From 8b84ebf6d63ed98da2bad265a7dec579ee56bd0d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Artyom Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 00:30:38 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] Record final validation and boundary PNG memory failure --- AGENTS.md | 6 +- REPORT.md | 47 +- evidence/README.md | 5 +- .../final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md | 60 ++ .../active-changes.txt | 11 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json | 142 +++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt | 90 ++ .../checks-final.txt | 14 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt | 14 + .../cleanup-recheck.json | 32 + .../cleanup-recheck.txt | 36 + .../delivery-targeted.json | 896 ++++++++++++++++++ .../delivery-targeted.txt | 29 + evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt | 53 ++ evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh | 8 + .../final-containers.txt | 15 + .../final-doc-audit.json | 701 ++++++++++++++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json | 37 + .../fixtures/gray16-40mp.png | Bin 0 -> 103565 bytes .../fixtures/gray2-40mp.png | Bin 0 -> 35759 bytes .../fixtures/gray4-40mp.png | Bin 0 -> 46441 bytes .../fixtures/rgb16-40mp.png | Bin 0 -> 385445 bytes .../historical-hashes.json | 17 + .../image-runtime.txt | 7 + .../invoke-probe.py | 11 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt | 28 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json | 742 +++++++++++++++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt | 12 + .../png-limits.json | 242 +++++ .../png-limits.txt | 11 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt | 7 + .../postgres-outage-retry.json | 199 ++++ .../postgres-outage-retry.txt | 5 + .../postgres-outage.json | 146 +++ .../postgres-outage.txt | 5 + .../probe-copy-fixtures.txt | 6 + .../probe-copy-script.txt | 6 + .../final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt | 7 + .../recheck-cleanup.py | 22 + .../resource-probe-retry.txt | 12 + .../resource-probe-worker.py | 42 + .../resource-probe-worker.txt | 12 + .../resource-probe.py | 40 + .../resource-probe.txt | 5 + .../retained-volumes.txt | 8 + .../running-containers-after.txt | 4 + .../runtime-containers.json | 167 ++++ .../scan-secrets.py | 46 + .../secret-scan.json | 58 ++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/sha256.json | 55 ++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt | 6 + .../stopped-containers.txt | 4 + .../student-test.txt | 20 + .../targeted-initial.py | 177 ++++ .../final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py | 179 ++++ evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt | 94 ++ evidence/load-validation.md | 42 + 57 files changed, 4620 insertions(+), 20 deletions(-) create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/active-changes.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks-final.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-containers.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-doc-audit.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray16-40mp.png create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray2-40mp.png create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray4-40mp.png create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/rgb16-40mp.png create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/historical-hashes.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/image-runtime.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/invoke-probe.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-fixtures.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-script.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-retry.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/running-containers-after.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/runtime-containers.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/scan-secrets.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/sha256.json create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted-initial.