Files
mtusi2026lab5/evidence/uploads/baseline/summary.md
T
ricoromaandClaude Opus 5.5 acc6584dd3 docs: record async-attachments evidence and report
Evidence taken on ff1a83b. The report covers level 3; levels 4 and 5 are
closed by the following changes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-31 08:30:46 +03:00

13 KiB
Raw Blame History

Профиль загрузок: метка baseline

  • Статус: complete
  • Commit: ff1a83b
  • Профиль uploads: варианты «до», «без лимита», «с лимитом» (образ «до» — commit 04f8592); клиенты 1, 10, 20, 40; повторов 3; окно 20 с после 3 с разгона
  • Тела: 1MiB — 1048276 байт (1024 × 341), SHA-256 d65ca4573a4064ee…, 10MiB — 10479107 байт (1024 × 3409), SHA-256 a8f0ef17afaf6046…
  • Реплика 1 CPU / 512m без swap, буфер приёма 4096 131072 524288; S3 1 CPU / 512m; брокер 1 CPU / 512m; LB 1 CPU / 256m. Worker не запущен: задания ждут в очереди, на прогон — новый volume брокера
  • Код успеха: «до» — 201, «без лимита» — 202, «с лимитом» — 202 (столбец s201 runs.csv считает код варианта, его называет success_code)
  • Пик — memory.peak cgroup, сброшенный через свой дескриптор перед нагрузкой (peak_source = reset); без сброса — наибольшая выборка раз в 0.2 с (пометка peak_sampled). Память до окна — первая выборка. Ответы по кодам — за весь прогон, загрузок/с и перцентили — по загрузкам окна. Значения — медиана (min–max) повторов
  • Посторонние контейнеры в VM во время замера: нет

Ячейки

«Пик старта» — memory.peak реплики до сброса (с её запуска: фиктивный хэш пароля, разогревающая загрузка); пик окна его не включает.

