From be6f10f195e1a78542efbceae91a51f96b4d6354 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?=D0=93=D0=BB=D0=B5=D0=B1=20=D0=9F=D0=B0=D1=80=D0=B0=D0=BC?= =?UTF-8?q?=D0=BE=D0=BD=D0=BE=D0=B2?= Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 15:16:17 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Persist messenger in PostgreSQL with sessions, cache and recovery evidence --- .dockerignore | 20 +- .gitattributes | 3 + .github/pull_request_template.md | 21 +- ARCHITECTURE.md | 32 + Dockerfile | 16 + Makefile | 16 + REPORT.md | 94 +- compose.yaml | 54 + evidence/checks.txt | 4 + evidence/http-load.csv | 1369 +++++++++++ evidence/http-resources.json | 110 + evidence/http-summary.json | 17 + evidence/index-restore.json | 3948 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ evidence/indexes.png | Bin 0 -> 80950 bytes evidence/indexes.svg | 2279 +++++++++++++++++ evidence/integration.json | 34 + evidence/restart-processes.json | 13 + migrations/001_initial.sql | 35 + requirements-test.txt | 3 + requirements.txt | 23 + scripts/bootstrap.py | 15 + scripts/index_experiment.py | 109 + scripts/load_experiment.py | 59 + scripts/plot_experiment.py | 28 + scripts/restart.py | 20 + scripts/restart.sh | 4 + scripts/verify_stack.py | 123 + src/__init__.py | 0 src/__main__.py | 9 + src/app.py | 173 ++ src/common.py | 101 + src/http.py | 85 + src/migrate.py | 28 + src/store.py | 130 + 34 files changed, 8920 insertions(+), 55 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .gitattributes create mode 100644 ARCHITECTURE.md create mode 100644 Dockerfile create mode 100644 compose.yaml create mode 100644 evidence/checks.txt create mode 100644 evidence/http-load.csv create mode 100644 evidence/http-resources.json create mode 100644 evidence/http-summary.json create mode 100644 evidence/index-restore.json create mode 100644 evidence/indexes.png create mode 100644 evidence/indexes.svg create mode 100644 evidence/integration.json create mode 100644 evidence/restart-processes.json create mode 100644 migrations/001_initial.sql create mode 100644 requirements-test.txt create mode 100644 requirements.txt create mode 100644 scripts/bootstrap.py create mode 100644 scripts/index_experiment.py create mode 100644 scripts/load_experiment.py create mode 100644 scripts/plot_experiment.py create mode 100644 scripts/restart.py create mode 100755 scripts/restart.sh create mode 100644 scripts/verify_stack.py create mode 100644 src/__init__.py create mode 100644 src/__main__.py create mode 100644 src/app.py create mode 100644 src/common.py create mode 100644 src/http.py create mode 100644 src/migrate.py create mode 100644 src/store.py diff --git a/.dockerignore b/.dockerignore index bc16e556..f6353cde 100644 --- a/.dockerignore +++ b/.dockerignore @@ -1,20 +1,6 @@ .git -.github -.env -.env.* -!.env.example -secrets -certs -volumes -data -backups -*.key -*.pem -*.p12 -*.pfx -*.jks .venv -__pycache__ -node_modules +.env +backups evidence -.DS_Store +__pycache__ diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 00000000..46526f6a --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +* text=auto eol=lf +*.png binary +*.jpg binary diff --git a/.github/pull_request_template.md b/.github/pull_request_template.md index 8ceefa10..42dfe8c5 100644 --- a/.github/pull_request_template.md +++ b/.github/pull_request_template.md @@ -1,18 +1,11 @@ ## Лабораторная 2 -Автор / группа: TODO -Целевая оценка (3/4/5): TODO -Трек 5, если заявлен: TODO +Парамонов Глеб, БВТ2301. Цель: 5, трек 2 «План запроса и восстановление». -Что реализовано и что перенесено: TODO -Команды запуска из чистого clone: TODO -Результаты проверок и ссылка на REPORT.md: TODO -Ограничения / известные ошибки: TODO -Источники и использование ИИ: TODO +Перенесён собственный API ЛР1 в PostgreSQL: транзакции и миграции, Argon2id, Basic → opaque Bearer, expiry/logout, Valkey-кэш профилей. Источник истины — PostgreSQL; отказ кэша допускается, отказ БД возвращает ограниченную ошибку. -- [ ] Весь обязательный минимум текущей и предыдущих работ сохранён с объявленными переходами. -- [ ] Контракт и публичные тесты не ослаблены. -- [ ] make check и make test выполнены; приложен реальный вывод. -- [ ] Сценарии отказов/безопасности своего уровня воспроизведены. -- [ ] Все секреты и приватные ключи находятся вне Git; отчёт не содержит tokens. -- [ ] README задания сохранён, REPORT.md содержит инструкцию именно моего решения. +Проверено: public smoke/persistence, гонка регистрации (1×201,7×409), rollback чата, 100 конкурентных сообщений, короткий TTL, logout, cache/DB down и восстановление. На 120000 сообщений сравнены 3 индекса × 2 запроса и стоимость INSERT; backup восстановлен в новый volume со сверкой counts,20 сообщений и всей истории. Keyset+compound:0.049мс против19.717мс; цена записи5000:140.445мс против112.982мс. HTTP:136.35RPS,0% ошибок, p95=122.238мс. + +Запуск: `python3 scripts/bootstrap.py && docker compose up -d --build --wait`; затем `make test`, `make verify`, `make experiment` (зависимости/Windows-команды в REPORT.md). + +[Отчёт и доказательства](../src/branch/solution/bvt2301-paramonov/REPORT.md). Ограничения: один host/БД, HTTP только локально, backup без PITR, короткие closed-loop измерения. Исходные контракты/tests сохранены. Использована помощь OpenAI Codex; данные измерены реальным запуском. diff --git a/ARCHITECTURE.md b/ARCHITECTURE.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d3f03664 --- /dev/null +++ b/ARCHITECTURE.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +# План хранения и транзакций + +PostgreSQL — источник истины для пользователей, сессий, чатов, членства и сообщений. +Данные пользователей неизменяемы в обязательном API. Valkey кэширует именно их +публичное представление на 60 секунд; действительность сессии проверяется в PostgreSQL +при каждом запросе. Поэтому отказ кэша не отменяет logout/expiry и не даёт доступ +анонимному клиенту. При отказе PostgreSQL защищённые запросы получают 503. + +users: UUID PK, UNIQUE username, display_name, password_hash (Argon2id), created_at. +sessions: SHA-256 случайного 256-битного токена PK, user FK, expires_at, created_at. +chats: UUID PK, title, created_at. +members: (chat_id, user_id) PK и внешние ключи на chats/users. +messages: UUID PK, chat FK, sender FK, text, created_at; составной FK на members +не позволяет записать отправителя вне чата даже при ошибке в приложении. + +Создание чата и всех его участников — одна транзакция. Создание сообщения — одна +транзакция после проверки доступа. Регистрация защищена UNIQUE, гонка завершается +одним 201 и остальными 409. Logout удаляет сессию в транзакции; Valkey не хранит +разрешение на вход. Ранее начавшийся запрос может завершиться одновременно с logout. + +История: индекс (chat_id, created_at, id), keyset по (created_at,id), LIMIT n+1. +Отдельный индекс members(user_id,chat_id) ускоряет список доступных чатов. Часы БД +единые, но страницы между запросами не являются snapshot: конкурентная незавершённая +транзакция может стать видимой позднее курсора. Для неизменной истории пропусков нет. + +Пул ограничен 5 соединениями, ожидание 2 секунды; statement_timeout=2s, +lock_timeout=1s. KDF ограничен четырьмя параллельными задачами. Cursor подписан +общим локально генерируемым секретом, который сохраняется при рестарте. + +Миграции нумеруются, учитываются в schema_migrations, защищены advisory lock. +Отдельный одноразовый сервис migrate запускается до API. Повторный запуск проверяет +хеши применённых миграций, не пересоздаёт таблицы и не seed-ит данные. diff --git a/Dockerfile b/Dockerfile new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b0c0c77f --- /dev/null +++ b/Dockerfile @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +# Google public mirror of the official Docker Python image; immutable digest. +FROM mirror.gcr.io/library/python@sha256:34386ef0cb081344d7ec1c103ba398e6e9f64e9ab3a1509accc92a4e24a07258 +ENV PYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONUNBUFFERED=1 PYTHONUTF8=1 \ + APP_HOST=0.0.0.0 APP_PORT=8080 +WORKDIR /app +COPY requirements.txt . +RUN pip install --no-cache-dir -r requirements.txt && \ + groupadd --gid 10001 messenger && useradd --uid 10001 --gid 10001 --no-create-home messenger +COPY src ./src +COPY migrations ./migrations +USER 10001:10001 +EXPOSE 8080 +STOPSIGNAL SIGTERM +HEALTHCHECK --interval=5s --timeout=2s --start-period=5s --retries=3 \ + CMD python -c "import urllib.request; urllib.request.urlopen('http://127.0.0.1:8080/health/ready',timeout=1)" +CMD ["python", "-m", "src"] diff --git a/Makefile b/Makefile index 9ecb223e..f2f9c453 100644 --- a/Makefile +++ b/Makefile @@ -24,3 +24,19 @@ load: test-persistence: @test -n "$(ACTION_SCRIPT)" || (echo "Set ACTION_SCRIPT to your implemented executable restart hook"; exit 2) $(PYTHON) tests/resilience.py --mode persistence --action-script "$(ACTION_SCRIPT)" --base-url "$(BASE_URL)" $(TLS_ARGS) + +.PHONY: up down verify experiment +up: + $(PYTHON) scripts/bootstrap.py + docker compose up -d --build --wait + +down: + docker compose down + +verify: + $(PYTHON) scripts/verify_stack.py + +experiment: + $(PYTHON) scripts/index_experiment.py + $(PYTHON) scripts/load_experiment.py + $(PYTHON) scripts/plot_experiment.py diff --git a/REPORT.md b/REPORT.md index e42f2b05..6935f3a8 100644 --- a/REPORT.md +++ b/REPORT.md @@ -1,37 +1,83 @@ -# Отчёт — лабораторная 2 +# Лабораторная 2 — PostgreSQL, сессии и Valkey -- Автор, группа: TODO -- Целевая оценка; выбранный трек 5, если нужен: TODO -- Commit/PR: TODO после публикации -- Использованные источники, библиотеки и помощь ИИ: TODO +Автор: **Парамонов Глеб, БВТ2301**. Цель: **5**, трек 2 «План запроса и восстановление». +Ветка: `solution/bvt2301-paramonov`. Код собственной ЛР1 перенесён и переработан для SQL и Bearer. Работа подготовлена с помощью OpenAI Codex (реализация, тесты, диагностика и оформление); измерения получены запуском реального стенда, не моделированием результатов. README, COURSE, обязательные contracts и публичные tests сохранены. -## Запуск из чистого clone +## Чистый запуск -TODO: версии runtime/образов, prerequisites, команды создания локальных secrets/.env, build, миграций, запуска, ожидания готовности, тестов и остановки. Указать необходимые действия оператора. Не вставлять секреты. Отдельно указать безопасную остановку и команду намеренного удаления учебных данных. +Нужны Docker Engine с Linux containers, Compose v2, Python 3.12+; для make-целей GNU Make. На Windows используется Docker Desktop/WSL2, команды Python запускать с `-X utf8`. Команды выполняются из корня этого репозитория; соседние лабораторные не нужны. -## Архитектура и решения +```sh +python3 -m venv .venv +.venv/bin/python -m pip install -r requirements-test.txt -r requirements-dev.txt +python3 scripts/bootstrap.py +docker compose config --quiet +docker compose up -d --build --wait +make check validate test PYTHON=.venv/bin/python +make test-persistence PYTHON=.venv/bin/python ACTION_SCRIPT=scripts/restart.sh +make verify PYTHON=.venv/bin/python +make experiment PYTHON=.venv/bin/python +``` -TODO: схема процессов/хранилищ, источник истины, транзакционные границы, ограничения. Что перенесено из lab1, что изменено в этой работе. Соответствие переменных из .env.example реальной конфигурации. +Windows: вместо `.venv/bin/python` используйте `.venv/Scripts/python.exe -X utf8`. `python scripts/verify_stack.py` сам создаёт временный Windows hook для неизменённого public persistence test. На Linux используется исполняемый `scripts/restart.sh`. Тесты создают только синтетические данные и на короткое время останавливают зависимости учебного стенда. -## Доказательства критериев +Bootstrap один раз создаёт `.env` с случайным паролем БД и HMAC-secret, при повторе сохраняет существующий файл. Переменные из исходного `.env.example` сопоставлены так: `DATABASE_URL_FILE` → локальный `DATABASE_URL`, `CACHE_URL_FILE` → `REDIS_URL`, `SESSION_STORE=postgres` соответствует фактическому источнику сессий. `SESSION_TTL_SECONDS` используется прямо; `APP_HOST/APP_PORT` задаются Dockerfile. Файловые secrets в этой лабораторной не реализованы. `.env`, backups и volumes исключены из Git. `docker compose config` без `--quiet` может показать секреты — не публикуйте его вывод. -| Критерий README | Команда/сценарий | Наблюдаемый результат | Файл доказательства | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| Публичный smoke | make test | TODO | TODO | -| Остальные пункты уровня 3 | TODO | TODO | TODO | -| Все пункты уровня 4, если заявлен | TODO | TODO | TODO | -| Выбранный трек 5, если заявлен | TODO | TODO | TODO | +Остановка с сохранением данных: `docker compose down`. **Намеренный сброс только учебного стенда**, если данные больше не нужны: `docker compose down -v`. Удалять volume для проверки сохранности нельзя. -TODO: добавить отдельную строку для каждого заявленного критерия. PASS без команды и наблюдения не является доказательством. Проверка инфраструктурного hook требует подтверждения, какие реальные процессы/хранилища перезапущены. +Python 3.12.15, PostgreSQL 17.11, Valkey 8.1 (точные образы закреплены digest в Dockerfile/compose). Docker Hub на машине возвращал 403, поэтому используется публичное зеркало официальных образов `mirror.gcr.io`. Python-зависимости закреплены в requirements.txt. API запускается непривилегированным UID 10001 с read-only FS и без capabilities; порт опубликован только на 127.0.0.1:8080. PostgreSQL и Valkey доступны только в Docker-сети. -## Эксперименты и отказы +## Архитектура и гарантии -TODO: гипотеза, hardware/лимиты, версии, объём данных, профиль нагрузки, concurrency/arrival rate, длительность/прогрев, повторы, успешные RPS, ошибки, p50/p95/p99, CPU/RAM. Сохранить raw summary без tokens и объяснить ограничения измерения. +Клиент → FastAPI/Uvicorn (1 процесс) → PostgreSQL; Valkey хранит кэш **неизменяемого публичного профиля пользователя** на 60 секунд. Пользователи/чаты/участники/сообщения/сессии — только PostgreSQL. Перед каждым cache lookup проверяется сессия SQL-запросом; наличие профиля в кэше не даёт доступ после logout/expiry. История не кэшируется: подтверждённый COMMIT виден следующему чтению. Потеря кэша допустима, потеря БД возвращает 503. Readiness зависит от БД, liveness — от процесса. -| Воздействие | Что ожидаем | Что наблюдали | Время восстановления / потеря данных | -| --- | --- | --- | --- | -| TODO | TODO | TODO | TODO | +Схема и транзакционные решения предварительно описаны в [ARCHITECTURE.md](ARCHITECTURE.md). PK/FK/UNIQUE/CHECK защищают целостность. Чат и все его участники записываются в одной транзакции; ошибка FK откатывает чат. Миграции выполняются отдельным сервисом до API, сериализованы advisory lock, имя и SHA-256 применённого SQL фиксируются; изменение уже применённой миграции запрещено. -## Ограничения и следующие шаги +Argon2id: memory_cost=32768 KiB, time_cost=2, parallelism=1; одновременно до четырёх KDF в отдельных потоках. Пароль UTF-8 не усекается. Basic применяется только при входе, Bearer — на бизнес-маршрутах. Токен — 32 случайных байта; в БД хранится SHA-256, не сам токен. Expiry проверяется по времени БД, TTL не продлевается при чтении/рестарте. Logout удаляет строку сессии. Полные токены, пароли, тела и SQL не выводятся в журналы приложения. -TODO: какие отказы выдерживаются и какие нет; что не реализовано; где учебное упрощение; какое улучшение подтверждено, а какое пока гипотеза. +Пул: 1–5 соединений, ожидание 2 с, очередь до 32; connect 3 с, SQL statement 2 с, lock 1 с. HTTP deadline 8 с, inflight 32, body 32 KiB; Valkey connect/read 0.2 с. При отказе ограничены очередь и время ожидания. SQL параметризован. Динамические SQL-имена есть только в локальном эксперименте с фиксированными таблицами/сгенерированной БД. + +Keyset `(created_at,id)` опирается на индекс `(chat_id,created_at,id)`. HMAC cursor общий и связан с ресурсом. На неизменной истории нет повторов. Между HTTP-страницами нет общего snapshot: поздно завершённая конкурентная транзакция с более ранним timestamp может оказаться перед уже выданным cursor; часы не считаются уникальным ID. + +## Проверки критериев + +| Критерий | Команда / наблюдение | Доказательство | +|---|---|---| +| Контракт и API | `make check validate test`: структура, OpenAPI, публичный smoke | `evidence/checks.txt`, `integration.json` | +| PostgreSQL, миграции с нуля/повторно | Compose migrate; повтор сообщает Already applied | `migrations/001_initial.sql`, `integration.json` | +| Сохранность всех данных/действующей сессии | public persistence перезапускает api, db, cache без удаления volumes; тот же token читает те же данные | `integration.json`, `restart-processes.json` с изменившимися StartedAt всех трёх процессов | +| KDF, Basic/Bearer/expiry/logout | неправильный пароль и X-User-Id →401; отдельный API TTL2: 200, затем401 через2.2с; logout204, затем401 | `scripts/verify_stack.py`, `integration.json` | +| Составная транзакция/гонка username | неизвестный участник400 и неизменное число чатов; 8 конкурентных регистраций: одна201, семь409 | `integration.json` | +| Конкурентные записи/пагинация | 100 сообщений/10 потоков, прочитаны все 100 уникальных ID страницами по17 | `integration.json` | +| Осмысленный Valkey/TTL/отказ | 5 повторных обращений дали +5 cache hits; при stop cache запрос200 за0.211с | `integration.json`, `src/store.py` | +| SQL pool/timeouts/отказ БД | при stop db запрос503 за0.009с, без credentials401; после start сессия снова работает | `integration.json` | +| Индекс и EXPLAIN ≥10000 | 120000 сообщений; все EXPLAIN ANALYZE BUFFERS сохранены | `index-restore.json` | +| Трек5: ≥2 индекса, запись, backup/new store | три варианта индекса × два запроса, пять повторов, restore в новый volume | `index-restore.json`, `indexes.png` | + +## Эксперимент: планы и восстановление + +Гипотеза: compound index позволяет читать глубокую страницу без перебора предыдущих строк; поддержка индекса повышает цену INSERT. `python scripts/index_experiment.py` создаёт отдельную synthetic database (основные таблицы приложения не меняются). 120000 сообщений: чаты 100000/15000/5000, текст около160 символов. Сравнивается страница 70001–70050 большого чата. Keyset использует сохранённый tuple предыдущей строки; OFFSET пропускает70000. Два прогрева + пять EXPLAIN на каждую комбинацию, тёплый cache. Для записи пять **зафиксированных** INSERT по5000, очистка только добавленных synthetic rows и VACUUM между повторами. Полные планы, buffers и каждый замер в JSON. + +| Индекс истории | Keyset, медиана мс | OFFSET, медиана мс | INSERT5000+COMMIT, медиана мс | +|---|---:|---:|---:| +| Только PK(id) | 19.717 | 171.559 | 112.982 | +| (chat_id) | 14.577 | 172.957 | 134.971 | +| (chat_id,created_at,id) | 0.049 | 14.827 | 140.445 | + +Выбран compound+keyset: примерно402× быстрее primary-only keyset в этом тёплом SQL-микротесте, при +24.3% медианной стоимости пакетной записи. Это не402× ускорение всего HTTP API: сеть, авторизация и сериализация здесь не измеряются. Простого chat_id недостаточно для упорядоченной глубокой страницы. Последовательный порядок вариантов и один ноутбук ограничивают причинные выводы; холодный cache и большие рабочие наборы не исследовались. + +![Индексы и стоимость записи](evidence/indexes.png) + +`pg_dump -Fc` дал3592366 байт за1.247с. `pg_restore --exit-on-error` в **отдельный PostgreSQL-контейнер и новый именованный volume**:4.026с включая ожидание старта. Совпали counts пользователей1/чатов3/участников3/сообщений120000/сессий0,20 выбранных сообщений и агрегатный digest всех сообщений. Dump лежит локально в ignored `backups/`; restore-контейнер и его synthetic volume удаляются самим экспериментом, исходная synthetic database остаётся для осмотра. Это snapshot логической копии: записи после snapshot могут быть потеряны, WAL/PITR и репликация не настроены. MD5 здесь только проверка равенства синтетических строк, не защита паролей или подпись. + +## Нагрузка и ресурсы + +Машина: Windows10/WSL2/Docker28.0.1, i5-11400H,8GB RAM, WSL4CPU/3GB RAM. Лимиты: API1CPU/256MiB, PostgreSQL1CPU/256MiB (shared_buffers64MB,max_connections30), Valkey0.25CPU/64MiB (cache32MB). Restore1CPU/256MiB запускался отдельно от HTTP нагрузки. + +`python scripts/load_experiment.py`: прогрев2с,10 клиентов,10.033с, closed-loop — одна запись1000 символов, затем четыре чтения истории по50 сообщений. 1368 запросов:1088×200 и280×201,136.35 успешных RPS,0% ошибок; p50/p95/p99=66.607/122.238/181.218мс. Тест создаёт отдельный чат,120000 SQL-строк исследовательской БД не подмешиваются к HTTP-набору. Raw: `http-load.csv`, `http-summary.json`, `http-resources.json`. + +Docker stats: API максимум100.05% CPU и47.89MiB, БД23.73%/25.43MiB, cache2.53%/8.289MiB. Это три дискретных отсчёта working set, не непрерывные максимумы/RSS всей VM. Генератор на том же host, closed-loop скрывает coordinated omission; один10-секундный запуск не определяет production capacity. + +## Ограничения + +Один Docker-host/одна БД — SPOF; backup не обеспечивает непрерывную доступность. Локальный HTTP разрешён только для synthetic данных. DB-role учебно имеет права миграций (разделение ролей — следующий этап). Expired sessions перестают авторизовывать, но фоновая очистка строк пока не реализована. Кэш профилей не демонстрирует ускорение истории и не заявляется как трек1. Idempotency-Key и несколько реплик появятся в ЛР3; здесь повтор POST после неизвестного исхода может создать дубликат. Все результаты относятся к указанному стенду. diff --git a/compose.yaml b/compose.yaml new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b153cb2d --- /dev/null +++ b/compose.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ +x-app: &app + build: . + image: mtusi-messenger:lab2 + env_file: .env + cpus: 1.0 + mem_limit: 256m + pids_limit: 64 + read_only: true + cap_drop: [ALL] + security_opt: [no-new-privileges:true] + stop_grace_period: 8s + logging: + driver: json-file + options: {max-size: 5m, max-file: "2"} +services: + db: + image: mirror.gcr.io/library/postgres@sha256:3645570cccdfa447589da9f57dd740faa29b30938e861289a5574b6ca6b03826 + environment: + POSTGRES_USER: messenger + POSTGRES_DB: messenger + POSTGRES_PASSWORD: ${POSTGRES_PASSWORD:?Run python scripts/bootstrap.py} + command: [postgres, -c, shared_buffers=64MB, -c, max_connections=30] + volumes: [pgdata:/var/lib/postgresql/data] + cpus: 1.0 + mem_limit: 256m + healthcheck: + test: [CMD-SHELL, "pg_isready -U messenger -d messenger"] + interval: 2s + timeout: 2s + retries: 20 + cache: + image: mirror.gcr.io/valkey/valkey@sha256:081c2f5cb575efc901aa80ff9cdbd1ec6a301682fd35e1ebb4b0990a4a4a8507 + command: [valkey-server, --maxmemory, 32mb, --maxmemory-policy, allkeys-lru, --save, "", --appendonly, "no"] + cpus: 0.25 + mem_limit: 64m + healthcheck: + test: [CMD, valkey-cli, ping] + interval: 2s + timeout: 1s + retries: 20 + migrate: + <<: *app + command: [python, -m, src.migrate] + healthcheck: {disable: true} + depends_on: + db: {condition: service_healthy} + api: + <<: *app + ports: ["127.0.0.1:8080:8080"] + depends_on: + migrate: {condition: service_completed_successfully} + cache: {condition: service_healthy} +volumes: + pgdata: diff --git a/evidence/checks.txt b/evidence/checks.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..fba78c95 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/checks.