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py create mode 100644 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt create mode 100644 evidence/load-validation.md diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index cf59244..02e3df0 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -73,13 +73,15 @@ make down # остановка своего project без Индекс — [evidence/README.md](evidence/README.md), отчёт — [REPORT.md](REPORT.md). Последняя полная динамическая квалификация — `0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc`; успешное повторное review — `42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91`. Между ними runtime изменён только в renderer PNG и policy RabbitMQ. Старые PASS не обозначать прогоном текущего кода. -Текущая policy `delivery-limit=-1` сохраняет инфраструктурные redelivery; прикладные попытки после claim ограничены `JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS=5`. На финальном этапе остаются реальный отказ PostgreSQL с >10 nack и восстановлением без replay, применение policy на существующем volume, HTTP/Linux-проверки tRNS и адресные проверки затронутых сценариев. Процедуры — [исправления доставки](evidence/review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) и [исправления PNG](evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md). +Финальная validation на `b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef` (runtime = reviewed R) завершила real PostgreSQL outage: 12 requeue → ready без replay, policy `delivery-limit=-1` на сохранённом volume, DLQ не выросла. HTTP PNG: 8 fixtures / 48 сравнений вариантов v1/v2 PASS. Delivery subset: 12 сценариев / 8 инвариантов PASS. Student-test: 980 passed / 1 Linux-only skip. Аудит повторного использования — [evidence/load-validation.md](evidence/load-validation.md), результаты — [evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md). + +**Новый major, validation blocked:** четыре PNG tRNS 8000×5000 (grayscale 2/4/16 и RGB16) получают 202 → failed/processing_failed при штатных 448 MiB/30 с вместо объявленного ready. Linux-пробник с импортами worker подтверждает MemoryError. Требуются отдельный fix/re-review и повтор только затронутых PNG/ресурсных сценариев. Реализация финальной фазой не менялась, исходные FAIL сохранены; полный track2 и пригодные серии автоматически не повторять. Свой стенд остановлен, четыре volume сохранены; push не выполнялся. Пять minor сохраняются: crash_publish_confirm фактически после confirm до COMMIT outbox; limits.py имеет ложный FAIL порядка secrets; reconcile_track.py ожидает upload 201 ЛР4; failed upgrade v2 нельзя отдельно повторить при ready v1; UTC/elapsed run2/3 расходятся и исключены из performance-выводов. Корневые старые evidence до SQLAlchemy — история; происхождение и неприменимость обозначены в индексе. ## Уровни оценки -Цель — **«5»**, трек 2 «Доказанная идемпотентность pipeline». Полное подтверждение для текущего кода заявлять только после оставшихся адресных динамических проверок; таблица доказательств и границы применимости — в `REPORT.md`. +Цель — **«5»**, трек 2 «Доказанная идемпотентность pipeline». Полное подтверждение для текущего кода заявлять только после устранения major граничного PNG, review и адресной проверки; таблица доказательств и границы применимости — в `REPORT.md`. - **3** — `202 queued` после staging и `COMMIT` задания с outbox; отдельные `broker`, `relay`, `worker` в стенде; durable quorum queue, publisher confirm, ручной `ack` после `COMMIT`; состояния `queued/processing/ready/failed`, оригинал в `originals/` и thumbnail; ограниченный retry (`JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS=5`) и `failed` с `error_code`; повтор job без второго набора вариантов; worker остановлен → upload → сообщение → рестарт API и broker → worker → `ready`; минимум lab4 сохранён. - **4** — crop и optimized WebP, лимиты worker по байтам, пикселям, времени и памяти, crash между `COMMIT` и publish, backoff с jitter и классификация ошибок, DLQ и replay, crash после записи объекта до `ack`, lease и fencing для зависшего `processing`, prefetch, очистка staging. diff --git a/REPORT.md b/REPORT.md index bd23b36..76caebc 100644 --- a/REPORT.md +++ b/REPORT.md @@ -1,15 +1,15 @@ # Отчёт — лабораторная работа 5 Автор: **Костылев Артём, БПИ2303**. Тема: «Очереди и асинхронная обработка изображений». -Цель — **«5», трек 2 «Доказанная идемпотентность pipeline»**. Полное подтверждение оценки для текущего кода пока не заявляется: после успешного повторного ревью остаются адресные динамические проверки двух исправлений. Ниже отделены сохранённые результаты от этих незавершённых проверок. +Цель — **«5», трек 2 «Доказанная идемпотентность pipeline»**. Финальная validation заблокирована одним major: новые PNG tRNS на границе 