From 48b84468009c45f4ddea72d8688556f6df286cd6 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: koichakaev <52+koichakaev@noreply.gitea.privcloud.tech>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 19:15:16 +0300
Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?=D0=94=D0=BE=D0=B1=D0=B0=D0=B2=D0=B8=D1=82?=
=?UTF-8?q?=D1=8C=20=D0=B3=D1=80=D0=B0=D1=84=D0=B8=D0=BA=D0=B8=20=D0=B8=20?=
=?UTF-8?q?=D1=80=D0=B5=D0=B7=D1=83=D0=BB=D1=8C=D1=82=D0=B0=D1=82=D1=8B=20?=
=?UTF-8?q?=D1=82=D0=B5=D1=81=D1=82=D0=B0=20=D0=BD=D0=B0=D0=B3=D1=80=D1=83?=
=?UTF-8?q?=D0=B7=D0=BA=D0=B8?=
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Добавить графики масштабирования и исходные данные rate-controlled испытаний.
---
evidence/offered-load-results.json | 371 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
evidence/offered-load.svg | 33 +++
evidence/offered-scale-results.json | 209 ++++++++++++++++
evidence/track1-rps.svg | 36 +++
4 files changed, 649 insertions(+)
create mode 100644 evidence/offered-load-results.json
create mode 100644 evidence/offered-load.svg
create mode 100644 evidence/offered-scale-results.json
create mode 100644 evidence/track1-rps.svg
diff --git a/evidence/offered-load-results.json b/evidence/offered-load-results.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4e75d814
--- /dev/null
+++ b/evidence/offered-load-results.json
@@ -0,0 +1,371 @@
+{
+ "method": "Rate-controlled POST sweep; 15s per sample; offered rate 250/500/750/1000 RPS; three randomized repeats; 8 API replicas at 0.5 CPU/256 MiB, DB_POOL_MAX=10, PostgreSQL 2 CPU/1 GiB, HAProxy 0.25 CPU; max in-flight 8192; per-thread HTTP client reuse; synthetic message/idempotency tables reset per sample; no Docker stats polling during load.",
+ "summary": [
+ {
+ "offered_rate_rps": 250,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 249.622,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_min": 249.559,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_max": 249.959,
+ "success_ratio_median": 1.0,
+ "p95_ms_median": 9.931,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered_median": 1.0,
+ "skipped_overload_median": 0
+ },
+ {
+ "offered_rate_rps": 500,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 499.579,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_min": 419.571,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_max": 499.857,
+ "success_ratio_median": 1.0,
+ "p95_ms_median": 41.601,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered_median": 1.0,
+ "skipped_overload_median": 0
+ },
+ {
+ "offered_rate_rps": 750,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 745.875,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_min": 693.24,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_max": 748.66,
+ "success_ratio_median": 0.999822,
+ "p95_ms_median": 100.889,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered_median": 0.999822,
+ "skipped_overload_median": 0
+ },
+ {
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 810.128,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_min": 553.163,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_max": 879.333,
+ "success_ratio_median": 0.972467,
+ "p95_ms_median": 1611.346,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered_median": 0.972467,
+ "skipped_overload_median": 0
+ }
+ ],
+ "samples": [
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-500",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 500,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 7501,
+ "scheduled_requests": 7501,
+ "successful_requests": 7501,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 499.579,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 3.277,
+ "p95": 41.601,
+ "p99": 71.014
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.015,
+ "message_rows_after": 7501
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-750",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 750,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 11251,
+ "scheduled_requests": 11251,
+ "successful_requests": 11249,
+ "failed_requests": 2,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 2
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 748.66,
+ "success_ratio": 0.999822,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.999822,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 3.819,
+ "p95": 100.889,
+ "p99": 1021.492
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.026,
+ "message_rows_after": 11249
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14976,
+ "failed_requests": 24,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 24
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 810.128,
+ "success_ratio": 0.9984,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.9984,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 109.324,
+ "p95": 1611.346,
+ "p99": 2175.384
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 3.486,
+ "message_rows_after": 14976
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-250",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 250,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 3751,
+ "scheduled_requests": 3751,
+ "successful_requests": 3751,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 249.959,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 2.744,
+ "p95": 9.931,
+ "p99": 48.516
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.006,
+ "message_rows_after": 3751
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-750",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 750,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 11251,
+ "scheduled_requests": 11251,
+ "successful_requests": 11251,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 745.875,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 5.657,
+ "p95": 79.469,
+ "p99": 164.156
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.084,
+ "message_rows_after": 11251
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14283,
+ "failed_requests": 717,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 717
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 879.333,
+ "success_ratio": 0.9522,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.9522,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 150.455,
+ "p95": 1296.214,
+ "p99": 2320.975
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 1.243,
+ "message_rows_after": 14283
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-250",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 250,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 3751,
+ "scheduled_requests": 3751,
+ "successful_requests": 3751,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 249.559,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 2.689,
+ "p95": 8.215,
+ "p99": 44.123
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.031,
+ "message_rows_after": 3751
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-500",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 500,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 7501,
+ "scheduled_requests": 7501,
+ "successful_requests": 7501,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 499.857,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 3.567,
+ "p95": 34.969,
+ "p99": 65.8
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.006,
+ "message_rows_after": 7501
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-750",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 750,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 11251,
+ "scheduled_requests": 11251,
+ "successful_requests": 11236,
+ "failed_requests": 15,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 15
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 750.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 693.24,