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +python -X utf8 scripts/check_contract.py +PASS: offline skeleton structure, local refs and Python syntax; application NOT tested. +python -X utf8 scripts/validate_openapi.py +PASS: full OpenAPI 3.1 and JSON Schema validation; application NOT tested. diff --git a/evidence/http-load.csv b/evidence/http-load.csv new file mode 100644 index 00000000..08e360ae --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/http-load.csv @@ -0,0 +1,1369 @@ +worker,method,elapsed_s,latency_ms,status +0,POST,0.00415,99.473,201 +1,POST,0.00578,108.551,201 +5,POST,0.015322,102.218,201 +2,POST,0.007225,112.014,201 +4,POST,0.009349,111.634,201 +3,POST,0.008632,113.049,201 +7,POST,0.018005,109.75,201 +9,POST,0.020841,115.852,201 +6,POST,0.016594,123.54,201 +8,POST,0.019242,122.525,201 +0,GET,0.103628,54.263,200 +5,GET,0.117544,48.052,200 +1,GET,0.114335,54.481,200 +4,GET,0.120989,53.626,200 +2,GET,0.119243,59.903,200 +7,GET,0.12776,56.283,200 +3,GET,0.121686,63.738,200 +9,GET,0.1367,50.846,200 +6,GET,0.140139,54.218,200 +8,GET,0.14177,56.663,200 +5,GET,0.1656,44.886,200 +0,GET,0.157894,57.179,200 +1,GET,0.168819,47.463,200 +4,GET,0.17462,44.577,200 +2,GET,0.179149,41.769,200 +3,GET,0.185427,91.644,200 +7,GET,0.184048,94.69,200 +9,GET,0.18755,94.539,200 +6,GET,0.194361,93.416,200 +8,GET,0.198438,92.385,200 +5,GET,0.21049,100.271,200 +0,GET,0.215079,99.4,200 +4,GET,0.219201,98.942,200 +1,GET,0.216286,102.811,200 +2,GET,0.220922,103.66,200 +3,GET,0.277075,101.154,200 +7,GET,0.27874,100.851,200 +9,GET,0.282093,107.344,200 +6,GET,0.287783,110.533,200 +8,GET,0.290827,109.647,200 +5,GET,0.310766,101.962,200 +0,GET,0.314482,106.17,200 +2,GET,0.324585,98.949,200 +1,GET,0.319101,106.057,200 +4,GET,0.318148,108.084,200 +7,GET,0.379595,102.003,200 +3,GET,0.378233,105.327,200 +9,GET,0.38944,106.415,200 +6,GET,0.398319,99.394,200 +8,GET,0.400478,101.745,200 +5,POST,0.412732,102.976,201 +0,POST,0.420656,97.2,201 +1,POST,0.42516,150.547,201 +4,POST,0.426236,158.12,201 +2,POST,0.423612,165.49,201 +7,POST,0.481601,110.77,201 +3,POST,0.483575,113.369,201 +9,POST,0.495858,108.831,201 +6,POST,0.497716,117.562,201 +8,POST,0.502232,114.389,201 +5,GET,0.515711,161.322,200 +0,GET,0.517859,163.19,200 +1,GET,0.575766,115.85,200 +4,GET,0.584361,112.403,200 +2,GET,0.589154,117.832,200 +7,GET,0.592375,121.063,200 +3,GET,0.596948,121.154,200 +9,GET,0.604695,165.53,200 +6,GET,0.615281,160.746,200 +8,GET,0.616627,163.191,200 +5,GET,0.677092,106.839,200 +0,GET,0.681054,112.652,200 +1,GET,0.69162,104.303,200 +4,GET,0.696767,103.822,200 +2,GET,0.706993,100.54,200 +7,GET,0.71345,98.914,200 +3,GET,0.718105,151.607,200 +9,GET,0.770229,109.834,200 +8,GET,0.779821,106.968,200 +5,GET,0.783937,106.765,200 +6,GET,0.776033,117.839,200 +1,GET,0.795927,108.229,200 +0,GET,0.79371,114.361,200 +4,GET,0.800592,112.113,200 +2,GET,0.807536,109.357,200 +7,GET,0.812368,155.025,200 +3,GET,0.869717,108.047,200 +9,GET,0.880066,111.094,200 +8,GET,0.886793,105.82,200 +5,GET,0.890709,114.42,200 +6,GET,0.893876,113.574,200 +1,GET,0.90416,155.199,200 +0,GET,0.908075,154.578,200 +2,GET,0.916895,156.952,200 +4,GET,0.912708,162.736,200 +7,GET,0.967396,124.603,200 +3,GET,0.977769,125.823,200 +9,GET,0.991164,173.402,200 +8,GET,0.992616,173.803,200 +5,POST,1.005133,168.867,201 +1,POST,1.059362,122.535,201 +6,GET,1.007452,175.882,200 +4,POST,1.075465,109.774,201 +2,POST,1.073892,117.193,201 +0,POST,1.062659,136.15,201 +7,POST,1.092002,113.041,201 +3,POST,1.103595,109.025,201 +8,POST,1.166424,95.373,201 +5,GET,1.174004,90.836,200 +9,POST,1.164575,101.565,201 +6,POST,1.183336,93.466,201 +1,GET,1.1819,96.18,200 +4,GET,1.185242,97.871,200 +2,GET,1.19116,99.581,200 +0,GET,1.198813,97.928,200 +7,GET,1.205047,99.788,200 +3,GET,1.212623,105.98,200 +8,GET,1.2618,66.495,200 +5,GET,1.264846,68.01,200 +9,GET,1.266143,70.145,200 +6,GET,1.276805,75.242,200 +1,GET,1.278082,86.881,200 +4,GET,1.283116,89.276,200 +2,GET,1.290744,92.766,200 +0,GET,1.296745,95.625,200 +7,GET,1.304839,91.491,200 +3,GET,1.318607,88.283,200 +8,GET,1.328299,83.666,200 +5,GET,1.33286,86.125,200 +9,GET,1.336293,85.301,200 +6,GET,1.35205,77.279,200 +1,GET,1.364969,67.537,200 +4,GET,1.372398,65.741,200 +2,GET,1.383515,60.232,200 +0,GET,1.392375,55.816,200 +7,GET,1.396333,56.648,200 +3,GET,1.406893,53.561,200 +8,GET,1.411968,55.288,200 +9,GET,1.421599,46.551,200 +5,GET,1.418989,50.7,200 +6,GET,1.429333,51.143,200 +4,GET,1.438142,43.613,200 +1,GET,1.43251,49.621,200 +2,GET,1.443755,50.036,200 +0,GET,1.448195,48.195,200 +7,GET,1.452985,52.259,200 +3,GET,1.460457,54.11,200 +9,GET,1.468153,49.39,200 +8,GET,1.46726,52.412,200 +5,POST,1.469693,57.632,201 +6,GET,1.48048,49.021,200 +4,POST,1.481759,48.19,201 +1,POST,1.48214,55.251,201 +2,POST,1.493795,48.541,201 +0,POST,1.496394,51.59,201 +7,POST,1.505248,56.055,201 +9,POST,1.517547,45.774,201 +3,POST,1.514571,50.137,201 +8,POST,1.519677,45.971,201 +6,POST,1.529505,41.794,201 +5,GET,1.527328,47.429,200 +4,GET,1.529953,48.46,200 +1,GET,1.537394,51.143,200 +2,GET,1.54234,48.05,200 +0,GET,1.547987,49.324,200 +7,GET,1.561306,44.826,200 +3,GET,1.564712,44.883,200 +9,GET,1.563324,48.341,200 +8,GET,1.565651,54.684,200 +6,GET,1.571301,51.489,200 +5,GET,1.57476,50.17,200 +4,GET,1.578416,53.048,200 +1,GET,1.58854,51.29,200 +2,GET,1.590394,50.948,200 +0,GET,1.597314,54.011,200 +7,GET,1.606135,57.747,200 +3,GET,1.609597,56.735,200 +9,GET,1.611668,56.272,200 +8,GET,1.620338,58.749,200 +6,GET,1.622793,57.73,200 +5,GET,1.624932,56.927,200 +4,GET,1.631467,59.771,200 +1,GET,1.639833,57.335,200 +2,GET,1.641344,59.999,200 +0,GET,1.651331,59.142,200 +7,GET,1.663885,54.822,200 +3,GET,1.666348,53.72,200 +9,GET,1.667941,59.466,200 +8,GET,1.679091,50.772,200 +6,GET,1.680527,54.775,200 +5,GET,1.681862,59.732,200 +1,GET,1.697173,55.141,200 +4,GET,1.691243,63.663,200 +2,GET,1.701346,58.887,200 +0,GET,1.710477,60.286,200 +7,GET,1.71871,56.495,200 +3,GET,1.720071,58.062,200 +8,GET,1.729866,57.564,200 +9,GET,1.72741,62.951,200 +6,GET,1.735304,62.449,200 +5,POST,1.741598,62.054,201 +1,POST,1.752317,53.813,201 +4,POST,1.754909,52.444,201 +2,POST,1.760238,48.364,201 +0,POST,1.770766,49.241,201 +7,POST,1.775208,47.585,201 +3,POST,1.778136,50.332,201 +8,POST,1.787432,43.067,201 +9,POST,1.790365,43.683,201 +6,POST,1.797755,45.67,201 +5,GET,1.803662,40.783,200 +1,GET,1.806132,39.785,200 +4,GET,1.807355,47.406,200 +2,GET,1.808612,48.221,200 +0,GET,1.82001,53.201,200 +7,GET,1.822796,53.343,200 +8,GET,1.830501,53.227,200 +3,GET,1.82847,60.493,200 +9,GET,1.834051,56.766,200 +6,GET,1.843428,56.574,200 +5,GET,1.844448,59.679,200 +1,GET,1.845919,61.12,200 +4,GET,1.854765,57.423,200 +2,GET,1.856836,65.325,200 +0,GET,1.873214,70.663,200 +7,GET,1.876142,80.211,200 +8,GET,1.883783,74.489,200 +3,GET,1.888966,78.453,200 +9,GET,1.890821,80.007,200 +6,GET,1.900005,73.027,200 +5,GET,1.904131,77.7,200 +1,GET,1.907048,76.512,200 +4,GET,1.912191,79.949,200 +2,GET,1.922164,81.397,200 +0,GET,1.94388,71.506,200 +8,GET,1.958275,63.59,200 +7,GET,1.956358,68.516,200 +3,GET,1.967422,61.413,200 +9,GET,1.970858,60.017,200 +6,GET,1.973036,68.377,200 +5,GET,1.981833,66.35,200 +1,GET,1.983577,66.049,200 +4,GET,1.992144,69.493,200 +2,GET,2.003565,67.304,200 +0,GET,2.015389,65.808,200 +8,GET,2.021868,61.424,200 +7,GET,2.024881,61.831,200 +3,GET,2.028838,66.353,200 +9,GET,2.030884,72.812,200 +6,GET,2.041416,64.251,200 +1,POST,2.04963,57.307,201 +5,POST,2.048189,67.266,201 +4,POST,2.061648,66.099,201 +2,POST,2.070872,59.99,201 +0,POST,2.081201,53.844,201 +8,POST,2.083327,54.566,201 +7,POST,2.086717,55.008,201 +3,POST,2.095194,49.799,201 +6,POST,2.10567,42.674,201 +9,POST,2.103699,48.646,201 +1,GET,2.106939,49.565,200 +5,GET,2.115458,50.95,200 +4,GET,2.127753,56.073,200 +0,GET,2.135047,62.625,200 +2,GET,2.130864,71.489,200 +7,GET,2.141728,62.743,200 +8,GET,2.137896,74.533,200 +3,GET,2.144998,73.367,200 +6,GET,2.148346,77.143,200 +9,GET,2.152348,75.606,200 +1,GET,2.156508,76.506,200 +5,GET,2.166411,77.877,200 +4,GET,2.183877,74.475,200 +0,GET,2.197676,63.801,200 +7,GET,2.204475,60.728,200 +2,GET,2.202356,74.674,200 +8,GET,2.212432,76.029,200 +3,GET,2.21837,75.27,200 +6,GET,2.225495,69.93,200 +9,GET,2.227956,77.3,200 +1,GET,2.233018,79.497,200 +5,GET,2.244292,90.713,200 +4,GET,2.258355,82.962,200 +0,GET,2.261481,86.941,200 +7,GET,2.265207,89.884,200 +2,GET,2.277035,88.708,200 +8,GET,2.288464,79.485,200 +3,GET,2.293643,78.174,200 +6,GET,2.295427,84.019,200 +9,GET,2.30526,79.245,200 +1,GET,2.312578,84.046,200 +5,GET,2.335009,79.82,200 +4,GET,2.341321,78.413,200 +0,GET,2.348424,73.756,200 +7,GET,2.355094,77.198,200 +2,GET,2.365748,75.696,200 +8,GET,2.367952,80.256,200 +3,GET,2.37182,79.694,200 +6,GET,2.379448,86.112,200 +9,GET,2.384508,87.509,200 +1,POST,2.396627,81.067,201 +5,POST,2.414832,76.419,201 +7,POST,2.432295,62.82,201 +0,POST,2.422184,75.444,201 +4,POST,2.419739,79.518,201 +2,POST,2.441448,59.348,201 +8,POST,2.448212,54.415,201 +3,POST,2.451517,58.671,201 +6,POST,2.465564,47.607,201 +9,POST,2.472021,48.26,201 +1,GET,2.477697,50.657,200 +7,GET,2.495118,47.158,200 +5,GET,2.491255,56.184,200 +0,GET,2.497631,52.959,200 +4,GET,2.499267,61.055,200 +8,GET,2.50263,63.83,200 +2,GET,2.5008,72.275,200 +3,GET,2.510191,72.665,200 +6,GET,2.513176,78.948,200 +9,GET,2.520289,78.629,200 +1,GET,2.528357,82.432,200 +7,GET,2.542281,72.441,200 +5,GET,2.547442,75.946,200 +0,GET,2.550593,77.207,200 +4,GET,2.560325,79.207,200 +8,GET,2.566464,78.813,200 +2,GET,2.57308,81.367,200 +3,GET,2.58286,81.134,200 +6,GET,2.592128,76.711,200 +9,GET,2.598922,81.646,200 +1,GET,2.610792,74.907,200 +7,GET,2.614726,79.909,200 +5,GET,2.623391,74.243,200 +0,GET,2.627803,77.604,200 +4,GET,2.639536,67.903,200 +8,GET,2.645285,74.454,200 +2,GET,2.654466,70.246,200 +3,GET,2.663999,73.702,200 +6,GET,2.668842,79.555,200 +9,GET,2.680571,74.02,200 +1,GET,2.685701,79.822,200 +7,GET,2.694639,79.547,200 +5,GET,2.697638,80.158,200 +0,GET,2.705411,84.325,200 +4,GET,2.707441,90.854,200 +8,GET,2.719743,89.404,200 +2,GET,2.724715,91.463,200 +3,GET,2.737704,88.318,200 +6,GET,2.748399,88.071,200 +9,GET,2.754595,83.55,200 +1,POST,2.765527,80.722,201 +7,POST,2.77419,75.699,201 +0,POST,2.789739,63.738,201 +5,POST,2.777804,77.679,201 +4,POST,2.798298,64.106,201 +8,POST,2.809151,56.374,201 +2,POST,2.816181,52.271,201 +3,POST,2.826025,50.935,201 +6,POST,2.836476,42.202,201 +9,POST,2.838149,45.608,201 +1,GET,2.846252,46.81,200 +7,GET,2.849894,45.203,200 +0,GET,2.85349,53.617,200 +5,GET,2.855528,53.747,200 +4,GET,2.862407,59.091,200 +8,GET,2.865533,57.903,200 +2,GET,2.868455,66.388,200 +6,GET,2.87868,70.04,200 +3,GET,2.876963,74.98,200 +9,GET,2.88376,85.37,200 +1,GET,2.893067,86.783,200 +7,GET,2.895102,92.232,200 +0,GET,2.907113,94.761,200 +5,GET,2.909278,98.677,200 +4,GET,2.921502,98.086,200 +8,GET,2.923439,108.683,200 +2,GET,2.934845,111.811,200 +6,GET,2.948724,108.277,200 +3,GET,2.951988,107.265,200 +9,GET,2.969134,100.571,200 +1,GET,2.979853,96.286,200 +7,GET,2.987338,91.609,200 +0,GET,3.001878,84.089,200 +5,GET,3.007958,86.431,200 +4,GET,3.019592,76.521,200 +8,GET,3.032125,72.056,200 +2,GET,3.04666,67.366,200 +6,GET,3.057004,62.541,200 +3,GET,3.059257,64.207,200 +9,GET,3.069738,66.624,200 +1,GET,3.076142,68.149,200 +7,GET,3.07895,68.083,200 +0,GET,3.086001,68.482,200 +5,GET,3.094394,69.555,200 +4,GET,3.096118,73.898,200 +8,GET,3.104186,81.976,200 +2,GET,3.11403,75.172,200 +6,GET,3.119548,82.401,200 +3,GET,3.123467,83.297,200 +1,POST,3.144294,67.533,201 +9,GET,3.136369,77.587,200 +7,POST,3.147038,71.932,201 +0,POST,3.154486,67.458,201 +5,POST,3.163953,60.591,201 +4,POST,3.17002,58.488,201 +2,POST,3.189247,51.345,201 +3,POST,3.206768,37.578,201 +8,POST,3.18617,59.109,201 +6,POST,3.201952,44.562,201 +1,GET,3.21183,40.243,200 +9,POST,3.213962,40.495,201 +7,GET,3.218974,45.892,200 +0,GET,3.221947,45.409,200 +5,GET,3.224555,54.356,200 +4,GET,3.228511,60.876,200 +2,GET,3.240594,63.402,200 +8,GET,3.245281,68.486,200 +3,GET,3.244349,71.733,200 +6,GET,3.246518,71.578,200 +1,GET,3.252077,81.747,200 +9,GET,3.254459,81.011,200 +7,GET,3.264869,73.305,200 +0,GET,3.267379,73.826,200 +5,GET,3.278914,79.019,200 +4,GET,3.289392,74.903,200 +2,GET,3.304,75.739,200 +8,GET,3.31377,72.389,200 +3,GET,3.316086,76.472,200 +6,GET,3.318099,78.323,200 +1,GET,3.333827,64.476,200 +9,GET,3.335473,65.226,200 +7,GET,3.33818,76.001,200 +0,GET,3.34121,75.215,200 +5,GET,3.357937,69.22,200 +4,GET,3.364299,72.82,200 +2,GET,3.379742,66.639,200 +8,GET,3.386163,65.242,200 +3,GET,3.392562,61.275,200 +6,GET,3.396427,63.452,200 +1,GET,3.398307,68.682,200 +9,GET,3.400703,73.235,200 +7,GET,3.414184,63.474,200 +0,GET,3.416428,67.571,200 +5,GET,3.427161,65.306,200 +4,GET,3.437123,67.364,200 +2,GET,3.446383,64.235,200 +8,GET,3.451408,61.08,200 +3,GET,3.453841,68.459,200 +6,GET,3.459881,65.254,200 +1,POST,3.466992,67.359,201 +7,POST,3.477661,59.629,201 +9,GET,3.473941,65.196,200 +0,POST,3.484002,61.151,201 +5,POST,3.492471,62.719,201 +4,POST,3.504491,56.341,201 +2,POST,3.510621,51.882,201 +8,POST,3.512491,51.395,201 +3,POST,3.522303,49.165,201 +1,GET,3.534354,39.092,200 +6,POST,3.525141,49.915,201 +9,POST,3.539141,44.163,201 +7,GET,3.537294,49.965,200 +0,GET,3.545158,52.872,200 +5,GET,3.555193,52.157,200 +4,GET,3.560836,51.57,200 +2,GET,3.562507,54.799,200 +8,GET,3.56389,56.187,200 +3,GET,3.57147,56.804,200 +1,GET,3.573449,58.474,200 +6,GET,3.575058,58.343,200 +9,GET,3.583308,56.38,200 +7,GET,3.587262,61.483,200 +0,GET,3.598034,57.936,200 +5,GET,3.607354,55.865,200 +4,GET,3.612446,61.199,200 +2,GET,3.617309,57.963,200 +8,GET,3.620079,60.93,200 +3,GET,3.628279,64.193,200 +1,GET,3.631928,64.02,200 +6,GET,3.633405,71.94,200 +9,GET,3.639691,70.383,200 +7,GET,3.648763,79.297,200 +0,GET,3.655974,88.66,200 +5,GET,3.66324,87.097,200 +4,GET,3.673649,83.115,200 +2,GET,3.675274,90.207,200 +8,GET,3.681012,92.352,200 +3,GET,3.692476,87.065,200 +1,GET,3.695955,96.675,200 +6,GET,3.705347,90.748,200 +9,GET,3.710078,100.236,200 +7,GET,3.728064,94.911,200 +4,GET,3.756767,72.371,200 +0,GET,3.744637,87.303,200 +5,GET,3.750346,88.946,200 +8,GET,3.77338,72.634,200 +3,GET,3.779543,67.661,200 +1,POST,3.792633,61.338,201 +2,GET,3.765483,91.915,200 +6,GET,3.796099,72.668,200 +9,GET,3.810318,74.205,200 +7,POST,3.822981,68.599,201 +4,POST,3.829143,68.033,201 +3,POST,3.847207,55.927,201 +0,POST,3.831944,73.282,201 +5,POST,3.839295,66.917,201 +2,POST,3.857403,54.023,201 +8,POST,3.846018,70.57,201 +1,GET,3.853975,68.724,200 +6,POST,3.868772,54.993,201 +9,POST,3.884528,48.705,201 +7,GET,3.891584,47.064,200 +4,GET,3.897183,52.829,200 +3,GET,3.903145,52.663,200 +5,GET,3.906214,53.605,200 +0,GET,3.905233,57.323,200 +2,GET,3.911444,59.636,200 +8,GET,3.916591,62.878,200 +6,GET,3.923769,61.1,200 +1,GET,3.922701,68.642,200 +9,GET,3.933243,61.76,200 +7,GET,3.938652,63.988,200 +4,GET,3.950015,58.022,200 +3,GET,3.955811,54.887,200 +5,GET,3.959822,60.127,200 +0,GET,3.962561,59.281,200 +2,GET,3.971084,60.269,200 +8,GET,3.979472,62.982,200 +6,GET,3.984872,59.529,200 +1,GET,3.991347,61.706,200 +9,GET,3.995011,61.152,200 +7,GET,4.002643,59.71,200 +4,GET,4.00804,60.583,200 +3,GET,4.0107,59.878,200 +0,GET,4.021846,56.772,200 +5,GET,4.019954,60.906,200 +8,GET,4.042458,50.279,200 +2,GET,4.031358,68.466,200 +6,GET,4.044405,63.654,200 +1,GET,4.053057,62.709,200 +9,GET,4.056165,65.975,200 +4,GET,4.068629,55.954,200 +7,GET,4.062356,72.948,200 +3,GET,4.070581,66.603,200 +0,GET,4.078621,64.989,200 +5,GET,4.080863,66.901,200 +8,GET,4.09274,72.396,200 +2,GET,4.099829,69.111,200 +6,GET,4.108062,71.212,200 +1,POST,4.11577,65.086,201 +4,POST,4.124587,61.142,201 +9,GET,4.122144,71.39,200 +7,POST,4.135308,59.85,201 +3,POST,4.137186,59.478,201 +0,POST,4.143613,55.994,201 +5,POST,4.147767,58.098,201 +8,POST,4.165141,52.313,201 +2,POST,4.168945,51.362,201 +6,POST,4.179277,46.495,201 +1,GET,4.180859,50.244,200 +4,GET,4.185739,47.795,200 +9,POST,4.193538,41.297,201 +7,GET,4.195161,46.972,200 +3,GET,4.196666,53.477,200 +0,GET,4.199616,55.722,200 +5,GET,4.205869,58.386,200 +8,GET,4.217457,60.873,200 +2,GET,4.22031,61.603,200 +6,GET,4.225775,59.186,200 +1,GET,4.231106,57.953,200 +4,GET,4.233537,70.458,200 +9,GET,4.234836,71.2,200 +7,GET,4.242137,65.36,200 +3,GET,4.250146,68.922,200 +0,GET,4.255341,74.959,200 +5,GET,4.264258,73.194,200 +8,GET,4.278333,64.248,200 +6,GET,4.284964,70.422,200 +2,GET,4.281916,77.919,200 +1,GET,4.289063,74.122,200 +4,GET,4.303999,75.585,200 +7,GET,4.3075,74.931,200 +9,GET,4.306039,78.331,200 +3,GET,4.31907,76.353,200 +0,GET,4.330303,73.663,200 +5,GET,4.337456,72.77,200 +8,GET,4.342585,71.366,200 +6,GET,4.355391,66.545,200 +2,GET,4.359838,63.568,200 +1,GET,4.363188,65.643,200 +4,GET,4.379586,51.921,200 +7,GET,4.382434,57.7,200 +9,GET,4.384373,60.049,200 +3,GET,4.395426,58.211,200 +0,GET,4.403969,58.181,200 +8,GET,4.413954,61.827,200 +5,GET,4.41023,67.437,200 +6,GET,4.421939,60.652,200 +2,GET,4.423409,64.146,200 +1,POST,4.428834,63.971,201 +4,POST,4.431511,63.273,201 +7,POST,4.440139,62.253,201 +9,GET,4.44443,64.208,200 +3,POST,4.45364,63.387,201 +0,POST,4.462153,62.425,201 +8,POST,4.475786,52.769,201 +5,POST,4.477669,53.031,201 +6,POST,4.482595,49.935,201 +2,POST,4.487557,47.51,201 +4,GET,4.494787,91.264,200 +1,GET,4.492808,95.289,200 +9,POST,4.508641,88.527,201 +7,GET,4.502405,98.434,200 +3,GET,4.517047,96.343,200 +0,GET,4.524586,100.305,200 +8,GET,4.528559,99.948,200 +5,GET,4.530705,101.521,200 +6,GET,4.532534,109.052,200 +2,GET,4.53507,111.372,200 +4,GET,4.586054,68.448,200 +1,GET,4.588099,72.343,200 +9,GET,4.597171,71.096,200 +7,GET,4.600908,70.618,200 +3,GET,4.613393,68.785,200 +8,GET,4.628553,56.033,200 +0,GET,4.624895,67.092,200 +5,GET,4.632229,66.906,200 +6,GET,4.641592,58.985,200 +2,GET,4.646446,64.229,200 +4,GET,4.654506,65.183,200 +1,GET,4.660446,61.052,200 +9,GET,4.66827,63.085,200 +7,GET,4.671528,63.187,200 +8,GET,4.684589,63.239,200 +3,GET,4.682181,71.271,200 +0,GET,4.691989,67.673,200 +5,GET,4.699139,68.935,200 +6,GET,4.70058,71.975,200 +2,GET,4.710678,70.639,200 +4,GET,4.719694,66.424,200 +1,GET,4.721502,68.956,200 +9,GET,4.731358,65.226,200 +7,GET,4.734717,72.387,200 +3,GET,4.753457,60.322,200 +8,GET,4.747832,72.681,200 +0,GET,4.759664,74.515,200 +5,GET,4.768128,68.164,200 +6,GET,4.772558,73.374,200 +2,GET,4.78132,71.832,200 +4,POST,4.786121,69.744,201 +1,POST,4.790461,67.184,201 +9,GET,4.796589,74.891,200 +7,POST,4.807108,71.647,201 +8,POST,4.820515,63.895,201 +3,POST,4.813782,74.056,201 +0,POST,4.834185,55.249,201 +5,POST,4.836302,60.452,201 +2,POST,4.853156,45.986,201 +1,GET,4.857647,46.381,200 +6,POST,4.845935,64.724,201 +4,GET,4.855874,57.347,200 +9,POST,4.871484,42.697,201 +7,GET,4.878759,50.345,200 +8,GET,4.884415,50.669,200 +3,GET,4.887841,56.226,200 +0,GET,4.889435,56.847,200 +5,GET,4.896757,58.58,200 +1,GET,4.904032,57.964,200 +6,GET,4.910662,54.424,200 +2,GET,4.899146,67.535,200 +4,GET,4.913224,63.538,200 +9,GET,4.914183,65.6,200 +7,GET,4.929106,64.153,200 +8,GET,4.935087,67.249,200 +3,GET,4.944073,62.523,200 +0,GET,4.946285,62.741,200 +5,GET,4.955341,56.726,200 +1,GET,4.961999,56.601,200 +6,GET,4.96509,59.128,200 +2,GET,4.966687,59.108,200 +4,GET,4.976765,53.977,200 +9,GET,4.979786,60.816,200 +7,GET,4.993272,58.509,200 +8,GET,5.002339,56.272,200 +0,GET,5.00903,52.834,200 +3,GET,5.006599,58.263,200 +5,GET,5.012069,60.643,200 +1,GET,5.018602,61.044,200 +6,GET,5.024222,58.461,200 +2,GET,5.025798,59.496,200 +4,GET,5.030746,67.537,200 +9,GET,5.040606,59.051,200 +7,GET,5.051784,63.822,200 +3,GET,5.064864,59.294,200 +8,GET,5.058632,67.217,200 +1,POST,5.079649,54.929,201 +0,GET,5.061865,78.13,200 +5,GET,5.072716,69.115,200 +2,GET,5.085297,75.085,200 +6,GET,5.082685,80.77,200 +4,POST,5.098286,73.314,201 +9,GET,5.099661,75.042,200 +8,POST,5.125853,67.088,201 +3,POST,5.124162,73.532,201 +7,POST,5.115609,83.482,201 +0,POST,5.139999,66.096,201 +5,POST,5.141835,69.476,201 +1,GET,5.134586,81.118,200 +6,POST,5.163459,66.029,201 +2,POST,5.160386,70.806,201 +4,GET,5.171605,65.87,200 +9,POST,5.174706,65.167,201 +8,GET,5.192943,68.261,200 +3,GET,5.197697,70.302,200 +7,GET,5.199094,71.221,200 +0,GET,5.206099,75.282,200 +5,GET,5.211315,75.573,200 +1,GET,5.215707,80.651,200 +6,GET,5.22949,73.44,200 +2,GET,5.231195,80.707,200 +4,GET,5.237478,76.928,200 +9,GET,5.239876,84.926,200 +8,GET,5.261207,81.611,200 +3,GET,5.268052,80.108,200 +7,GET,5.270369,85.545,200 +0,GET,5.281385,85.655,200 +5,GET,5.286892,86.919,200 +1,GET,5.296363,84.441,200 +6,GET,5.302934,83.158,200 +2,GET,5.311905,77.692,200 +4,GET,5.314412,82.163,200 +9,GET,5.324806,81.258,200 +8,GET,5.342822,68.896,200 +3,GET,5.348163,71.282,200 +7,GET,5.355918,65.272,200 +0,GET,5.367045,61.684,200 +5,GET,5.373814,62.965,200 +1,GET,5.380808,59.944,200 +6,GET,5.386095,63.311,200 +2,GET,5.389601,61.655,200 +4,GET,5.396579,63.902,200 +9,GET,5.406067,66.045,200 +8,GET,5.411723,64.964,200 +3,GET,5.41945,67.795,200 +7,GET,5.421193,67.621,200 +0,GET,5.428738,70.119,200 +5,GET,5.436783,68.122,200 +1,POST,5.440756,65.091,201 +6,GET,5.44941,64.155,200 +4,POST,5.460488,54.634,201 +2,GET,5.451261,66.447,200 +9,GET,5.472116,55.689,200 +8,POST,5.476691,59.869,201 +3,POST,5.487248,52.745,201 +7,POST,5.488818,51.997,201 +0,POST,5.49886,48.508,201 +1,GET,5.50585,48.911,200 +4,GET,5.515125,42.155,200 +5,POST,5.504909,54.684,201 +6,POST,5.513572,46.577,201 +2,POST,5.517711,43.606,201 +9,POST,5.527809,48.54,201 +3,GET,5.539996,48.936,200 +8,GET,5.536563,54.336,200 +7,GET,5.540818,52.883,200 +0,GET,5.547374,49.318,200 +1,GET,5.554764,51.666,200 +4,GET,5.557285,54.339,200 +5,GET,5.559597,54.887,200 +2,GET,5.561328,56.935,200 +6,GET,5.560151,60.162,200 +9,GET,5.576351,64.195,200 +3,GET,5.588935,58.132,200 +8,GET,5.590902,58.457,200 +0,GET,5.596695,54.048,200 +7,GET,5.593705,59.466,200 +1,GET,5.606433,55.794,200 +4,GET,5.611627,56.268,200 +5,GET,5.614489,55.792,200 +2,GET,5.618268,54.955,200 +6,GET,5.620316,58.207,200 +9,GET,5.64055,61.031,200 +3,GET,5.647071,62.513,200 +8,GET,5.649361,62.585,200 +0,GET,5.650748,64.8,200 +1,GET,5.662234,56.806,200 +7,GET,5.653173,72.257,200 +4,GET,5.667899,62.953,200 +5,GET,5.670284,63.397,200 +2,GET,5.673226,62.685,200 +6,GET,5.678526,63.443,200 +9,GET,5.701584,56.958,200 +8,GET,5.711949,52.944,200 +3,GET,5.709587,57.757,200 +1,POST,5.719043,49.452,201 +0,GET,5.715552,54.606,200 +7,GET,5.725435,53.204,200 +4,POST,5.730855,51.905,201 +5,GET,5.733685,51.392,200 +2,GET,5.735915,51.848,200 +6,GET,5.741972,49.167,200 +9,GET,5.758545,54.546,200 +8,POST,5.764897,49.471,201 +3,POST,5.767348,51.509,201 +1,GET,5.7685,52.857,200 +0,POST,5.77016,52.675,201 +7,POST,5.778642,46.186,201 +5,POST,5.785081,50.754,201 +4,GET,5.782764,54.435,200 +2,POST,5.787776,50.997,201 +6,POST,5.791142,49.545,201 +9,POST,5.813094,48.344,201 +8,GET,5.814372,52.37,200 +3,GET,5.81886,57.483,200 +1,GET,5.82136,68.977,200 +7,GET,5.824831,67.836,200 +0,GET,5.822838,72.408,200 +5,GET,5.835853,73.891,200 +4,GET,5.837203,76.214,200 +2,GET,5.838777,82.067,200 +6,GET,5.84069,82.89,200 +9,GET,5.861443,81.335,200 +8,GET,5.866747,82.133,200 +3,GET,5.87635,78.893,200 +1,GET,5.890341,72.298,200 +7,GET,5.892672,72.228,200 +0,GET,5.895249,79.082,200 +5,GET,5.909747,66.621,200 +4,GET,5.91342,67.558,200 +2,GET,5.920847,64.308,200 +6,GET,5.923583,67.921,200 +9,GET,5.942782,62.81,200 +8,GET,5.948886,60.558,200 +3,GET,5.955247,57.585,200 +1,GET,5.962643,61.27,200 +7,GET,5.964904,63.675,200 +0,GET,5.974335,58.481,200 +5,GET,5.976373,61.515,200 +4,GET,5.980983,68.22,200 +2,GET,5.985158,69.843,200 +6,GET,5.991507,72.053,200 +9,GET,6.005595,74.026,200 +8,GET,6.009449,71.862,200 +3,GET,6.012838,74.432,200 +7,GET,6.028589,68.309,200 +1,POST,6.023917,74.846,201 +0,GET,6.032855,71.074,200 +5,GET,6.037894,68.582,200 +2,GET,6.055005,61.223,200 +4,POST,6.049206,68.322,201 +6,GET,6.063564,61.322,200 +9,GET,6.079625,61.604,200 +8,POST,6.081314,61.469,201 +7,POST,6.096901,48.77,201 +3,POST,6.087274,59.993,201 +1,GET,6.098767,55.167,200 +0,POST,6.103933,51.553,201 +5,POST,6.106484,51.149,201 +2,POST,6.116231,44.0,201 +4,GET,6.117538,49.318,200 +6,POST,6.124889,46.948,201 +9,POST,6.141233,39.177,201 +8,GET,6.142787,41.931,200 +7,GET,6.145675,45.59,200 +1,GET,6.153939,41.151,200 +3,GET,6.147269,57.268,200 +0,GET,6.155492,51.788,200 +5,GET,6.157636,57.787,200 +2,GET,6.160235,59.885,200 +4,GET,6.166859,62.268,200 +6,GET,6.171853,65.904,200 +9,GET,6.180415,68.954,200 +8,GET,6.184722,66.611,200 +7,GET,6.191276,67.952,200 +3,GET,6.204542,84.382,200 +1,GET,6.1951,97.833,200 +0,GET,6.207283,93.886,200 +5,GET,6.215428,87.971,200 +2,GET,6.220158,95.088,200 +4,GET,6.229131,91.863,200 +6,GET,6.237761,97.037,200 +9,GET,6.249374,146.755,200 +8,GET,6.251336,148.479,200 +7,GET,6.259232,152.124,200 +3,GET,6.288928,124.535,200 +1,GET,6.292937,131.089,200 +0,GET,6.301174,128.991,200 +5,GET,6.303404,187.381,200 +2,GET,6.315269,178.648,200 +4,GET,6.320997,181.701,200 +6,GET,6.334802,185.202,200 +9,GET,6.396133,130.296,200 +8,GET,6.39982,129.2,200 +7,GET,6.411413,181.218,200 +3,GET,6.413468,181.411,200 +1,POST,6.42403,179.385,201 +0,GET,6.430168,180.916,200 +5,GET,6.490789,128.123,200 +2,GET,6.493922,127.072,200 +4,POST,6.502702,129.267,201 +6,GET,6.520009,116.952,200 +9,GET,6.526435,167.137,200 +8,POST,6.529024,167.404,201 +7,POST,6.592638,106.725,201 +3,POST,6.594883,114.317,201 +1,GET,6.603418,113.745,200 +0,POST,6.611088,107.819,201 +5,POST,6.618916,105.485,201 +2,POST,6.620998,105.481,201 +6,POST,6.636965,96.807,201 +4,GET,6.631973,105.588,200 +8,GET,6.696433,47.546,200 +9,POST,6.693577,100.657,201 +7,GET,6.699365,97.408,200 +3,GET,6.709204,98.578,200 +1,GET,6.717168,104.145,200 +0,GET,6.718911,104.471,200 +5,GET,6.724404,166.522,200 +2,GET,6.726482,171.852,200 +6,GET,6.733776,167.264,200 +4,GET,6.737565,176.564,200 +8,GET,6.743983,172.186,200 +9,GET,6.794241,138.917,200 +7,GET,6.796779,193.662,200 +3,GET,6.807785,185.293,200 +0,GET,6.823386,189.307,200 +1,GET,6.821321,194.617,200 +2,GET,6.898348,131.616,200 +5,GET,6.890931,191.594,200 +6,GET,6.901044,186.928,200 +4,GET,6.914133,186.91,200 +8,GET,6.916172,187.005,200 +9,GET,6.933162,182.796,200 +7,GET,6.990446,132.02,200 +3,GET,6.993081,136.642,200 +1,GET,7.015942,122.238,200 +0,GET,7.0127,128.267,200 +5,GET,7.082529,113.264,200 +2,GET,7.02997,167.455,200 +4,GET,7.101048,100.69,200 +6,GET,7.087978,115.793,200 +8,GET,7.103181,114.007,200 +9,GET,7.115963,115.299,200 +7,GET,7.122476,113.779,200 +1,POST,7.138183,152.958,201 +3,GET,7.129728,162.239,200 +0,GET,7.140971,152.632,200 +5,GET,7.195797,104.603,200 +2,GET,7.197428,107.592,200 +4,POST,7.201741,108.662,201 +6,GET,7.203776,112.925,200 +8,POST,7.217192,105.801,201 +9,GET,7.231269,102.314,200 +7,POST,7.236262,98.545,201 +1,GET,7.291145,48.295,200 +3,POST,7.29197,49.229,201 +0,POST,7.293605,48.856,201 +5,POST,7.300403,47.663,201 +2,POST,7.305025,47.615,201 +6,POST,7.316705,43.169,201 +4,GET,7.310406,51.375,200 +8,GET,7.322996,44.945,200 +7,GET,7.33481,44.245,200 +9,POST,7.333588,46.868,201 +1,GET,7.339446,46.284,200 +0,GET,7.342464,49.925,200 +3,GET,7.341203,53.0,200 +5,GET,7.34807,50.263,200 +2,GET,7.352643,57.94,200 +6,GET,7.359881,52.168,200 +4,GET,7.361785,57.994,200 +8,GET,7.367945,59.201,200 +7,GET,7.37906,65.181,200 +9,GET,7.380458,67.158,200 +1,GET,7.385734,69.587,200 +0,GET,7.392397,70.199,200 +3,GET,7.394206,71.691,200 +5,GET,7.398338,79.776,200 +2,GET,7.410587,75.997,200 +6,GET,7.412053,86.288,200 +4,GET,7.419783,87.408,200 +8,GET,7.427149,83.538,200 +7,GET,7.444292,73.089,200 +1,GET,7.455324,68.794,200 +9,GET,7.44762,78.865,200 +0,GET,7.4626,73.116,200 +3,GET,7.4659,78.467,200 +5,GET,7.478118,82.038,200 +2,GET,7.486587,87.108,200 +6,GET,7.498344,86.516,200 +4,GET,7.507229,79.369,200 +8,GET,7.510691,84.128,200 +7,GET,7.517424,83.987,200 +1,POST,7.524122,79.621,201 +9,GET,7.526489,85.141,200 +0,GET,7.53572,81.347,200 +3,GET,7.544372,82.31,200 +5,GET,7.56016,77.244,200 +2,GET,7.573698,71.075,200 +6,GET,7.584863,66.607,200 +4,POST,7.586601,66.445,201 +8,POST,7.594841,59.297,201 +7,POST,7.601414,56.215,201 +1,GET,7.603746,61.458,200 +9,GET,7.611634,55.088,200 +0,POST,7.61707,56.089,201 +3,POST,7.626686,53.577,201 +5,POST,7.637407,52.464,201 +6,POST,7.651473,45.913,201 +8,GET,7.65414,44.151,200 +2,POST,7.644777,54.511,201 +4,GET,7.653049,48.655,200 +7,GET,7.657632,57.453,200 +9,POST,7.666725,49.746,201 +1,GET,7.665208,53.35,200 +0,GET,7.673163,60.033,200 +3,GET,7.680266,57.65,200 +5,GET,7.689876,60.38,200 +6,GET,7.69739,59.858,200 +2,GET,7.69929,67.768,200 +8,GET,7.698294,75.702,200 +4,GET,7.701708,77.762,200 +7,GET,7.715088,66.11,200 +9,GET,7.716475,73.871,200 +1,GET,7.718561,74.171,200 +0,GET,7.7332,74.161,200 +3,GET,7.73792,76.965,200 +6,GET,7.757251,67.173,200 +5,GET,7.750258,75.25,200 +2,GET,7.767072,65.962,200 +8,GET,7.774,61.711,200 +4,GET,7.779473,61.55,200 +7,GET,7.781201,67.7,200 +9,GET,7.79035,62.599,200 +1,GET,7.792734,71.982,200 +0,GET,7.80737,67.589,200 +3,GET,7.814889,67.23,200 +5,GET,7.82551,59.539,200 +6,GET,7.824427,62.63,200 +2,GET,7.833037,63.97,200 +8,GET,7.835715,70.74,200 +4,GET,7.841027,68.1,200 +7,GET,7.848906,65.069,200 +9,GET,7.852952,71.439,200 +1,POST,7.86472,67.148,201 +0,GET,7.874962,64.402,200 +3,GET,7.882123,59.07,200 +5,GET,7.885054,63.92,200 +8,POST,7.906458,47.07,201 +6,GET,7.887059,69.355,200 +2,GET,7.897011,62.002,200 +4,POST,7.90913,51.435,201 +7,POST,7.913978,56.927,201 +9,GET,7.924395,59.022,200 +1,GET,7.931872,56.558,200 +0,POST,7.939368,54.147,201 +3,POST,7.941197,55.162,201 +8,GET,7.953531,45.341,200 +6,POST,7.956417,43.809,201 +5,POST,7.948977,52.378,201 +2,POST,7.959016,45.673,201 +4,GET,7.960569,54.233,200 +7,GET,7.970908,52.451,200 +9,POST,7.983422,48.808,201 +1,GET,7.988436,46.797,200 +0,GET,7.99352,43.817,200 +3,GET,7.996362,48.699,200 +8,GET,7.998876,48.172,200 +6,GET,8.000229,56.451,200 +5,GET,8.001358,57.422,200 +2,GET,8.004692,61.492,200 +4,GET,8.014806,64.75,200 +7,GET,8.023363,65.251,200 +9,GET,8.032233,59.526,200 +1,GET,8.035236,65.356,200 +0,GET,8.03734,65.16,200 +3,GET,8.045065,65.965,200 +8,GET,8.047052,66.511,200 +6,GET,8.056684,65.902,200 +5,GET,8.058784,68.5,200 +2,GET,8.066188,69.625,200 +4,GET,8.07956,69.81,200 +7,GET,8.088617,62.065,200 +9,GET,8.091763,69.276,200 +0,GET,8.102503,60.451,200 +1,GET,8.100597,64.669,200 +3,GET,8.111033,56.477,200 +8,GET,8.113567,62.979,200 +6,GET,8.122589,61.361,200 +5,GET,8.127295,60.38,200 +2,GET,8.135816,67.38,200 +4,GET,8.149374,69.429,200 +7,GET,8.150686,78.966,200 +9,GET,8.161043,70.661,200 +0,GET,8.162959,77.567,200 +1,POST,8.165269,77.714,201 +3,GET,8.167513,80.421,200 +8,POST,8.17655,72.538,201 +6,GET,8.183954,71.66,200 +5,GET,8.187694,78.574,200 +2,GET,8.203199,65.504,200 +9,GET,8.231707,50.968,200 +4,POST,8.218806,69.628,201 +7,POST,8.229655,61.567,201 +0,POST,8.240532,51.668,201 +3,POST,8.247937,53.951,201 +1,GET,8.242986,61.406,200 +8,GET,8.249092,62.054,200 +6,POST,8.255624,70.211,201 +4,GET,8.288437,39.021,200 +2,POST,8.26873,60.06,201 +9,POST,8.282679,48.02,201 +5,POST,8.266271,65.868,201 +7,GET,8.291224,52.473,200 +0,GET,8.292203,54.399,200 +3,GET,8.301895,54.357,200 +1,GET,8.304396,56.694,200 +8,GET,8.311151,60.063,200 +6,GET,8.325838,58.582,200 +4,GET,8.327461,59.175,200 +2,GET,8.328792,59.062,200 +9,GET,8.330703,59.613,200 +5,GET,8.33214,69.41,200 +7,GET,8.343702,60.905,200 +0,GET,8.346606,60.737,200 +3,GET,8.356257,59.373,200 +1,GET,8.361095,62.226,200 +8,GET,8.371217,63.038,200 +6,GET,8.384424,52.835,200 +4,GET,8.38664,57.842,200 +2,GET,8.387857,58.105,200 +9,GET,8.390319,61.633,200 +5,GET,8.401554,52.888,200 +7,GET,8.40461,57.572,200 +0,GET,8.407346,57.527,200 +3,GET,8.415634,58.61,200 +1,GET,8.423324,56.951,200 +8,GET,8.434259,54.536,200 +6,GET,8.437263,55.075,200 +4,GET,8.444486,49.682,200 +2,GET,8.445965,54.585,200 +9,GET,8.451955,55.737,200 +5,GET,8.454446,56.166,200 +7,GET,8.462186,51.365,200 +0,GET,8.464876,61.597,200 +3,GET,8.474248,60.078,200 +1,POST,8.480277,62.684,201 +8,POST,8.488798,60.437,201 +4,POST,8.494172,58.25,201 +6,GET,8.49234,63.582,200 +2,GET,8.500553,64.07,200 +5,GET,8.510616,56.612,200 +9,GET,8.507695,69.574,200 +7,POST,8.513552,69.224,201 +0,POST,8.526476,62.032,201 +3,POST,8.53433,63.749,201 +1,GET,8.542965,64.14,200 +8,GET,8.549237,62.07,200 +6,POST,8.555926,63.42,201 +4,GET,8.552425,72.636,200 +2,POST,8.564627,70.135,201 +5,POST,8.567232,75.413,201 +9,POST,8.577273,75.839,201 +7,GET,8.582779,73.431,200 +0,GET,8.588514,84.961,200 +3,GET,8.598082,92.087,200 +1,GET,8.607109,88.227,200 +8,GET,8.611311,95.146,200 +6,GET,8.619349,94.112,200 +4,GET,8.625064,94.284,200 +2,GET,8.634769,87.522,200 +5,GET,8.64265,94.178,200 +9,GET,8.653115,97.763,200 +7,GET,8.656214,98.069,200 +0,GET,8.673484,88.288,200 +3,GET,8.690174,82.627,200 +1,GET,8.69534,79.421,200 +8,GET,8.70646,70.969,200 +6,GET,8.713464,72.205,200 +4,GET,8.719351,75.202,200 +2,GET,8.722294,77.672,200 +5,GET,8.736833,76.441,200 +9,GET,8.750881,67.822,200 +7,GET,8.754287,74.11,200 +0,GET,8.761775,73.599,200 +3,GET,8.772805,71.19,200 +1,GET,8.774765,71.473,200 +8,GET,8.777433,72.659,200 +6,GET,8.785675,76.318,200 +4,GET,8.794559,72.233,200 +2,GET,8.799972,68.941,200 +5,GET,8.81328,66.777,200 +9,GET,8.818708,66.666,200 +7,GET,8.828402,69.332,200 +0,GET,8.835378,68.355,200 +1,POST,8.846246,71.777,201 +8,POST,8.850099,69.207,201 +3,GET,8.843998,76.569,200 +6,GET,8.861996,65.621,200 +4,POST,8.866795,63.262,201 +2,GET,8.868915,78.364,200 +5,GET,8.880059,72.029,200 +9,GET,8.885378,80.01,200 +7,POST,8.89774,68.983,201 +0,POST,8.903738,65.739,201 +1,GET,8.918035,63.098,200 +8,GET,8.919309,64.238,200 +3,POST,8.920571,65.789,201 +4,GET,8.930061,68.197,200 +6,POST,8.927622,81.324,201 +7,GET,8.966728,44.116,200 +9,POST,8.965392,46.527,201 +2,POST,8.947283,65.448,201 +5,POST,8.952094,61.381,201 +0,GET,8.96948,54.841,200 +1,GET,8.981141,48.249,200 +8,GET,8.983551,48.224,200 +3,GET,8.986364,47.947,200 +4,GET,8.998261,50.968,200 +6,GET,9.008958,58.101,200 +7,GET,9.010847,62.67,200 +9,GET,9.011922,64.142,200 +2,GET,9.012733,66.685,200 +5,GET,9.013477,74.698,200 +8,GET,9.031779,63.432,200 +0,GET,9.024326,73.866,200 +1,GET,9.029396,71.171,200 +3,GET,9.034315,76.44,200 +4,GET,9.049234,68.341,200 +6,GET,9.067063,64.405,200 +7,GET,9.07352,64.562,200 +9,GET,9.076068,63.641,200 +2,GET,9.079421,67.102,200 +8,GET,9.095214,53.156,200 +0,GET,9.098195,57.874,200 +5,GET,9.08818,70.102,200 +1,GET,9.100571,65.729,200 +3,GET,9.11076,58.901,200 +4,GET,9.117578,62.93,200 +6,GET,9.131473,61.377,200 +7,GET,9.138087,59.551,200 +9,GET,9.139712,61.668,200 +2,GET,9.146525,61.797,200 +8,POST,9.148374,62.689,201 +0,GET,9.156072,56.922,200 +5,GET,9.158284,57.382,200 +1,POST,9.166303,56.241,201 +3,GET,9.169664,64.546,200 +4,POST,9.180513,56.305,201 +6,GET,9.192854,61.368,200 +7,POST,9.19764,57.942,201 +9,GET,9.201384,61.23,200 +2,GET,9.208327,62.434,200 +0,POST,9.213002,58.983,201 +8,GET,9.211065,62.791,200 +5,GET,9.21567,73.936,200 +3,POST,9.234214,59.473,201 +1,GET,9.222548,76.38,200 +4,GET,9.236822,79.736,200 +6,POST,9.254226,78.25,201 +7,GET,9.255586,77.844,200 +9,POST,9.262619,75.47,201 +0,GET,9.271988,70.503,200 +2,POST,9.270766,74.618,201 +8,GET,9.27386,77.775,200 +5,POST,9.289611,70.64,201 +3,GET,9.293693,72.625,200 +1,GET,9.298934,71.452,200 +4,GET,9.316562,64.653,200 +6,GET,9.332479,66.033,200 +7,GET,9.33344,67.006,200 +9,GET,9.338094,71.59,200 +0,GET,9.342496,72.453,200 +2,GET,9.345388,74.207,200 +8,GET,9.351639,71.18,200 +5,GET,9.360257,75.623,200 +3,GET,9.366323,74.472,200 +1,GET,9.370394,75.365,200 +4,GET,9.381219,73.259,200 +6,GET,9.398516,73.86,200 +7,GET,9.400451,73.322,200 +9,GET,9.409689,71.316,200 +0,GET,9.414952,73.02,200 +2,GET,9.419599,72.196,200 +8,GET,9.422824,74.762,200 +5,GET,9.435883,63.544,200 +3,GET,9.440799,66.024,200 +1,GET,9.445762,67.488,200 +4,GET,9.454482,60.905,200 +6,GET,9.47238,56.713,200 +7,GET,9.473776,61.051,200 +0,GET,9.487976,50.113,200 +9,GET,9.481012,63.769,200 +2,GET,9.491798,56.55,200 +8,POST,9.49759,52.109,201 +3,GET,9.506826,52.099,200 +1,POST,9.513254,48.439,201 +5,GET,9.49943,63.184,200 +4,POST,9.51539,49.746,201 +6,GET,9.529098,51.628,200 +7,POST,9.53483,52.268,201 +9,GET,9.544784,46.165,200 +0,POST,9.538093,53.808,201 +2,GET,9.548351,51.485,200 +8,GET,9.549701,55.898,200 +1,GET,9.561696,46.557,200 +3,POST,9.558928,50.36,201 +5,GET,9.562619,56.209,200 +4,GET,9.56514,62.655,200 +6,POST,9.580729,62.516,201 +9,POST,9.590952,57.914,201 +7,GET,9.5871,65.626,200 +2,POST,9.599843,63.164,201 +0,GET,9.591904,74.61,200 +1,GET,9.608256,69.641,200 +8,GET,9.605603,74.147,200 +5,POST,9.618831,67.667,201 +3,GET,9.609293,79.45,200 +4,GET,9.627798,72.604,200 +6,GET,9.643248,75.985,200 +7,GET,9.652729,70.299,200 +9,GET,9.64887,83.781,200 +2,GET,9.66301,79.717,200 +0,GET,9.666518,87.083,200 +1,GET,9.6779,80.193,200 +8,GET,9.679754,81.682,200 +5,GET,9.686503,87.581,200 +3,GET,9.688756,89.619,200 +4,GET,9.700407,95.829,200 +6,GET,9.719237,93.238,200 +7,GET,9.723032,91.496,200 +9,GET,9.732655,83.836,200 +1,GET,9.758096,66.78,200 +2,GET,9.74273,87.365,200 +8,GET,9.76144,71.041,200 +0,GET,9.753606,83.414,200 +5,GET,9.774089,68.921,200 +3,GET,9.778384,71.665,200 +4,GET,9.796271,70.118,200 +6,GET,9.812479,66.106,200 +1,POST,9.824879,58.151,201 +7,GET,9.814535,69.482,200 +9,GET,9.816494,70.003,200 +2,GET,9.830099,68.665,200 +0,GET,9.837024,69.587,200 +8,POST,9.832484,76.865,201 +5,GET,9.843014,76.717,200 +3,GET,9.850053,79.51,200 +4,POST,9.866392,72.952,201 +7,POST,9.88402,57.419,201 +6,GET,9.878589,64.544,200 +1,GET,9.883034,69.749,200 +9,GET,9.8865,68.544,200 +2,GET,9.898805,63.462,200 +0,POST,9.906618,57.293,201 +8,GET,9.909354,67.593,200 +3,POST,9.929567,48.628,201 +5,GET,9.919735,60.688,200 +4,GET,9.939348,63.627,200 +6,POST,9.943136,61.802,201 +7,GET,9.941442,67.069,200 +9,POST,9.955047,61.822,201 +1,GET,9.952786,64.239,200 +2,POST,9.96227,61.257,201 +0,GET,9.963913,61.287,200 +3,GET,9.978198,49.563,200 +5,POST,9.980426,47.548,201 +8,GET,9.97695,55.011,200 diff --git a/evidence/http-resources.json b/evidence/http-resources.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..658d7ede --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/http-resources.json @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +[ + { + "elapsed_s": 1.946, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "91.99%", + "Container": "708c0b14bcabe0bb0be47442021e3d8ec55216233ab670f9b65f29ebe87e86fd", + "ID": "708c0b14bcab", + "MemPerc": "18.54%", + "MemUsage": "47.47MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-api-1", + "NetIO": "3.03MB / 2.85MB", + "PIDs": "3" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 1.946, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "2.44%", + "Container": "ac5c6c65019c906f0a2284b60a2bd70967d8a7e43525195fcaece09eef0c72d9", + "ID": "ac5c6c65019c", + "MemPerc": "12.76%", + "MemUsage": "8.164MiB / 64MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-cache-1", + "NetIO": "52.7kB / 82kB", + "PIDs": "6" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 1.946, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "19.95%", + "Container": "85dd609cc3ea3334e57ca89675de2511a61335046299ec29594c78ad72cedec0", + "ID": "85dd609cc3ea", + "MemPerc": "9.77%", + "MemUsage": "25MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-db-1", + "NetIO": "483kB / 2.76MB", + "PIDs": "11" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 5.872, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "97.06%", + "Container": "708c0b14bcabe0bb0be47442021e3d8ec55216233ab670f9b65f29ebe87e86fd", + "ID": "708c0b14bcab", + "MemPerc": "18.71%", + "MemUsage": "47.89MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-api-1", + "NetIO": "32MB / 31.7MB", + "PIDs": "3" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 5.872, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "2.53%", + "Container": "ac5c6c65019c906f0a2284b60a2bd70967d8a7e43525195fcaece09eef0c72d9", + "ID": "ac5c6c65019c", + "MemPerc": "12.95%", + "MemUsage": "8.289MiB / 64MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-cache-1", + "NetIO": "135kB / 218kB", + "PIDs": "6" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 5.872, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "22.76%", + "Container": "85dd609cc3ea3334e57ca89675de2511a61335046299ec29594c78ad72cedec0", + "ID": "85dd609cc3ea", + "MemPerc": "9.89%", + "MemUsage": "25.31MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-db-1", + "NetIO": "1.14MB / 24MB", + "PIDs": "11" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 9.786, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "100.05%", + "Container": "708c0b14bcabe0bb0be47442021e3d8ec55216233ab670f9b65f29ebe87e86fd", + "ID": "708c0b14bcab", + "MemPerc": "18.68%", + "MemUsage": "47.83MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-api-1", + "NetIO": "58.7MB / 58.4MB", + "PIDs": "3" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 9.786, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "1.82%", + "Container": "ac5c6c65019c906f0a2284b60a2bd70967d8a7e43525195fcaece09eef0c72d9", + "ID": "ac5c6c65019c", + "MemPerc": "12.95%", + "MemUsage": "8.289MiB / 64MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-cache-1", + "NetIO": "189kB / 303kB", + "PIDs": "6" + }, + { + "elapsed_s": 9.786, + "BlockIO": "0B / 0B", + "CPUPerc": "23.73%", + "Container": "85dd609cc3ea3334e57ca89675de2511a61335046299ec29594c78ad72cedec0", + "ID": "85dd609cc3ea", + "MemPerc": "9.93%", + "MemUsage": "25.43MiB / 256MiB", + "Name": "mtusi2026lab2-db-1", + "NetIO": "1.89MB / 50MB", + "PIDs": "11" + } +] diff --git a/evidence/http-summary.json b/evidence/http-summary.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..561b7293 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/http-summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +{ + "warmup_s": 2, + "duration_s": 10.033, + "concurrency": 10, + "profile": "closed-loop: 1 write then 4 history reads per worker; 1000-character messages", + "requests": 1368, + "success_rps": 136.35, + "error_fraction": 0.0, + "p50_ms": 66.607, + "p95_ms": 122.238, + "p99_ms": 181.218, + "statuses": { + "200": 1088, + "201": 280 + }, + "resource_source": "Docker stats samples; CPU percent is host-core percentage, memory is cgroup working set" +} diff --git a/evidence/index-restore.json b/evidence/index-restore.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..43042744 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/index-restore.json @@ -0,0 +1,3948 @@ +{ + "version": "PostgreSQL 17.11 (Debian 17.11-1.pgdg12+2) on x86_64-pc-linux-gnu, compiled by gcc (Debian 12.2.0-14+deb12u1) 12.2.0, 64-bit", + "rows": 120000, + "chat_sizes": [ + 100000, + 15000, + 5000 + ], + "repeats": 5, + "plans": [ + { + "index": "primary_only", + "query": "keyset", + "execution_ms": [ + 19.717, + 73.474, + 13.974, + 13.225, + 74.636 + ], + "median_ms": 19.717, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 6317.68, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.917, + "Actual Total Time": 19.544, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 10356.73, + "Plan Rows": 34668, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.915, + "Actual Total Time": 19.537, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5311.82, + "Total Cost": 5355.16, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 11.424, + "Actual Total Time": 11.428, + "Actual Rows": 44, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4736.0, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 3.461, + "Actual Total Time": 9.44, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.104, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 19.717 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 6317.68, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.713, + "Actual Total Time": 73.441, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 10356.73, + "Plan Rows": 34668, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.711, + "Actual Total Time": 73.434, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5311.82, + "Total Cost": 5355.16, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 6.954, + "Actual Total Time": 6.956, + "Actual Rows": 40, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4736.0, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 3.649, + "Actual Total Time": 6.153, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.135, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 73.474 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 6317.68, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 11.211, + "Actual Total Time": 13.897, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 10356.73, + "Plan Rows": 34668, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 11.209, + "Actual Total Time": 13.892, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5311.82, + "Total Cost": 5355.16, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 7.629, + "Actual Total Time": 7.632, + "Actual Rows": 44, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4736.0, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 3.991, + "Actual Total Time": 6.827, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.414, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 13.974 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 6317.68, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 10.389, + "Actual Total Time": 13.206, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 10356.73, + "Plan Rows": 34668, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 10.388, + "Actual Total Time": 13.201, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5311.82, + "Total Cost": 5355.16, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 7.704, + "Actual Total Time": 7.706, + "Actual Rows": 44, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4736.0, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.052, + "Actual Total Time": 6.858, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.152, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 13.225 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 6317.68, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 71.8, + "Actual Total Time": 74.612, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6311.85, + "Total Cost": 10356.73, + "Plan Rows": 34668, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 71.799, + "Actual Total Time": 74.607, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5311.82, + "Total Cost": 5355.16, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 47.208, + "Actual Total Time": 47.211, + "Actual Rows": 44, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3891, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4736.0, + "Plan Rows": 17334, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 43.141, + "Actual Total Time": 46.138, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.162, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 74.636 + } + ] + }, + { + "index": "primary_only", + "query": "offset", + "execution_ms": [ + 128.966, + 184.693, + 110.659, + 178.235, + 171.559 + ], + "median_ms": 171.559, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21386.34, + "Total Cost": 21392.17, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 115.487, + "Actual Total Time": 124.548, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2595, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2961, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13219.1, + "Total Cost": 22912.44, + "Plan Rows": 83080, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 78.595, + "Actual Total Time": 121.852, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2595, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2961, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12219.08, + "Total Cost": 12322.93, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 57.285, + "Actual Total Time": 63.136, + "Actual Rows": 23483, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 10288, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2595, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2961, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6728, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6632, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4486.0, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.012, + "Actual Total Time": 6.455, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.112, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 128.966 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21386.34, + "Total Cost": 21392.17, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 175.321, + "Actual Total Time": 183.158, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2368, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13219.1, + "Total Cost": 22912.44, + "Plan Rows": 83080, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 73.494, + "Actual Total Time": 180.507, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2368, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12219.08, + "Total Cost": 12322.93, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 65.002, + "Actual Total Time": 70.766, + "Actual Rows": 23484, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 10024, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2368, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4486.0, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.031, + "Actual Total Time": 18.774, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.115, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 184.693 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21386.34, + "Total Cost": 21392.17, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 103.446, + "Actual Total Time": 108.434, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2495, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13219.1, + "Total Cost": 22912.44, + "Plan Rows": 83080, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 65.872, + "Actual Total Time": 105.917, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2495, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12219.08, + "Total Cost": 12322.93, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 49.533, + "Actual Total Time": 56.887, + "Actual Rows": 23467, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 12328, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2495, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 4512, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4486.0, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.018, + "Actual Total Time": 6.581, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.124, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 110.659 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21386.34, + "Total Cost": 21392.17, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 168.071, + "Actual Total Time": 175.13, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2602, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13219.1, + "Total Cost": 22912.44, + "Plan Rows": 83080, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 68.472, + "Actual Total Time": 172.41, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2602, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12219.08, + "Total Cost": 12322.93, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 63.676, + "Actual Total Time": 71.654, + "Actual Rows": 23499, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 11464, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2602, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 5368, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4486.0, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.011, + "Actual Total Time": 34.255, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.113, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 178.235 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21386.34, + "Total Cost": 21392.17, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 111.806, + "Actual Total Time": 169.057, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2610, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13219.1, + "Total Cost": 22912.44, + "Plan Rows": 83080, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 72.626, + "Actual Total Time": 166.507, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2610, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12219.08, + "Total Cost": 12322.93, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 