40 Мп получают `processing_failed` при штатных 448 MiB вместо заявленного ready. Остальные адресные проверки завершены. Нужны отдельный fix и review; полное подтверждение «5» и готовность к публикации не заявляются. -Ветка: `solution/bpi2303-kostylev`. Проверенный ревью код: `42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91` (далее **R**). Последняя полная динамическая квалификация: `0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc` (далее **D**). Между D и R из runtime изменены только `infra/rabbitmq/definitions.json` и `src/messenger/attachments/infrastructure/images.py`; SQLAlchemy, Alembic, outbox, lease/fencing и публикация версий не изменились. Документационный коммит этого отчёта не меняет runtime. Публикация — отдельная фаза, только в private MTUCI-Labs; этот этап ничего не публикует. +Ветка: `solution/bpi2303-kostylev`. Проверенный ревью код: `42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91` (далее **R**). Последняя полная динамическая квалификация: `0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc` (далее **D**). Между D и R из runtime изменены только `infra/rabbitmq/definitions.json` и `src/messenger/attachments/infrastructure/images.py`; SQLAlchemy, Alembic, outbox, lease/fencing и публикация версий не изменились. Финальные проверки выполнены на `b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef` (V), runtime которого побайтно совпадает с R. Документационные коммиты отчёта и evidence не меняют runtime. Публикация — отдельная фаза, только в private MTUCI-Labs; этот этап ничего не публикует. Индекс происхождения всех доказательств — [evidence/README.md](evidence/README.md). Источники решения: skeleton и контракт курса, собственная ЛР4 с поздними исправлениями до `4ed889c1e4008e3f6040ae2534bef99262d3b8ce`, документация библиотек; при подготовке использован Codex. Перенос 253 файлов разобран в [forward-port.md](evidence/forward-port.md). Нормативные `contracts/`, `tests/`, `README.md`, `COURSE.md` не изменены. ## Воспроизведение из чистого clone -Нужны доступ к приватному репозиторию, Git, Docker с Compose v2, make, системный Python 3.9+, uv и OpenSpec CLI для проверки спецификаций. Приложение использует Python 3.14. Команды ниже — инструкция, а не заявление о новом прогоне из clone: на этапе отчёта Docker не запускался. +Нужны доступ к приватному репозиторию, Git, Docker с Compose v2, make, системный Python 3.9+, uv и OpenSpec CLI для проверки спецификаций. Приложение использует Python 3.14. Команды ниже — инструкция, а не заявление о новом прогоне из clone: первый отчётный этап Docker не запускал; последующая validation использовала существующие volumes, а не чистый clone. Вместо `` подставляется URL репозитория ЛР5 в MTUCI-Labs, доступный после публикации. На общей машине запуск разрешён только в выделенной фазе и своём project; занятые порты не освобождают остановкой чужих контейнеров. @@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ make down `make student-test` поднимает одноразовые Docker-зависимости; его нельзя считать offline-проверкой. Suite сам использует `infra/compose.faults.yaml`, временно меняет параметры своих relay/worker и восстанавливает их. Level 4 включает все шесть сценариев уровня 3. Новые JSON сохраняются отдельно от квалификационных файлов. Стенд останавливают `make down` без удаления постоянных volumes; `reset-data`, `down -v`, `reset/clean` в процедуру не входят. -Для защиты и оператора: `make worker-stop`, `make worker-start`, `make queues`, `make topology`, `make failed`, `make dlq`; `make replay ID=` возвращает failed в queued с audit, повтор для ready — noop. `make reprocess ID= PIPELINE_VERSION=2` создаёт новую версию при доступном исходнике. Регламент недостающих адресных проверок приведён ниже; полный повтор пригодных серий не требуется. +Для защиты и оператора: `make worker-stop`, `make worker-start`, `make queues`, `make topology`, `make failed`, `make dlq`; `make replay ID=` возвращает failed в queued с audit, повтор для ready — noop. `make reprocess ID= PIPELINE_VERSION=2` создаёт новую версию при доступном исходнике. Результаты адресной validation и оставшееся исправление приведены ниже; полный повтор пригодных серий не требуется. ## Архитектура и решения @@ -75,22 +75,22 @@ Python 3.14, FastAPI, gunicorn/uvicorn-worker, dishka и dishka-faststream, pyda **Повторы.