Вариант Тело C Пик старта, MiB До окна, MiB Пик, MiB anon, MiB sock, MiB OOM Успех 429 5xx ошибка соединения Загрузок/с p50, мс p95, мс S3 пик, MiB S3 anon, MiB LB пик, MiB Пометки
до 10MiB 1 153.4 (153.1–153.5) 106.0 (105.5–106.1) 121.2 (121.1–121.4) 111.4 (111.2–111.5) 4.1 (4.1–4.1) 0/3 262 (248–262) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 11.40 (10.85–11.45) 82 (81–82) 113 (107–130) 515.7 (513.8–518.1) 240.2 (235.3–249.7) 30.8 (30.4–32.6) —
до 10MiB 10 153.2 (153.1–153.5) 105.5 (105.3–105.9) 169.8 (169.4–169.9) 144.1 (143.6–144.2) 14.7 (11.7–17.0) 0/3 241 (238–251) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.30 (10.05–10.60) 908 (906–925) 1352 (1290–1369) 518.7 (517.4–519.4) 280.4 (277.1–281.8) 35.2 (34.5–36.9) —
до 10MiB 20 153.2 (153.2–153.2) 105.7 (105.6–106.0) 178.0 (177.8–178.4) 147.3 (147.2–147.8) 19.8 (16.3–22.9) 0/3 268 (263–269) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.90 (10.75–11.00) 1821 (1788–1861) 2164 (2154–2284) 517.9 (516.8–522.5) 254.3 (253.5–268.4) 41.8 (41.3–42.5) —
до 10MiB 40 153.4 (153.4–153.4) 105.4 (105.3–105.5) 181.0 (181.0–181.2) 151.4 (150.7–151.8) 16.2 (15.9–19.8) 0/3 266 (254–278) 457 (455–460) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.75 (10.45–11.45) 1820 (1728–1846) 2179 (2020–2277) 523.7 (517.7–526.6) 257.5 (247.3–269.4) 53.6 (52.8–57.0) —
до 1MiB 1 153.2 (153.2–153.3) 105.7 (105.5–105.8) 109.5 (109.3–109.6) 101.2 (101.2–101.6) 0.9 (0.6–0.9) 0/3 1565 (1564–1584) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 67.90 (67.60–68.75) 14 (14–14) 16 (16–16) 513.0 (513.0–513.0) 188.3 (185.2–195.2) 31.3 (31.1–33.0) —
до 1MiB 10 153.1 (153.0–153.2) 105.8 (105.7–105.9) 120.4 (120.0–120.5) 107.0 (107.0–107.0) 5.1 (4.9–5.3) 0/3 2883 (2836–2903) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 125.30 (122.95–127.30) 77 (76–77) 107 (104–108) 514.7 (514.7–514.9) 231.7 (223.0–234.9) 35.9 (35.4–36.7) —
до 1MiB 20 153.4 (153.0–153.8) 105.6 (105.5–105.7) 127.6 (127.4–128.6) 109.9 (109.8–110.4) 9.2 (8.9–9.7) 0/3 2883 (2869–2921) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 125.15 (124.70–127.55) 158 (155–158) 188 (184–192) 514.8 (514.7–514.9) 225.2 (219.4–239.2) 39.4 (38.8–41.1) —
до 1MiB 40 153.2 (153.0–153.2) 105.1 (105.1–105.5) 132.9 (131.6–133.0) 114.5 (114.1–115.0) 9.7 (9.5–10.0) 0/3 2838 (2785–2915) 460 (460–460) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 123.70 (120.65–126.45) 159 (156–162) 197 (189–200) 514.7 (514.6–515.3) 211.9 (195.5–226.1) 53.1 (53.1–53.2) —
без лимита 10MiB 1 156.4 (156.0–156.4) 108.8 (108.7–108.8) 123.9 (123.9–124.1) 113.9 (113.8–114.2) 4.1 (4.1–4.1) 0/3 256 (253–261) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 11.05 (10.95–11.25) 86 (83–87) 108 (107–114) 517.4 (515.0–518.2) 246.8 (239.2–253.1) 31.0 (30.8–31.2) —
без лимита 10MiB 10 156.4 (156.3–156.5) 108.4 (108.3–108.9) 227.6 (226.9–229.1) 206.2 (206.2–206.5) 14.5 (13.1–14.5) 0/3 211 (205–213) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 9.00 (8.80–9.00) 1094 (1092–1116) 1480 (1471–1491) 517.0 (515.6–517.1) 340.9 (333.8–355.6) 32.1 (30.8–32.1) —
без лимита 10MiB 20 156.1 (156.0–156.3) 108.2 (108.0–108.4) 331.0 (329.8–333.0) 308.4 (308.4–309.3) 17.1 (15.8–22.2) 0/3 218 (215–230) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 8.90 (8.80–9.50) 2210 (2090–2214) 2676 (2512–2721) 516.2 (514.8–519.6) 337.6 (333.2–345.7) 38.1 (37.6–38.4) —
без лимита 10MiB 40 156.1 (156.0–156.2) 108.8 (108.7–108.9) 510.5 (502.1–511.9) 503.8 (486.8–504.7) 15.2 (9.4–15.5) 3/3 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 762 (727–844) 40 (0–40) 0.00 (0.00–0.00) — — 182.1 (170.3–206.7) 156.3 (149.0–185.6) 53.4 (51.0–58.8) oom peak_sampled