37.29, + "Actual Total Time": 43.569, + "Actual Rows": 23489, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 11072, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3949, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2610, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 5768, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4486.0, + "Plan Rows": 41540, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.011, + "Actual Total Time": 6.339, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 3861, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.324, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 171.559 + } + ] + }, + { + "index": "chat_index", + "query": "keyset", + "execution_ms": [ + 13.441, + 14.577, + 70.087, + 13.662, + 83.644 + ], + "median_ms": 14.577, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 6475.28, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.635, + "Actual Total Time": 13.414, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 10518.53, + "Plan Rows": 34704, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.633, + "Actual Total Time": 13.409, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5469.42, + "Total Cost": 5512.8, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 7.106, + "Actual Total Time": 7.114, + "Actual Rows": 34, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4893.0, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.085, + "Actual Total Time": 6.321, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.121, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 13.441 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 6475.28, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.733, + "Actual Total Time": 14.535, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 10518.53, + "Plan Rows": 34704, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.731, + "Actual Total Time": 14.529, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5469.42, + "Total Cost": 5512.8, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 7.013, + "Actual Total Time": 7.015, + "Actual Rows": 40, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4893.0, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.152, + "Actual Total Time": 6.279, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.23, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 14.577 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 6475.28, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 66.561, + "Actual Total Time": 69.897, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 10518.53, + "Plan Rows": 34704, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 66.559, + "Actual Total Time": 69.891, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5469.42, + "Total Cost": 5512.8, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 63.233, + "Actual Total Time": 63.236, + "Actual Rows": 44, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4893.0, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.659, + "Actual Total Time": 62.023, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.323, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 70.087 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 6475.28, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 10.64, + "Actual Total Time": 13.635, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 10518.53, + "Plan Rows": 34704, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 10.639, + "Actual Total Time": 13.63, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5469.42, + "Total Cost": 5512.8, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 7.67, + "Actual Total Time": 7.672, + "Actual Rows": 40, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4893.0, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.498, + "Actual Total Time": 6.888, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.254, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 13.662 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 6475.28, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.035, + "Actual Total Time": 83.613, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 6469.44, + "Total Cost": 10518.53, + "Plan Rows": 34704, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.033, + "Actual Total Time": 83.6, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 5469.42, + "Total Cost": 5512.8, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 9.531, + "Actual Total Time": 9.535, + "Actual Rows": 40, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4048, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "top-N heapsort", + "Sort Space Used": 37, + "Sort Space Type": "Memory" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4893.0, + "Plan Rows": 17352, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 4.371, + "Actual Total Time": 8.113, + "Actual Rows": 10000, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 30000, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.212, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 83.644 + } + ] + }, + { + "index": "chat_index", + "query": "offset", + "execution_ms": [ + 186.094, + 127.692, + 180.612, + 172.957, + 137.825 + ], + "median_ms": 172.957, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21570.35, + "Total Cost": 21576.18, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 179.759, + "Actual Total Time": 184.506, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2472, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13403.11, + "Total Cost": 23132.62, + "Plan Rows": 83390, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 75.651, + "Actual Total Time": 181.264, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2472, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12403.09, + "Total Cost": 12507.33, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 67.613, + "Actual Total Time": 76.427, + "Actual Rows": 23427, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 13424, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2472, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6752, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 3472, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4643.0, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.011, + "Actual Total Time": 6.626, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.599, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 186.094 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21570.35, + "Total Cost": 21576.18, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 121.578, + "Actual Total Time": 125.884, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2429, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13403.11, + "Total Cost": 23132.62, + "Plan Rows": 83390, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 75.407, + "Actual Total Time": 123.341, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2429, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12403.09, + "Total Cost": 12507.33, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 38.978, + "Actual Total Time": 47.258, + "Actual Rows": 23478, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 10584, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2429, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6248, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4643.0, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.036, + "Actual Total Time": 23.273, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.221, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 127.692 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21570.35, + "Total Cost": 21576.18, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 173.229, + "Actual Total Time": 178.848, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2366, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13403.11, + "Total Cost": 23132.62, + "Plan Rows": 83390, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 66.691, + "Actual Total Time": 176.043, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2366, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12403.09, + "Total Cost": 12507.33, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 60.451, + "Actual Total Time": 69.222, + "Actual Rows": 23457, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 10080, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2366, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2962, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6752, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4643.0, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.009, + "Actual Total Time": 8.403, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.395, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 180.612 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21570.35, + "Total Cost": 21576.18, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 166.129, + "Actual Total Time": 171.345, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2699, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2960, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13403.11, + "Total Cost": 23132.62, + "Plan Rows": 83390, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 73.732, + "Actual Total Time": 168.696, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2699, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2960, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12403.09, + "Total Cost": 12507.33, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 68.905, + "Actual Total Time": 75.136, + "Actual Rows": 23506, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 9592, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2699, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2960, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 8480, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 5568, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4643.0, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.009, + "Actual Total Time": 21.533, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.109, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 172.957 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 21570.35, + "Total Cost": 21576.18, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 129.959, + "Actual Total Time": 135.199, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2543, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Gather Merge", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 13403.11, + "Total Cost": 23132.62, + "Plan Rows": 83390, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 88.783, + "Actual Total Time": 132.415, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Workers Planned": 2, + "Workers Launched": 2, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2543, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Sort", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 12403.09, + "Total Cost": 12507.33, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 63.737, + "Actual Total Time": 71.064, + "Actual Rows": 23478, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Sort Key": [ + "created_at", + "id" + ], + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 10512, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk", + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4106, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 2543, + "Temp Written Blocks": 2963, + "Workers": [ + { + "Worker Number": 0, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6328, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + }, + { + "Worker Number": 1, + "Sort Method": "external merge", + "Sort Space Used": 6816, + "Sort Space Type": "Disk" + } + ], + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Seq Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": true, + "Async Capable": false, + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.0, + "Total Cost": 4643.0, + "Plan Rows": 41695, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.015, + "Actual Total Time": 26.824, + "Actual Rows": 33333, + "Actual Loops": 3, + "Filter": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Filter": 6667, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 4018, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Workers": [] + } + ] + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.472, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 137.825 + } + ] + }, + { + "index": "compound", + "query": "keyset", + "execution_ms": [ + 0.049, + 0.196, + 0.029, + 0.094, + 0.029 + ], + "median_ms": 0.049, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16.52, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.012, + "Actual Total Time": 0.035, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 13376.95, + "Plan Rows": 41523, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.011, + "Actual Total Time": 0.031, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.111, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 0.049 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16.52, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.01, + "Actual Total Time": 0.112, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 13376.95, + "Plan Rows": 41523, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.01, + "Actual Total Time": 0.102, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.083, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 0.196 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16.52, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.008, + "Actual Total Time": 0.02, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 13376.95, + "Plan Rows": 41523, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.007, + "Actual Total Time": 0.017, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.063, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 0.029 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16.52, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.024, + "Actual Total Time": 0.064, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 13376.95, + "Plan Rows": 41523, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.023, + "Actual Total Time": 0.053, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.216, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 0.094 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16.52, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.008, + "Actual Total Time": 0.02, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 13376.95, + "Plan Rows": 41523, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.007, + "Actual Total Time": 0.016, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "((chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid) AND (ROW(created_at, id) > ROW('2026-01-01 00:01:10+00'::timestamp with time zone, '696c0138-3d4f-bd16-e6b0-c1b6fff540ec'::uuid)))", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 6, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.052, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 0.029 + } + ] + }, + { + "index": "compound", + "query": "offset", + "execution_ms": [ + 19.838, + 19.25, + 13.916, + 14.827, + 14.409 + ], + "median_ms": 14.827, + "plans": [ + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 11647.76, + "Total Cost": 11656.08, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 19.809, + "Actual Total Time": 19.82, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16600.21, + "Plan Rows": 99764, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.011, + "Actual Total Time": 17.815, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.1, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 19.838 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 11647.76, + "Total Cost": 11656.08, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 19.195, + "Actual Total Time": 19.208, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16600.21, + "Plan Rows": 99764, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.069, + "Actual Total Time": 17.045, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.44, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 19.25 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 11647.76, + "Total Cost": 11656.08, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 13.85, + "Actual Total Time": 13.892, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16600.21, + "Plan Rows": 99764, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.032, + "Actual Total Time": 11.926, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.218, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 13.916 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 11647.76, + "Total Cost": 11656.08, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.803, + "Actual Total Time": 14.812, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16600.21, + "Plan Rows": 99764, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.018, + "Actual Total Time": 12.965, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.234, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 14.827 + }, + { + "Plan": { + "Node Type": "Limit", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Startup Cost": 11647.76, + "Total Cost": 11656.08, + "Plan Rows": 50, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 14.375, + "Actual Total Time": 14.385, + "Actual Rows": 50, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0, + "Plans": [ + { + "Node Type": "Index Scan", + "Parent Relationship": "Outer", + "Parallel Aware": false, + "Async Capable": false, + "Scan Direction": "Forward", + "Index Name": "experiment_idx", + "Relation Name": "messages", + "Alias": "messages", + "Startup Cost": 0.42, + "Total Cost": 16600.21, + "Plan Rows": 99764, + "Plan Width": 225, + "Actual Startup Time": 0.028, + "Actual Total Time": 12.328, + "Actual Rows": 70050, + "Actual Loops": 1, + "Index Cond": "(chat_id = '64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171'::uuid)", + "Rows Removed by Index Recheck": 0, + "Shared Hit Blocks": 2754, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + } + ] + }, + "Planning": { + "Shared Hit Blocks": 0, + "Shared Read Blocks": 0, + "Shared Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Shared Written Blocks": 0, + "Local Hit Blocks": 0, + "Local Read Blocks": 0, + "Local Dirtied Blocks": 0, + "Local Written Blocks": 0, + "Temp Read Blocks": 0, + "Temp Written Blocks": 0 + }, + "Planning Time": 0.187, + "Triggers": [], + "Execution Time": 14.409 + } + ] + } + ], + "writes": [ + { + "index": "primary_only", + "batch_rows": 5000, + "committed_ms": [ + 194.955, + 130.708, + 105.758, + 112.982, + 107.794 + ], + "median_ms": 112.982 + }, + { + "index": "chat_index", + "batch_rows": 5000, + "committed_ms": [ + 134.971, + 163.012, + 176.464, + 132.247, + 119.119 + ], + "median_ms": 134.971 + }, + { + "index": "compound", + "batch_rows": 5000, + "committed_ms": [ + 165.151, + 123.352, + 125.609, + 140.445, + 145.072 + ], + "median_ms": 140.445 + } + ], + "snapshot": { + "counts": { + "users": 1, + "chats": 3, + "members": 3, + "messages": 120000, + "sessions": 0 + }, + "selected": [ + [ + "00007f59-a9d2-3b84-3ef6-091415782365", + "88255127-540c-95c6-cac6-18d9e4630a5b", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-109350", + "2026-01-01T00:01:49.350000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0001e8fa-aaff-dcf0-e91a-76b3ce513a5a", + "88255127-540c-95c6-cac6-18d9e4630a5b", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-101333", + "2026-01-01T00:01:41.333000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0001fe5c-dac5-95be-e3c2-98a08c99a1c5", + "88255127-540c-95c6-cac6-18d9e4630a5b", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-104987", + "2026-01-01T00:01:44.987000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000209d4-d5f3-45da-b78b-66295ca75999", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-79772", + "2026-01-01T00:01:19.772000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000251f9-16b9-e4e3-a885-72d4a8047563", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-16308", + "2026-01-01T00:00:16.308000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0002b449-3bc2-28d4-c8a5-949664801557", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-29651", + "2026-01-01T00:00:29.651000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000313b0-ff0e-d495-0396-6e648ab33022", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-76332", + "2026-01-01T00:01:16.332000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000341d0-5544-f48f-fa05-f45f76dbc946", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-83651", + "2026-01-01T00:01:23.651000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0003c8a7-b0d7-99c1-dabf-45599abb2dcf", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-3460", + "2026-01-01T00:00:03.460000+00:00" + ], + [ + "00048192-4d3d-3489-843c-cdfe54d65984", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-53856", + "2026-01-01T00:00:53.856000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0004b478-630d-6fc0-e9f7-10f8ef2f0ffb", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-15792", + "2026-01-01T00:00:15.792000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0004e22f-10fc-ee50-40c6-a8fffc910cfc", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-60822", + "2026-01-01T00:01:00.822000+00:00" + ], + [ + "00052d15-f4e7-d68b-269e-eeb7f90ab192", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-90960", + "2026-01-01T00:01:30.960000+00:00" + ], + [ + "00061b8b-7e6c-7660-1881-a72e5c006355", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-53908", + "2026-01-01T00:00:53.908000+00:00" + ], + [ + "00061f5e-d8e9-2727-ce0b-66d5c1f929c4", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-9014", + "2026-01-01T00:00:09.014000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0007f005-203e-29ee-e42e-4f7bd8c8ce55", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-39009", + "2026-01-01T00:00:39.009000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000894ce-771d-b0c5-4257-c0f11ba3738b", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-50802", + "2026-01-01T00:00:50.802000+00:00" + ], + [ + "0009890d-722b-c19a-423a-4256dcd2f4d8", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-90624", + "2026-01-01T00:01:30.624000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000a09f8-b6a1-5757-366d-e31e47f20ceb", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-32627", + "2026-01-01T00:00:32.627000+00:00" + ], + [ + "000af189-7b90-0d83-02d6-a2a1b6f7cb7d", + "64fbbeee-3c1b-b5be-9d4f-5bd05fe83171", + "00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001", + "payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-payload-17917", + "2026-01-01T00:00:17.917000+00:00" + ] + ], + "all_messages_digest": "897c5828c0607c030860f5537915650a" + }, + "backup": { + "seconds": 1.247, + "bytes": 3592366, + "sha256": "bb3aa237912e8427554885f7c3b183224b405a03a97a5a3f44acbc9d08fcd9a5" + }, + "restore": { + "seconds_including_startup": 4.026, + "fresh_volume": "lab2-restore-2d6df06983", + "published_ports": false, + "counts": { + "users": 1, + "chats": 3, + "members": 3, + "messages": 120000, + "sessions": 0 + }, + "all_messages_digest": "897c5828c0607c030860f5537915650a", + "selected_20_match": true, + "verified": true + }, + "limitations": "Warm-cache serial variants on one local host; logical backup snapshot, no WAL/PITR; synthetic DB retained for inspection.", + "database": "experiment_2d6df06983" +} diff --git a/evidence/indexes.png b/evidence/indexes.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3a534e63af5827b572326788b63f26db2d98d9a1 GIT binary patch literal 80950 zcmb5VXH=72_wI`#qDZkL-9~Rpkq#;fNbg8!DuzxdA@qP^L6oKvklsV@JwOmqKzi>G zkxnSm5=aQ_m3RN&ea;yBd^s7z@!%tA_qx|y*SzNM3e(qBXJTMyprN5*dZO{jkcQ^; z9~zpIeP>RC|MMJK%?JJ?@Adepmyw&Dm(O!gD2>i@FLxI=FBiub*S(>ha7QXT&x@(xjX=tt`QvaNIf_M`{bApEE$)g9x zzDaA-XB)!zj*pLJBBd2RD`^?T78+c*vCccd_hkOk?-4#;M{z+d!HG(Tipq3DZz1!q zA3t=&ijH^QYnt4lP@0y4ljSN>B$txpmJ~N?CS`3G6P%0d2zdWSn-U+f)ZQgY@c#ev z_uG#f1`Ot!}))HK5zf>JNQWd^YC~?!~EZ$X+GRK>HdHIa-Z|UtN-T}{(b;2 zab1T```a_mg$^hWe5t3qukPSq3(MrD(%z8K;9kHzw;7k#NG@l2#Oh036^fTpuKo?9 zwEHKF@(g(gvB&^P$AR1Mzdz4@)#&^|ZckRI5wvcobsQ^AXOneLGj9q)+UYq(dhGvu zzSALG@=Z&;amYAVzj?kl6?a+C@TYN!^>k9eM%^M|(oN-oMn%^XQ6$c~jM+(g^v~7_$o5-W*TvfKbm-}v1JZnBF`Qqmp_%vcP zKHsE()Kp?pV47zg+M=|Z_yTdb?@{5opeY%2=sTFH&SF$zt@Je}W}e4hDw0#~#Z_@@ zm)3ALTa4Gr3#XAn$C|3}G5%jpE$^8YDMVb&Wbn>n_qwu3EQL^J+ty`fgM@Bi$uRQ4 zS3TwN`R>Hg4KsFWr@l zNHyjZJ1!Y17Kt~pK9K6Dyl_xf6|S$%OUAar;zhRx7X1d4|~^r&;jn z$n>7D_bfcHYM1egyA=uOXKm!bgY9^*#^aQKU=3dOmW6nJhqWTYH;0 z6?AXW)3P6m;EQ;tm=r$kPm#PTW;w>)25a0K$&LI>V(L#)a2$UWaO8eWAtsXc@RM*| zQPm<9R-3>wzty~)u41ctZKqRWb9qKNYKP%iE&MAYe0K3c>CTkRO>_tg%_}Ki@GS%7la}w=_areU$Ek)gSK%zOHBnyV$R}U<4#1~gIF3l? zUP=wdx{VfFVIP@ao#j5*St2$bk?`0@X^2*x(bfnKm80bXgG@E!&iP1%jWY_x z;PQ@}WjqS|Fy}Z~UE~JV@DuD zxv|9c9{UFQugBVmM{{yXcZ!n2YVWk)QnCSMQ5i`Z^W*#&q$)KRw)j-Rb6&%yIfQO7 zkoki49|`Pge!K~GO;^dAFl{c!2M`w20k*%($M^nb^r6Kc*AA! zO}R=8UAf~R-z0-kQ5fpijh&@l88b_d#}8lr_#MtB*>yxAud9m6f(3E57|xeo4?d>Y z!