** После claim временная ошибка назначает новую outbox-попытку с equal jitter: половина экспоненциальной задержки плюс случайная половина; штатная база 2 с, максимум 5 попыток. Постоянные ошибки дают `invalid_image`/`processing_failed`, исчерпание — `retry_exhausted`. Просроченный processing возвращает relay через `jobs_lease_idx`; старый держатель не проходит fencing. Ready не откатывается при upgrade, ошибка v2 оставляет v1 доступной. Невалидное сообщение отвергается в DLQ; реестр failed и replay доступны через CLI. -В R policy `delivery-limit=-1` сохраняет инфраструктурные redelivery при длительном отказе БД; прикладной предел `JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS=5` остаётся. Это исправляет прежний путь queued → DLQ после 10 nack без автоматического восстановления. Динамическое подтверждение новой policy на существующем volume ещё требуется; уже лежащие в DLQ сообщения смена policy не возвращает. Произвольное удаление сообщения при уже опубликованном outbox также не исправляется автоматически: outbox/lease не равны универсальной сверке очереди. +В R policy `delivery-limit=-1` сохраняет инфраструктурные redelivery при длительном отказе БД; прикладной предел `JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS=5` остаётся. Это исправляет прежний путь queued → DLQ после 10 nack без автоматического восстановления. На V policy подтверждена на существующем volume: 12 requeue после реальной остановки PostgreSQL, затем ready без replay и без роста DLQ — [evidence](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json); уже лежащие в DLQ сообщения смена policy не возвращает. Произвольное удаление сообщения при уже опубликованном outbox также не исправляется автоматически: outbox/lease не равны универсальной сверке очереди. **Изображения и ресурсы.** Оригинал неизменен. EXIF orientation применяется, прозрачность накладывается на белый фон, EXIF/ICC/XMP не копируются в варианты. Thumbnail — JPEG в 256×256 без увеличения, округление вниз, минимум 1 px; crop — центральный JPEG 128×128; optimized — WebP в 1280×1280 без увеличения. JPEG quality v1/v2 = 85/90, optimize=True; WebP = 80/85, method=4; Lanczos, reducing_gap=3.0. R исправляет tRNS, включая grayscale 2/4/16 и сравнение полных RGB16 samples до потери младших битов. -Предел входа — 10 485 760 байт и 40 млн пикселей; renderer — 30 с, Linux `RLIMIT_AS=448 MiB` на процесс, до 100 задач на дочерний процесс. Контейнер worker ограничен 2 CPU / 1 GiB, API — 1 CPU / 512 MiB на реплику, relay — 0.5 CPU / 192 MiB, broker — 1 CPU / 512 MiB, PostgreSQL — 2 CPU / 1 GiB, S3 — 1 CPU / 512 MiB. Старое измерение 423 MiB не переносится на новый RGB16+tRNS путь без проверки. +Предел входа — 10 485 760 байт и 40 млн пикселей; renderer — 30 с, Linux `RLIMIT_AS=448 MiB` на процесс, до 100 задач на дочерний процесс. Контейнер worker ограничен 2 CPU / 1 GiB, API — 1 CPU / 512 MiB на реплику, relay — 0.5 CPU / 192 MiB, broker — 1 CPU / 512 MiB, PostgreSQL — 2 CPU / 1 GiB, S3 — 1 CPU / 512 MiB. Старое измерение 423 MiB относится к обычному PNG. На V четыре 40 Мп PNG tRNS дали `processing_failed` на первой попытке; Linux-пробник подтверждает `MemoryError` внутри RLIMIT_AS, несмотря на peak контейнера 640 196 608 байт < 1 GiB. Граничный сценарий остаётся major. **Очистка.** Staging удаляется после безопасной публикации и завершения активных версий; у failed хранится 86400 с, затем replay возвращает expired. Проверка активных jobs и сериализация cleanup/reprocess защищают используемый исходник. Удаление выполняет relay; worker не получает право DeleteObject. Quarantine-миграция поддерживает унаследованную сверку S3, но демонстратор `reconcile_track.py` для квалификации ЛР5 непригоден. ## Проверки и таблица критериев -Динамические PASS относятся к **D**, 2026-11-06 UTC, кроме явно помеченной более ранней проверки топологии. Это аудит сохранённых прогонов, не новый запуск на R. Новые tRNS и policy проверены offline на R и перечислены отдельно. Полные команды, environment, exit codes и SHA находятся в связанных файлах. +Исторические динамические PASS относятся к **D**, 2026-11-06 UTC; более ранняя топология и новые проверки V помечены явно. Это аудит сохранённых прогонов, не новый запуск на R. Новые tRNS и policy дополнительно проверены динамически на V в отдельном блоке ниже; эти результаты не смешиваются с D. Полные команды, environment, exit codes и SHA находятся в связанных файлах. | Критерий | Команда / сценарий | Наблюдение | Файл | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Контракт, синтаксис, типы | `make check validate lint` | PASS на R, повторены на этапе отчёта; приложение этим не проверяется | [Аудит отчёта](evidence/report-audit-2026-11-07.md) | -| Собственные интеграционные тесты | `make student-test` | Предкоммитный diff, зафиксированный как D: 819 passed, 1 Linux-only skip, 19 stack deselected; полного запуска на R нет | [student-test.