diff --git a/evidence/track2/backup.dump b/evidence/track2/backup.dump index d5c2f16..52557de 100644 Binary files a/evidence/track2/backup.dump and b/evidence/track2/backup.dump differ diff --git a/evidence/track2/benchmark.json b/evidence/track2/benchmark.json index 98ff159..82c690e 100644 --- a/evidence/track2/benchmark.json +++ b/evidence/track2/benchmark.json @@ -1,28 +1,28 @@ { "hypothesis": "Keyset pagination on (chat_id, created_at, id) avoids large offsets; redundant (chat_id)-only index does not improve reads but slows writes.", - "hot_chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "hot_chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "read_plans": { "keyset_limit_50": { "node_type": "Index Only Scan", "index_name": "messages_chat_history_idx", - "execution_ms": 0.061, + "execution_ms": 0.323, "plan_rows": 50 }, "offset_50000_limit_50": { "node_type": "Index Only Scan", "index_name": "messages_chat_history_idx", - "execution_ms": 6.117, + "execution_ms": 5.577, "plan_rows": 50 }, "keyset_with_extra_chat_id_index": { "node_type": "Index Only Scan", "index_name": "messages_chat_history_idx", - "execution_ms": 0.052, + "execution_ms": 0.055, "plan_rows": 50 } }, "write_messages_per_second": { - "with_extra_chat_id_index": 23192.1, - "production_indexes_only": 38756.3 + "with_extra_chat_id_index": 17808.1, + "production_indexes_only": 22943.3 } } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/evidence/track2/restore_report.json b/evidence/track2/restore_report.json index 8105232..caf161e 100644 --- a/evidence/track2/restore_report.json +++ b/evidence/track2/restore_report.json @@ -1,69 +1,69 @@ { "source": { - "messages": 116022, - "users": 88, + "messages": 113003, + "users": 8, "sample": [ { - "id": "ffb54a59-afe2-41b7-9d55-e53a68117a84", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "ffdc1b38-be68-4b22-b3ac-9cfa0a8b95e7", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff90fc55-75ed-4633-85da-219d49656ebe", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "ff7ceafd-9fd1-4880-8a05-607961c68543", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff77cfb7-e1a3-45e3-ad54-c9b88a79cc1b", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "fef0853c-9b43-4f1d-bd5f-2941a08eeac1", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff102c2f-a3f2-4e39-a9c5-9a997a49f157", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "fee4413a-af81-4a84-8f4a-0c6704462f02", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "fe8a483b-94c8-40fc-a5d4-b0e2fd2602fc", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "febc6e0a-110e-4cda-8320-7fc88e5faf52", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" } ] }, "restored": { - "messages": 116022, - "users": 88, + "messages": 113003, + "users": 8, "sample": [ { - "id": "ffb54a59-afe2-41b7-9d55-e53a68117a84", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "ffdc1b38-be68-4b22-b3ac-9cfa0a8b95e7", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff90fc55-75ed-4633-85da-219d49656ebe", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "ff7ceafd-9fd1-4880-8a05-607961c68543", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff77cfb7-e1a3-45e3-ad54-c9b88a79cc1b", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "fef0853c-9b43-4f1d-bd5f-2941a08eeac1", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "ff102c2f-a3f2-4e39-a9c5-9a997a49f157", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "fee4413a-af81-4a84-8f4a-0c6704462f02", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" }, { - "id": "fe8a483b-94c8-40fc-a5d4-b0e2fd2602fc", - "chat_id": "01aeb3d4-8235-4964-8981-ace0cec560df", + "id": "febc6e0a-110e-4cda-8320-7fc88e5faf52", + "chat_id": "9d97f9d9-1ad0-4ab6-b95a-f35411c401b6", "text": "w" } ] }, "counts_match": true, "sample_match": true, - "restore_seconds": 3.75, - "dump_bytes": 3024158, + "restore_seconds": 3.6, + "dump_bytes": 2945586, "data_loss_boundary": "Logical pg_dump is consistent at dump start; concurrent writes during dump are not included. WAL/PITR not used — RPO equals changes after dump began." } \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/scripts/track2_benchmark.py b/scripts/track2_benchmark.py index 5bcf422..486905b 100644 --- a/scripts/track2_benchmark.py +++ b/scripts/track2_benchmark.py @@ -86,6 +86,13 @@ def main(): conn.execute('DROP INDEX IF EXISTS messages_chat_id_only_idx') conn.execute('CREATE INDEX messages_chat_id_only_idx ON messages (chat_id)') conn.commit() + + indexes = conn.execute( + "SELECT indexname, indexdef FROM pg_indexes " + "WHERE tablename = 'messages' ORDER BY indexname" + ).fetchall() + print(indexes) + plan_keyset_with_extra = explain(conn, keyset_sql, (hot_id,)) write_before = insert_batch(conn, hot_id, user_id, 500) conn.execute('DROP INDEX IF EXISTS messages_chat_id_only_idx')