|K=X?R3lFUJ_o~Sp*Q)%Ho|m?ir)?Yhcq|Npf%(tryUG!HUIXpP91wyB#0SErFZ7 zf(^!Q|N9GXw{4V?U97kb%zIZYl) zW08HwmyaVlGSl-mZmLR)-HA&)NAEdcrA6t38IUTcMH0S5#y%Ngny*|^SR>gZ+v2r8 zAw4UBJ1Gd)iKqAf`2vSURwHUh9HC6b){PUzZID!(z^%uVFD%)vLVBw<&o0z0rATI~ zM^*QV*RM(JfKo8I_tf0HJ3+c4-jO&3*E1HKRqdBTEcZ1Z?)0kMGkQ4gG+FIhG5MA- zTkbylu)g?RC&Xy+C#Yo3PQ&?7v|cLAdu{BwX%Pe(SD_s*@yqV=`wZfqg_m~Uy*ykl zE+1Ej6H8!C;HQahZ(DR&IW%1Q1=hQw?G)5Q>0th=cT)`lZ(7e|LO94Z$m{|;-nF8@ zCg=c~D9RdMp4r$I?6a}n;|I#4ZE?ePM{Y%eWC&Vs$+_dIbAQHT?KX3;CnLK>jH(kC zKSkQe^Nkc)jAD;Lef`$_hF+aBwS449veq7cRD5konyKTDQEa-z4=-&p_-^ZEHcK?} z1pL@l*Wp+CAFql!9j{K^FqHmKGvhBjZvWS>D60)D4HQcuSPV7>_yoXmwEc^0<`W zy|1Y{7|JthVFpKmHEtkV>kXE;nCM1o8!UaUiUYgpVdT=Vna!U4;PO?|OyU6*Ih>rNn0jP#VGP2wXwDSM-n9s&XDpgQSp9jUS?%^$Bz+V?QZM}m8{4I8}uo1a|m zhD-TNNp!=Grk0J!O%DATYza!qR>V5C*Nn0+P1rnKVyzqf z4~XJ2GrqQcJLgNHlu7MoXzlpR>@}NgWpDSJexa(v{x~=I#mbPPUTSY_iDHO z!YS+i-3**?3L6c6JEUsZG&`JNR!Lo&=^Yv@~sO~ zfjiyRo2L!bOm9}P_vpq53g#qxC)ANv3tE^9VjEV~g`*`{Hyd_zgBQP$!Uu5rLobNw zq1@%Y!K4-bo!vpb#PE@{2ej}RzoqyPx^w8x{U~lFrntu{%Bj{B{idyJfVmmzW&+EjC7>Orrk9p}e{I`P zK{Z}*n5c9-Qr_B4JXu3e@rJV27KYZ~f)o~U3^ZY$F5dArt8qHuS8OW|Zy{4jEtb_T z=J}DoW{w)C{lecU z)$iiQ)8%qpC2WOLtZ`+c*S!4Y6HG7<&Gmp=H1ss>QbJ0Z<(8Pf!3eME%O+`B3tb5^ zZZL&UD!%`o4b2%nxs0MWqTdv%dYb-_j>Fxsu4y+b?L++&j(pXFN9l%l?Nj{F$l~q$ zpdR~_6HShw?a?>T&s*MCD;m5$Nw*de(5;R-&!FD98gHL+cPS;HxG_Ehn&+3fX+-k} zWoG@PT2We*;h8K0<7w{?#T;9&jhS^{8x--cGFr==F^*K{U6N`b7mgG?YqDWM{3uR5 zhw&@E_#i=d`ZCK}sg=waqQB&ehmd`aXDG=U!Chh)2nl^-kSF&<%Ux}!6Lot)=MZdZ z^~3OxbC6>z_XpW;$}iDDFTcEC#&ACD0kk6N8To;ak>RA@S3aGPNY(7l%FS3k<%8Rc zj{1K(rG;uYF!&JWOk{#Emm++z>vDGXl-GNXP}ou3z>8+|V1z2}$|_%BM@e0pgHupJ z{n-NKH$vt_sAFmYvLqy1D6H^e94sL0mpTvfrCXA-jo)wHxGY)b0*_ZA(G#Q2O<7R1 zU&cUcLQZpTR!(blczg!4Ut40!5`UmwR0_vt7Hy zx>0*?b$FeWH5bipk(*?5TPO#8kbjz+#4O5>+BG^D)@Xw#>+P+L4|3Ze=4^09o+0vP zMk^Te3OhPVlBR|8q0oAPU#_heO31_|5A)#7X}ZSGMGI(TeUN>l|DH?c<)TiAH)K)% zDz}{H?Z2B8AidTj0*gK+SW`^t{!YuKRm*fAf1e9%7`frskk`OHPfNI!_)*|L`ytx^v+WC|$d`)(G#$e(bHxsEVyLR~#yL zb1+A5?DU7NjCED~CxVtxJdef_9%%Z?UWC%cCsLFCwFxDr*sqkf?1&F`byaK~@ zK3UAACb9EGTyWIW5Kq$X$_)jE-Z=48w~iRWm1-B06p7%YLqdIV-6Fe9hWIDp;@Tf7 zNi_`{rOjNSQ7RSb|Nfd*mARlC0eTuH1(vA* zP}Ivy5cm+Z<3LtDO2zRG;rCle6Vn@z-5ytH&iB-D!Q_r2GoJYD;A}M5|I;D=D zC$LWiDU_b@nOERVn0J;=&7$ijEmL|Q*cKfX(4bb96|+bvymZ_>Td&1#oB!`4lyLFb*q>?6fHe0kGzzv6~|0Y z2ED^Bmx8y5!+|YI*GRBRztbuTG$W@(@hg#ALg%TX*&0W z-5Z0ts;sQ6(o`l>C-41#vlm9&o@JMiiJLrIaL6ceZT!+UQ8z_#JOxijb^&79<@c;c z_Q60obDm;~rl1;$tGS0&LQ65KdjdTzpSg{3ywY7}%$qeG*f{@1>q}#tIj;Z@a@Rm1 z1r+~-ftJIA9ZJ*sJ67v6^4fp=i;??bm-sV|B6CuMCXTtNim;sc12w0obym~uNk339 zIoAkaY05XRfQAJY{GVOR{^o2=k$S*U=Jo)rwv9VLM5pNr4UNPf8k%^uqRinh6d+Wk za7bcux3%G7AB)Q2vlJx3Jh2%a8$D_hj2zp_mBvCW3!t?Sfr4QoS|`z^z!6H9yHJT$ zFUlNzQ!X~N)sTzw$$;-X5dDejUVw}XcWQC96)aS1_T*mK1WKg~G)A+%PYuSUpnRt> z#F>C@3}aNf&_# zt>_(Quo=wWa&GM3b(%o2osR%trOU3J37pfq1(0Ir#zDpN(3C3J^h9i?(fiP#3bY>E zn*=kGa(B+JPppZ~C5aUf7n zeD(U?=*~w5@qDhE8k|OG?XqB$V`d?nc-4^40zZoFQl#)_GQOlqt?Ma6rCm2W*$n@l z;Px5YLXQ7_tgev!dae(9pZw!#YdWR7+I3P}#JJU{O{Z=yQo&{MRcreCBQ{32hOPJA zA%n_tkdDem3SrXqYC0i8h<>pc{gEeGdD1E(WMr5b= zNRT^FvcG2(K!?&DK4351$R0;nvL+RYWsWAwt(V()1@>1if4d8tlC3{-z{F6bT*mGs zQucsU9v3NiX08XC!8$HIL&GoK?1K`+n@KWmDN0urNz0i8KShCne?aQi;4PwN zCP+Km;YRQ7f^Ste*m~yQ-_Yun+Kawx;670BUUR4^3r};_;J0+tr=iJs$as+^+9CdOB*ceR+(IRm=!0vfu87rg%qoR{&!~hN_HIS?>hLJd&xnhm7~~r@KXPHx6AcAy=B5{ z-ob#AvF_~jV58d*&deo0-@7_+$msIR3aBG;io9sl<180O^>Gnk43xJdBSy?0Sfq(t z*7o5X19ScUxP~c%_9_}TT4JMe?0-dw7XItwm7^~8DlBop|NJ+dbeFeaeQ`aREXw=W z*Dx8TZ5!}oGVVCAOyBMsxlrP1xz_0OWagOK|5C3LIEn^X!9Bn;pN1syE$M}KX2Rm&7Zp8wzZOz zO0qcy{lQ@g4l!!=yzQ>jkic%e) zP6vf@YsHD_5N1AHxOKSM2#ScHa=`Ag0XcE{j$`+$LEFDS!yZWbTcUHz!z#lOYfLC) zo*!pz#PU;fpk|McRE!rp8;LW{p#~$dG8V@8@pgmjTDJ3pZ_&^&v$@l} zdYc`jXj#yrksP72|L0A0wtcDcO@HEsYpSrV(1^$zjiHN>qO8ZF^C*uv_8DyFkeROH ziuKzd;CyJAJCGSz?QFkKS5V-+!jQQoI27M}!xfE;;FJ zl+%Y)y)vv+cAv zlu?*g7oSo7#?l7)I_5!6mkRWjPJ)!+cz_t(wI@mLx3$mlC>i!`yuv<|vsH^tYhz#9 zbG|*AtOdPU?<(LPTof+o*q8R8PsFL46{^(sNy029?4m|I@5Z zv0-uL?J03EVP1nUGsP8SqLsqiY|IoE}B%vFk0h!^IwYd&wzt~I)wG)cTl_?ZH&;1 z(xaBP5{V->iZUT)CEn=nj7dJ0Ur%9O>i8h0 zhxo=LKBL2Wxa@w@tARWbNrz4+wSP$}*qdrz>Rzd{?r%Af8vc3_yMj&p{y zJ^Hv%Gf?nMRyibN zz^wRf2JGkifl5cC;5$yht`iI~kOBgX`)Qp?cRjI^hhdoJC!MnK7wri8hwGQBHWl%O6(Jj}R{tJm)9p>aZkFcyI_2@3 zBg-h0#SA9-?{r~D<_fxoaMnH*={-iNO0=I@8PKsa>kymrdmD0pV-W!njK1`7u|(ke ziYWhD_NzCS#&X+5`RNY43R$GZy}Ep|Uo`Hhwn^1kd*esCV^hQ5C)PlUF=Ztj$7QG8 zFS`%PXC(faNcHWdo0dAAa&Faky~pMU*Ktc@+z3MBgaX&*W9Vbr-l%B*;KMET^1b_$ z?@lf-NPSwY?@;#FTCnpzc!IJI=P$wuagf1rOyWqdEB}|?@fQd0RU#x=k)66Z==w3< z>rS2dcm(S_gDHB-RZobu@IIFCi{WTxtoRu3uM_dxa$JvY$BOO97nN?Dr(@u8(|J0B-h1yF@ z{{ou;*7qEBWv({SDcu(rmA$FDNi924%&zb}E_F4EDfCxvs;DUax=Kuc0i}qW;l&D{ zbC&HF_DBbwEJ{Rq_^`(HfgpnuY*2 zbH2uZOXOh?%C?hRxmKWE&T8%3Jkvg^+EoAe(^c<-+!NZR+QFi%MS75^7=zsJr6+kI zJXbVaKtC@CsdVVuG;=q3@X5WcUwNQIl+AH_Rnu427A6@u}#bsFA9qpX;m_^LD?Dn9=DCC0IY;UN;+hsC*gq3hq@Q#)*o#1eO2E z9^;9-wC?kP{oGGD=Y+b@tC*3M4_UxU_ddd-vk3MR{P?F?wt3YT8aF$t)fh&cZ7vBu zO--O=oMgA|_~!oljM)prHe@nOu1n%cDUxW%!;3z1!<1nU!zf?fxSC!2hDh;#PWr!h z!)yOMSB(4Gp;K@wQCKp^_G3pR7(k4lW+`bp@~?n)#$KK?82MN}R=MGbsSI+m%zv0h z^DTt;^^jq*cZ{J`L!-~5^Vw!o`2 z5m7ox#FXLO+ac3u`lZuc^cSViq(Qk0FBm}tTe^#A{g*AZmMZ0OLw?4&e-fQ@uejQk za)?#Mdoc_-Oh`3~X-RNZiblYdVzc6riDzZ*A4Wi2Ppn0KSgd;Mf>dBu`CsI zPkE#u{-#^K%G<0@M+Sko)gfv$oi_TbPRzk%RYZC!qCx|&T1XLiM;7ye_f7AA-2H%x z{iOL?UZ``?DhP8!6lm0l6(2uZ>2!%Nl-XUWXS{}LI@j=kdrct(+Kuse^q;1aNs;yCM{iCB#ccGZ0F+Na z!I*3*%7UUXHO+u23s-2#xR?mZUFHg?a=9#EJYrd!m4_h4H^B@nam9Fg}k4+o-p!&E~9GNL5_u8 zs@?QTA0h3}M}?@f!@eE$hlT+`(IbfVemA4D`qK9eZwc(_OywHfBBzA7F{IQP=8s3j z#-Hxaece?Rqc8IsCkHYW<3N&^GYZw>O(mR(V}jz9tj;b{@G0 zb4*_E5_x8b4ZQCLJCc|3Hr+;>EbWrWE1Xv23mNOkt-rt6l$mH=t-YZV07khsB0eW_ zINqn%Dzp6Pr<(`!oGT`3`p@tOPnQ>?VNQA3g__q^)wD_twap`ZQXV<|S`9(ZE@qaW zK+q0DrJc;{*CK)Ee%oYlnUrF5)uz@o_cMthyh;(8#j)(TAi-#9YEX(jw}&B(e0)z@ zb2k^q#4k7IB@cJ%t)3P=QQMWhrxg#w+~w;q?Tw=r7ABY2-`y;dbEh_ zdX44#H|!7JPS^{z=UtB{(HoxEJ@Hn*&9cVExUX;TLJYgu2Lc!XjU~=Bhd6K4opfi& zr;dRI-=9qqi_pq$F@(E#$W)0x&m z9y$jXt#P@kcbtMxzU`=^OF5UnDYv=Rr!^UU(toyx=_c24RZu8HE0DMhR}T$Tf`K^8 zb-kadc6-%Ex2dJOX-%!U3^-roOA|SdCVigydq6MUavdx-2%EGHL0N=9Isv7#oHGwH zjL(7uKZ+QQIg5s;`Ff0MH=lHwIa;`^&HRgOt;liH$tF$nf;=qmMp*epE9sbUwCA_x zjy+nM^TL1ud8Iw8NqBb-Edr?&$UmBWxjK}00|z%Z!}#jB9>`A%m>l!1x;>T=MyT>i zvz-gm5FNLw6RuKYc`Q>oP3KTsF4ZiCE~($Zq-BRSECl^1I#+xcv)ELBz*Bt16OxO& zifX!qiq_Pd;W&Ja|0;3bGF8s$ELV5LgXzlt2!oZ;lGJ0LmnI$l?vvFpEZ**pL};}h zDh)2vd*zu~wPt1I@#X2CM7scgBxxn*sHww_z!_!;+y|WykPe*Sc*3 z^h##-nr(8bpsmqTlw)?Gr;m%t6QiQzJkbcYaCVhtSVGa#Ai%ay&?|a0ca8FALz8eBXUlc&5CL@_M#k@ zT)VG{R*j9&r9u7{#C!>HbNrp9CDrj4F7s-5^HY%9_36Xa$(j;mF-PW1PoK2S59r4a z&Q_fHO}ud)7eAtVq486|B_XtWUx$w5N|{0gm$U!Gg>%YDER)z|-A-DxGIJ}+zNllL zer5Vh^dDbZ&Ev9i=107k%A<{mD&hHkW3{g7d1KQk&DT%_!b>5_0-{@ZlDTd!13*Iw(Eo|ONW!e9Z_kr1Qh?F13}mMfl8bliW03%BjY4C zjdgWW{1)TWCX=e&ph~&3A*3pXtFPekawMJC&9oG6p9;v%&w7;z(=3hy(BL>S4(oj( z`W7bUCD>7{>CSn59nosmlt!QDN_?|-Vlf*TD~w-6bO`3`Yk50y4PdgBaSfE*{MlE+ zsrV5|I)>qW-e}GDtMALsF{pR^9jSYFGS?c6!wV<{Yg%qLNs+Nt>{2i3gyPXVm%GhS z*CU3S;zPdAC~NN>yPGE__!JLi5`ByRysYiga8pYm!Z$4S<29Shrz%tGTzRh*>4`0a zwoCjp(-)@zmYOC_ynL1`pCvjvX6Jd1W7Z>WnVkVE|U6 zh>vC1ukUa@RvIG}m*(;_Rlz>ILn!HG(t0>6o%>#+|EWoS`%|tb1n?q_UHx-~J8pVoU9QKo>^I0sDaZxqY%awyUbdw|{qOwK>o$?9$y z0E*$*?2~3Y0VGxeX6WAEVnr>``y1)1p%cW9tl}`9;R3UoR0{B11A!hOP|YhW6|-Xg zDsH2U(^H{b-q|EC#MvCq2|y}yH^Dr8YaQ35GC%jH`OVofk;Sg~OM~{n0NfO|tSzOu zgk9tfv~3OFq8yPovB?TPB<$g~mdzkqhcd@~_r;^~Uf5J^e;gpe>bEz1Dd2z_4=7 zYbBs^#=(DD{ydDkmMB&7W4zv{#EM?JFvwzarV$D78KNr=J52=7B?FgxiM*T{wT1^% z90C)Mvf}s>2f)ZwCaH|Wpq|RQMd`EGR{T{nZeyj*#AbS)eJ}&wNKFBwoiV=)U0_5s z$5RX@G}tzt;HjDyzZh^}4+RDv9pr3+XIJg?Fj4uudhL*YJgjzOx?X+CI!?s=@26jY zM@f9anUm!C@mS_Gmh}m!jBECvE(=~9tj?yqBPXYe*kBdMD=qz3vX6RC>E?`tK06sY z=r**pmq?2nZ1^oQfo&Yz{_}?A{gj*AM5W-bB{GgR0K2n~OH}mpY{&h5f7V<3{JQE?SvCODuwdxY$9<`?8??NQSj#%k1ENg2 zgEAGXW6q&`2b57D)gmqegpN{n|fNQQu(z1Zom3hCitXl&ATMl z36@pGhb_ro15dC3N5s|mZoN>@nb2F6Jpwlznd%%6dFA!~$p`M29$TuC$@JX5-%|>f zD(3jmO8@2$G!&P6I;=siw1527- za+K}n-y}L)6V@k3Wn3qu>UGz~E84hgq*$gs43_L?_EdLFckF>vhmDuCpMd_2M3poW z5=tJvV>nu<0OZi|(k?b}1h9(xXfUt9jRt8n6@i(wckkopZOQ!BgLpv_l7p*FB*?Tc3 zu*29=eP;ab2Ah(X-Ish}!53UCh}Oa@V;jjizyhqmf2c-?(rz9|0H5yx)#u}zIT!E1 zO~pBnD}cUFId0YZqsp3&F-TA3`h3zI(>D;2agvVV6jvN*!k=j~5xM%62RtjTOVYY$ za6~X*-;t4+I&a{)M?Xk*j{-w65;Ldl`9VeI2EoA+o2Js8nE<%?gOZ^s8id#23`hG} z;x%a}53jAb;*?P&%ART&$6EC z*V%NR{1k%2^k3}(sG=&j(eCnCnQi<1%$+XD-hH>+(*XkQpCSDsp@8zt8LN4F?t2(a z*|fm48(Wh0?&PpFgQjt@rCdJnPQ->H>^9vi?0a?ZhO@i*hK6~;$-s!;8!obt$zLJO zf7J^KvTjb%Pwi*Ixi8)7Z_lMkT29jF6d!2lllyiO`WnZxBFS*riit9a);v-6Z1PEN zuLFnioyqmVH*|j<+{k-v0(lgGUEyx7rn9nr zykjmMA`2kNu@!?BX1Yq%2-PO@*N2ryGhK||AMf<}A^wog(%dinBB4ObLK6+Q3a0E; z>+z#b83nruIUA$3*)04u7nn_g9`nXzqtTscpmYM|;6&LvbNWR=Ie(rg`4&tk^tF$$S=GRM8-@#tk?0hbw-X#sCeUGUZKv+aG~UK33%M5bwu z=Jy&V(=RI+uReu}SBc1bE&mbEX507MyOO2@Ax8_S#E@mp{3`|0pAwE`3 zelthvU_k1ul7o0S`Dx^wtB(**K2eINDu`}U*DDhJ#hawd#V;K(5lPQ@?O9G6%9i*5Jir5y(#Os5(lM`y4NFGHDd4NWi-|SyYrcFfwVr+Q`OX87t&+9t5B(j2Vx_k znppUVY>GM@+BQ9_y2q9Wzh1-wv!)K)i!V*|u5wB?qHTYExZqvS1r8e}m0|B9XQm=r zq2PRk_5!n!h3U*5fBw#rMs|>7NU=|4ui+E#z4Sc4Vyst{IG_>p*PV^p#JO(W>{qr~ znwQ_ClJKs6kmTe1%cTUa3A5ZlXYY(TLqLVBxea+2?9icXPSad3@)Trru$v-nt#jXURUaS=Stjr%vKIQR(kXadhi;?!rrK- z=hPP78S5_ZZ_QQD$7qHvTo!tqcRfin;x`x_z_c!$7=QQCJ2xw-BQWojb7A(C6Z2hg zTGShtsoJvf2EPhX;hgP2@QU}Q>cZfb->g5d-JwxglBw+`OW zv%C*%dK7lCdMHLd0ldRF4(MbUfR4GVEqB^K-&)Bz2cE$eNllEjOT?_86J3OERN1yM z1IckbmS!2jF5Sf&XZeCUWYmlkOCJAv7Q8__(5h~HIted=Jcl+Ou=)wOhaPr@OILo1@I(LBJ(cJp~NUb#f4hsTCP}&avlD(% zR!9T{j=EALxQsYU-`RI)knr&41lbg6@H8pvlg4_vBG#40;#O6~nhM{wIH{!f zqf5Jf5$bb;o@DT0RfAv~Q*}oRd3*AoE1iagrbj>s$uOWBZOcE<6Tp0Nr3@q&q=Hk6 zZ=42oiJA%ua7}k+v~pffP#xv&??ZemZu7E2!@aF?s+>oA0{=DBuLMy}ynM?6t8IqC zZ>fd1@48<7y^^4@V>+tg_}QwYOf8brG1x4WnM)$TFnW5Q=A|DM71B$DXQ=}b{-5ql zJZHSt!`67Gjr(FmQ+HwSez~0C`b1}P6;))5v7VxQI_;t?kjCsq3l|l&E2q`G*={O`P;O- zV-IaD**t3p#_LD3mDc=UK%d*%kn$@LYcZJSc!Fl$a%K)2nJj0b81-oe9<31tnp5;j zz1Mo0^9TJox0!~z#?xo*foLSiiww!i1Ky@&ZU9fB)o`Pd4&r9TmRKsb;)BRq}GxwfB)2g4LM2wT?g`Ed8e2pc=5*ZI(Uw& zD2OIVPGYuG0yge~%g7|h4E3uc)`K=F2+U_IKrNC)lDv!xOhpsBGe(E~B{-pTNgl0i z-eckId><>5cKdd5`e!j9{!ygZ(7JS)!~qVY426) zf{cY&DBw@OQ9*n$9#MW#aZ#Cm&!O#bXgw3*Oto?=9Qnj8;TSaU<-GxWtI#0wx=e)| zPMJJexjygZINtNO%w_-&7Ss{!zqZLcz3QF1XV73a$+_Nt3MRCcqwJ#C9G1xx!I9I zi@~3>YJ>jVqmSkWXtNlv|2Ggr=)ElR^v+c9`^W%EdEP2=;**cxS;)+=ob)D*buhDR3eXo7Gsj<0yp^{ zHCtpZtUKBvC|U6_CVn}#nagMDg4Z`-`}|M=Q&qukp3&{yRt`7qVJ`=4y-Oj;-efyW z=PaNXa)@A!Rwt{R%@QE_*-NA^7nBeGsUEvcSJ><2w|$+K`17|c`Il{zltbTjGWPx8 z?kU5?N^&H%_w!9(ZfXck<36`5eK45Z0CUf z#w2_Op76h$PNgloNz2@R1BN}Yv#__Onn;KUQqo`0N0tZg%>TYrz5uK^tiv(YUVPwe z1=_6%%fPK)1V0f9%_-ebNWgF4xVTE%p0t=(1Qal#uG}a_?#eRYN6L$Ce*N;rg`k-R zat33uUo%|VQNm{EYibmBOZR5FdmMZh;=b0#W~9e{m6*50^NK^+0iWEhY=$2m8j4N5 z=bAv}1lQoAQQt?95Lm~fi%@?mG|8v*(-!&r3@Db{Dn9Y(553;8Ba|-^6ERzSah9H8 z$tm|ItShH|n^-^qhrh2Xq+s41UsOZt4QtqFIu0@dak%Iu&CWP+8C(##2w9B3V--a= zfJiKUj3_2-cZ&0`?a`nAXyG=@^Bh2-@doW*bmdoW*E4^r*F8P(k%lu`HTQBVtPhho z3tZqDWbwso7{QWqcL1|Xf_Zz@LaUcSU$v{nfAXHU)FU5p9)r5zLd{nyyfRhq1DBwh zRY1ssPpAOx==-1ZO?7aa8bksUov}?S`%NiG{J|5npDqfGwq`XEyW`RSm^B`hJlBi?1J}UmSm^0Q)|0PkEtZI3lj^M8K;S&wXal_HIg6XT zAS1x8ep4PC1%3dsSceyNHZS(hwuE+rK6O1+55n3)39|Z=f2dVBr8u&05-a|#qE~s+ zM)ywRqKD#0oP#47_)|m|KMvPh6Ux-Pt-f*fr_@u&hoiqMWbRxZtMitc@}1HN1u2W{ zYkIZFPt`W-bCrrx;zQ#UY6oCi`1Hb7y`*!~x0}{B9;4p|Lsr}O zrc^t>amb+n$Fp+K8e~r<1@t%Vhvza*+7zEK%7ybI%EKQi+NeY$f(xhs7$%8FU%doY)b1)TtqVDS(Q;Of`C=EB(S`lm%k8=kxv52?IoD z^aP?uns1m$^&5hUsbZ(zB*lp7F0e2!?!qwyvnT!F1Rq}+KFDhAFNbOcB+qU<|2Y?U zXG{uTk5Ed7nm76*25a1GERL+E4o3+WKVsMoz7s%QtLl8z^Z*~#TCgY1ncU_)J_I_T z6fL~Was|NjYIZD_*7DLl^EWCm;xX}+8<>M!1Oz`DeM5E4ZA5-?WYf3H$m)$#Agtb^ z(Z9-7U~NQnop$(|@|gS;4KkZ_>F{3lWN@62NeA$_tlaPcR;mF8wjJLo`NSFwe)T)D z$a?4A&mmb_5J6>gO63VJCVF-C6LMSoVL@K2L%+FiWlXcI_(ZWwcSt!6wZjVhr9e8N z=d1f<(#DQs9Ud;vysDhDLF-_XiP!}h%CqB*A5>)kJU;%TFyo$;0)zpfn3 zT8@7LMNfV0uo}>k&pTUn0GS^rZi7urH92?48wE+DQTXghTICTr9=EbYMI$RL9hCs1<;CS*F(RfP&NOgxh zO-R(ATHsF&{Cn&QYAYk2vimoxBfE zwH~1n$gq)_#sFlIMGbR3@}5KAcaU)$N#lM0Ln-4zw{HXas@vHPkeMZcjOx{0NowR5 zxi@Tfqe(`RpjGB#zcnVVL|&^nA_jpJUi92PC|;Bnon(1wv?s67*E~;6|0du|V?hzx ze}MoIbQ>VCZx++PZoBVBKTBGN)w2Ww7i+u*$m%rQG)V4#z!gv&{t)m=_d@-DW*%Mz zku1xK?7eS@wXwT66EmwTTVt2C+wdn(o>YqazEsJr4oM9`G|tA_*Q%EmGaCjdF9Tdt zBiM2Odno3^Kku6Jg_R9Jq4naDALXj|rYNl+U5_sQWa-$b&(fI6jv;uDnt?#JnoGsZ zroLRzx+HCIjt@^#tlw(mMiMZNN}e@`JWwfdeKei&mKy%G0TI*|T~**zxw2li-cYuv z4JFpR7dpY|$T_ocrM8!45fonrd0Zol)g)cL*zQIs$Vn_ZgPPOs0TP}{^TaqoBfh_G z3`wayVDx~;mAtDjIrZohqwIBhgV==JY!qbR10;kR25kU>r25_1e{vQbfV+tg<@Rrn z9ncT$@8CW=?6E<`;49{b66S#xs41!eaJKm5!$M$Tqrn7f0mT+IVt;*nm&!W6=VlW0 zLBPk>!qZV{G?SWIv}p>m1EI_n4E7No;QGWGFB9jx>%uWQ*}8Mm$&e+K4tgZjNf7T~ zF(T#PxqQmIn2Sk<8#;oKPGc;Y2b=% zGlRYo_?=M7puxF3ScoucyYC1V_2V7^91c-_*1*H48RD*pxjR>$;SYrmHxd?M$?P=}@eNYkCe`Pm+k)rRC%-D^;BpzokT#{;VR=eCUQ#7e zdI(W8qY6rT7!g)&;94)Qf(5z07O_iE_WT!7i=WHuVwy8?MXr`hE$mH%3muG})8}O& zb{#(rO}_+vDt3)|p4;n$6`muMwQ*N;%1Bo>cADEKLnUh@;E8*N_Yw%Aphi`W$3oPl zi(m?xor+8i8$-&v2lr|^w9$7B4)Z$C#1lbREdlFA+-yzyiT`oUn~ zn)q~$MT2jdm3pNJSA<@RJcLL~ED)=>$H}y`Ui@&5ku$0|EHixtHd>rKU0vydm@Y)< z>^yDb?RM+0ng&6+mPoDfbWHERpO^IZN6k<>h^CdQQR{OF>HAH`lwP}HL1D0kQmb~J zj7DHa^A2+T3cG6crKXwKr8KHxw2l`Mxy<)tdtOmh(qT)b^QhRWM+sEJ8HFz5_`CCj-N>7mts9=sRD*MWsQTk(`m8Drwuwcq|*Ua9O;=-D8fba#fj^ zx-T;hr@fDf^;Ko0Mb1m4F)EN(v5VZbR(kD zAl)g_11c~GeQpBcpOwYT4jd+)R; z0}1y-JCnEi(WDrsa0~tk4bRptUP-~(5`c+UkFl$<*pO2*c>)PX?6T5m1-4$LGJwi0 zCur8O6JVKzx6cnlF{`ldHfN~u%@TYb1}1%ePww4u1OExJK~DgqO7q>|C|h{W+${ZK zWB1rOI!dNyuJ*2(lIMjYy;TMCp$q(tW>c993RV50Z6?Bj6)G>o+i$OzLq9bw> z_Pto;$pRK5!81rqIoJ^ZPjPVyD$HB_E)VE;n{bo4DoNP7K!ZiSs&X4PvlHfcp+zE1 z+mmBlI*(2Yajy#esL))j=)>LGh#lGT0aZ}i{aOf|+Z}KMtjMIx)XEG#W>C>qJEPrq zqitJQL;GmH1HHqTwbrQOzLZ5-`|Fky-Z2*Vs}(hF$Kr|-_F+e}h_|gWHQs!AONf%z ze@(L2^sbdrYTwo718Ryq>WgtuQeRwf%s3XTf5y@<&z@T@SI&^@^X28TvliAI#S`k* zZE8IgjlG4s+2{J*u`I=Y&e$wAl~{|ZIPLHHa*wBQ`Rs-*a*j-Qm_-~|(kySZx$W^$ zy{>f6TrD7N@x`Uf7uX^kQ^F&xic|ZrRse&zn2}AZ;=jty8&&_C%DUM<8&|erLxG~F2OP=^ewKoG!toe3EVu+ z6gOOm=w!}1IHwl+EX7&POqgBs^a&_RG%(wZldYv{!05w57~ zB=%W@pd_EX#q^kVyqaqSM9l){s$)_;rF!D?!j(0wz3E2g_Jzh-u1VXtuDkIRT?JTe z*D9^iG`E#8d^w*)HNDSJ$>@3s-_jMcsCnTsTTcGG%gL!(Yn{Ijn2qRG0VNC?U?$sDHE~=R&W;v1&hyLw;lh^!Dl5V(;etl8bDa2C#Q> zj+&;HdU6CBu$5N4&f$9_HviMLWP!%QKaOSbQ&(#36VA~S^AchHY7VM&M>v_&LQ2&R zx=qn$@qfQL|6xhRm{!~dur95H7cMgNuc+GZd&$9Cx$fw%5oWA5aSm2Xn5I_w9wS$>!o=eMAb8)**Jw1t>q$G+%< zvG$beB42S-Av%Zcy8#i%DizE0v|lV`eGQO`64s|!GWk@mkJxsmXFMMu>GC8Pehk{qPB94kwG4gyr%1&gCW zl})+UvgFsU#I4T#o>ka-EVj}q@QEN*LoodOJ3~O=n&@-cvI%*%|RQFP`i~6&YcUQERV~u9xN=IE|xZj?j-Vi0P z*IH29kh$|3R*IWMSUBOlUA*NOSK}$Gc+1NEEoPC9q7{dJC(5s_ARxr~oS7>e=IHP>ke07X!pRPtRkRV)*4uwf6 zxA`R!n1w- zEoj*Nb0xJ*M)&J-8Olf)$x>8utXK^%eln;Fv-q?)k$#lNt>6?-wn7!Xz>|Z_H2QR7 zgqlZ;=c8BlH4thxJT>@(Zl?1eA?Hb|p6I`(m=SIs#B*ze`uAd9C67&Z$IIWupEp%H zk-d-Y;jHarE{++|OA8%m&!%6cD_%G%V;Eq-Ug77|V#3XG*D^5LxQ9~E@WXZP)@!+t zeALpu06bwtWU82kLoNGzJ{9wN_Y6;thGGM~+ay!gx|P7k(E~1vGVic5JqbZuE>F{r ziRPXq!B~b3-3{kF!oFxYczt0;HjGNIhjSlVX}XsZLQq>tpD|Chd)~mGtq^qyWE=Z0=aiD&!_F`~ zZ$45coxI`46lhUfAGSkFo?o>pB>3$qRxDX`zH7gYz(H&fV?N(o`gMZfXx`mR|VczQpR9j-k(pY#cqkaHBrP0`p}v;s;f+d%36H?_p|xz1!u;|QY?BAq?S&hg;)ndymr9iLEGk4d)$}k?MyQ8@&F=2qH##Fin}!vsQIDt3t5zr@EO-*k^{!Ma;^3 zJ}&K7SMES3(UjlHGVNjIsn0=ldKGT4DNM=|2-vA5g}0x!2-T@n$#D%<{!!6R z;$zz+r2O*VAibQDung)M>L&Q;ld?WzDFis<9jz+}AcJ+=xgtb0+98J4}o7?urhglT>hETeSGoBncmx1{3x zwRQIFr@L{Q(!YR`Cy4qPdOTJ|nbL1cNVwV7=Tnu+KirDU(?qSKN^xx-`#-;bmb8{H z`_6f(1imq{B;JoZSTP`yR>YfS^kApt%8h_=--b4q_Tne9%NN3rLIT}(!z z^9T0L2l`76J$Ez0=Y5m5g2UVC5>|vOixt=0K;9Djb-(SUF`7H|>z>Iks@2$3^3M4c zoS$+mIL?iYUsSj)+byLIwk5=ldZv`>T#J!9iQ~)slQmacJ{9kw`a@Hk=hDJDBBFJs zJ#1X5%_SgN$GEg42^ewF>$bezI0RwFb<9?cR=%OIfeO zYMtV;mv9bSd$F-~V6%)h82eO9BJ2D5_3G*NFxn+8>9YeOF2wJ7wjTqp&Pw^G{^46dPt-F`)8QAi zM@qDP1$@K4PtAliYf&Uyha?jAwJO-45gF+s?;_BD?04}`45FsownRVNA20g=e&CwOg-iRWLQ$N#`Co`B90rLRz|Da(HEbOTnyEB+m989f+{wp^ zpgj`;XtD6g}P>6jk(e+ABDF*W>N#oJNSrwOLcSzy4H+U-M&Jg-RA6fcRlIOZu zLXd1f<#M!ePx+g6I+u3t1(U|%ov4jii4hUnNWFKrWIkC}t<`Kd?wc=fw)61>t0`n*_^CaV#?gpF#WAj{K{2W(6up(1i8k8S74>2+6G%xb=!5W zvDKc-qyAtnc4x=RWQyVH(=Ap_;loKso@GwrR>ipqz4u?r^`|Wx`&CLEddYAW#3PN8 zy0td+H~P~&Wc5)dU32*1I>-J`4|bnqpHS8+(}fo0+z&nOZtR@p6Ds;WZ@N5B&(1y4 zk0S;oIi1`ELAO7U9h9|UP1Z4+)DOINm5vp9)kPiJ#%G3VD0?3C6!*A8%SxjvKj&a- z$%`!^MdfNMXcyCZwGlpq->jJMn0x!=5BK~7@>f94HB(*Evb!p{L^dB#reE<)WxMA# z_Ke02Qnw@77osf+vqqe{D$;#ONaxQj0;&OqD!lon%()ixqyxpKJ-_xH(6BBqx0P$* zzxl%f3?gsWUe&vr*Yli|&8j%;)S}`!36HfO`NEvThhA>UI1JkXW~A)l*wSofpBB+N za4}U!e?t*~;O&|d>EQ84cCU_f5(wbOKX;xqSsT?~>1j5m6NO&SRZgF`KO>sEY7ESr zK0b3}wpkX*r22GA_^H4+YR5jhX-|R?HAsn>8C#;XAHOA5!o?{4{U^{&j=%SPd(*x> zz28wi(5Z?TN6znwx8ZkPy6GG41J(YW?NeqObI~#`)Q2x9-k2p_7C${u{)Y2V8O5~) z`_>r$xw#7ESzd6C+A*7VB)(?vs%W3DxmxxzRc+Cu>_DMIg5u)l1b{oX?c%FSP$^u* z8Xc3T=G5jBq9u3jJ*0vh6IOa3CEM1=1g1^ahwTw}nG4?WI4|hEHy-%r+Y0= zAb8o6+!~X+$i5N7Q}g?dCh$XdJSmshsWcI}gA4OG8D~67b${O2f6@F5H$i*F`*lx{ z9O0sEcTxapMa_W}TU|55QEUu>_%n%UUG|{{K8F1B}T8nRaStX}#aIfBY;0=8M435zhCn z1+IC`{-fuA19f3)xW>D31-fv*fc@X13rr6aV1eK+0ck{;HwZAIZe5_85Vmiy#Z6ZN zLgD>_?jjyHQr=w(IM+C`3iJe~5N?AGOaejUkRs5Q|Ag6RK&lo6p!HdRUKXssCi)W% zYrHnS0OK!0iimf$Zg6zgBwc$kw85#Hw=@i0@lR%{vj}kdDAfur>}7)j(`RvXupn3C zfWWZ5ab7k4q?0~!)Z1}@fU$~L@uk3;7zdjC5?|+{z8&frG&;^ntke_nyWLVxxZM1U zV?{jW<3IWg>_4v!A_|8O4`Pr2R@a}m2!z&%6;QwxEoP1(-3F33P;I%}$}Lwu%q>jX zTnP{bvrAk>%J-D-so!VDx_=!&1f&{dgSD+`sE_!@O~v z;nh0p8%3V-Pg3y)cIBT-UFJ0|=Spq=PR{q;*{%V@!r=`DA)7g5P&%+K$&EnthPU3& z!#g2OS#r&602%sf(a;P+;Ia~vRxP$CZ1JWz+A<7{O(e` zIJhqHk06q_qf+;Ao9Gy$6jk_LMDXqY-QivS>pK1egfrY zcmwIcSMSB0wGc;C9(#c3Y5-3e*DZ6H)Kc{XK2UTC(8qoQz4^SSN}4l2(Ks%9egjBN z{UB5^t(Eh=*A{)uF@C{qPqHW9L*#cd05ad zRHzZ2w8aP$5UMr~K08YZ!ib9V+;RX^H=}H2<4|4LSK3+=9Ttn1bLX+j-+oNiYrafY zi4()Gic!p6E;=ycvkugEK=X%oDhRGa5tg-Zbna|69K}hRthU=e)E^rfTVq_?0s>FS zsKLIH+83@;vh1j682b|OZ?XN$GJfXm+e;s zg~;>-CRQ9s_1hg3k}mIhZuq27Wq}9L2VdU9zrXsc($Q6HX74OcFt&mKX(1bwA&r(l zB_%hfkD6G`PbUMP##MZ4QG)(i0L{?yH2c6+HU`SHM@N(~JeT~A|5kfqy%l=+j^aEVU0cdiuwlA}K@JUS4Hg&3I+()M3At45Eg3 zNnz1)gzQQsRqCySfhOZ2(Ju^*1}cepc1oznIkTA(!vbW)yPw=?SAgh$N4RHWKA;7- z3xBA!AK)&!kmv%xE-~St+c!!~aCM3srk&}@(2vIBjwxc3r1`g9=WLVU|YC+x?>z_=+a@wGfj8La4K zLcN55F*)~x-1OIdbmR}Gyd~KwUsl|*eYc|R&_LV)|3w-x8o_-o8#-qsXyqwOcJ^Uuf~==Z>TRsE7I&?S)7vFcCbixqRYU7{x7etHXnZQz z)pdd;^DR5edPtSK(?k4$8&el?-0H^kOc>v!#y9ZV5#o}~l@sjfDNx~_Kjrm9X7~!n z$zsV~H?CE+x-PGq&iH(;Y^t z(RXfiY*vS(8T1oEk0tlLtzhqJ`eB(KXU<;|`kg*V|8&JT9!{qKCY@Y8Sg{_JUPZA* zRYfC3e?F>znTJ-AZK4|65~aYx9@Q2FZi(W&N0b(+{g6sO=pB;my^{;>9{;HUHD&(o!f4kyTH#RCwdv?3RxEpIw zq~S??Z9!7jljpqkGQ2wPD0s)&XX{uP>1tC7QdR*GV`<%#C9c%cE85M0Gd zz9#|HjOP3WS8gnBCbE+uC$NI?-0vpER@x?DF}k$I>9;teSB42?NSohM>^I9=PQpqr zCX=4>P@Y|eH&De#0eO4~)9FV-wq*YmpS04yqINxg#;j~Xr1NWWdYX}Mw{uLO8-}NN zRbT*{o=1hvO$rDEhHI*{s=$VcY>WJ=Dq(LMqtVL3kO9dyYPDE645-f-!I}7HSltRl zQZu^d1$gTro~pX-oA9*11AcP2gdHLf7s z9?F*;(ya(c$ofe7=_(H~q~uIE=Fk`fXk317PWwHuMi0JwFKR(9+u63a{FIcBm$@p< zm9ov57+blaEUJW4afZOp#58&#UFZB*btP^`-rFxz^*jrI4tU&yHQ-lClMaE1wulxFZQDR#v{L?=C~PNjPxGx zPPQzd$#BjBxpEBnnzhG*6cB%o`q?66M|?nADTzzjy@q(hyOqEdKjd{a4auRF#zE^7 z1EsfV)0Z#Y`bC!z>ltzx1-OG?&itCKEb1DdX}+9boC?64^eZzhdz=)mS`qmgs1ZZq zGNQe37`K5yunl&bG7#ALJe>}Ggq+d>Q6jp_o$qPF)PO`O)X^GJGhUe zOeKkJQktDeXq3i4!W0Gi zfk-&1hbK>YF7bwh7y&;Ce`e*i+^MFe8!{)LhgjS)4?*ybB%=5ahLVzl<91Ph9&mEn z5O+CU!xaguqj>KIKpyy_+8#(gwF8O0P{ZEinwi^9vi=Zz3~j)fip9J_>h~s~Ty2d% z$#Nd~y$+Vx#vn^-oP;ln@f;ZsHAiOFO7_H+_jf+qe0ikMjBEr;$d3hw82W5}H-{|r z^tdiZ?d!90(U(`M_^;H{BRp+rM+GW=#gq*?EV14!)= zM}Dbk58OU1SO-W#`M?SFwO*OSTih>cRt~D;7c460)m#lBgp@_>!wepxcW@K{S))OK z>US!wt03w4=OwCIvOs1BsEIjr$Y)?o#Cz}G=U7<>qsKb&mjyw89g~Zi>CQlW9dvqw zxPGF*({AiIDdjWb+EoTgy1|2AkQTH4MiW$aU%?N}vX6u=OlWe9W_H&4`V#cWarz)% zrKIDr0SS`ra^;HTDwK~=NOjutLmJR|KF^Ki;tpW`-UG&Oy}-`@Od>HgDlas6lIAw< zU5XTH;O=jNR1Zm8BhZ+)d1y~r!EIbM;00eViJgYp&gOjF0{=mtm2&-Q{)BQXk@$OAIh${&}4%u?ZuIV1TOXov&i}1xrM= zbBTmG6*0;&LW8&M!QnUfn+AtMLdQLrS#rGB4K9dx+7mLsVq#|)u%@yc(cLu~qp<#9FyY?13`jD^k^8#ERzlblz_O! zs0o=B;`uYiGD>=tW$Na~Tf%`CO&3e*zM!b$i{4~fe2qKqH?7xQQS^VJ-B5nj*Cc!+ za{vnHMycU}RENor_!UUH{^aj&H9)$5?)|PJv98q(X*R#ZgfvL>Ych_v!z6~Y<_(V- z(fX0bAIrN#apYn4&5u|{`2XNlt(OjM;qX^8*FpO}^gn8!iLl{mhilJi-}~0DXFE)M zAR&|@PkbRG_^rRM#%L!mj7sWRGq|DC_uhDRP$NCl-`Arz-xSpld9eK{+E?2n@JUDC zInQlW(X(v}gJ^E3f`}aX_!o7&V!CYZG~533r~1FY?012!LGFIf4PzwXZ@mu*y=H6T zV=B6#17#>mgZNg!i0%tWV}VwPT|&cFw!0$!{bfv}7`iNqgQskEBw<{RIY|GuqmpyV zfYdlV>%Fzc3nrwB{g2B@st*=2xfb`TvG|SKTFX2D^Vzci&5>Y`R0-nD)fE*mg{jWCK{QxDn z`1umVodW+7a4hch0v*T<^q0~ATQdhmxjC?M&zsbE%}WyD&&Z#&N(V*regZ}VhT9kd zEFq4+i0+1Ewh^}A;C^lnSVVkJNbL|k9DF5TiMlSGctK(re%Z~=z}T1-cb9{|Lr`Yw zF8%Ie)BPM9N)pkF8+c#81gMH+f7>ae3^+GgzGc`B0W+@^Ac08SQ)@NdUa>VblMa~c zV7g2S?7H~)rf=64>Fi} zzPo4Qh&(t_v;mbDmyBi(!RC&VxB)*Q{k5ibj%{~w`h8`WiIN5n_Pfk)LO&(JjmvA1 zGuJekvI4lpR>*eR0BHcDz(N@Ue~|a?2P(~i%(ee{{lE2mj*c*msT*u7houZ5XJ~_z z=FbXfb6cz6lrAy73j!Zy(0eIEdV%{fHaQKXPw+yYOL}p|ryta+%D_QX28YZxK%I#B z7Y#~UkrW^eNT6tara{n1gNiu~2mv#ok=-xGE6}9YohvV=Lxt2KLO-2T@EC_HhBDYJXJrg@VoyqW&HC7C3~Ru z?V@;xjzG|Lo2q~yU=@TK(Ew}@Dn$!4c>x724gC0Be>2)wb&kMshc8C6YYVv zsKkogMz+Hc1gucLcR3dTD*-s-_zy~~1vBA8HC1?_2`C8DY#t8+uu0uDFPIL$oP(Y( z2J-@ANILlb?h~ZQ^3IFdU+x@|2rI|$Q#z&}PGdWyn}&ne{NdeZ6=yr>R4{(+x`d1* z0N{DKQ;jks5;BT`oMIE7&Cf_>XZ{vVC_p2lW>9ZRhVLTzz?WCd_6ZyF-3>bx0sWqU zSO&FOtPTM#!&KW3pOIy)0ZA47y+{aM<2&&W9!3~@WYUYdWB|~Y>fHk%ta&-d3ssUb z_y`AQcQ1R-nU5jTXbKrXymy%^5_P%mz}Hz`BMlX@>!%n$>*O2TGNa<)JB(1m z_{pXoD1b9?Sb+vYc?mtAsr>WXJ+Go47;;kUrO3Zd{N|`DPIft%JaTaH zTp}p9OA>4dx`Xzp5u(j{Ww6*fViWjqw#-gw>QYZPIeK4dfqfrX4;52@+e?Wzq;~2L zj=)#lp*2WZ!AzOsRdK>VJ+18$Kf_$Fb8;x>tJ)s*kIzL=$U*H$hQl{ykOx;JD zxat8C8QbfzeDh#}d7F@^=?5}RW+inWCuorhUAhl^d4pek11{w@)gR_jyv48_+1i~Q z7t9GOtk_@BtR@aJr!??na-$8dY_yhUR=vBC6GT}kJCj>$HZCWDF9{|Jt5AA>`oq-xK+`o&G8;1n_>gV! zQ?MtJnETOes5vjMEBOoR8bPG|bsKSf0)*>#ZPD4r)fK)K0#$s!oo3TScH=0EPgyg{ z$AdX3jRQ}Lc7@*`f!ae9CepQmvNwb}xn_L28+>-^-rY3v#1*H(Cp`lZKnSX^GST}# z5>d@z%k0?6u9oOW-3LO84)f~FN2znG9?Gl&wLnLWOlvY5d%Sq}Z_p|HE0GR9k6htE zW_HiU#FEa?!G9A>wuvi(klMfn6j_GMe|`IK6Tl2jFJl=&vl6fqlKAWiAFd$G`zWZ( z1Ebx(nm*`4C3e5vfNSlb&CiEYFUO#?T{0h3ojdDjbig*QFE?fr>OBqcp7@mc=sWZV zL#mCTT|(G^>W`9NclRR~)#FLX<9zKfa*YTJn%@(qD`K1;0az3bh28Khvc&gKP@|Oe z3TaZHk@}-D!asiQhsG2H5g~M>f+81abx`Y+&lQnaDYR#Q|8qrdn zryCEiLNS-ZewzbjXpp)JK_?}lO~3m`9W6M?FM*GE&^MqATq37BE&z$KAle%wRcMe> z6;%37l1OIi+;8MIxKTU;qnj)N?>B$=Z0nSF=~kd8vIk3u0#QRbh$C_KmOwN{Q7n!P z)sr}?i>DSN9h8HA-@FcYCf%;hd*$R4$%!LRd6uznFIJF9OVPsD8x^z`-pju}gNi9$ zWO5TFVEKkxYhKXowKr@RG|7w?x*vt9oUn+kS`?9Ws3DBgD6ucOMLUrN#YNk7O%uDf z$VOSHvDCEb2*3T9c#NJKSc^qcU99@L2GJ8q)?^5gnu!ijwjtFpAk+u@XG5#g$KM{1 zyjY#Ky<+S!&x-nf&M@wf-~pv^J;elE9^~qK=^ge@gGHVYoB^vlCc>Ox5EPNw4XZa; z^HX%(qnAh^JCq}2mX?_>YBpeY&Gdtr6f%#6-_`vL3d=Q;2x+andjJvO)uGX)39X3M z_;c`WmTn2qT9z25Zarwps{5Ovv|riZyeFwk%tKz|$P1L%h(>G$69Cj`h5Fc3Q8nw_ zG<3RS21EWvD=nnrge!4CbKQ)6iP+uJ4Qz0RB&WggEB=4~oO~gQFu}pZvy14;Fw#1* zC>Q(ZCH)_J0ePjr7ytKL|4%ajKbJyRoIbeapKu1(s9mW(OwM`|a z5xqG}S<0dO-Q+CT{9^Um8+tJAX-yc0W3C+h#M+>GPzL#78}g|_=4PmfL|hSgJolid z8aL$(Y$_q)5r>D69!Emo@ELUtDp^o*YTlJ{!yIrZB+I*?hu&=dIUL;T)~%ovADXSW z*%}wK=NkIDo&n^ptzhGA%OGHJ3tDOx@eo5-A#OY&zJ%GK$O@pYbceX&yE`Ki3LAW_ zFYLQQ2->s>!xh-<`Jv+M>UajQ{g?;T!kY+EXCbl`w62k*fF7s{+F*hk9Bpe?AluG( z)co#t{hytS8Y%K=D!Z9tiZ+<#zadIR2LvF=e$-{RymCm`T486$P7y)t6a_VJ`h9Ph z`Zfbdb%|*zRm}~Uo@jG^3<8!pDy)%cuz?!g&-`QB>^(`pII?x~OAfAUPuNa^4+X5U z&rpuw#^JPKOY86k6E1vy!3gR6mI5oc8KeY`Q7Y)C_B}pOwnqb8c?gHFO1qI&v<*J) zHZvnFgIKN&oQ`m-w+0=Tv0=4Z%ueVp z2FE}Bh5nUyLxG9AR1z?hRa6g1R%K~r-g(IR3n5*|*b8~^funTWNePdhA{eL=ep(*$SL`w#eH9>K= z{eq3q(G;8WWN}%%zk)6yvh~wB!a*2TT8;PJQ4l!lN!B^t^W-Z9=+7BoSGeMY>tI z%P?NJF^(>>B=1er{Aw*fMyB0~^KxG_cI@in_cC6u zGib<_8}qYIL`YEWh1~;pJ`j!H#9(+~8r(CSucCiG@(_XLJ1qH*_7VZeTQ;IiNFqql z+~W&FH!F7|m=qG&@7%ZQ$+*3fpOb>xus)RnRmm*FD8_+DfH@c~niYnl6pzdbFc1Nh z1^bty!X)&9Ue``J9MM~Zz1@qHJsb|DUYkyrs}vZl^o>4TujiEBfYW?Pa$(K4VOW)k z?+Xkvv5Sb&P1xDeZCO#su2eZI7?R|QhVcLsU5gX@&brrA3eJS4-AF? z){s+-rvUhkxDwktTu)0ZI?o_feig~<2`@=6BkUDsxCEi%8Htsn(+|$yg?hww)C0UF zT8k{Z-&Ch#hN1Ng%3b$Xa9w!4R1HBY2B_?VAL1kzGcH)68Xo8=clpo2B4|k3J!td( zI^{f#UW~xO_7Dcitm@Aiz84Ci?6+I?@)(p{Xmi#{B|T>04vN_}@HL3c>Bzr@hLi5V zxz|ZCLi!yhRK)sjZ{o|F&CU=r*V6e8jMj6XU8kG#9<8(qdzOKTCcTH8FsY+CR(~Nr zC-Jvs+btfeyfxKwm`yDd=o_fRpnLCHWZ z7~xQF)sQkSO9=CpZrMmca zBzUhyMug?iV*7?iNE`<9>A^l#Qgx1#*nRm=#A2iXhc#D41!3@+m>bBXd=((-w8+bx z8>RO;PHCpdAC7q(YTP3?;Jq<=FCpKsylZC*xjyZvz(km|oNQRun~WcK6R=>N|H4F9 zxxFCujvWj^MN!I}Nj4xV<`7BDCqDQ$k?J&iRf3%1kJ(u&TK3?Xa$!VJ13lmH-q?r- z)=&u+c4TX1PWc)|*>f8FhWaH2Mk4f)W`H3cmS$c7W{sD-GZeCg5ZG3s#}Elf(e7+esjB8OkOwr(fJIHA8HZpl3=0mYW`IeF zpTgVW>&$Hc)3tGzj!a3d^brCXg@wRZR1h_*I*v(0xGO>qI8(n2;L=bIuD*M4^Qs3# zHA_muu!9+ZHcHLdjzuEoS2;XCWyq1H`VyC(bLCxv_J|;yl|HzR z*ub>CBq%2%MlF2%;~oP}O&M{sPhk+GYur%agvyuiTEG|pkFD?#+9OLYsq_P)X8r&8 zYklI3xELOEIQaI6@+0WC@%O`X2H zDQY>vUgHC?CynR`+=mSe9m3J(XIE(;t|s8zZP1{?`Fg`f#Rt?VT(lek%uK0UARZ`E zO~#r#oOOm^E06|+zb0d6;#o0}{#`;ORg_>TL)wBGt+t8}k$Gu&hDH>}`Z2QUbMwU) z9r7(JwZ42ovyWj5-vb?|_;Br;=C*4|lRf=!NM|Txxh@GgPRTM(==!ZdTTS^Vy|+Eo ziEpYQR1}-;=t^H4u!ma=bcYp(^FfgUUX2!eCg6Dh5pQ)oRA)w!oh{Bq2!_HyR1!qAe@Yfr;KIrU9(UwKuS=ocrKMW&C{j?E9zFeA)Az!6u8}ZTkhqF z+mz66Ep*Y^{sm-p<-=vbQG80w-p(MMcZOq;&ASfNNEg)xbJ zHQ_lIsubZ=E3oNz(CTu6EKNw7Ia2$dMwjUxSg@k8e4l$(G(EyByQw!&76wQC7yRX7 zm>aPRW{hI{2V*uCD%;feR|4R@n*jcDr`%TsQGW*JJn$iZ-mCjti^S zf#^sWgMzOO@{8N0_PDD_P1DJLQ0)&dK1H5{G7oZ^6=%E>-h@bE zd;O(Cw*=&ALJp;7EystM!yaIpBaziLG8c$WJJy&5tCEEw59DD&8EHSW?Mvl>P%LsyR>VoR^J_A(C7SlU%dTuUc=Lh`xgIX$5Z{UOyK#Y5c($r$HX|)=u3MD%t zI5NMRU~TI|^dMA0Io-5%We?w7rf>geQ;dd{-T&kg0FV5TP!*QXL|dO3b9luT7P~lJ zTZ@}*Gpl{H3WW9F{C2T#SQVooYm0{Le3)^Al7@3Y2T&8wWD~w$!X%<*Chx#&xf|?{ zJdf(JawYGtX##6Mn;$r2OIpWI{rJyxWJ+xg0j#7buE0rhYwm0eQ+mugAd9N$nR}gPYHmTC zDv8ZesOH?4wtX@=l`pK>ulrtD6u=IAtAK!R8c=2`nTg{W5%vkKR$fS)ZF{;YM8(HfclmG_%xwkCOnptN%5)$a2m7x{^F(x!r_AlI1AWG^WO@sWKktv(+jnex!Ay(pA zKE=3~fF#JXepE3(5a`llEVUC4s6NtU$0S}2IPkv1Xvcn19GC|}Y7S7fH%!uz44McK zNX^2smZlK`06Xp@#RBafU2_98r}o)^Lr=so+6BmDtfetv7^YSJMh$AlK0y5RKANqc zA((#Pc=!v*kniaelI|XhQjn*@mgh=ZZ>)^39Q+W*u6{=E%WieaLVz09lnjCYf4#d# z2RfDGcVX9B$l%go_i{+0KE<%kHh}2Vm+gd4jlK+pG;M4r+U}#L{ig)P+a+jGcA-W+ z({*o2paOgu`v88*y0-hvb&cIWUH7C zZ0&4wMCUi)gepdoA9^*ZIDVdJ8wQrj8~NUKFjaSMoThj02qd{7Q{E9_C9oNRwgv4M zgx>f@BA&D4x6rsOobk8r8tEvv1?Kie&=w0J#tJJBK=}5T3%nsmMX9T;v@x-PT%+U- zo^ETo$9$GV13143r$qR!0pGEwrBKDNUEbL}7)({my{z6md-QGVQ>U^V%Nvw4OMZQ@ zziK}ZWiW>W7Hq>KA^(5Eq_#RVTIJKXK zrt;ovKS>z1i)}Wi`Xjkcz=NHAG;F2eTTunydQ@ZhR$Tap79sT)f-~p6Uae0x_4XnW zf(L-fTai$4?2QXR-dZDIrMY{i0+&j4V4nPp`uTK*=NalxOFMX2ii?