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/student-test.txt) | +| Собственные интеграционные тесты | `make student-test PYTEST_ARGS='-q --tb=short'` | V: 980 passed, 1 Linux-only skip, 19 stack deselected; полный запуск с real-broker | [student-test.txt](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt) | | Текущие исправления | Offline-команда с `--confcutdir`, шесть unit-модулей; отдельно `--noconftest` для границ | R: сохранённые 430 + 20 passed; 114 прежних вариантов побайтно совпали; Docker не участвовал | [Команды и результаты](evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) | | OpenSpec | `openspec validate --all --strict`; `openspec list --json` | 22 спецификации PASS, активных changes нет | [Аудит отчёта](evidence/report-audit-2026-11-07.md) | | 3: минимум lab1–4, 202 и thumbnail | `make test` | Публичный smoke PASS через LB | [final-smoke.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/final-smoke.txt) | @@ -99,7 +99,7 @@ Python 3.14, FastAPI, gunicorn/uvicorn-worker, dishka и dishka-faststream, pyda | 3: отдельный broker/worker, quorum, confirm, manual ack, prefetch | `rabbitmqctl list_queues/list_consumers/list_permissions`; проверки падений suite | Топология и prefetch=2 зафиксированы до forward; COMMIT/ack повторно проверен на D. Старый delivery-limit не доказывает policy R | [queues.txt](evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/queues.txt), [consumers.txt](evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/consumers.txt), [permissions.txt](evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/permissions.txt), [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | | 3: worker down, рестарт API/broker, затем ready | `pipeline_suite.py --level 4`, `worker_down_broker_restart` | 202 queued, content 409, сообщение 201; очередь [1,0] переживает рестарт; тот же ID становится ready | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | | 3: конечные состояния и повторы | `s3_outage_recovers`, `retry_exhausted`, `duplicate_after_ready` в suite | S3 восстановлен → done на попытке 2; failed на попытке 5; дубль ready → duplicate_noop | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | -| 4: варианты и Linux-лимиты | `image_matrix`, `worker_limits` в suite | 26 fixtures: 17 ready и 9 отклонённых; 40 Мп, 0.5 с / 200 MiB → контролируемый failed, worker жив; штатно ready, peak 423/1024 MiB. Новый RGB16+tRNS не измерен | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | +| 4: варианты и Linux-лимиты | `image_matrix`, `worker_limits` в suite | 26 fixtures: 17 ready и 9 отклонённых; 40 Мп, 0.5 с / 200 MiB → контролируемый failed, worker жив; штатно ready, peak 423/1024 MiB. Новые tRNS на V не прошли граничный ready-сценарий, см. ниже | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | | 4: outbox, crash COMMIT→publish | `crash_commit_publish` | Relay exit 137; outbox не опубликован; после восстановления ready без новой job | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | | 4: backoff, DLQ, replay | `retry_backoff_jitter`, `malformed_message_dead_lettered`, `replay_failed`, `failed_retention` | Задержки 0.722422/1.010937/2.240832/4.845013 с; DLQ +1; replay failed→ready, ready→noop, после retention→expired | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | | 4: S3→COMMIT→ack, lease/fencing, cleanup | `crash_after_s3_before_commit`, `crash_after_commit_before_ack`, `lease_expiry_fencing` | Exit 137 в заданных окнах; один набор вариантов; старая аренда fenced; staging ready очищен | [level4.json](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json) | @@ -125,7 +125,7 @@ Python 3.14, FastAPI, gunicorn/uvicorn-worker, dishka и dishka-faststream, pyda | `retry_exhausted` / `replay_failed` | Fault-injection, контейнеры не требуется останавливать | 5 попыток → failed; явный replay → ready, повтор → noop | Сценарии 17.6 / 28.4 с; failed — ожидаемый исход, не потерянная job | | `worker_limits` | Worker остаётся running | 40 Мп: принудительные время/память → failed; штатный режим → ready | 15.4 с на сценарий; ошибок процесса worker не зафиксировано | -Последняя сохранённая остановка своего стенда: `make down` без `-v`, затем пустой список контейнеров project и четыре сохранённых volume — [down.