без лимита 1MiB 1 156.1 (156.0–156.4) 108.5 (108.0–108.9) 112.5 (112.5–112.6) 104.2 (104.0–104.2) 0.9 (0.9–0.9) 0/3 1400 (1384–1401) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 60.45 (59.95–60.65) 16 (16–16) 19 (18–19) 513.0 (513.0–513.0) 215.6 (214.7–219.1) 31.5 (31.2–32.9) —
без лимита 1MiB 10 156.2 (155.9–156.3) 108.5 (108.2–109.1) 127.9 (127.6–128.0) 115.2 (114.9–115.3) 3.5 (2.8–3.8) 0/3 2888 (2843–2907) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 125.85 (124.20–126.85) 79 (79–80) 105 (105–106) 517.5 (516.9–518.1) 224.4 (224.3–230.9) 33.1 (32.8–33.2) —
без лимита 1MiB 20 156.3 (156.3–156.6) 108.6 (108.1–108.8) 137.5 (135.9–140.8) 126.5 (124.9–127.7) 5.8 (4.1–6.0) 0/3 2820 (2781–2999) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 121.75 (120.95–132.75) 161 (149–164) 199 (196–206) 517.6 (514.7–518.2) 226.4 (216.4–234.6) 37.8 (37.3–38.2) —
без лимита 1MiB 40 156.2 (156.1–156.6) 108.6 (108.3–108.9) 163.6 (163.0–165.6) 151.6 (151.0–151.8) 6.6 (5.8–9.4) 0/3 3075 (3075–3090) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 133.35 (133.25–134.85) 299 (299–299) 366 (353–367) 520.2 (520.2–521.0) 229.6 (226.6–233.6) 53.1 (52.7–53.6) —
с лимитом 10MiB 1 156.1 (156.1–156.3) 108.3 (108.2–109.3) 124.1 (124.1–124.2) 113.9 (113.9–114.2) 4.1 (4.1–4.1) 0/3 260 (259–261) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 11.30 (11.20–11.30) 83 (83–84) 108 (104–116) 514.8 (514.7–516.1) 239.4 (237.9–247.5) 31.5 (30.9–33.2) —
с лимитом 10MiB 10 156.3 (156.3–156.4) 108.4 (108.2–108.8) 172.9 (172.5–173.1) 147.0 (146.5–147.0) 15.8 (12.3–19.1) 0/3 252 (249–260) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.50 (10.45–11.00) 900 (852–902) 1253 (1192–1283) 518.7 (518.1–520.8) 263.6 (253.4–269.4) 38.1 (35.1–38.4) —
с лимитом 10MiB 20 156.2 (156.0–156.3) 108.8 (108.7–108.9) 180.1 (179.6–180.8) 150.1 (149.7–150.1) 21.6 (20.3–21.8) 0/3 267 (259–267) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.75 (10.45–10.85) 1818 (1811–1928) 2175 (2113–2190) 517.8 (517.8–519.5) 259.6 (253.1–269.8) 42.8 (42.7–43.6) —
с лимитом 10MiB 40 156.2 (155.8–156.5) 108.8 (108.5–108.9) 185.6 (184.9–185.6) 154.3 (153.8–155.2) 20.2 (19.8–22.5) 0/3 264 (258–270) 453 (451–453) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 10.90 (10.50–10.95) 1848 (1802–1892) 2224 (2125–2252) 518.4 (516.4–520.4) 262.2 (243.6–281.7) 52.9 (51.7–54.4) —
с лимитом 1MiB 1 156.2 (156.2–156.6) 108.6 (108.1–108.9) 112.3 (112.3–112.5) 104.1 (103.9–104.2) 0.9 (0.9–0.9) 0/3 1407 (1404–1434) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 60.95 (60.85–62.25) 15 (15–16) 18 (18–19) 513.0 (512.9–513.0) 218.8 (184.3–231.8) 31.5 (31.3–32.9) —
с лимитом 1MiB 10 156.3 (156.3–156.4) 108.6 (108.5–108.7) 123.4 (123.2–124.0) 109.9 (109.8–110.2) 4.9 (4.1–5.4) 0/3 2504 (2496–2681) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 109.25 (108.20–116.35) 89 (84–92) 123 (114–130) 514.9 (514.9–515.0) 223.0 (191.9–224.6) 34.7 (34.6–37.5) —
с лимитом 1MiB 20 156.2 (155.9–156.3) 108.4 (108.3–108.7) 131.0 (130.8–131.2) 112.6 (112.6–112.8) 9.7 (9.6–10.1) 0/3 2513 (2498–2554) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 108.55 (107.95–110.10) 178 (178–180) 230 (219–234) 514.7 (514.7–515.1) 206.4 (203.7–218.8) 38.2 (37.8–39.4) —
с лимитом 1MiB 40 156.3 (155.6–156.4) 108.5 (108.4–108.8) 136.2 (135.6–136.4) 117.3 (116.9–117.7) 10.1 (9.5–10.9) 0/3 2611 (2565–2614) 460 (460–460) 0 (0–0) 0 (0–0) 113.50 (110.60–113.55) 173 (173–179) 212 (208–214) 514.9 (514.8–515.2) 224.0 (220.1–232.9) 53.2 (53.1–53.4) —