=F&EN4|fX2ot zES|A{&$Cx%D0`kZJa+bzBXn`td8Sd6jTp-0z{q(DraXRNYsDTK{U*fl=sC&o!)O~i zYrj0?m%In9tV54T&)>Ka%d-nO`VBbBo%YYD&EACr5wHSmv-YJM|6~wQaJ+o_<6JP% zVu7=@Fwg*(+y-5AKF>Gsm;SyEorV5Y3P|bA|8L;;?@xSsdL(o|n#P7dy(av>|8lS( z*em?|M=<|CZCY7BJDXyr7W);S^DFXym`~WL_qu-Nu1PTO0Nvj|&0_o)INtrg{q_*| z{$(`rLUb1dxy^Z?9?XE7$_qdDum)4-y`jvrEcn`3R&=ceSyp(l@g?&Vb&I}`2z>Y z4$b8y)ZB)A!S;tOw1;QltQ2PU`r*F`AqkmBnxgE*4u)<#m8o(-l=oE#$T7&kqW7Eh z6!;hZdnf0rJ~+KDcWwy3o3d06U6V-QbMW5T--H^su$`g+dXJ8m@Z2)#2w{8G_6f|h zI$GgGYlR+A+ci2P+HV(mX8?-1M7Ebk0HJg+LE)Vqw(-A@W3XnY3?ZHf3n<(m3| z*lNV=3#HNkFAG70O7)h+F7!mEU(<6&trk&8pb*?}m*(6V>sy)sE+s!3WNTXzo1&nK z%yjVfB0x40M)Q(8z`*mQ%ZUwS`*kNi9xY>_k;K59kZAsPk+U-$XRQ-=H^uH<{KWSIXx0n^K{9}832dK>i5tQ8A^z@^Y(^2#a-F{rV=P{cy~r(i?BG1v}mLp#(R zK{Q^gz8w1X+2^zzQ@%b>XC>Ano62pVh+1fUGpuyYbqAZVR%9FmK91WN>EwEJn}Pqn zFU#;I8YnUj#_O%nMmlRDWe+3DgrU$V=s@JT9i2>#&r&0BhS3Wc*g{c`Ux7&&4828O z0Ful=%~niO4GpPFgPtBnLCjLi3E|LwkAkCHB*5f_?A8C=paCc0L^CRSn2npQknjpc zNa*HTe#OKZN5Fl+C(V$4>MgP%+txO5Y#d^j*+ucur541&Q(;Kxpj$(5%4H=$r-}LQ zMo@p@S0MjlEc%mDu#f^vRb5#Ts)Va5EpWu(E`iAFXYF+i&*IttF^N8O=n|J!Mlh<< z+8~t&e8KDtY(QJMALj0q8%MhVBsE>Nh4x$;95eX0vyJ8dxsW4cAf2)O(Xt6*fTeLn zRJH6*V_hWVLhWF=m4}R+K_C{19E(wpt_qfDNo^^Rk0PO3hy*vBp`|kTQC7kTqT&t} zTN688JOAg&?uXU#56NmA9KgLrAQv$)tU*S2h@&#|j4l2W!pjjq(7zhCayGSQCw2-=RN8;yrm zcK#%^#_wUdfG4Ma=uP4$TmN68)jr3Qd=p(r?N`i^jv&ZD7hlBng1-N5=8Uvk`qy_G zG3Z(OU4X6=19DHBfes&jXXgPG&m{$Rt%Xdg=D%eg{1D5%rnteQ!C~$X?Nwk~EsX=9 zZ2pn!*VR2?@WGT2}bF-ZVteC z5!9asY`0yYp(X0pd8No(4NS{``JAPWiLf@)z!cRSV!|#n3GAxOfnH($Yr1KdFo0Z65n15wsf!pE zXVXfIp%qPu3M_owz1}NnaMmGm7M{fukfK4S5XvRsi(Q(Yg*x;eVH4tbG-T6hle_%` zX?$?s^*8N6``WGM65wbbMWm|JPkJ}R0n;h*p9Tt>txi3n`BYM|Yo;j~`p{um-n09m z$+IyqStt_rZZuo`{f|{(zja$Gc{0HpujdR1&N)vaKp-<9AuOg|4?Dd9TZV#I1zP-o z7kjbR&Jf#&Ck%jL+X@BkZMe0&1Rh#2G+xL*IZXv*ZwB1w~d8P8g#X6l_U6jKe(-uc|KHkOFCUzKZKpNAJz)+O3 z2>m{ujW!~ZF@~=_m(?Rh^j%-T8Sms(EO3SZ*ATHmBB9k51%!pdn-~^GjYJy|uFZg5 zu>cHIFCc8oYgzH#yrj6X7nS`9zVI=a!=^o7oq2KwjvggIj%<^U(s>;f#M{GcA?gEZ zLO&rZ`&nRw;StZVx|1fHT78Mt+Q4MH4%zeF^TUmd%@3|7DYivp8=kN084fGGv2t^po)Y;*%M5RE0)FUB0ox2=K zo))5;rPX9JRMZ3~LH&qBJ@xhmoQP7xNxxv(mg+eH3#a3&CCcOcWbMz*AG1AsLyntB zcj4wO!h()oo&yr>Lhr*AHOLFePnsQOKdNd(H8-Tn%6qY5F6o5tehf?cS7J@w!@a|^ zfQ#L31vKg8;pjId*)t)&w+vO$ zz$&m4<`ce_JTB~k%vSijQF+g9ymDR6H~gFz@nCyRUz~e zaJ&Q&$_U}DWN+F{0|E0A`Mn}5GVRn{3m8N1hRjt5@^4y4heSc^hZ_I&KK2lvuhx{> z4htDP6ua4^i23>1mBJ4N z0UXNuDcu2iI2%5-IKra}+eij-}?;Gf`j>+F5TasP`1l>K7 zWzA@>*ZguW1cn!pkcgzJy<(OcJLRCIYVx4B#f=*@ct3$0AdK9X5E-V4@(j~N)n3sR z5*1=~6Y8$iTLS?l4Gx=mfzRk61XpL;uYhx048Tfb(4>)=`q50`aK`N5eMTKp%vVrO zdDd#m6awNL15%rz159E);h|orHU#J65S#Nx$SeEsK;u=Js={`$mJt9IXF&YH3smjW zXH?QTLu&({mB>Cuu3Igo`W)rNr0X}JlgS-0Vq0o&ta#RiQk0IRi6CEH^ZOjmrjRnA z2mpC=4KLt51$7zVJlj=*M^?2qT)|5qU5sE5OO$I4g0uBzbPbu_Fupb3@8kpAfoDP9 zGGA_)U|2e*ry~7YDA*45a(QV7hYYSq_|n z_UE}M*0pFy&o6!98mQ#52uCFS*>6@Ab8{7c5v;B zm_t+of*WGlKXF_szrA}D{@eiYY1pShJMbFy)w{Mg=NWVlHX7Fw%XYFrAN3 z3i~TF&vjBV{hQo{Zw`Z2@JyU~5;VVzBK8H+^Cl*!GdnvCS*DZYB4`Gw0ddPw`^>J< z`zDw~1h>>Z)b$QhBi_9~_^yH&dC8<$N!NLWMP1nnUuQhew@e9A^~Jt^Xk4Tf%0GytV{R^6^!%@CH?Iex>2uk)OchCiM`FAJTI+w)#=b# zEwn5nB)@cCE$|+>ny6KP>sHQFCFv zQ**>ldqU#QJlX-ohNzvlHkLq`Ff8bY$To8@Wj;QkSr!xtJ&1`t1IdseB6(zj1Oum^ z4mlM{b4tuE#DT%-fajyF*nr+yFj!q)CedMjvsGq`Y17$VUqQeP_G?zmJgh` z#G<{o{pQ?<{3jXORA?!fVl!>eMKLsMAp%VKWB}umvZmm1?fG~AXXUfo&@VW(4oM?D zQxK^o-~~mmZq98_oP8z!<~fG|K9bgwA*=_uY!?UiVpyzSh&As*7Rb|?q8~C==AmdJX+j~AAth?1 zc`}n(WlEAVg~Do3W`)QUm6Wj}BFTSVkM@4w@B5GA|2vMa_iJ0$de-yY_kCU0d7jsK zDfk+f_0vVLEFFZ4syDQq)IFz$Hm*#s5~O1Xc6~;#?cKSPPuAX}*Z3xKDOsH(8-elf zY-{fbI%QFOf!I~bqKZMN3LjV2Ygcw6=x6$9lTaTXH#4t(CJ>J8!pBLpgz4~O-sW|4 z9hWtqe@*=-14-gY)MKVGLLB-G_KKx$>D&udkG!Z6^0vgDYeV&K6M1KW4fssVQB)bY z=Q(`X87%miWRiXd1o>8$p=&R;xM z%_pVQK{vd#?+0L7eUQ!iAXLhr;tO3^HEHZO@V8|&%N$~xvhy>9OHmx_@cNVMR`$xBi>h3bbtzp*ECZt7nk&>Hl~Rdth)Q%g@d0-YGh*7ayB7c}ws z&F$hHOjof!1|sCEPhSIoPo7b?<|8VW{_e0F%xJ%NDVyu`%Fb7nrSn-6PeC|XiDtAk zy2VRLwrQT_IHraeyPkJJT;EZ_gr-xIaMib=h?@+ysiTu^<`J*8=Y3_&Y55e2% zz8b6T!93-E{uEyDf6V)$awel_9s7??H+;FWfD%}C1^)9YKsp*2E%u*(3Tat#7Qg?u zyJ-yqcu{2d;L?9yp@HF6f>>a;LDSP9qCt}y5_3OL4e~p4U6){Qp z5Axc+fQ?zPrwH60!Xqz*9ObX6S0Ql?e{|;cx1Od38YrNSvW0K%f4)MUGKoVAc!ILq~gdLh}GIxzpC35Dr434x4-|*ssAn?-`VS%ieAIa*y_|l zL>C2M5DFBJ__C0G6pnwVKKj!cgG^_WJw_kAxZ^%=V$f>lo0_VzNKFQ`w`RW8UPw0Xk+wI<_}ZuY3#H z^3M%q2@UhKRHrnMKhJ3Xu{(Lq53A4BAzgT<{4Y3$)~d;zAnBcNs3sa6MdeYS4;a@# zp^;?ExF-Gzn}62;EA?{h{s{-FZ~9Twv7~Y+oL5Mw1_qVtJ-%m~F*5+E$FrYEi{deQ zi0)T4@ZnOp5p+A3?c2&UUyog%saExjD4=MsnMOTg!bVfZIxusGfZ=xcL4X;K=J40o zUV@{jat=#N{(r&tz7||r#Cr!{JAn49(G2QECOl+dIR17P@Wn7Nr=id(OV_lsSCLch zf5ZE`+n6JsE==RFY48nN{XcYljIyK(2Cv9C#QX~^%&a)6^v8^J{2h9@guep9s)qk{H4jAxX> z%u5TSxU%RNp&|y*-nj*upEoC)y@GyL^7pyTyv(wK)d*J1fgsUCSpdvJQA)}0PKY#NeV++6owdVIUvHw*9OYjtA|2)Vecp|L#adpI(}w|xfw8@pmfTf zOBtY-?~@hV?sCwO{CFz!h_qL9NNF^UKjMiN9feMNi~@^CwxS@EFg^sZV0n5w6T}wG zVs~O3hoqKMnSAZ*$>|#I2A|s>ccZ@Z`R>y82lZ6I6DPp)rqNj>srVA~Fbg&5D3)z` zNZr&>*Y2XoI2w&LK7TXGCr9cn^TA@V+nDOb992Tw_XF&VM!y4Yty9%rmEEuQFnr5K#@FE!Ibd9Ke?brn@17gR1%YPX@2~HkBiZ zwc-I0JZY%fZl{&^=Bqp)z86sKEhyKkxjLu~5u*naU9aPcksO zWza*Nc3oB0p}lBh**)4xK43#g0F9NE=?&Q5ZaDCgW5Mu4K$30gRfe*VLhL@vEJthJ z7EBGWq27Se(V!2RCq|Duqw7y>eh-Qhh2;#v<9mcF3kqU_DxERe!g8RM-c}NlG^@^A1HsR=_oO{| z;=R>#KV8g)4njUR8@QA+B!V_uy(Jcl6yEN*DGm;~{adKL=!pJyZ<_b_Z})PMSGZ|Y z%cD~U7@@#$b6A8=rox$MS|7k#nhO>}@E?X|5})}JK#a0A$H&Y4PY0nY{qk60n8^(cwX0`k`2) zb$$J0b=L@wh)gc?r9Yyu_==+%KBI~4aKJU^ehTsc81YB@Cd*s|9llNz-M;UX!h0CIHPmgw6$nYc$kToiVwcO`b6!TFN9*EKGx3Yl6 zP#P>l7?>StM_u!x+ZzSx`-vQ2O|>Coh^j;r@nQ42oplo2<-E;HHnQ|F1rn?&izJvZSsLH|{vcJV1&z(Jm%$myN z!dLG8>jfwL>?KrLaUVAK?x?dP{hpEP*L5#0&VKXxAfguO7)v2@*$*<}{RyPBM@i@_ zOH$;y4rr9#kXnHQ;MErUjSSx&55f9?t5u_fv*DGYKsB6g@9xfZp|8TopwH`G&vII- zqoeHn^5%)P6X)z&4NABa6s#R}|5Ecn$g`xG#Gs{m7RAZ8%+Xey=5o?#fHJ9>O*rw1 z0PE^Mt1EMB+WT)ke`$!e@t}g%vb!V_mUR|PdT)lM1 z7X$vMCSp;=2XEcZ)!k#^@^Zb+55^Q@x?%a{UZLHIrLiTaO-vVjq_7fni)>brD-ypt~!xK4n>%_U5LnCJqU@-=0=g3Y^5uCU}_olP|{tKjO$`I0U11y6w>c?8G zRlB~INU_AZ5?GM>?>8-fjWg!;CI2JelfIKkD?czAnU=;DN0Kqq*x%c_SH4oR9Gx^H z;;Q1!>(AUCZ35Nus|g_|$54ExkFM`OELG-q?*7StUicw|E!{u_^&ZgtJ)dP3`y>5* z{n;e?G)$i42#A!7{((E$@GQPV;AQ`bg_l4Wh7y+X>nw_chOZqdzhLF1)`vS?plXP_ z8oNk$!;-huAdxBJEp-igN~2=|El}irpU~pMHOuaTc7`ztO3V{XtX6^9_cVb-xC%v2 zmNzX)?P)o?N0F}7Se7O}(X z<{G#LmPkD)C96jAj8L$Xtlt$n@5=b`%_3;`Iy^6Z>OrW7VAdek(Z2Qmq)CIfbW2Z7 zQxEA<8`+tXl-kV{9EMRllj8nl%b1kw3vH?&4NNxXkWa-4F9l@d~@V86jqQ-L|;Alef|miE^?uZ~GQiFy<4KNj|+ZsDFJBy1JESEfPPcXnpK_66mQ6IyO` zztknU{tohH7>%8y+yD)!Jp*f-o9@L%kIqlC%b3zt8F%T#w%Y5iDAw(x9ns`1 zgY-I6RAt=i2U|vdB6qCYwQZM>etR@zr*{R!mu1Yl7_Sw1=-9B=Af&rL1wJlYbVEke z;)i6;ZW{7=MpB1zF_D>(iymBB7j$4s?X=A|cv@WU-1&9g)jm-@8^*%#u01&_>%FNs z4=4EA<(AqHllHP+Zpe4eIlg&rk!*!(m38uZJ5X;J36jC{-oot(4kDpG(E_LIVm*5d z9`U7cYWqh?zcD42^e$0Vmse;D^q{3$Z=jwCu$``&-FzIlWj#H-E!q8Nu|*Pu@nvk2 z=}N)IKA51UNFlmge2Mw!9B_kQjV|4D$efVe`EqxSH^;>*&w+nLmjYB%%IDyvPlYMbZ2+F!gY zXV(zYpl)ZY+v80VjYWsufRib3%WYb7p7t<4O{yBasI{y&6>-$p*P z{9BTAa~~|8YHU}G6RDwstP(s=Oq^+!6`XPM*Z2Ip9L!}-y@)P|I)WD#c|1T5z3_3(AZbd$hf9oimRa0#{E7mo?xUcJi}wBY z@e6pHs+ZR3J!-~K)g}eGE5YL&4R3PDPH&_F2DZ$Icp%%XZ!LU%%p!;>&(p=ypr- zG4{{jN{%Fa9RXaF`A!oE*0$-|ZXH|JUQydzw?6b>vAfBTPJgZvnBic&gNA~DE6cD> z9f`OsMv&hfapJACgIwyi;4`c7YF{|q1EZ6kaj}GGz-#IX+oq87XB{kJKn)( zrw#nkmA|pB@%mX;9~{v`=MLhYzTSNhEWjKk_JZ8e&6$2bekOxkDJxY%qD{K!QWQSX zHx>*Q`U%_Dxo@uD@THYn=B^AM?$)gvdKms|gAagP)ef6=&$i`xWZMwIvI>0G@QbVy!-GD^NIJm4|Lf)KL!m(I2f;5)TUtS$W$+2`i)?%~rAe;l z_yBeILGCAq0GKa$7+^Fbl@!?F;#X!-`D@FFOX9Z?%=IOa;(-`-tw$=KuULO1?G%)h zlZTsmVx5kdm7ffp5qqu=OTR9^*w|V0UF~hty^H*QEc$zt6AeZGF^cOALJTjkXNh+W(E@P4J_x4KTkz(HA%Q-xLsFh8Q<8T&A;%#wx8C#R+ z_i0bj_UMP}F3e1q;$aOUq#qoJ4=LGm{;Wzs{`WV>?9XQWdZyd#R%M`gMo^P0d)E^W zYA+)fEdY&0GMu2q8QM?y7AU=V^ZG$oYRR4`Lud_#ck;gAAKai}5Z4)r1GdTVluWca z)~EvkEGO#MnLfoMkteErw$dh>CliCuB(y(71B89E?#sqf&1c3nM^<=BJy-EqIY} z!k0BaA8nSj%GAH!m3q$D@{d1cEH4CJKftqY?S{LH)(GjXT_AM+;*zRc2R02ZJ$9js zuXy?fuDPj`3ujKUx;k*8sp50A$7+8CNu2*i7 z3dY5>1;&4U73OrW{XI1fHIjhGqybnqd($5rY8Q^>d6_f=bfER53ELawoF+Y)#KR-(|h%$UV8-|TE6U3}3fZPEx1X!)2|PHm+UI9|`EdEoG;8cwz# z;iKud8{^f^+Ae$b`rEzo+Ii327ypSZta|Fn)sLNW=zq%jw3@y;+0_%A)_pD$dj-2d7v&C;2e+z=nLlxU_(5xZnQgL9eaVKIr> zWc0c|CgWoI_y}RH3=k4pFo%*L;ndMe9@fM5!K6ouYHw_lOJ9qJxaN7!aR5f{pRx+= z-_GHiChb=98-ZdZtlsIz57w?rHK|kh_^t#5Z?(}iSCcZOArfY8#;2 zh+H_meA?v6mjZrlv~#fCK!aVy{`R%jR5~_rJ5lRq|4RA6cmeUJDOxuLR0#039!|3= z5ksaHM1<6jv-M|NT6W3mZW9+YJ&^rr3hs!_3f9%de~<6uJ_!6&1}&B7@y8^)oOJKg zbGFtN)qWr4yIu8TvipY>ES5yB`!??F_v}VRYRTb46#~MmWjZrFyTRRtB>B#ozwx^G zY6~>ki8O!2MwNf0QW?#qJuTwU&sV#)flZEu2E3ABClfQRDj+3>2+d+>@3}kNNQnHb zGWXKs2zr9^JWIa{Xzcm+C;zD1b8g zG71%tn{{e@>$i{r6eHq)H+ZGkM=YwDVM)Oa5nJdHT{lcVGC`0-$=h!s4M)LHH&kFEqP9xy*UNACUPImtrj!9`zyw zrK^7miH^hg?c5)$2nlIKT-dv|qh%ZG;Jc3Zp8;Bw6<#K3%jN3xkvSG0?F81@>1~&4 zykyWh-)1}?-wT_8E6|-cct(S~5Aj>}!}Qy@wf1}6_q6XVm^zh{_C=7(@tmfbblO|4 z)inlX;Zm7=!^*x21O2f-xTpHCFBzS3PD$s?}7a-Fg~PYxsy9J7&Yyk9GsXvQ8^sS>?t%BszYmxkKF( z%ctgXX_%@0vMu|BxD@iz;hv4HoPlXd%-`Q`oWY_jFwFywLar%uKU}XF5pop_Ci8d37V&Ca%clqccKg{|g~Qb@kI6j)rWg^fT## zQ?s~)cD%^>d*0GZDZseeTD#EUX=ONd`=`7G@X2sUN{|wo$wS)Yb6!qtS)mCYQFASIGi$4SG zzaL(bEAW3VpZ=2LZ?`X&-Q&9sFu4Prn%lO&U?P1)Y?&oJMqo3Tz`}>4drR(6-wm!YSAO@-vkGXKZ|1$*YNDk@=i&>8_(p^sc zto(;qZ>gG%^Hp+Uz)i>}ckWjdTd~^_}i~Ls`OXxuMa#d;oxkc8aXn{`V;Zv*b39 zK)bbsn4{aU*NeSaJ%iphG2OnQCZ`8&MEWZ?wBJ)!=bQR$8mFE2kl+d74`Bj?=2%sPm?76gL>-N6oM@Mj@ZM}ez zuj}heJq}*AS!!L!I!A;TXE)Z*Ik<7)<7t~rmeJ#TLavT0SS>cH$wutcgWjyHzhk1V z)_q|McE-0E2sE4>S)e_C*xh)9>zo$H#?gS=Zouo{E$A++BLV2d#wOEUWpBEXs4dTX zGd`@^@2rtpKYs(mjzm1IeK{Ktp~T6PCw1;5bbcD+7%QCLKjR}yr1l3kLu`Vbt3Rf_ z7!EsY+If=!@y!>oso!@l?^XUC;^6Qk4osy_;cNzUVs9I3+wGA2Ia%K5{Z>&};GBUN zVJ(!-r2@>MaAzt9u5KDr7pWhZl-SURCgyNg@Nj{Z1N0Uw^Hvm&D+LS=cU0>j9EqXf z?*7rQAK(VN4C=rZhT3HFJ7tY;1Ze&N1wt;SW>-<2w90zMsuF5Sf0sB4`lG(g-a`780N_rf|wcNu|+u1{{QPS@nSpe*u z;9sMPiuIC2HF~&vluG37bwDy$0{gaRut@g4mm3d4v#EdMkz$bKc7<$@&|S=}$Wmn` zK-eM$HKiYDw-T6rwxVCu`Z&cV!IOZ#Uh(%b3;swHnjZ>btr=i0t*UDNb7aIM&VcTO z(3^#9lX<&n&_)@BIF|NmJXKL__6O_MufGr--QBax(lVCXz@V;THPe*gPz_*IkLRh>DfnnLSWdKso)l z=H)*ZLme6bRba@FfRwo}8k~yZzHZR{8OWR-_{pXwbNYSl6I@wP9K;W<_w?|vgv3+g zxH^j?Yb7{v<3V_fyaU95P53^se3Ya;pJ5lVq%&=EUnv2#yYvo zr<0rW-itdotsWC^RK#SEiIX&Z3j#4kxe&@foF8Tv=SVJFym)ahfFd0<`ZhM{GZz!h zl?6mR);M5MvR`nP!P8xG!N;Q-VpRO_D4J4qp9hif8Zr*V?InQi*UX`-9&9y4@ebmCMbv&I~~u~P7y zHe14+OKduj3&9H)F5FXIuceh%N3Y=2abrj(dH|-f8)!y?wJUrT1D03y;kO-3m&k{s7Eq&(#OSBhSAw`rpFpq8mCp5hRnXWRm z!VV4&-ep|4g)+Du!-6f5l*!=ep9>8o$tPWEX2z^lM016a4gic;NJ0FgMxYw*rS3fT zd&qz#uwsG%iRCe&nRDmT&M^OI;!>K- zcdMO@nED10gJ;f|v6$8!u*-{z6s5^2sqHvcuN9z>9tUP2yq1S~j13N|1C3c5VK7?} z%p7uV6I$MZhYk;Y7@Crj@*tc(fHjqz(=J1IYOej~ym_<&DHphZFs6k0anaSDCE5tZ z!O$e>!iFgpS<}0ZANO_4zYHtQ>mMu77iK;&3>_K)W@&iVGQelDPmJc3G%%+|qTkt6 zgy#6@7%Lvy>x5aZgbj+nG_#|PkMTq#psyvRbate~SBSvFKH9#x1Eg{0^y#~7-_Ydv zRP?;VR4Jo2zJbmR-vRrkoXzOnT!Qp(mCqtL#a1yb87!r(Ig>fO6DEY`j3*WK*2CWO z*~q{Prx5s`8IGv`U>{0d6r^X}J0p8bhO~VJ`6t!$@<6AV%6T%Y$qJNcnF0 zi@5_zJMq5o#g$#}S}(UDf&9Vw@)9BC)!nu&1V&j~QL!ua%Jz)7NrLX%}mc`a3HUD9RBt5D48OzTenW6uSzKS z{px+;+zTcv{Tk;eZ8W4dXVxrXb#-+^PXmKQA}**8NE{dM)M3XwLGrhok$vd>*}6Y} z{ra`XNJE32oqK#F$Mp@`4C0V!9;!)Gje_*brL(52hw+2du!Xrx6!rd8!tacnV^5zx z9Wr@F_p9=nT@2^QIm4BOjHeJ3x+u&W-+lak!svnLaOUNOYG%Mc#qrix(a@*^T4<`)IRh{vC+;<0O&aAHwIK$o($`_8r zljpL<*5OqsIOR?Dd|otr_J?l@^sLy5j!LZW&=?fszFL7eHHMFotkG)w`jhZHxi7C) zOeS6{rLgw=w^&w0H8t9@Uq%%cYCDHR61~Ze5f3Q^c<*;!ziTYHeaxb{cKQY~dS48n z5!Xk}CyGcB^y0+^l8jm5NS1*Bfd(XsNM5lt*;gKM?}4{fs1*~9we7xn=`t7AS!ej| z;1g`ZSjeyswMm+$J~dZUhBp&wdL|ZPNgH8AowSV(4(ifwoa3b*)7NVaC4wl*xh-gB z(u39m>&i{iFJHctIwnnT$^6MuW+gn55abeo>YyPO?P@e&%DJty5^|2K8Nw@8=zE((Lvivn{?=J*geB72J3t$bo%ZPu1-@7-WHjY_>8jZ0cv{}LcVaWC>^#60@ z7f8tj3u{fSg9Hq{2YO&cC8=#i_}!i=cN^^BAY`pMH}awT{*gu`0qWo$$3#v|AX`n}n>jX_vLI-u)Cp^YQFi)_KyX=;l7c!-p*;o(jQ z%tWw~+O{lOwB~r@g=oTgSY3KsuCMC;;(~6v9;f7(_*uqcSYt#~ct)rlJ3MwUCeRdF z3cc}9HTDp3QaqV-4bw)Vs98Ygd$c*!PC;a`w`&IuKv87$Ac^KUFa89@i2nFFe5D1X zoh74IY)?HRU1ZX`KxLcjt57vqU6sSc^p+XIEiLZXuV0Vfdo$p$6!*Asue<0XBS^=a z3Vd9ob~{v45tq0ZX*xRIow7h_19VT47{s{shJdTt{x1iiV2tm{3f6cH$7jeBw^9W_ zoo6u}C<|2X&6mW9)+?*G8SQ<|)vceF3w^!V_AeS!ybC^;7Yq2!9Js}3hn z#A>(l#{1OEs@tP?Ecc)CzHTQUU6#_B_$Re~`^sOW?W<7o@$?MHoBEBMtTS@4#-tG1 zYlg5I10WdCf#RlYX%?X*>49^QiOPAt!W|ORK9uOwuS_{UbYNQmKzsR3Fo?=vZ%T}LhUR9uPNViMh{%`&`yP7UTc zS231I8`0Q5g`1Q6+KB5jCvWPJbAL=58c7zA7TdDA;VsJ?r&24rK25v5_;&B!E#ooh z*tz%E)?<|Av17=9H#dbV3vMBW;QQ*>bk!|?O`Xv4*I$2G;-1YE6f7%TAuy4TF9>H% z_%PPvp4D`?I4(1&`|}uohySi9rcVvo?m%!anD3`|e4`?$E z0-R7(Nn(`FYaOg6;dBFzi~^nIa~q)7dUxAyBIg4}5;U#>fp((;gI=ZknJszb*&kW( z%`8GL{DBT!90EG1GxT@cZC|_O$`AA#9V>TOPG4Clvg(&LDydeyG!@Frs_&PLJ|-a` zJ_}9pfgH~+_&!`O-ZCah^6L41Mu;9tpCl&Qx!nTOsi`@!DJwWc@ z8*|uiiQ~}Hna*DA+7U>FLnA~=t`Sy0wsAXRH1MgScQc2*Hg-QJ&Y|r%s+_?+^bSWf zSv~OY2|x%Bt3D5ry)O>+BOcxKGnPiZ?2#|KNR3UEDjIc{6IImby2%{fAFa@GSRY4V zd#{=T-*j>^BMXqy_1E2-|60`Pk=!rVPS@i{%Dka()!(K&*)>DQ%<95wQ~|PROQ8;iOOOWvap>(ty3pZs$Ok$kS~8 z2@lu_;}o6OEL&D=?Wsl=q^$>JPzu6k?Uid(RU7r^K;eER?cvV+pLMgji)1X%ho{#HVPIy@Sd4e-z zDr`jxT zMIg!bgERP+aopS{xyke!z82G&t{b+C`ndAPGuhNB-&oJ&CEB0=;2iZuCs{Et^4l2# z9-f{}O(OJ5?bAx#hi<5u&Oqe)%asY8eI{?Kk5f=XaGI}XXWR`G?s`mcCV{HA68`|?x)xf zBJ)@+^YWzJnS7r9#o{bicI9aV^syY;u|S9$4Jo(`RWd)Mzu4b-TTnDucTB|EHiEcI ztsR{KgF}8FnCf2D;K-3IBm#z@e)qZwCeLLaleT(-=5sGEFA*`ZXD+P_egf4&E7pPs zlkT@HrjrX|*E>G}YFxOJAh1<){rWhw2lR;jgf(@M zpvU9uOu!33-FI~|zc+dM+pj{{nll$HI1mrFKLT_fgi{C=5>$o*H;s-7oFX(fyzb85 ztnyQzX5S=JArm-6iV6vFnhfZDe7zye)#?Sf)5y8n#UF@6#TUd~F)kAp$g2-u zay0_oJ-54W8E|21ADlH8g z{9vR(Yq9v2jKM4-d3l*hvmOGmKj2BPbF^ahoEROBwk!!Qi@oO2b?>=xuLb>prATwl zNqA2+88Y>KH-2w-mcWFT$4{PofWevA*uAo;M!>Z~-r4pGxt|n_cm3FGmYd>adY^}i ztgFCk0O0!AZD)=L$56B=U5t*7USXcK0m8{g!A$lga4+&x^I4oN;okyQty*=*micwg z8OmQ#4hoNbR@6-Pe5eN#XRQQ2Rh!9R7%ely>PTgGfLZZh0{H{cTNaG`kU(1ksVXt^ zcjBZ;Gk5N6SfzT=m9B!lZ{oy>en4_{u+5wDnENU;o0~?X&%zcA@FM$7#PFVVwc=x* zK~d{v!_i{%7Y<@!8joaI99T5AB3PfNa%?mVxX0plx(x!iHGd-@NKs-z85!FpEr zC?yIGHsW+sju@~Upq=>Vgp5m%zb~3bOw)mZz7-|E2Zb%;K_ws{Z4n5pH*|R8#*NjM z^t&yauq@O=fd}I;2S5k5zLkpa5!Iu;(^oio-MzbVF6Q+09|9y4`8AbZwM%f!bImdL z^o3smchOQ{0|bsBO)TuP*po|=g|C(PI-%%DMc0CC`{7siOkqU7%XV479;VU2qM+S#Z;*F|{_)G3uLJn{3;TzJMHU22TIQH_p1`gl$nm0Fl>Ekw4QM{mzH z==u#!Cjub{PdB%2&YHnF;qlk1UBB6mp&t9tzwJiONd8!~)Jz|TOOKDIIL_i2aAi@g z4lK*x+^80t;^UJ{W|g*Bf^G{y3SWfUe?dnxb1)k}12csGz8t+zx=w04v}z&o#Ip~^ zw$#Nso5(~0b^=cer5MC(0q}UeV;>$|n{F|3X{97)kFvx;kmTh}b>n802| z$CjiTfheuI^I{}uKl?1kn+bvF`ODzk1*P;<73VP{rPdts2|b|nzH?Fh0lcxGmt$D!D_zjHl`YfQw@gAN!8+w0Bt%y(BkO$z}Dv3~v?z`BI{ify-% zkmoK&^m+Y;xv~ycL?x@CI?=@BpOYxZz5f;oYiV@`6trT=Sf{T4z1ucT;xKomG9JB* zTDWz>bo`KpuyH&OPu3W2?%Ok#0I;O*p}(gndQCnhm-K|)6q!)=P@44}v!Ox)g@O9Z z2+DbOE%kf@qtA#}nsiO- zaXiSRQEgjRE8bhg?25{G=;A_D9N)fuivcP#zFJb$*%x(G6XQP?(;WvetbKOMTua>b zUeve6V0}xgL9-}T%m?Q%vAq4vbsTx}0)Y+?BU`$eBALa+_RSa%+L>8FPl!{(?TF>$ zbYm>Huqi=s*g5O9EwoMg@UY^^LV{E*u|C~#|ALuvAsoMtd zkf|p4+Sey*YIK12tqTw4&OL8@q3Z{hzmQt;dhD*1&Gay-uR$72F1f8(`n`DY3?7*Z z7sA)EiCwUwfba)6gLOyXRp_}ddyz>7EJxn(G2jpTzT=>=R<75EsvwaMXgZdUR1#?h z*h{`C))y~cl-YWi$sN-6w-|`WoxFu~AiUl-c<8IRTTz5^+LKPRN}V?k+>9Uv6nDJJhHr<&tc5dw?T|q84Kr*t$$w2L`f1&=;zomm-SNZUiq`rQ6`OTuZZLBQ+s<& z&WRs(pROb&Cs%Ez@ep;=!tIx6S7_A7#&9Yxk_bsI6f}~8aD&{D_)t^1BZmjNOi6?? zv9w^C6oW++Tn^r~!))R@x+3id5uoLN4%5smc^+R6N?~MnPO(v?H$8F>1#l5HHjT5# zNv5z?@e(>=^?`6pqj0}l{s3S`cK`S9MlP0-sKs)gbT2iIJ>O*YAE4p%lavV@wf_k; z)CpxAK70`+@imo9I*V|a*xyN#F9BJy2!i#KWEC0L%^V`JUT7=YO!GhZ4$PJ^--gje zLePJGJKvp82pg1o*-D4tLR1L{|02}Tq0JaPY!YMsnKH5_19}g3D{splfu@?J7RUiZ zyIz)WK=+L$(#8w9EAV5S^oG&u7^mdo2WIVg;#>P{C(MMZ??oP~w_$^CL!NNi9m12d zJ%&=}@_q-ZY<4vRZNQh=N!#w-(2rK%Vd3$0{Vb*Q*htVe@lCZE-}deGiO|zMa^#4A z%zM)1MZHaZFrRf~MMa%a3VFoe1Zl(Nau8>=?f-{N*_E1m0XXUf!j<^>fm$2C#>pm{6?v%8th z>}ND47lyQ;f2zz99Z|+;x>5?)Dw#z7aH)F=CZ+YDUE)*bMt7Yno6>kDpf28NSC)kW zrU-6V`d>Dja{Aitu^Ihd0vSx6^=r}2LoaY{w8D(+kc%sQBlbDd^!c+-9G_>CqB6*;A^X5Fj;VREjkHl4MM`Q1!;A3M>G|-Y&RV_UaJED2weu(XFMU7 zy1-1P;%ym+qGM&ubN`tD5%cnT9$1)YwR=KhU735#jb@$_Ns8#}FwP-Nvlo(vcu%s` z?r&Kkmk}FZ4pcZ_CoS>hQ(&!xs6;SuNcC9u;4_h9bMCnxXS=@s-j6Oz}2 zLq`OzwhFZ`!)$@3`{K~MxH=cEg@kR)#f&1fch#Ax_Pd!-fvhrHGefwY2cq<#)9lc*H0lJLVf#;e{&lE)uES`F{#JGIqWL0CO<#F^5YCk z&z@y-Eg3oc0TX)DFW>kB-TPY+6k`$C$~~Bu&<|KbBUhNzx?75l%%3ptO2zyUle-Vl zPFQZch+e|cp;n6`Fj=CYBxv@4GZ~=j0%{;;5?B8`lSyEPNm^&L;RcVx3_!yd!rNa7-2>yCUFh+-)+}*zV5O5S7 zo9%QJEU9l02^FHYbNJynU|Akv3JVqyU}CGAnH88NJ60im@qjYGry7EUqW*8=N??!~ zugg&WLTbIP{|IV?L9Zf!1c}sExz3y~%3QspG0V`7h4pC)&f3mRa7TRSego#-viDJI zIVPhS(6EOGou5*1r0C)#G|8~1D{BE82Q^Fho<@Y1`wzUOs$9toa$g1m%D0Fhp$bBB zRSZGYQfLWu@BYLxrFz-90hgJ%n%*NTXM7{d`B=*$e`ADK`VeTK3enSMh2ats_Os|k z99}$eQE=sc@K4ggwv0otukmxhV)du_cur8qN^HFoar*4pUZw(PCviK1^9ls`Ba$6; z_zi3mBL7LoMX(~p25X3rM3!a=1olwy^QTX>N%8{kzjzDgm?VggHV#4=bWN!3Eljw3 zQ2Pawjd+e5o&7ix3vvF70R-rAVB{ySHz6@ZWsKWe)RKc`v4965Ix)CYbw~VGV<08lD<43#6f(mxxFx(Y zNeh&iB^H2#{rrD^omHv9GCXBKgF?*nJWL@Z7e)%9DE!uC8Ds{b3Br%%25aExduW2e z30P?U!yRt?`SYi~h9k7eQ`L5w=+va_+==1t_8nOebLbE!344B{yFI|dKL7x~B5Tx~ zf|y1rrgFC|vpVSlgd*dwZNl+Q;Cdk`tM3|!U&5^`#-@!!Pxw2g#)8~MeSL)|+;YpD z<zg4@X@13G7#XP|NSCVlAF=-DhkWj9sU*DF@SMmp3Mt;6fbSr zx?00FD@hvO3y7}>`ueCz(aagi+)0bs(8}#6N9Isf9YomosssJ5E1txU@2Cd$l>A7s z-s>d-8;adnELs0KH1oBQAVZp1<}7HCaunH3ngcdL=|im3 zBI>3-T!MSffw$QT7BZzL%0}dK;mcoCDAwdYh+p(mpAVMi1V%{ z{9Jemg)xw!-xzmG@eId#9(GVXVRq33v9cT9y_HjUA3zWertB2fflF-)z`Wdc?dp0t z!|`72X2e06wGVL9Esn!~7vaR4e3n#e*vxUk+&SDe;TG%zJ5zuw5MXV{8yVOxvFYXp zuX%Q)Kp|xt>TrYH^z;@a$Za*v&CNY3TwGjj1IS-$j*?6Z7_wfpx@RmbF(6ZzV*{5u zQXEaqcN@z+SIB>CQQLFkqd;T*%+HUGk2iXHkCWT5;LEz7QeX1kpG?xsk5u=pw^T5N zVYp6FO8Y=}?g?P_diBf|wnskU$|7OtjGcsdpww;HVWjnJ1m+{}_=cI=b}QiT24+S5kgLL=t`q^TH6)Qcr0l2c9@C0c>V(?w@FnP50zw%HPlHSt9p z5ZSg5j-hRtFdUMyzvR8(AuI^8Q!?hft9{Mji02N0PPWX8fX7s{KBKK9}MmuaUDnDh4^OX#>G0Z z90>Nw+m7f@fjt%8ak4vCA0(0uhg7%(lI32s>1vzxqMbdY0gZ@HJ?0>PO^DvwzOS<4 zv+fTI6|W5m&}8XBG^N)}QGo46Wgw-7VMiH^p{0#K5atqrcrJQKge*y_k{%B9jmet; z%=*J6jDUlQkF!sWuUPS4LKg~|$$hAME!BP2qoAS$v(5R{ZBr8pf{0P6fF83CcZVTG z*bZ^*+unf*+kBSL9K2v6rxusSA{ZNM-Rq zC9Jk8jw-r$ASC+#$y~x-dYV<-K@w)Y35?&!O+Q)-LS=SHV%s~h4v|;|U%MtGTX$ru4OIxcaB{N@m3e`%dZjYL#Y{x*KEu z2W(&&VdWdOPAl&L*GEA&?yk<8PQd#$W>bLUDy00y6rq9jcXxBoXJWCc1ZyjDk5CoY zTO^e4QK4hdW~qE+%p0xV(`U}m!IkWT?6X{q2#XduD1GF%Gnt9;$%9TENjC1!fb)cf zaea+ccGiS$Ru~y}0Ajk*gGh_Ta&ns(%G97AAVW(JBju&*huoYii*6@;7nfj<$(+mt znP_^IkVI^RC4?`*tt!mxjdmWY5z56v5jDr?bmk3wqf9oy!6J>aarnW;P^w0qMab8$yXj5E-lT#OG&yH7y^g{NmPiF$$XT*tqia(k8noFrB<& z9#B{;*kFICcE+7gD(u@^$~DFJu52FYW5v?BO% zaHDEF8NG5WrU$5~)L%Ys2L&u7Ma7u@X{+J@_9+;PyAT3;@jza8#k`; zHzisKhEZhc(!w7~NQB!I1`1B(<>iTKC&av^N5PVs$^m3TO76X0j)2hh?s`BxCw4^# zytpOk4v7QaZvVv;RJeFB-`W(%hB(-kH1%>=Y-Fn)?X`^Pr#cj}pM6j02+)``B$lx4 zJJ>}LSXLjdrP)R>UhHR%2Ub)ZWKm97@=BqGd-m)>eWF}*lqwN&>uWo6mAN+Y2`vyg zbbgr~L|j0OG!tF4MafzhPr+2{;Tb4GQ^%QgLiITyvx~zDIBu-PQLdlBtXPp&aS2C2 z>~-M8bo3J2XGR0WlwAW2{f!$pZo4wCVMV=%WsEN#AT80-{Yua$kON?7K8AjFy2D`R zv;-3vS=wh<5r->bjv zHfB0Bb=)2}I-765t)of8{~%CV4(N$h3k53!-2QoWQi;DPy2Op2R;LUD#j#i4ha8dM z+#)<+DCaj5If>gI=RKl$HTWv|aq2^@v%Y@)dhdY+DgXlmE|KW?&yD#f@Hr64-|_3-9#sLG5X0;|KU3=9sDe&h@TvE{VWFmSH2dPS{E z7=)lQw$)3?8VglIon$m~1_RjO{Q%-E7Kxxv{Q6Shg*sa=v|^dc1q|)^>AyLO**!B~ zs5rQDeL$FvBV6lNXM9Cf^wLW4PEL5crfL7`06oXW(ry1TVuc3+%xnHBqLXgM43BAW#ZcZx0#0 z$dPp{L+7^7b!l4E9pENt@Zoy@TcXW=m&(3>&0ANcqm^H9yz5h|6e^#qpmmBH7s0Xe zNyfYXz}vxg^|}VT6Tv*URu7CVB5p@KfB+O2bjGjBsdJ1qSPJElMKeGorpv~elWZKe${31 zo?Uah<1<>o9*Q8ILmmasLUe9uqR~biU9K1GI63&eK3(@8s*&AX7C_o z{@l4X4w%^X)^R(u0RamHuR;#=b;?yV266TtEkE8drK?lpM{{jm#mV%$DdMm8?KvMb zfvVZ9jvaw(P8_#$=ciBAo|x=9=R^kpP}BIi`sBZEtlR;A%_TOlD>Vfw^lX;VpV|8k z@<&_c#h=`S2da3VB1e48<0Be|CH4xie&eB8h(`Rk4xmYxquFy#B zAR|Z^LK+aHA%wNXMxPkv+)*t-p(PvqnBCP(2KxKWC|)HW0UDz=)?3)~4Io`e1K6!? z#aOnR5R17_7B>LiQpXel{Y|dat%U4yWoJ$UQkvzc7W|3G z1fV4X1+DC(48Z9`rr(wj-wO~dn$|G5epA_t2N4_M4IAOLV~I!auXxbnzQ-I|JZ}mr zpbn)!vEJy_C?d!eLB_fRLLnO4wqo_s-dG@>+aWHpt5oX9iMj?+gSD?gwU^G zf-5Y02nMDEd2iELSKXJW8IG{G4yGpu3T8PlUP3bcMNc@ms_nh02_< zXR^*72umJy0_H6Nu%K_||5PMnLFSH!M>Z0x(__b~s=dl}k@-dX%jOD-Pio}^o@DTq z%=b0}%Md}@+H<;f^8b{t)m^6Fh%l56Geb^ zKD}LA`#b<|m9-O3A~)B;;w~!~%j*OtknN@fdW7}gHqcjMHQJ-n0Kz<*I1g%fBN@c5 zNbF!8@)N_Faj+4l7arNnGBoj}(zkjnk&IPC5DP>$N&w2t9VwJnLLu|J$>xYXiw0d7 zCvA}oh_^(jyJJ6_-iFgoA{7)-`c7)elifysxc*l7EncIw^#H00iPBuS*e1e2mWP)& zw5YbW)_NZ#nXdmL%MjxU7TY=@DgiZ^HYOec9)BNljn0uzpY|(b-G&}`Ikq-AX`enp zb}(!pwKH!8!c9hYIf7#=RO?rIFg{mtc7+Y8yh}z^Z~Y5RK=f!T z@9oucQ)IZq%G;-T8|j9y+Kowr035gy29D?$x~&g&a4A@}6b3hJCbcorM;A8}CjVbO zws=^Td2BXIc2W;?QUSk9e1pi(XiL_`)87Qs>?Q*yP5nHX)BPrwv;)$FTN6aCudnar z>M_1GvPMWY9b(aK)RKYO-SCFkFF5{mR@hpQe< zm3W<;C|VLIAqw{hfFIElz?J`);{BX&`PuvkgCg;;fEK;uR^kRFdoTd_`6T^CcegD zrowSm0JZAA(7#(cW;i0T^u2cN8qZc^O-)TR?)6OBb{~vDVCM5A-Z2bDG)a{SJg)_d zw&c3I!q0fCz66&oqsL-*Dlhm@1lSZ~1j~LX0cc_r8lk4ap8jHM%)GK9#`VBDs%4H5hIxxd@#>3QDgdDpwv zyVkpY{c+a89>2qVU)N{42DVUTeU3b9W@Ak%N(^H4TGO8i{U71MNe74dLuY!6pk;+B zmUUNxnC2D-Ku%6oB6~nYj@5*8|0n8jyh{M!wj0(#0Mu94^kWGZ<+Q79*Fz4#xHluZiY)`toyZ6lqqb}oq z3Fnu5d4^i=_?6fx`an4W@?^D*)NT`y!>Xv{rR=|aQgNVyxM{h8DG*_N|L6E(0rB?1 zhcEh~6mlc2Zx_D*4FfgW`{K4$x9eiDxmR|dva+%MYHch&w*y%JGBwuxC>iWZ zxCk|bxREKvp~g9t;3>5SDaelXG_&95=wBR^4W`ld1gq>*I06CK2WbPCQ+>Jj{6?an zd(ccr7~}5Pt&mOC?RGuC5S!u91)lyN+zqN1T=}c1RiC_WK)uAe_XI7A0|B?t(>gT| zQ&dbMq2Pd=(16g$f4e8)wXtIvz^TvE{($xlx~fgMB2_50;{GpKv|fS#s~{En!UYRX zP;w>e!LcFBZ+?a!zYIr-Xd$81cWONE6i4h~{Bm;M1r!;{dgzO#Hl+Ik9ZWJN`jXRN zI)IqVna9#4##TOEqgMC20_3GSfdln1Ac9fPLYimH7g#pEAfY;srF>rt>&9 zGz)H>H4-*==(^PAH}f5r+N{Jz1ac|}qMQ7r|BYu=4 z7F0_<2(m?EkC5}56F*i}PNwOsT0I*fL-5I|lRb@?I9db=j!Al&M3rfPTBRsEPT}OA zgPqn4tkF8z3&&t&tXN4}y>>|!Vv6k|NMAGMKrYbU8A&e92-su%%C8U-@`4mPpY@9H zhpN1G2yeTo;S-r;44xQn-|d*98h|z-)tDS@c%~{5oPewE<|k*u00BXlKJ%2E16lw! zn^zd%(?RBX+PCx(r`ej3c&vnQ*Aw+7n9$B?T;h$C>RNg;Eg=SlT7TBQ;f`o2dsPw* zPnhqBHx$I}5pvbn_a^BZfNoj$-r(!R>DuyZT#c@E=CMwT2dd;fhkR)7h<1T&;OK^Q z_lSN@5knT*Eh0o@m2Hlz$+Tsi-|{DVw*#tkxJU1Gh9gFwpx)thM6HWdQaaxDZEk+a z_azzVJOoL42&r>X)mL2L{#>7+xj~o-5kJWwBPf0u7bO5!W+I_lkU;slSVUka{FA4l zVbKA>4$eL-2RpM$6ZH%rH+WiB87(J-9W%hkXMwjNhlk6f=vl20wGAy^y8g?g9$j;C zd|dk5f+ys@#BN3zmOuuFg6$BsFM%0TZ72yFGf@$ArBgd@dj@wew64ne7rv@ZiIXFt zoVB@K;OL^>txq7M*Ce<#$*4hf9Q4;_Z1woYeL2C@>Yw`z6TSGMk^O?!Sru+zZf8H< zeq8?IoJsr%NSy~rk!vT!B=b5e*Q-RUp7AOTeb55AuGSXX&yP`jvRq!cfyJjZ~GRjeXaS)mMu93Y1+Bc*6t-%69WZ9jmR+aN$TVe;?LTy=n{AD*1f6IlTnD)6ZZu_Svo=S{m~0lkSex%FMc4VzT$2=WA4 zgf&V`6IHc;XwO1C&w)}U;`z5Z_J5LPh`{UGpLDeyPAeU_rrVb1a+E}uv{ZcGUui$o6f-lO!D5q>@tzznB1#>Jfc z>6pc#WMEYq)|A7iTpuZAsUObTW{as9}kD zqqg~n9d4`lNwjI|*PkF?tE^4|5(gsHkZ`q_2OdGb4f}3|OV9m1N(k~h_Lu(#g2Cei zFDCK?Qu_L>moYz3W47coTDEJ$>ykFziJ=FE5m7gzifRVPQTJdx7vj}yf+`5Q*p@jl z0CtSc@8Von^<1Yz1bx*!8CCnMcbM>cjDT;EI64M|3`ed1imVMwc3}NB(E)5;p`0HJ zwoW4S2h~bz@p~GC0JVotN|EdwlR7<=4Qj4pkwgX<)sC-FA7+PTQR9)mwz0WhRfObb z%=HYw5e)sx<&!q&Bl(Q1e<5?)LFW+lkx6 z+*H{tFZEL)8Q^F)DsVB2+%8|SEjV=lLFP7|^(Og)dLW^m(qZ+v-HcBrSLZ^&qoyqD z4W>~YpCQ3jGiSBP>FC?!`UohM}!1FuPR$R+tvnQWZbHm>rR0SN>zl ziLV>Ec0KG?d(D~y_PR~GiM8&JnL>X!s+r9py`*hC3Ksly%X-m`<2kWovNv;$S4!hA(v zz`KMkwE+ef3{>(8U$*1tdoY_8s_7~U0R@|JYmp~=WX*4{BWhJEIdD$63jL8mdUX*1 z>9ID)kL>>Z$yQ5OuG|7$l}V1xd(VvD{vpz-QDB$Qyi+86uuu&}T=_dUh`Jsl>yQ2o zY^@4pa!LMrkiL-{6SLiv;s1z(BLBnSpb#N`hy)W`2Fd#PV8%#;4HiojLYm{tewgW& z(^*YP|H=T%E-UBY;1Cabfd+^3p)evyIZsc*n`4Y%v2y^|h~*#o%EzGp;RATEOp|l< z>eE{~y1J@a0S(lV>Kp3bs);3)cgvP7FRBJX42Dv_r;bG3UO&a}KNad7D0B)Z@CFLm z@+q`_<`l9=Js?)W*JJqKJ1D8Ydz|`()}^plQIV)=OkTlegA4D;QG{cis906tGM1c+EuZwLq~*qp8C^0eAgFcEuCRIE zFbkNdvIy2!(J%#LFTu*=kCS4A1jNNIVJ+M~{#=AB8Cp#?7IIo}E{J21sQE%Y8X=uH z1$KRleDG}?@>l2qi8lQP3Rz-w_=Swr!QfLhjBGR?b0STif|!d!5$QdE&Bmd0F=-hZ zvLQ2ZNdtok7yPh7ICfVproMU&2PH-yT0jCN&?l-AT@5aj`ma)91Wlt7@^DgGx>7L0 zYfhVpyqHP(YT*=AYD8>92K0Tx z3Ftzk7)ixigUyCBlXdi!g;;pC|4;#QN)t5sCnVGO3L9$6n3M&pquZR^7oDOYvV!?F zxFj+li<%`(^gWYcSv za=;oQoCrEdL{MrZ@}Z@{74Fs#zL(Now^S}hwYutU=s*NB^<^Gx;2cCA?eICGihQTY4Gl}Vg( zp7zKx3jl<4dr>?|ZLdcrgSTSzQtC|{=l?=Vr=bP93H`W_#Jo<2$vy@t8Hj+qebF1_ zDo*uv>D6fW(m7B^5NR&fybwsZo7IB5%-1r`_8qp=^%}rY6fxT_j{5XK5opnub^f(t zz#m>MWWh_c*j01d@h} zBd{mEA`J?J1>&M@c6Jf*kLu(%QEw-IVGfcDASRN`K6L{-Hipv^G|tS%0*j-GYB`z| z%gQP&yNU1Pwa>l5i0De6oW@oRg_%)6OL%VjZ9QlNN?%4$Xd*3~F^7_O@HlmHPQ?6$ zKa#Q38!KO1%`zoZKS?Z|>5s@yg;!We9rYKQ#y%DfN&RH=3(M9+{ouj*RdV>nkj;;j zIF8p3`>3wsr4lcw=TwlC6pE?28)4Fz2`r>uA@Isl>__oR~Q*sGOD8K)pol{@6Pd{z?55;ln~$sUO<+Q8x?q|1=ukFSLL35dZ%B zO1~oa0hl4O`z0FW<&dC(-6rK*$!I^kK1$Tzl-Mw?oh|+D}zL)n8 z$HcNA9pkJETgcaGo#9CfW5y>YRM9OOLy!lm%t;4BD9BjTFKE4}OO9k7;~FZ1rEyi4 z6Y)4>KF942DOHWxPFOo`VcRD`o1Y+WB-3}ZTq&_is~0U|{`cYyib>=L^|Mrq@((QF zMTHjC5L1K0Pw2o^6o)pqa~ho3TGO|bM*IcDNXL;p^l+GDyb~qN#XLw_DUsfLZSn<% zOlB_ozcqAqeB{@(wUqi7J%UjrqG4n#ET0f=&r#!_(4A!RNd2q$h$PPlr!1TwXNnJ<*TTUnSf!8}sB5ARR68@I{_ih`N?CfW2fBVnY%aH`6&i3u#o6AeS*hckkwD_2Vt+5_SmxM?7A?P4{ z=B6ETB-$&ilqx{xh{ah8NTEcTpcx+)JF_uSDC;XMf$pz!Ya1FG;!!H;C=b<^er}BA zcIa4CTC~*cNvVM8G5b;5je>pjE7#q$eOUm9V>+&nmzNfDs<~#NMLdYjXW2vTT*tGv zF8xiS7E-UqQTlMQC<2=mGmC*gMp{^x;!ymaeC|yLwLIDt-jr!3loPMkm zR36Y2>h_p<8iy#P5??WKN^J=AK9H`KfgD|qWNaRt)6irt6Oj8MZYg6C3pSa#rPp^O z8vGWRuDaMrwQb`o_nb)h0ZJ)AjGiGJ?Ez@Y;WeDOjn^E@;~Sev<^83%K-{}L7bZSkWc^ePT zr9VLL|GU+edddH8clkejtN;B*_8(Ux>T7NcRaWRxfWo38_S-iWfkyql=9d}n{r{(f z@qc*S|L1QtwuI;nfG-e>09jbz%29w0Wi!}!hgR|LC4h$rQ6VXp$zqy0zd`O3V$&q* zRp7B9*aVM~8EBZ=82mK+AJu^PM%vgC$YQpDG)a?%$>U;iaq&wM$j|=jI|WquG{E!A zrsBoQ7oJYV?D;= z?|eg=@+qV(@ekPa*ovM`;C|@gK_h5rkBwRHOR|ciyNPUSC1ZidE?|%|4=5}RS4;BQ zRd57y~&7i%jKX0Z1tw zu<371RRq1tOGq3-r`@m%UVQWn*+gfMNb6yl4B-ZlWF(mbQ*Ze+zJ4Pw>G5d|0`s%E z;q*p81OhO&L;u)04ZM-(mtQ>92^LkjM~O;dt~7$1Ho@)*3Jwb?eXdJ{HqasFP3Q$o z0#lF&_I}PVN#MZ0bEq2LJ~|utP!DSDDxPS<{o&@&m4=CdvdNN$@25cHPWZ#4la^d8N1$ZZlb@D!WSE9W$ty0awi>!&{>jX zl6Nh>BKyl`-!FbO>vWQh{Zx)oK}M}sLI10a)u7~uj{V_2dV}HlJr04I)^Y|gU)R;e zAw-=elBIi4BcT!D4;x{0)BJ1!X6d$&hP8~s`*lw5TIQsjMHOnR2Mz7#vV*GHjw|s& zyp7nTxl3j{tm7Cz-fo#L7Xb1CEj$3ZI@8pcQ_mDdz)O4sV9Hxam0G?