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/down.txt), [stopped-containers.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/stopped-containers.txt), [retained-volumes.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/retained-volumes.txt). На этапе отчёта Docker не вызывался, новое состояние стенда не измерялось. +Историческая остановка стенда D: `make down` без `-v`, затем пустой список контейнеров project и четыре сохранённых volume — [down.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/down.txt), [stopped-containers.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/stopped-containers.txt), [retained-volumes.txt](evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/retained-volumes.txt). В финальной validation стенд снова остановлен без `-v`; контейнеров project нет, четыре volume сохранены — [down](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt), [проверка](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt), [volumes](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt). ## Трек 2: гипотеза, методика и числа @@ -174,13 +174,28 @@ Python 3.14, FastAPI, gunicorn/uvicorn-worker, dishka и dishka-faststream, pyda `openspec/config.yaml` проверен, но не изменён: разрешённый scope отчётной фазы исключает конфиги и OpenSpec. Он уже содержит SQLAlchemy/Alembic и контекст ЛР5; в унаследованном правиле design осталось `201` для PostgreSQL+S3. Для upload ЛР5 нормативен `202` после staging и COMMIT, как в `contracts/`. Эта документационная неточность не меняет HTTP-реализацию. -**Обязательное продолжение финальной фазы, ещё не PASS:** +## Финальная validation V: результат и оставшееся исправление -1. Применить `delivery-limit=-1` на RabbitMQ 4.1.8 с сохранённым volume, зафиксировать эффективную policy и исходную DLQ; выполнить real-broker тесты. После опубликованного outbox вызвать настоящий отказ своего PostgreSQL, получить более 10 `job.requeued`, восстановить БД и без replay получить ready с прежними job_id/attempt и неизменной DLQ. -2. Через LB проверить tRNS fixtures grayscale 2/4/16 и RGB16 для v1/v2, точного непрозрачного соседа 12346, Adam7/filter=4/EXIF=6, исходные bytes и все варианты. Под Linux проверить новые пути на 40 Мп при штатных 448 MiB/30 с, принудительные ошибки и последующее обычное задание. -3. Адресно повторить затронутые duplicate/reorder/fencing, COMMIT/ack, malformed/DLQ и retry-exhaustion/replay, сохранив команды, контейнеры и инварианты. Область повторов определяется изменившимися путями; старые пригодные серии сохраняются. +Аудит по README, измеренному SHA, diff, конфигурации, ресурсам, dataset, повторам и сырью — [load-validation.md](evidence/load-validation.md). Три пригодных функциональных track2-повтора приняты, вся матрица повторно не запускалась. Изменение только документации не аннулирует эти свидетельства. Новых SLO/throughput-обещаний нет: выбран трек 2. -Точная процедура и fixtures: [первое исправление](evidence/review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md), [глубина PNG tRNS](evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md). Эти проверки выделены финальному агенту и не заменены offline-тестами. Полный `make student-test`, нагрузка и запуск из чистого clone на R в отчётной фазе не выполнялись. После адресного подтверждения уровней 3/4 и актуальности трека можно заявить полное подтверждение «5»; сейчас это целевая оценка. +| Проверка на V | Реальный результат | Доказательство | +| --- | --- | --- | +| `make check validate lint`, OpenSpec | PASS; 22 спецификации, changes=[] | [checks](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt), [OpenSpec](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt) | +| Сборка и публичный `make test` | PASS; образ содержит reviewed images.py, версии закреплены | [build](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt), [runtime](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/image-runtime.txt), [smoke](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt) | +| Policy на существующем volume и реальная остановка PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL `9f62ea9d176b` exited; 12 `job.requeued`; без replay ready с той же job и attempt=1; DLQ осталась 15; 8 инвариантов PASS | [команда](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt), [JSON](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json) | +| tRNS HTTP v1/v2, exact neighbor, Adam7/filter/EXIF | 8 изображений, 48 побайтных сравнений вариантов с независимым белым эталоном; исходник, metadata/hash/размеры, stale/duplicate noop; 8 инвариантов PASS | [команда](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt), [JSON](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json) | +| Адресные duplicate/reorder/fencing, COMMIT/ack, malformed/DLQ, exhaustion/replay | 12 сценариев, 8 инвариантов PASS, 11 ID / 47 объектов; одна ожидаемая новая DLQ от malformed | [команда](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt), [JSON](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json) | +| PNG tRNS 8000×5000 при 448 MiB / 30 с | **4 FAIL**: grayscale 2/4/16 и RGB16 получили 202 → failed/processing_failed, attempt=1. Штатный ready-сценарий не пройден | [команда](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt), [JSON](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json), [fixtures](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures) | +| Принудительные timeout/memory и последующее обычное задание | PASS; worker остаётся жив, обычное задание ready. Это не отменяет четыре FAIL выше | [png-limits.json](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json) | +| Повторная read-only сверка после staging sweep | PASS; нет pending outbox/staging/nonterminal/дублей, 10 объектов совпали с БД для 7 ID. Исходный ранний no_orphans FAIL сохранён | [cleanup-recheck](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json) | + +**Major:** объявленный [OpenSpec-сценарий PNG на пределе пикселей](openspec/specs/lab5-image-variants/spec.md) требует ready при штатных пределах. Новые 40 Мп tRNS fixtures размером 35 759–385 445 байт его не проходят. [Linux-пробник с импортами worker](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt) воспроизводит MemoryError в `images.py`: grayscale 2/4 — белый RGB-фон, grayscale16 — `I → L`, RGB16 — маски/повторное декодирование. Без tRNS gray2/gray4/RGB16 проходят; gray16 превышает память и без tRNS. Это провал конкретного граничного сценария; потери данных или падение сервиса не обнаружены. + +Требуется отдельный fix-агент: уложить обработку в ресурсную модель, сохранить точность tRNS и пройти review. Затем повторить только затронутые PNG/ресурсные проверки и сценарии, которые затронет фактический diff. В этой фазе реализация, конфигурация и OpenSpec не менялись. [Findings](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json): один новый major, пять прежних minor и одна документационная неточность. + +Первый outage-прогон невалиден: `docker compose start worker` автоматически запустил БД; повторён только этот сценарий с точным container ID. Первая передача пробника через docker cp отклонена read-only rootfs, затем использован stdin/tmpfs. Эти ошибки обвязки и ранний cleanup FAIL сохранены отдельно и не объявлены успехом. Все команды, условия, ограничения и остановка — [RESULTS](evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md). + +Запуск из чистого clone и отдельная throughput-матрица на V не выполнялись. Полный student-test, HTTP и реальный брокер выполнены. Публикация до fix/re-review и завершения адресной validation не готова; push и Telegram не выполнялись. ## Вопросы защиты @@ -189,6 +204,6 @@ Python 3.14, FastAPI, gunicorn/uvicorn-worker, dishka и dishka-faststream, pyda - **Почему дубль безопасен?** Job/версия идентифицируются в БД, lease сериализует работу, fencing отвергает старого держателя, уникальный ключ эффекта защищает варианты. - **Как отличить долгую работу от смерти?** Живая работа продлевает lease; истёкшую восстанавливает relay. Поздняя фиксация не проходит lease_token. - **Почему v1 не затирает v2?** Versioned ключи и условие монотонного published_version; ready v1 остаётся доступной до успешной публикации v2. -- **Что ещё не доказано?** Потеря confirm, все сбои диска/сети, производительность под изолированной нагрузкой и перечисленные динамические проверки последних исправлений. +- **Что ещё не доказано?