256": "20b05a0e5272a4ee1ccbddef83494e62621ffb0236e56a15c17e7f8f0083f6d7", "js_sha256": "a078cc3065d6f87ee441f2bc0ff43af25094e66db4bd661d74cf3cd1c501fc2a" }, "Chat/chat.service.ts": { "source_sha256": "b43a57b6e6e17a3133f2061d5660f8e36b62e049975b0d6d800517f99d942699", "js_sha256": "208e1298e119284bb587ba80b8ef650e7c8fd9031a17ff5079f50732902a62c7" }, "Chat/chat.controller.ts": { "source_sha256": "1e3b1e0a5abc053625c5b1a6dc14f5b5b3e87676b1af0bdd73e78ad95d1eb325", "js_sha256": "6ac78b848b82f03a4134a9e19e2b802fef59d06b938f2e747fa361c2293fd5c7" } }, "striped": true } ], "samples": [ { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 1, "successes": 11300, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.101, "rps": 188.018, "mean_latency_ms": 170.03, "p95_ms": 437.91, "sql_queries": 22651, "sql_per_request": 2.0045, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 22651 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 110.44, "rss_mib": 572.86 }, { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 1, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 80.182, "rps": 51.084, "mean_latency_ms": 625.658, "p95_ms": 1960.791, "sql_queries": 8470, "sql_per_request": 2.0679, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4374, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 81.41, "rss_mib": 567.86 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 1, "successes": 8162, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.142, "rps": 135.713, "mean_latency_ms": 235.249, "p95_ms": 646.713, "sql_queries": 16463, "sql_per_request": 2.017, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 16463 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 90.2, "rss_mib": 571.11 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 1, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 35.83, "rps": 114.318, "mean_latency_ms": 279.681, "p95_ms": 723.32, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 94.92, "rss_mib": 571.23 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 1, "successes": 17153, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.704, "rps": 282.567, "mean_latency_ms": 113.157, "p95_ms": 243.983, "sql_queries": 17206, "sql_per_request": 1.0031, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 17206 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 106.31, "rss_mib": 576.19 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 1, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 52.243, "rps": 78.403, "mean_latency_ms": 407.523, "p95_ms": 987.832, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 80.45, "rss_mib": 576.19 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 1, "successes": 15925, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.169, "rps": 264.672, "mean_latency_ms": 120.746, "p95_ms": 268.879, "sql_queries": 15977, "sql_per_request": 1.0033, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 15977 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 105.46, "rss_mib": 576.48 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 1, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 22.406, "rps": 182.806, "mean_latency_ms": 174.946, "p95_ms": 414.242, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 103.49, "rss_mib": 576.33 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 2, "successes": 14354, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.252, "rps": 238.233, "mean_latency_ms": 134.067, "p95_ms": 305.055, "sql_queries": 14406, "sql_per_request": 1.0036, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 14406 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 103.01, "rss_mib": 576.27 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 2, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 25.494, "rps": 160.668, "mean_latency_ms": 198.958, "p95_ms": 427.198, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 99.91, "rss_mib": 576.27 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 2, "successes": 16307, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.093, "rps": 271.362, "mean_latency_ms": 117.835, "p95_ms": 277.764, "sql_queries": 16339, "sql_per_request": 1.002, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 16339 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 103.54, "rss_mib": 576.77 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 2, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 22.63, "rps": 181, "mean_latency_ms": 176.596, "p95_ms": 359.748, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 102.17, "rss_mib": 576.38 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 2, "successes": 12604, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.091, "rps": 209.749, "mean_latency_ms": 152.428, "p95_ms": 398.121, "sql_queries": 25278, "sql_per_request": 2.0056, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 25278 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 104.2, "rss_mib": 576.5 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 2, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 29.777, "rps": 137.555, "mean_latency_ms": 232.438, "p95_ms": 530.581, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 96.07, "rss_mib": 576.5 }, { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 2, "successes": 14650, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.062, "rps": 243.914, "mean_latency_ms": 131.102, "p95_ms": 298.279, "sql_queries": 29335, "sql_per_request": 2.0024, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 29335 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 106, "rss_mib": 576.5 }, { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 2, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 30.574, "rps": 133.969, "mean_latency_ms": 238.29, "p95_ms": 521.311, "sql_queries": 8210, "sql_per_request": 2.0044, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4114, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 91.63, "rss_mib": 576.63 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 3, "successes": 9990, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.13, "rps": 166.141, "mean_latency_ms": 192.396, "p95_ms": 503.539, "sql_queries": 20093, "sql_per_request": 2.0113, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 20093 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 92.44, "rss_mib": 576.6 }, { "variant": "profile-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 3, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 21.25, "rps": 192.755, "mean_latency_ms": 165.859, "p95_ms": 318.167, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 107.92, "rss_mib": 576.6 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 3, "successes": 13516, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.141, "rps": 224.738, "mean_latency_ms": 142.252, "p95_ms": 365.937, "sql_queries": 13588, "sql_per_request": 1.0053, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 13588 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 98.43, "rss_mib": 576.85 }, { "variant": "striped", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 3, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 26.545, "rps": 154.303, "mean_latency_ms": 205.891, "p95_ms": 585.601, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 102.74, "rss_mib": 576.66 }, { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 3, "successes": 14799, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.082, "rps": 246.313, "mean_latency_ms": 129.797, "p95_ms": 278.595, "sql_queries": 29663, "sql_per_request": 2.0044, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 29663 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 105.5, "rss_mib": 577.03 }, { "variant": "baseline", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 3, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 24.616, "rps": 166.398, "mean_latency_ms": 192.054, "p95_ms": 475.632, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 94.84, "rss_mib": 576.8 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "warm-history", "repeat": 3, "successes": 11202, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 60.069, "rps": 186.487, "mean_latency_ms": 171.531, "p95_ms": 473.5, "sql_queries": 11368, "sql_per_request": 1.0148, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 11368 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 89.43, "rss_mib": 577.13 }, { "variant": "access-join", "workload": "writes-single-chat", "repeat": 3, "successes": 4096, "errors": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 29.46, "rps": 139.035, "mean_latency_ms": 229.808, "p95_ms": 525.113, "sql_queries": 8192, "sql_per_request": 2, "sql_calls": { "SELECT": 4096, "WITH": 4096 }, "cpu_percent_one_core": 94.07, "rss_mib": 577.13 } ], "correctness": { "baseline": { "access_statuses": true, "redis_outage_and_retained_keys": true, "rollback": true, "delayed_old_fill": true, "empty_cache": true }, "profile-join": { "access_statuses": true, "redis_outage_and_retained_keys": true, "rollback": true, "delayed_old_fill": true, "empty_cache": true }, "access-join": { "access_statuses": true, "redis_outage_and_retained_keys": true, "rollback": true, "delayed_old_fill": true, "empty_cache": true }, "striped": { "access_statuses": true, "redis_outage_and_retained_keys": true, "rollback": true, "delayed_old_fill": true, "empty_cache": true } }, "completed": true }