%g%-w%kfB z_H64=Ug%cF#^S#E=*o$9M`u^A;HHXNkFM=l53*%&>Rapu$^=-UWZPq(($=vaFr@J} z1+n^Y~_XipxcHl2e{|vKR|boEeBkDP8lEy^8%q*?fFnyO`Cxt%$x?J|`oX49xrUoZ%ko z;Nh#12G_~%hptlDqQ;md7@_`Jc>I6bfBx(CA-xy+rWYk8e3dsPZB39k7D&)Utn6Bh z9IU;T7(qxtH*T}rMoPd1J20mC280y^gZ=POjs)>% z-On;p079bf0w(zOw!wswgRXKiZnKgb=f9U^xIZ2koRDh@VkRVHd=zW1=x&H}XV3$* z7|jva+}5r)VS0Am(F~qm>fxnC)V#UCDolPt{2AEOP>d;%hU)Lji&chCo;uN_Nw9Z? ze<_lLZdaC|xru|6wkFe3j|9vS(7C3--JKtj3CO6QTlRn2ON%{fX1rkzEmn5Io>tRj zePF^;`C84Z>A8-=1YPk-!U}lyz;R+QBAq4(@gy>Wt_JhjZAHCf2$TyL^HFy1Z21XT zG&Vuta)X#Uuon{N6d<7%3Hm$ma6t5VH(VIHh&T*`nr$-EIG|;|3+74xA>Qw$d>TK+ z+ZtkOyBG&8yt{#ID6`F%(Hzi}YsTEWmr+`?_&{M%jB#n;ei9Er(mzPrJG6d5BNy0n zd*tq-;Lmw@ou&mv)TH6?W^L_uIN1b?{MF+4R~fkUi@wdWj?VtFJ*lQJe0>Qx?9PFB znn5?Jj-QI%5LmI7&@EdMxwZg^w4V8Ulb($1ti`NTbycHz)rUNC( zq9+qqBoNjWeG2?`jiM@jaZ7xTAN+(v)cI2dB(N&jFG>yMKKT;6G4lz0*E)`e(Gvn(o<0rVHwJAq<(sW_Cv3i#pTb zeh-~;5D0i>bZiypTnGYhU<%#DVrxCuJfNieh-(j^p!i^7$}oo96A>|I#ldxmlSob` zvIRAdBUyQiotTjFt#h_k7kZ%BJ~Fb*MFXBC9VI3CS-r^Q*lk+5&el-777lE_YW5(= zhUmL^WGlR;qnY27K**Vo9?g5RAr%_jgO8H^M#o_r#x=g9vpB8u*9N1@`R5@KDNik~ zpT2iAoWG)E{nN_0m<->(Hy+nqFYGz{;S%`OH|r7@^E0QH)J`2sIiJQ0IvwCNk>84x zWB?TlUA_Va6Vt$c0PsF*LLUy^t$O2H012E)b8&o$4^WiK^i+5p#SH1V;zf}1Yi(8U z?a=Qt0G5GOey5CO9Sc%hj)I4?gHD$JTXblznQlmgz6GS9Y{5B~#OVRW~ye zw7m+D{BmY(?DYHsB+L`udpIkpV39MUdlN4EjLEkQanFI~rt?!jPv|g&-%dtHA2HwT zk|BMvssLtZoQ>ji?KbT(7xk9NV|x(BU{&KpAAM~ZA32Ov5}!0Wvsl)^jL$I31%09V zo(%vFiKn2&bqa`U=aXYFEL&9kG^Gz=xyEA|5^f?XM!zCdHa3K=cFVYWY)LUVvrsYf z%a_I(Cxu!xa!AUE=ID900Er2E2EDt%Y1M=!lVeKE@yqo7Xn{==rx>LXJLV11aADM@ z?b;=5QvN6#j^`Q^C!Cpw!;Dl7q%0ipO-Zqarq})?>X+rifEWLYkanthI1C81`9cea z?08{0cz72zSRYP8fp-#$t|f>Z@w$y~eA^gUlv6oqm1RK~u5=qp?H5E{vWtuc%pU|! z8E_{OLWG@VFo|s-1EK%2>uao*R%%Wdo*bcvv`fM?x3et01=puPZe)MtIPR)~4L4OM z0jsD=sYk&h|B|!x;!|z#SQG>FeX;LxeER zLT-BPc_7HGr>%(coO8vBTY%d~nNaue#v_S)7jy#tfJ@ZX(9EACxe38N`Hnb75>>#< zec^1WgL)z!ph~ACBCB@~4|kNUvc(Vs`UEliOkNoX$;l=1qEus;m2N2Zy8;QU7#=yc zG`wTHKFiuLje{;5KY4GxI22yy!8nxLis)D&3dL=2pqp4$ftZ9o;)~ZcT~oeP)7z za}Vz@mz$egr?oP(M0eVss7^akuxboRm$lU(EW!xnMY-&XNv3~h7ZOYS)5rddym*4JnL0H6P2sK$vGQMeT3c`zOHQ$l7;=(^Bj7G8#_G+d z(>zE1-N)HeQWN&6)hWXojOOVL6P828Q`cnIxIP~54$5B4CgFHNsUK?ntf*s@+akZ? zRA7{2y?m&k3TDNU+^%x$x=CeF-J5q>w5vCZ;)<0}5R|EoDHGkgx{XkAS0cwr7?uWu zK778f@%Q0R(HhQL{Q%z=MirotO3THjBqoZiCs0`eMM~%`!?Mj_t8Ke@oYQ9 zHD1$p82I7_Ik zK*6eLS$&>fDj`!H%h&Z`5eG+>!5fmZ7tSWZe&nx&BE_=O>hT!wzA2+ezL{%wo!sZy zP|JBX=M4D3#jZOXy@_k2U=jDPH6<7Sx-b?~WQ(jOky@lzRY~n9&rIfnsILv1A3KYJj678JLz(CA}gs3ZjFz1w1|22Rgrr_+MT4fwf%M|9ecP*{y;(IF;Bh9 z#f3fhKNL@&Cy^}lT%6g^Yf*OjNjLl_nxB0M=W(NH2>nunWxguwtDBVh(GZJ`qOujL zcgpN|Iw1U3Z~tvW3CEFH%IjJCZjq;3GgGmEJy|~5m#huxUR*XqTT?A~%qmtUEs7P@ zORo>8|NL6l=rdNf9WMqO5ZI;N#Vea6caIPo_MHMGyr`dZML}l}k&yzl4wc%i+kIr% zm7Wg5HBEm}Y|}DGLDEh<_@n-|7H+kx!c4N9k3^)8Ua=BZqI^#${zPJsG%%@!!4^|e zNs;%^SO=WQw(`PR+j2X_{&f0E|N3J@7mTZ*Dz3Tli=+V93{!LZX}?}bfB(AMFe^}z zE@Ia5d|cpCw0-9W5YrPH~} z&FBo1G8)tKk6xI_dRQ>GZ;E*sEo$1N`<}#(%xUZGQ_Mv7pv-A;z3H|W$pdQzcb@Q-&E#nuC&j` z5hX<~I`gwlE^vV&t`m%%zWv1x#C2f1G&!EqTt6JGnp8?ihM|?=QIS zwl?CL?AzyeHAmgMgCzf|DjM-Pa`@?aO9DYr{a#W#=c@vFE@q~C- z1XFHwy3>d$)2wSX$UNW2EE=6|I5xVlZ2IF%=3(}3vrPz^p>#jM-l@`)X|mv z#k3Nf4SzT8T&$Q+y0eP3M};O%ad^wVW!}~7Ts;f78cI)*%_@P4DHk;O4Gr78b=NaD z-1hsqnp1(8KG)oc=L=%Q-pQ|o46x$-sLULB>Q~!ipQ`IZE*+L?g3TJ9urZ13U&*#s3bNG;R z$Ld^%4U9|7meLzsljr+fD~?Y>Aikr=dM@|x;mf!@o?<9owmZ_>Z7*trz>H|pDAfDs z!@@b1a`T>M=hyBar^T~uJc7Er#o6=WylsjVy{cJzNai7>iGUUf2@}ghg6(dWu9=D# z*sM)Niw@jnkH=$<=_@EnV9ThFeIIL{K%DQ^zx3TQH zoel%~w#1*`^t0n0qYVy7cYVmVQ$57OV);8%?VRPc@-YTHcSGwJDE0Zs^U~;?+qKA`_36`}YrK8jS zy*}Hxr%ZGjo-KRSaPwMb1myP-Ds6gREfZ@*rYz3MI+&-P*`So~)hG~i*8bByzenm; z^KGFC`-09ljPre%+Yzs`&YRxgoAvp9ncvP0L}lHS6rx!LJG!$r@iR(sV{^LhZctqt zQa#Jeqhnuq(srzPPVCzxjc(flJyVkj#j@8{CsLjM8$t_I>gh-@s*1P|r9pI}>56Cr zwtTcC7Ln3NYlBR69rl}9CZPn0-}-35;GLcx^i{C;vhOO(H}#J{_2{Tewa(-dzxH(B zfvZ*Lp2?iQuINxr+e>W5u6iXrNp1H<1wPjP*&~p#TJWN>lG%f7^oQXdUQvBy4xZD) z#GleHug|sEP*%im?t5CR+HJh$THlowf3eE1QAz* zqO_FG_jVo1DJZUoDZ}UTIlkw2F{bH7#de<;RAUx}}D?E^k`w z?2@Jj4xtXeHoR6TDe%NFl|gBZ%9%5XZlv2q}lfs_+9;?hUymm#waQ9d!4>~ zr6#-7go>9C00!Yn?`dXzRm|qS$h+k9U7q$$-4v+f<;C3QJ62a$-HG1sWiREtmznT_ z;}`QKgBZvt-n>uFh4MqVreG@1U(PqKr@`&4Ly%F<6Ajg0NVy?uo^d^=O;4lmNi(vR zPdCLXs7$fP@oy4UPqGTZRvliKk=gAKr*NUAbz+^2U(cY>ly8pZqUBpp$PNP}PpYc+ zNc7XK9~8j9$`>k96I%Ym6D>}Aoi%6!|L%kfSM%9&Q(MBDTHWVr7HMWz6OkMrTEZnT ziJH1x#mclgNc91jtlA5>KkAL1)nZSN={WB7SUBhd!x*RXYdF6; z?_H+s8@0R*lhRe*#`Brl-}D}EkoxIY%@4f`N8lt6T`J{#a_sk>QaZY!&_d67DIy;6 zF{1W7p_xSn6&u;>p{FSfYgN-6(m;&2Z^YU8?4CU@g_HOaH{WJR5dNUH5|ou_wPl=w zGk0l1%n`dwf%8r<(t1Yg8)|N3BjxIF#Epv+Zd__t+#l8~TA3ad;TKqQ!aJUJ$)V4S ztNpb{@bvNSZpkV4m?|PYUO3RZ;Bi1ez>z5dsT}R*WIic|wZ772v)8K4Y0#8#-oB|<-Y?I3Pm?67;AyyXL zaSuv%$QYQp*k5|UH#9aT?takuqSrieQTh0b;xethqYZ8Rqur*j3)bXqRAFW^T3eUThloxDo>bc;B9asA=D?GPhvN7vN>*;u;)O@gHdR~yBW>x z3n(n_57|)qcyV!M=FM4~hP=h^Ef}m7yYm_{_06)=7gMQ9v3v|Vo|(Id zO=2VaYiDg;VO5Jd5bH&C5u^a(k$GJe$F@IdlH^g5d8IQsWH!K8@U+%HC`~uT*&qk* wFl+cV_2a+j1pk$%VLb)^{cj|CKEvPKEz9O@lREcd1$n&6evN&}drx@&Kgv{}9{>OV literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/evidence/indexes.svg b/evidence/indexes.svg new file mode 100644 index 00000000..0e184ce4 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/indexes.svg @@ -0,0 +1,2279 @@ + + + + + + + + 2026-10-16T15:07:23.045307 + image/svg+xml + + + Matplotlib v3.10.8, https://matplotlib.org/ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/evidence/integration.json b/evidence/integration.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..5b6601c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/integration.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "public_smoke": "PASS: lab2 public API scenario; infrastructure and grading evidence remain separate.", + "authentication_negative": "wrong password, Basic on protected route, X-User-Id: 401", + "registration_race": [ + 201, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409 + ], + "rollback": "missing member: 400; chats count unchanged", + "concurrent_messages": { + "sent": 100, + "read": 100, + "page_size": 17 + }, + "cache_hit_delta": 5, + "cache_down": { + "status": 200, + "seconds": 0.211 + }, + "database_down": { + "status": 503, + "seconds": 0.009 + }, + "logout": "204 then 401", + "short_ttl": "SESSION_TTL_SECONDS=2: 200 then 401 after 2.2s", + "migration_repeat": "Already applied: 001_initial.sql", + "public_persistence": "Executing explicit persistence hook; hook output suppressed to avoid leaking secrets.\nPASS: persistence preserved confirmed data and existing session. Hook scope needs operator evidence.", + "passed": true +} diff --git a/evidence/restart-processes.json b/evidence/restart-processes.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d1777e44 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/restart-processes.json @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{ + "before": { + "api": "2026-10-16T12:03:16.324917557Z", + "db": "2026-10-16T12:06:50.396973657Z", + "cache": "2026-10-16T12:06:47.794944116Z" + }, + "after": { + "api": "2026-10-16T12:07:04.752894207Z", + "db": "2026-10-16T12:07:04.023045701Z", + "cache": "2026-10-16T12:07:03.931354369Z" + }, + "volumes_removed": false +} diff --git a/migrations/001_initial.sql b/migrations/001_initial.sql new file mode 100644 index 00000000..3b9cda97 --- /dev/null +++ b/migrations/001_initial.sql @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +CREATE TABLE users ( + id uuid PRIMARY KEY, + username text NOT NULL UNIQUE CHECK (username ~ '^[a-z0-9_]{3,32}$'), + display_name text NOT NULL CHECK (char_length(display_name) BETWEEN 1 AND 100), + password_hash text NOT NULL, + created_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT clock_timestamp() +); +CREATE TABLE sessions ( + token_hash text PRIMARY KEY, + user_id uuid NOT NULL REFERENCES users(id), + expires_at timestamptz NOT NULL, + created_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT clock_timestamp() +); +CREATE INDEX sessions_expiry ON sessions(expires_at); +CREATE TABLE chats ( + id uuid PRIMARY KEY, + title text NOT NULL CHECK (char_length(title) BETWEEN 1 AND 100), + created_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT clock_timestamp() +); +CREATE TABLE members ( + chat_id uuid NOT NULL REFERENCES chats(id), + user_id uuid NOT NULL REFERENCES users(id), + PRIMARY KEY(chat_id,user_id) +); +CREATE INDEX members_user_chat ON members(user_id,chat_id); +CREATE INDEX chats_order ON chats(created_at,id); +CREATE TABLE messages ( + id uuid PRIMARY KEY, + chat_id uuid NOT NULL REFERENCES chats(id), + sender_id uuid NOT NULL REFERENCES users(id), + text text NOT NULL CHECK (char_length(text) BETWEEN 1 AND 4000), + created_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT clock_timestamp(), + FOREIGN KEY(chat_id,sender_id) REFERENCES members(chat_id,user_id) +); +CREATE INDEX messages_history ON messages(chat_id,created_at,id); diff --git a/requirements-test.txt b/requirements-test.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..9dff8880 --- /dev/null +++ b/requirements-test.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +-r requirements.txt +httpx==0.28.1 +matplotlib==3.10.8 diff --git a/requirements.txt b/requirements.txt new file mode 100644 index 00000000..13add4d9 --- /dev/null +++ b/requirements.txt @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +annotated-doc==0.0.5 +annotated-types==0.8.0 +anyio==4.15.1 +argon2-cffi==25.1.0 +argon2-cffi-bindings==26.1.0 +cffi==2.1.1 +click==8.5.0 +fastapi==0.143.2 +h11==0.16.0 +idna==3.20 +opentelemetry-api==1.45.1 +psycopg==3.3.6 +psycopg-binary==3.3.6 +psycopg-pool==3.3.3 +pycparser==3.11 +pydantic==2.14.1 +pydantic_core==2.50.1 +redis==8.1.0 +starlette==1.8.0 +typing-inspection==0.4.4 +typing_extensions==4.16.0 +tzdata==2026.5 +uvicorn==0.54.0 diff --git a/scripts/bootstrap.py b/scripts/bootstrap.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7372ac02 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/bootstrap.py @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +"""Generate local synthetic credentials once. Never prints their values.""" +from pathlib import Path +import secrets + +root=Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] +target=root/'.env' +if target.exists(): + print('Existing .env preserved') +else: + password=secrets.token_hex(24) + content=f'POSTGRES_PASSWORD={password}\nDATABASE_URL=postgresql://messenger:{password}@db:5432/messenger\nREDIS_URL=redis://cache:6379/0\nCURSOR_SECRET={secrets.token_hex(32)}\nSESSION_TTL_SECONDS=3600\n' + with target.open('x',encoding='utf-8') as f: f.write(content) + try: target.chmod(0o600) + except OSError: pass + print('Created local .env; values not displayed') diff --git a/scripts/index_experiment.py b/scripts/index_experiment.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..abd39621 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/index_experiment.py @@ -0,0 +1,109 @@ +"""120k skewed messages: query plans/write cost + real fresh-volume restore. + +Host orchestrates Docker; --inside runs synthetic SQL in an isolated database. +No production table is changed and no credentials are printed. +""" +import hashlib +from datetime import datetime +import json +import os +from pathlib import Path +import statistics +import subprocess +import sys +import time +import uuid + +def inside(dbname): + import psycopg + with psycopg.connect(os.environ['DATABASE_URL'],autocommit=True) as admin: + admin.execute(psycopg.sql.SQL('CREATE DATABASE {}').format(psycopg.sql.Identifier(dbname))) + with psycopg.connect(os.environ['DATABASE_URL'],dbname=dbname,autocommit=True) as c: + c.execute(Path('/app/migrations/001_initial.sql').read_text()) + c.execute("INSERT INTO users(id,username,display_name,password_hash) VALUES ('00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001','benchmark','Synthetic','not-a-login-hash')") + c.execute("INSERT INTO chats(id,title) SELECT md5('chat'||n)::uuid,'chat'||n FROM generate_series(1,3) n") + c.execute("INSERT INTO members SELECT id,'00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001'::uuid FROM chats") + c.execute("INSERT INTO messages SELECT md5('message'||n)::uuid,md5('chat'||CASE WHEN n<=100000 THEN 1 WHEN n<=115000 THEN 2 ELSE 3 END)::uuid,'00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001'::uuid,repeat('payload-',20)||n,'2026-01-01'::timestamptz+n*interval '1 millisecond' FROM generate_series(1,120000) n") + c.execute('DROP INDEX messages_history') + c.execute('VACUUM ANALYZE messages') + cursor=c.execute("SELECT created_at,id FROM messages WHERE chat_id=md5('chat1')::uuid ORDER BY created_at,id OFFSET 69999 LIMIT 1").fetchone() + keyset="SELECT id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at FROM messages WHERE chat_id=md5('chat1')::uuid AND (created_at,id)>(%s,%s) ORDER BY created_at,id LIMIT 50" + offset="SELECT id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at FROM messages WHERE chat_id=md5('chat1')::uuid ORDER BY created_at,id OFFSET 70000 LIMIT 50" + result={'version':c.execute('SELECT version()').fetchone()[0],'rows':120000,'chat_sizes':[100000,15000,5000],'repeats':5,'plans':[],'writes':[]} + for variant,ddl in [('primary_only',None),('chat_index','CREATE INDEX experiment_idx ON messages(chat_id)'),('compound','CREATE INDEX experiment_idx ON messages(chat_id,created_at,id)')]: + if ddl: c.execute(ddl) + c.execute('ANALYZE messages') + for query_name,query,args in [('keyset',keyset,cursor),('offset',offset,())]: + for _ in range(2): c.execute(query,args).fetchall() + plans=[c.execute('EXPLAIN (ANALYZE, BUFFERS, FORMAT JSON) '+query,args).fetchone()[0][0] for _ in range(5)] + result['plans'].append({'index':variant,'query':query_name,'execution_ms':[p['Execution Time'] for p in plans],'median_ms':statistics.median(p['Execution Time'] for p in plans),'plans':plans}) + # Five real committed batches, then remove only those synthetic rows. + measurements=[] + for rep in range(5): + start=time.perf_counter() + c.execute("INSERT INTO messages SELECT md5('write'||n)::uuid,md5('chat1')::uuid,'00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001'::uuid,repeat('payload-',20)||n,'2027-01-01'::timestamptz+n*interval '1 millisecond' FROM generate_series(1,5000) n") + measurements.append(round((time.perf_counter()-start)*1000,3)) + c.execute("DELETE FROM messages WHERE created_at>='2027-01-01'") + c.execute('VACUUM ANALYZE messages') + result['writes'].append({'index':variant,'batch_rows':5000,'committed_ms':measurements,'median_ms':statistics.median(measurements)}) + if ddl: c.execute('DROP INDEX experiment_idx') + c.execute('CREATE INDEX messages_history ON messages(chat_id,created_at,id)') + result['snapshot']=snapshot(c) + print(json.dumps(result,default=str)) + +def snapshot(c): + counts={table:c.execute('SELECT count(*) FROM '+table).fetchone()[0] for table in ('users','chats','members','messages','sessions')} + selected=c.execute('SELECT id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at FROM messages ORDER BY id LIMIT 20').fetchall() + digest=c.execute("SELECT md5(string_agg(id::text||chat_id::text||sender_id::text||text||created_at::text,'' ORDER BY id)) FROM messages").fetchone()[0] + return {'counts':counts,'selected':[[str(v) for v in row] for row in selected],'all_messages_digest':digest} + +def host(): + root=Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] + def run(*args,input=None): + return subprocess.run(['docker',*args],cwd=root,input=input,stdout=subprocess.PIPE,stderr=subprocess.PIPE,check=True).stdout + unique=uuid.uuid4().hex[:10]; dbname='experiment_'+unique + cid=run('compose','ps','-q','db').decode().strip() + source=Path(__file__).read_bytes() + result=json.loads(run('compose','exec','-T','api','python','-','--inside',dbname,input=source)) + start=time.perf_counter() + dump=run('exec',cid,'pg_dump','-U','messenger','-Fc',dbname) + result['backup']={'seconds':round(time.perf_counter()-start,3),'bytes':len(dump),'sha256':hashlib.sha256(dump).hexdigest()} + backup=root/'backups'/f'{dbname}.dump'; backup.parent.mkdir(exist_ok=True); backup.write_bytes(dump) + # Distinct container and brand-new named volume: no restore onto source storage. + image=run('inspect','--format','{{.Config.Image}}',cid).decode().strip() + volume='lab2-restore-'+unique; target='lab2-restore-'+unique + run('volume','create',volume) + try: + run('run','-d','--name',target,'--cpus','1','--memory','256m','-e','POSTGRES_USER=messenger','-e','POSTGRES_DB=messenger','-e','POSTGRES_HOST_AUTH_METHOD=trust','-v',volume+':/var/lib/postgresql/data',image) + start=time.perf_counter() + for _ in range(100): + try: run('exec',target,'pg_isready','-U','messenger'); break + except subprocess.CalledProcessError: time.sleep(.2) + else: raise AssertionError('restore PostgreSQL did not become ready') + run('exec','-i',target,'pg_restore','-U','messenger','-d','messenger','--exit-on-error',input=dump) + result['restore']={'seconds_including_startup':round(time.perf_counter()-start,3),'fresh_volume':volume,'published_ports':False} + # pg_restore schema/data includes all constraints and indexes. + query="SELECT json_build_object('users',(SELECT count(*) FROM users),'chats',(SELECT count(*) FROM chats),'members',(SELECT count(*) FROM members),'messages',(SELECT count(*) FROM messages),'sessions',(SELECT count(*) FROM sessions))" + counts=json.loads(run('exec',target,'psql','-U','messenger','-Atc',query)) + digest=run('exec',target,'psql','-U','messenger','-Atc',"SELECT md5(string_agg(id::text||chat_id::text||sender_id::text||text||created_at::text,'' ORDER BY id)) FROM messages").decode().strip() + selected=json.loads(run('exec',target,'psql','-U','messenger','-Atc',"SELECT json_agg(row_to_json(t)) FROM (SELECT id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at::text FROM messages ORDER BY id LIMIT 20) t")) + selected=[[str(row[k]) for k in ('id','chat_id','sender_id','text','created_at')] for row in selected] + # Normalize equivalent precision/offset rendering, preserving actual instants. + for rows in (selected,result['snapshot']['selected']): + for row in rows: row[-1]=datetime.fromisoformat(row[-1]).isoformat(timespec='microseconds') + assert counts==result['snapshot']['counts'] + assert digest==result['snapshot']['all_messages_digest'] + assert selected==result['snapshot']['selected'] + result['restore'].update(counts=counts,all_messages_digest=digest,selected_20_match=True,verified=True) + finally: + run('rm','-f',target) + run('volume','rm',volume) + result['limitations']='Warm-cache serial variants on one local host; logical backup snapshot, no WAL/PITR; synthetic DB retained for inspection.' + result['database']=dbname + (root/'evidence').mkdir(exist_ok=True) + (root/'evidence/index-restore.json').write_text(json.dumps(result,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2)+'\n',encoding='utf-8') + print(json.dumps({k:v for k,v in result.items() if k not in ('plans','snapshot')},indent=2)) + +if __name__=='__main__': + if '--inside' in sys.argv: inside(sys.argv[-1]) + else: host() diff --git a/scripts/load_experiment.py b/scripts/load_experiment.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..cc41fa62 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/load_experiment.py @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +"""Bounded closed-loop HTTP load, raw latency and Docker resource samples.""" +from concurrent.futures import ThreadPoolExecutor +import csv +import json +import math +from pathlib import Path +import subprocess +import threading +import time +import uuid +import httpx + +ROOT=Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] +def docker(*args): + return subprocess.check_output(['docker',*args],cwd=ROOT,text=True,encoding='utf-8').strip() +rows=[]; samples=[]; done=threading.Event() +def sample(): + while not done.is_set(): + data=docker('stats','--no-stream','--format','{{json .}}',*docker('compose','ps','-q').splitlines()) + samples.extend({'elapsed_s':round(time.perf_counter()-start,3),**json.loads(line)} for line in data.splitlines()) + done.wait(1) +with httpx.Client(base_url='http://127.0.0.1:8080',timeout=10) as c: + body={'username':'load_'+uuid.uuid4().hex[:18],'display_name':'Load','password':'synthetic-password-123'} + user=c.post('/api/v1/users',json=body).json() + auth=c.post('/api/v1/auth/sessions',auth=(body['username'],body['password'])).json() + headers={'Authorization':'Bearer '+auth['token']} + chat=c.post('/api/v1/chats',headers=headers,json={'title':'load','member_ids':[user['id']]}).json() + path='/api/v1/chats/'+chat['id']+'/messages' + # Warm up the pool/cache for 2 seconds, outside measurement. + deadline=time.perf_counter()+2 + while time.perf_counter()=5 + docker('compose','stop','cache') + try: + start=time.perf_counter() + r=c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers) + evidence['cache_down']={'status':r.status_code,'seconds':round(time.perf_counter()-start,3)} + assert r.status_code==200 + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers={'Authorization':'Bearer '+'x'*43}).status_code==401 + finally: docker('compose','start','cache') + docker('compose','stop','db') + try: + start=time.perf_counter(); r=c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers) + evidence['database_down']={'status':r.status_code,'seconds':round(time.perf_counter()-start,3)} + assert r.status_code==503 and time.perf_counter()-start<10 + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me').status_code==401 + finally: docker('compose','start','db') + wait_ready(c) + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers).status_code==200 + assert c.delete('/api/v1/auth/sessions/current',headers=headers).status_code==204 + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers).status_code==401 + evidence['logout']='204 then 401' + +# A separate API process with short TTL uses the same persistent dependencies. +name='lab2-expiry-'+uuid.uuid4().hex[:8] +docker('compose','run','-d','--no-deps','--name',name,'-p','127.0.0.1::8080','-e','SESSION_TTL_SECONDS=2','api') +try: + binding=docker('port',name,'8080/tcp').split(':')[-1] + with httpx.Client(base_url='http://127.0.0.1:'+binding,timeout=10) as c: + wait_ready(c); body,user=register(c); headers=login(c,body) + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers).status_code==200 + time.sleep(2.2) + assert c.get('/api/v1/users/me',headers=headers).status_code==401 + evidence['short_ttl']='SESSION_TTL_SECONDS=2: 200 then 401 after 2.2s' +finally: docker('rm','-f',name) + +evidence['migration_repeat']=docker('compose','run','--rm','--no-deps','migrate') +if os.name=='nt': + with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory(prefix='lab2-hook-') as tmp: + hook=Path(tmp)/'restart.cmd' + hook.write_text('@echo off\n"'+sys.executable+'" "'+str(ROOT/'scripts/restart.py')+'"\n',encoding='utf-8') + evidence['public_persistence']=subprocess.check_output([sys.executable,'-X','utf8','tests/resilience.py','--mode','persistence','--action-script',str(hook)],cwd=ROOT,text=True,encoding='utf-8').strip() +else: + evidence['public_persistence']=subprocess.check_output([sys.executable,'tests/resilience.py','--mode','persistence','--action-script','scripts/restart.sh'],cwd=ROOT,text=True).strip() +evidence['passed']=True +(OUT/'integration.json').write_text(json.dumps(evidence,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2)+'\n',encoding='utf-8') +print(json.dumps(evidence,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2)) diff --git a/src/__init__.py b/src/__init__.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..e69de29b diff --git a/src/__main__.py b/src/__main__.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..2e8fadcf --- /dev/null +++ b/src/__main__.py @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +import logging +import os +import uvicorn + +logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO, format='%(message)s') +uvicorn.run('src.app:app', host=os.environ.get('APP_HOST', '0.0.0.0'), + port=int(os.environ.get('APP_PORT', '8080')), workers=1, + access_log=False, server_header=False, timeout_keep_alive=2, + timeout_graceful_shutdown=5, backlog=64, h11_max_incomplete_event_size=16384) diff --git a/src/app.py b/src/app.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..eccf04f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/app.py @@ -0,0 +1,173 @@ +import asyncio +import base64 +from contextlib import asynccontextmanager +from dataclasses import dataclass +import os +import re +import secrets + +from argon2 import PasswordHasher +from argon2.exceptions import VerificationError, InvalidHashError +from fastapi import FastAPI, Request, Response +import psycopg +from psycopg_pool import PoolTimeout, TooManyRequests +from starlette.exceptions import HTTPException + +from .common import ApiError, invalid, json_body, object_fields, pagination, string, uuid_value +from .http import Boundaries, error_response +from .store import Store, clean + + +@dataclass +class Settings: + database_url: str + redis_url: str + cursor_secret: str + session_ttl_seconds: int = 3600 + db_pool_size: int = 5 + max_body_bytes: int = 32768 + max_inflight: int = 32 + request_timeout: int = 8 + write_rps: int = 100 + write_burst: int = 100 + + @classmethod + def environment(cls): + result=cls(database_url=os.environ['DATABASE_URL'],redis_url=os.environ['REDIS_URL'],cursor_secret=os.environ['CURSOR_SECRET'], + **{name:int(os.environ.get(name.upper(),field.default)) for name,field in cls.