Сценарии спеков

  • attachments, «Одна копия тела при записи в S3» (C = 10, 10MiB): рост пика над памятью до окна — «без лимита» — 1.19 тела на загрузку; «до» — 0.64 тела на загрузку (порог «без лимита» — 1,5 тела, «до» — больше).
  • attachments, «Память не растёт с числом загрузок» («с лимитом», 10MiB): пик реплики C=10 172.9, C=20 180.1, C=40 185.6 MiB (сверх C=10, MiB на клиента: C=20 0.72, C=40 0.42), sock C=10 15.8, C=20 21.6, C=40 20.2 MiB, LB C=10 38.1, C=20 42.8, C=40 52.9 MiB; OOM 0, 5xx 0, 429 1357.
  • load-balancing, «Буферы соединений ограничены» («с лимитом», 10MiB, C = 1 → 40): пик LB (52.9 − 31.5) / 39 = 0.55 MiB на клиента; sock (20.2 − 4.1) / 39 = 0.41 MiB на клиента; сумма 0.96 (порог 1 MiB на клиента), OOM при C = 40 0/3; выполнен — да.

Гипотезы

Гипотезы — REPORT.md, раздел загрузок (commit до прогонов); здесь — их проверка числами ячеек тела 10MiB, лимит реплики 512 MiB.

Гипотеза Утверждение Числа Выполнена
H1 «с лимитом»: пик при 10 MiB и C = 10, 20, 40 ≤ половины лимита; сверх C = 10 — ≤ 1 MiB на клиента; OOM и 5xx нет, лишние — 429 пик, MiB: C=10 172.9, C=20 180.1, C=40 185.6 (половина лимита 256); сверх C=10, MiB на клиента: C=20 0.72, C=40 0.42; OOM 0, 5xx 0, 429 1357 да
H2 «без лимита»: пик растёт на ~1,2–1,3 тела на клиента, 40 × 10 MiB — OOM; «до» — ~2,1 тела и OOM при 20 × 10 MiB без лимита C=10: 1.19 тела/клиента, OOM 0/3; без лимита C=20: 1.11 тела/клиента, OOM 0/3; без лимита C=40: — тела/клиента, OOM 3/3; до C=10: 0.64 тела/клиента, OOM 0/3; до C=20: 0.36 тела/клиента, OOM 0/3; до C=40: 0.19 тела/клиента, OOM 0/3 нет
H3 успешных загрузок в секунду при C ≥ 10: «с лимитом» ≥ 90 % «без лимита» на тех же C, пока тот жив 10MiB C=10: 10.50 / 9.00 = 117%; 10MiB C=20: 10.75 / 8.90 = 121%; 1MiB C=10: 109.25 / 125.85 = 87%; 1MiB C=20: 108.55 / 121.75 = 89%; 1MiB C=40: 113.50 / 133.35 = 85% нет
H4 503 из-за срока записи в S3 нет ни в одном варианте, пока реплика жива 503 в 69 прогонах без OOM: 0 да