+ "success_ratio": 0.998667,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.998667,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 8.339,
+ "p95": 858.144,
+ "p99": 1593.896
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 1.208,
+ "message_rows_after": 11236
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-250",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 250,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 3751,
+ "scheduled_requests": 3751,
+ "successful_requests": 3751,
+ "failed_requests": 0,
+ "failure_types": {},
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 250.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 249.622,
+ "success_ratio": 1.0,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 1.0,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 2.685,
+ "p95": 17.715,
+ "p99": 52.77
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 0.027,
+ "message_rows_after": 3751
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-500",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 500,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 7501,
+ "scheduled_requests": 7501,
+ "successful_requests": 7493,
+ "failed_requests": 8,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 8
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 500.067,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 419.571,
+ "success_ratio": 0.998933,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.998933,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 9.042,
+ "p95": 1812.817,
+ "p99": 2541.843
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 2.859,
+ "message_rows_after": 7493
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14587,
+ "failed_requests": 413,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 413
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 553.163,
+ "success_ratio": 0.972467,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.972467,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 535.721,
+ "p95": 2011.397,
+ "p99": 4616.569
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 11.37,
+ "message_rows_after": 14587
+ }
+ ]
+}
diff --git a/evidence/offered-load.svg b/evidence/offered-load.svg
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..52da8b7c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/evidence/offered-load.svg
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+
diff --git a/evidence/offered-scale-results.json b/evidence/offered-scale-results.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..59ba78a6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/evidence/offered-scale-results.json
@@ -0,0 +1,209 @@
+{
+ "method": "Randomized paired blocks at offered 1000 RPS, 15s per sample; three repeats; compare 8 versus 12 replicas at fixed 0.5 CPU/256 MiB per API replica; DB_POOL_MAX=10, PostgreSQL 2 CPU/1 GiB, HAProxy 0.25 CPU; HAProxy server-template supports 16 backends; scale to 8 before each DB reset to release idle connections, then scale to target; synthetic messages and idempotency keys truncated per sample; HTTP client reused per worker.",
+ "summary": [
+ {
+ "replicas": 8,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 726.979,
+ "completed_success_rps_min": 584.377,
+ "completed_success_rps_max": 851.508,
+ "success_ratio_median": 0.981267,
+ "p95_ms_median": 1504.722,
+ "error_count_total": 874,
+ "message_rows_after_median": 14719
+ },
+ {
+ "replicas": 12,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed_median": 555.8,
+ "completed_success_rps_min": 545.991,
+ "completed_success_rps_max": 774.91,
+ "success_ratio_median": 0.999733,
+ "p95_ms_median": 1986.412,
+ "error_count_total": 12,
+ "message_rows_after_median": null
+ }
+ ],
+ "samples": [
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14719,
+ "failed_requests": 281,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 281
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 851.508,
+ "success_ratio": 0.981267,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.981267,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 206.696,
+ "p95": 1307.155,
+ "p99": 1984.206
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 2.286,
+ "message_rows_after": 14719,
+ "message_rows_after_error": null,
+ "replicas": 8
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 1,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14996,
+ "failed_requests": 4,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 4
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 774.91,
+ "success_ratio": 0.999733,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.999733,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 400.696,
+ "p95": 1664.779,
+ "p99": 2378.651
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 4.352,
+ "message_rows_after": null,
+ "message_rows_after_error": "psql: error: connection to server on socket \"/var/run/postgresql/.s.PGSQL.5432\" failed: FATAL: sorry, too many clients already",
+ "replicas": 12
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14804,
+ "failed_requests": 196,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 196
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 584.377,
+ "success_ratio": 0.986933,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.986933,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 496.284,
+ "p95": 2007.63,
+ "p99": 2684.382
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 10.333,
+ "message_rows_after": 14804,
+ "message_rows_after_error": null,
+ "replicas": 8
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 2,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14999,
+ "failed_requests": 1,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 1
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 545.991,
+ "success_ratio": 0.999933,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.999933,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 605.99,
+ "p95": 2589.505,
+ "p99": 3420.92
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 12.471,
+ "message_rows_after": null,
+ "message_rows_after_error": "psql: error: connection to server on socket \"/var/run/postgresql/.s.PGSQL.5432\" failed: FATAL: sorry, too many clients already",
+ "replicas": 12
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14993,
+ "failed_requests": 7,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 7
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 555.8,
+ "success_ratio": 0.999533,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.999533,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 717.667,
+ "p95": 1986.412,
+ "p99": 2959.931
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 11.976,
+ "message_rows_after": null,
+ "message_rows_after_error": "psql: error: connection to server on socket \"/var/run/postgresql/.s.PGSQL.5432\" failed: FATAL: sorry, too many clients already",
+ "replicas": 12
+ },
+ {
+ "variant": "offered-1000",
+ "sample": 3,
+ "offered_rate_rps": 1000,
+ "duration_seconds": 15,
+ "concurrency_workers": 512,
+ "max_inflight_requests": 8192,
+ "offered_slots": 15000,
+ "scheduled_requests": 15000,
+ "successful_requests": 14603,
+ "failed_requests": 397,
+ "failure_types": {
+ "Failure": 397
+ },
+ "skipped_overload": 0,
+ "offered_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "submitted_rps_actual": 1000.0,
+ "completed_success_rps_total_elapsed": 726.979,
+ "success_ratio": 0.973533,
+ "effective_success_ratio_offered": 0.973533,
+ "latency_successful_ms": {
+ "p50": 291.159,
+ "p95": 1504.722,
+ "p99": 2242.259
+ },
+ "drain_seconds_after_offer_window": 5.087,
+ "message_rows_after": 14603,
+ "message_rows_after_error": null,
+ "replicas": 8
+ }
+ ]
+}
diff --git a/evidence/track1-rps.svg b/evidence/track1-rps.svg
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..39f258ce
--- /dev/null
+++ b/evidence/track1-rps.svg
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+