__dataclass_fields__.items() if field.type is int}) + if len(result.cursor_secret)<32 or any(getattr(result,name)<=0 for name,field in cls.__dataclass_fields__.items() if field.type is int): + raise ValueError('Invalid configuration') + return result + + +def create_app(settings=None): + cfg=settings or Settings.environment() + store=Store(cfg) + hasher=PasswordHasher(time_cost=2,memory_cost=32768,parallelism=1) + dummy_hash=hasher.hash(secrets.token_urlsafe(32)) + kdf_slots=asyncio.Semaphore(4) + + @asynccontextmanager + async def lifespan(api): + await store.open() + try: yield + finally: await store.close() + + api=FastAPI(lifespan=lifespan,openapi_url=None,docs_url=None,redoc_url=None) + api.state.store=store + + @api.exception_handler(ApiError) + async def api_error(request,exc): return error_response(exc,request.state.request_id) + + @api.exception_handler(HTTPException) + async def http_error(request,exc): + return error_response(ApiError(404,'not_found','Route not found'),request.state.request_id) + + async def database_error(request,exc): + return error_response(ApiError(503,'unavailable','Database unavailable',{'Retry-After':'1'}),request.state.request_id) + for exception in (psycopg.Error,PoolTimeout,TooManyRequests): api.add_exception_handler(exception,database_error) + + @api.exception_handler(psycopg.DataError) + async def data_error(request,exc): + return error_response(ApiError(400,'invalid_request','Unsupported field value'),request.state.request_id) + + def unauthorized(basic=False): + scheme='Basic realm="messenger", charset="UTF-8"' if basic else 'Bearer realm="messenger"' + return ApiError(401,'unauthorized','Invalid credentials',{'WWW-Authenticate':scheme}) + + def bearer(request): + value=request.headers.get('authorization','') + parts=value.split() + if len(parts)!=2 or parts[0].lower()!='bearer' or not re.fullmatch(r'[A-Za-z0-9_-]{43}',parts[1]): + raise unauthorized() + return parts[1] + + async def actor(request): return await store.authenticate(bearer(request)) + + @api.get('/health/live') + async def live(): return {'status':'ok'} + + @api.get('/health/ready') + async def ready(): + await store.ready() + return {'status':'ok'} + + @api.post('/api/v1/users',status_code=201) + async def register(request:Request): + body=object_fields(await json_body(request),('username','display_name','password')) + username=string(body['username'],32) + if not re.fullmatch(r'[a-z0-9_]{3,32}',username): invalid('Invalid username') + name=string(body['display_name'],100) + password=string(body['password'],128) + if len(password)<12: invalid('Password must contain 12..128 code points') + async with kdf_slots: hashed=await asyncio.to_thread(hasher.hash,password) + return await store.register(username,name,hashed) + + @api.post('/api/v1/auth/sessions',status_code=201) + async def login(request:Request): + try: + scheme,encoded=request.headers.get('authorization','').split(' ',1) + if scheme.lower()!='basic': raise ValueError() + username,password=base64.b64decode(encoded,validate=True).decode('utf-8').split(':',1) + if not re.fullmatch(r'[a-z0-9_]{3,32}',username) or not 12<=len(password)<=128: raise ValueError() + except (ValueError,UnicodeError): raise unauthorized(True) from None + if await request.body(): invalid('Session login does not accept a body') + row=await store.credentials(username) + try: + async with kdf_slots: await asyncio.to_thread(hasher.verify,row['password_hash'] if row else dummy_hash,password) + except (VerificationError,InvalidHashError): raise unauthorized(True) from None + if not row: raise unauthorized(True) + token=secrets.token_urlsafe(32) + expires=await store.create_session(row['id'],token) + return {'token':token,'token_type':'Bearer','expires_at':expires, + 'user':clean({k:v for k,v in row.items() if k!='password_hash'})} + + @api.delete('/api/v1/auth/sessions/current',status_code=204) + async def logout(request:Request): + await actor(request) + await store.logout(bearer(request)) + return Response(status_code=204) + + @api.get('/api/v1/users/me') + async def me(request:Request): return await actor(request) + + @api.post('/api/v1/chats',status_code=201) + async def create_chat(request:Request): + user=await actor(request) + body=object_fields(await json_body(request),('title','member_ids')) + title=string(body['title'],100) + if not isinstance(body['member_ids'],list) or not 1<=len(body['member_ids'])<=100: invalid('Invalid members') + members=[uuid_value(v) for v in body['member_ids']] + if len(set(members))!=len(members): invalid('Duplicate member') + return await store.create_chat(user['id'],title,members) + + @api.get('/api/v1/chats') + async def list_chats(request:Request): + user=await actor(request) + limit,cursor=pagination(request,'chats:'+user['id'],store.secret) + return await store.page(user['id'],None,limit,cursor) + + @api.get('/api/v1/chats/{chat_id}') + async def get_chat(chat_id:str,request:Request): + user=await actor(request) + return await store.chat(user['id'],uuid_value(chat_id)) + + @api.get('/api/v1/chats/{chat_id}/messages') + async def list_messages(chat_id:str,request:Request): + user=await actor(request); chat_id=uuid_value(chat_id) + await store.chat(user['id'],chat_id) + limit,cursor=pagination(request,'messages:'+chat_id,store.secret) + return await store.page(user['id'],chat_id,limit,cursor) + + @api.post('/api/v1/chats/{chat_id}/messages',status_code=201) + async def create_message(chat_id:str,request:Request): + user=await actor(request); chat_id=uuid_value(chat_id) + await store.chat(user['id'],chat_id) + body=object_fields(await json_body(request),('text',)) + return await store.create_message(user['id'],chat_id,string(body['text'],4000)) + + api.add_middleware(Boundaries,settings=cfg) + return api + + +app=create_app() diff --git a/src/common.py b/src/common.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..7d4e9e84 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/common.py @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +"""Strict contract validation and resource-bound cursors.""" +import base64 +import binascii +import hashlib +import hmac +import json +import re +from datetime import datetime, timezone +from uuid import UUID + + +class ApiError(Exception): + def __init__(self, status, code, message, headers=None): + self.status, self.code, self.message = status, code, message + self.headers = headers or {} + + +def invalid(message='Invalid request'): + raise ApiError(400, 'invalid_request', message) + + +def uuid_value(value): + if not isinstance(value, str) or not re.fullmatch( + r'[0-9a-fA-F]{8}-(?:[0-9a-fA-F]{4}-){3}[0-9a-fA-F]{12}', value + ): + invalid('Invalid UUID') + return str(UUID(value)) + + +def string(value, maximum, *, blank=False): + if not isinstance(value, str) or len(value) > maximum or (not blank and not value.strip()): + invalid('Invalid string') + # JSON can encode unpaired surrogates; they are not Unicode scalar values. + try: + value.encode('utf-8') + except UnicodeError: + invalid('Invalid Unicode') + return value + + +def object_fields(value, required, optional=()): + if not isinstance(value, dict) or not set(required) <= value.keys() or value.keys() - set(required) - set(optional): + invalid('Invalid fields') + return value + + +def timestamp(): + return datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(timespec='microseconds').replace('+00:00', 'Z') + + +def encode_cursor(resource, key, secret): + data = json.dumps([resource, *key], separators=(',', ':')).encode() + return base64.urlsafe_b64encode(data + hmac.digest(secret, data, 'sha256')).decode().rstrip('=') + + +def decode_cursor(value, resource, secret): + try: + if len(value) > 1024 or not re.fullmatch(r'[A-Za-z0-9_-]+', value): + raise ValueError() + raw = base64.b64decode(value + '=' * (-len(value) % 4), altchars=b'-_', validate=True) + data, signature = raw[:-32], raw[-32:] + if not hmac.compare_digest(hmac.digest(secret, data, 'sha256'), signature): + raise ValueError() + scope, created, identifier = json.loads(data) + if scope != resource or not isinstance(created, str) or not created.endswith('Z'): + raise ValueError() + datetime.fromisoformat(created.replace('Z', '+00:00')) + UUID(identifier) + return created, identifier + except (ValueError, TypeError, binascii.Error, UnicodeError): + invalid('Invalid cursor') + + +def pagination(request, resource, secret): + if any(len(request.query_params.getlist(k)) != 1 for k in request.query_params): + invalid('Duplicate query parameter') + if set(request.query_params) - {'limit', 'cursor'}: + invalid('Unknown query parameter') + value = request.query_params.get('limit', '50') + if not re.fullmatch(r'[0-9]{1,3}', value) or not 1 <= int(value) <= 100: + invalid('Limit must be 1..100') + cursor = request.query_params.get('cursor') + return int(value), decode_cursor(cursor, resource, secret) if cursor is not None else None + + +async def json_body(request): + if request.headers.get('content-type', '').split(';')[0].strip().lower() != 'application/json': + raise ApiError(415, 'unsupported_media_type', 'Expected application/json') + def unique_pairs(pairs): + result = {} + for key, value in pairs: + if key in result: + raise ValueError('duplicate key') + result[key] = value + return result + def no_constant(value): + raise ValueError('non-finite number') + try: + return json.loads((await request.body()).decode('utf-8'), object_pairs_hook=unique_pairs, parse_constant=no_constant) + except (ValueError, UnicodeError, RecursionError): + invalid('Invalid JSON') diff --git a/src/http.py b/src/http.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..33eedad9 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/http.py @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +import asyncio +import json +import logging +import time +from uuid import uuid4 +from starlette.responses import JSONResponse +from .common import ApiError +logger=logging.getLogger("messenger") + +def error_response(exc, request_id): + return JSONResponse({'error': {'code': exc.code, 'message': exc.message, 'request_id': request_id}}, + status_code=exc.status, headers={'X-Request-Id': request_id, **exc.headers}) + + +class Boundaries: + """Admission before body buffering; no unbounded application waiting queue.""" + def __init__(self, app, settings): + self.app, self.cfg = app, settings + self.active, self.tokens, self.updated = 0, float(settings.write_burst), time.monotonic() + + async def __call__(self, scope, receive, send): + if scope['type'] != 'http': + return await self.app(scope, receive, send) + request_id, started, status = uuid4().hex, time.monotonic(), 500 + scope.setdefault('state', {})['request_id'] = request_id + started_response = False + async def tracked_send(message): + nonlocal status, started_response + if message['type'] == 'http.response.start': + status, started_response = message['status'], True + message['headers'] = [(k, v) for k, v in message.get('headers', []) if k.lower() != b'x-request-id'] + [(b'x-request-id', request_id.encode())] + await send(message) + admitted = False + try: + if self.active >= self.cfg.max_inflight: + raise ApiError(503, 'unavailable', 'Too many in-flight requests', {'Retry-After': '1'}) + now = time.monotonic() + self.tokens = min(self.cfg.write_burst, self.tokens + (now - self.updated) * self.cfg.write_rps) + self.updated = now + if scope['method'] in ('POST', 'PUT', 'PATCH'): + if self.tokens < 1: + raise ApiError(429, 'rate_limited', 'Write rate exceeded', {'Retry-After': '1'}) + self.tokens -= 1 + self.active += 1 + admitted = True + chunks, total = bytearray(), 0 + async with asyncio.timeout(self.cfg.request_timeout): + while True: + message = await receive() + if message['type'] == 'http.disconnect': + return + chunk = message.get('body', b'') + total += len(chunk) + if total > self.cfg.max_body_bytes: + raise ApiError(413, 'payload_too_large', 'Request body exceeds byte limit') + chunks.extend(chunk) + if not message.get('more_body', False): + break + body = bytes(chunks) + delivered = False + async def replay(): + nonlocal delivered + if delivered: + return await receive() + delivered = True + return {'type': 'http.request', 'body': body, 'more_body': False} + await self.app(scope, replay, tracked_send) + except TimeoutError: + if not started_response: + await error_response(ApiError(503, 'unavailable', 'Request timed out'), request_id)(scope, receive, tracked_send) + except ApiError as exc: + if not started_response: + await error_response(exc, request_id)(scope, receive, tracked_send) + except Exception as exc: + logger.error(json.dumps({'event': 'unexpected_error', 'request_id': request_id, 'type': type(exc).__name__})) + if not started_response: + await error_response(ApiError(500, 'internal_error', 'Internal error'), request_id)(scope, receive, tracked_send) + finally: + if admitted: + self.active -= 1 + # No query, body, headers, usernames, or message content in logs. + route = scope.get('route') + logger.info(json.dumps({'event': 'http', 'request_id': request_id, 'method': scope['method'], + 'route': getattr(route, 'path', 'unmatched'), 'status': status, + 'duration_ms': round((time.monotonic() - started) * 1000, 3)})) diff --git a/src/migrate.py b/src/migrate.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..a66ac916 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/migrate.py @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +"""Versioned, transactional migrations, serialized across deployers.""" +import hashlib +import os +from pathlib import Path +import psycopg + + +def main(): + with psycopg.connect(os.environ['DATABASE_URL'],autocommit=True,connect_timeout=5) as conn: + conn.execute('SELECT pg_advisory_lock(23012026)') + try: + conn.execute('CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS schema_migrations (name text PRIMARY KEY, sha256 text NOT NULL, applied_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT clock_timestamp())') + for file in sorted((Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1]/'migrations').glob('*.sql')): + data=file.read_bytes(); digest=hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest() + row=conn.execute('SELECT sha256 FROM schema_migrations WHERE name=%s',(file.name,)).fetchone() + if row: + if row[0]!=digest: raise RuntimeError('An applied migration was modified: '+file.name) + print('Already applied:',file.name,flush=True) + continue + with conn.transaction(): + conn.execute(data.decode('utf-8')) + conn.execute('INSERT INTO schema_migrations(name,sha256) VALUES (%s,%s)',(file.name,digest)) + print('Applied:',file.name,flush=True) + finally: + conn.execute('SELECT pg_advisory_unlock(23012026)') + + +if __name__=='__main__': main() diff --git a/src/store.py b/src/store.py new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ca81c016 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/store.py @@ -0,0 +1,130 @@ +import hashlib +import json +import logging +from uuid import uuid4 + +import psycopg +from psycopg.rows import dict_row +from psycopg_pool import AsyncConnectionPool +from redis.asyncio import Redis +from redis.exceptions import RedisError + +from .common import ApiError, encode_cursor, invalid + + +def clean(row): + if row is None: return None + result={} + for k,v in row.items(): + if hasattr(v,'isoformat'): v=v.isoformat(timespec='microseconds').replace('+00:00','Z') + elif isinstance(v,list): v=[str(x) for x in v] + elif type(v).__name__=='UUID': v=str(v) + result[k]=v + return result + + +class Store: + def __init__(self,cfg): + self.cfg=cfg + self.secret=cfg.cursor_secret.encode() + self.pool=AsyncConnectionPool(cfg.database_url,min_size=1,max_size=cfg.db_pool_size, + timeout=2,max_waiting=32,open=False, + kwargs={'row_factory':dict_row,'connect_timeout':3, + 'options':'-c statement_timeout=2000 -c lock_timeout=1000 -c timezone=UTC'}) + self.cache=Redis.from_url(cfg.redis_url,socket_timeout=.2,socket_connect_timeout=.2, + max_connections=8,decode_responses=True) + + async def open(self): await self.pool.open(wait=True,timeout=20) + async def close(self): + await self.cache.aclose() + await self.pool.close() + + async def ready(self): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: await c.execute('SELECT 1') + + async def register(self,username,display_name,password_hash): + try: + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + row=await (await c.execute('INSERT INTO users(id,username,display_name,password_hash) VALUES (%s,%s,%s,%s) RETURNING id,username,display_name,created_at', + (uuid4(),username,display_name,password_hash))).fetchone() + return clean(row) + except psycopg.errors.UniqueViolation: + raise ApiError(409,'conflict','Username already exists') from None + + async def credentials(self,username): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + return await (await c.execute('SELECT * FROM users WHERE username=%s',(username,))).fetchone() + + async def create_session(self,user_id,token): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + row=await (await c.execute("INSERT INTO sessions(token_hash,user_id,expires_at) VALUES (%s,%s,clock_timestamp()+%s*interval '1 second') RETURNING expires_at", + (hashlib.sha256(token.encode()).hexdigest(),user_id,self.cfg.session_ttl_seconds))).fetchone() + return clean(row)['expires_at'] + + async def authenticate(self,token): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + session=await (await c.execute('SELECT user_id FROM sessions WHERE token_hash=%s AND expires_at>clock_timestamp()', + (hashlib.sha256(token.encode()).hexdigest(),))).fetchone() + if session is None: raise ApiError(401,'unauthorized','Invalid session',{'WWW-Authenticate':'Bearer realm="messenger"'}) + key='user:'+str(session['user_id']) + try: + cached=await self.cache.get(key) + if cached: return json.loads(cached) + except (RedisError,ValueError): + logging.getLogger('messenger').warning('{"event":"cache_bypass"}') + row=await (await c.execute('SELECT id,username,display_name,created_at FROM users WHERE id=%s',(session['user_id'],))).fetchone() + user=clean(row) + try: await self.cache.set(key,json.dumps(user),ex=60) + except RedisError: pass + return user + + async def logout(self,token): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + await c.execute('DELETE FROM sessions WHERE token_hash=%s',(hashlib.sha256(token.encode()).hexdigest(),)) + + async def _chat(self,c,actor,chat_id): + row=await (await c.execute('SELECT c.id,c.title,c.created_at,ARRAY(SELECT user_id FROM members WHERE chat_id=c.id ORDER BY user_id) AS member_ids FROM chats c JOIN members m ON m.chat_id=c.id WHERE c.id=%s AND m.user_id=%s',(chat_id,actor))).fetchone() + if row is None: raise ApiError(404,'not_found','Object not found') + return clean(row) + + async def chat(self,actor,chat_id): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: return await self._chat(c,actor,chat_id) + + async def create_chat(self,actor,title,members): + if actor not in members: invalid('Members must include the current user') + try: + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + cid=uuid4() + await c.execute('INSERT INTO chats(id,title) VALUES (%s,%s)',(cid,title)) + async with c.cursor() as cur: + await cur.executemany('INSERT INTO members(chat_id,user_id) VALUES (%s,%s)',[(cid,m) for m in members]) + return await self._chat(c,actor,cid) + except psycopg.errors.ForeignKeyViolation: + invalid('All members must exist') + + async def create_message(self,actor,chat_id,text): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + await self._chat(c,actor,chat_id) + row=await (await c.execute('INSERT INTO messages(id,chat_id,sender_id,text) VALUES (%s,%s,%s,%s) RETURNING id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at', + (uuid4(),chat_id,actor,text))).fetchone() + return clean(row) + + async def page(self,actor,chat_id,limit,cursor): + async with self.pool.connection() as c: + if chat_id: + await self._chat(c,actor,chat_id) + query='SELECT id,chat_id,sender_id,text,created_at FROM messages WHERE chat_id=%s' + args=[chat_id]; resource='messages:'+chat_id + if cursor: + query+=' AND (created_at,id)>(%s::timestamptz,%s::uuid)'; args.extend(cursor) + query+=' ORDER BY created_at,id LIMIT %s'; args.append(limit+1) + else: + query='SELECT c.id,c.title,c.created_at,ARRAY(SELECT user_id FROM members WHERE chat_id=c.id ORDER BY user_id) AS member_ids FROM chats c JOIN members m ON m.chat_id=c.id WHERE m.user_id=%s' + args=[actor]; resource='chats:'+actor + if cursor: + query+=' AND (c.created_at,c.id)>(%s::timestamptz,%s::uuid)'; args.extend(cursor) + query+=' ORDER BY c.created_at,c.id LIMIT %s'; args.append(limit+1) + rows=[clean(row) for row in await (await c.execute(query,args)).fetchall()] + selected=rows[:limit] + next_cursor=encode_cursor(resource,(selected[-1]['created_at'],selected[-1]['id']),self.secret) if len(rows)>limit else None + return {'items':selected,'next_cursor':next_cursor} -- 2.54.0 From 3999ad24e9595555749c48d00a587d6a5272a690 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: =?UTF-8?q?=D0=93=D0=BB=D0=B5=D0=B1=20=D0=9F=D0=B0=D1=80=D0=B0=D0=BC?= =?UTF-8?q?=D0=BE=D0=BD=D0=BE=D0=B2?= Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2026 15:31:32 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Verify clean deployment and exclude local secrets from build context --- .dockerignore | 18 ++++++++++++-- REPORT.md | 4 +++ evidence/clean-clone-restart.json | 13 ++++++++++ evidence/clean-clone-verification.json | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 67 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) create mode 100644 evidence/clean-clone-restart.json create mode 100644 evidence/clean-clone-verification.json diff --git a/.dockerignore b/.dockerignore index f6353cde..bc16e556 100644 --- a/.dockerignore +++ b/.dockerignore @@ -1,6 +1,20 @@ .git -.venv +.github .env +.env.* +!.env.example +secrets +certs +volumes +data backups -evidence +*.key +*.pem +*.p12 +*.pfx +*.jks +.venv __pycache__ +node_modules +evidence +.DS_Store diff --git a/REPORT.md b/REPORT.md index 6935f3a8..a4f8470f 100644 --- a/REPORT.md +++ b/REPORT.md @@ -81,3 +81,7 @@ Docker stats: API максимум100.05% CPU и47.89MiB, БД23.73%/25.43MiB, c ## Ограничения Один Docker-host/одна БД — SPOF; backup не обеспечивает непрерывную доступность. Локальный HTTP разрешён только для synthetic данных. DB-role учебно имеет права миграций (разделение ролей — следующий этап). Expired sessions перестают авторизовывать, но фоновая очистка строк пока не реализована. Кэш профилей не демонстрирует ускорение истории и не заявляется как трек1. Idempotency-Key и несколько реплик появятся в ЛР3; здесь повтор POST после неизвестного исхода может создать дубликат. Все результаты относятся к указанному стенду. + +## Повтор из чистого clone + +Коммит be6f10f собран в отдельном каталоге .setup/clean-lab2 с новым volume и новыми локальными секретами. Полная интеграционная проверка повторно прошла: 100/100 сообщений, гонка регистрации, cache hit +5, отказы cache/DB, expiry, logout, повтор миграции и persistence с прежней сессией. Результаты: evidence/clean-clone-verification.json, реальные времена рестартов: evidence/clean-clone-restart.json. diff --git a/evidence/clean-clone-restart.json b/evidence/clean-clone-restart.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b2d308bb --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/clean-clone-restart.json @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{ + "before": { + "api": "2026-10-16T12:26:12.421719826Z", + "db": "2026-10-16T12:27:19.188705708Z", + "cache": "2026-10-16T12:27:17.815782719Z" + }, + "after": { + "api": "2026-10-16T12:27:34.893221429Z", + "db": "2026-10-16T12:27:34.36080408Z", + "cache": "2026-10-16T12:27:34.173884108Z" + }, + "volumes_removed": false +} diff --git a/evidence/clean-clone-verification.json b/evidence/clean-clone-verification.json new file mode 100644 index 00000000..72f1e6d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/clean-clone-verification.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "public_smoke": "PASS: lab2 public API scenario; infrastructure and grading evidence remain separate.", + "authentication_negative": "wrong password, Basic on protected route, X-User-Id: 401", + "registration_race": [ + 201, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409, + 409 + ], + "rollback": "missing member: 400; chats count unchanged", + "concurrent_messages": { + "sent": 100, + "read": 100, + "page_size": 17 + }, + "cache_hit_delta": 5, + "cache_down": { + "status": 200, + "seconds": 0.209 + }, + "database_down": { + "status": 503, + "seconds": 0.006 + }, + "logout": "204 then 401", + "short_ttl": "SESSION_TTL_SECONDS=2: 200 then 401 after 2.2s", + "migration_repeat": "Already applied: 001_initial.sql", + "public_persistence": "Executing explicit persistence hook; hook output suppressed to avoid leaking secrets.\nPASS: persistence preserved confirmed data and existing session. Hook scope needs operator evidence.", + "passed": true +} -- 2.54.0