** Потеря confirm, все сбои диска/сети, производительность под изолированной нагрузкой. Граничные 40 Мп tRNS на штатной памяти проверены и не прошли, поэтому готовность к публикации не заявляется. Документация сверена через Context7: [SQLAlchemy 2.0.45 async](https://github.com/sqlalchemy/sqlalchemy/blob/rel_2_0_45/doc/build/orm/extensions/asyncio.rst), [Alembic 1.16.5 async migrations](https://github.com/sqlalchemy/alembic/blob/rel_1_16_5/docs/build/cookbook.rst), [FastStream 0.7.2 manual ack](https://github.com/ag2ai/faststream/blob/0.7.2/docs/docs/en/getting-started/acknowledgement.md). API 0.7.2 сопоставлен с используемым FastStream 0.7.8; прикладной порядок COMMIT/ack проверяется кодом и evidence, а не одной документацией. diff --git a/evidence/README.md b/evidence/README.md index 91d5414..1fccc0c 100644 --- a/evidence/README.md +++ b/evidence/README.md @@ -1,11 +1,12 @@ # Индекс доказательств ЛР5 -Актуальный [REPORT.md](../REPORT.md) подготовлен после успешного повторного ревью кода **42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91 (R)**. Последние полные динамические серии относятся к **0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc (D)**. Они не являются прогоном R: после них изменены renderer PNG и policy RabbitMQ. Проверки новых путей через HTTP, реальный отказ БД с >10 nack и Linux-лимиты остаются финальной фазе. Цель «5» не подменяет их выполнение. +Актуальный [REPORT.md](../REPORT.md) подготовлен после успешного повторного ревью кода **42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91 (R)**. Последние полные динамические серии относятся к **0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc (D)**. Они не являются прогоном R: после них изменены renderer PNG и policy RabbitMQ. Финальная validation на `b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef` (V, runtime = R) проверила HTTP tRNS, реальный отказ БД с 12 requeue и адресные delivery-сценарии. **Новый major:** четыре 40 Мп tRNS PNG не достигают ready при штатной памяти. Validation заблокирована до fix/re-review; цель «5» не подменяет эти FAIL. Аудит применимости — [load-validation.md](load-validation.md), новые результаты — [RESULTS](final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md). ## Как читать каталог | Файлы / каталог | Код и роль доказательства | Применимость | | --- | --- | --- | +| [Финальная validation](final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md), [аудит нагрузки](load-validation.md) | V, runtime = R | 980 tests, HTTP PNG и real DB outage; 12 адресных сценариев PASS; четыре 40 Мп PNG FAIL, один major; полный track2 не повторён | | [Аудит отчёта](report-audit-2026-11-07.md) | R + изменения документации, 2026-11-07 | Реальные лёгкие проверки этого этапа, ссылки, хеши, арифметика; без Docker и новых динамических тестов | | [forward-final-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md](forward-final-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) | D, полная динамическая квалификация после поздних исправлений ЛР4 | Основная измеренная база: 819 passed / 1 skip, smoke/persistence/failover, уровень 4 и три повтора трека 2; до исправлений R | | [review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md](review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) | R, исправление глубины PNG tRNS | 430 unit + 20 границ, 114 совместимых вариантов, fixtures и 34 хеша; offline, не Linux/HTTP-квалификация | @@ -37,6 +38,6 @@ - `forward-final-2026-11-06/baseline.txt` — 0 тестов; `baseline-regressions.txt` — ожидаемые 29 FAIL до исправления. `review-fixes-2026-11-06/regressions-fixture-error.txt` — неуспешная промежуточная fixture; `review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/regressions-before.txt` — воспроизведённый дефект. Их сохраняют как диагностику, не суммируют с PASS. - [findings.json](review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/findings.json) содержит пять minor: окно confirm, limits, legacy reconcile, отдельный replay failed v2 и часы. Дополнительная документационная неточность `201` в `openspec/config.yaml` отражена в REPORT; конфиг этой фазе менять запрещено. -Нагрузочных RPS/p95 для R здесь не заявлено. Финальный агент повторяет только отсутствующие/затронутые/непригодные серии и сохраняет пригодные результаты. Необходимые адресные сценарии — разделы «Обязательные проверки финального этапа» в [PNG](review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) и [доставке](review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md). +Нагрузочных RPS/p95 для R здесь не заявлено. Финальный агент выполнил только отсутствующие/затронутые проверки и сохранил пригодные серии. После fix повторяются только затронутые PNG/ресурсные проверки по новому diff. Исходное назначение адресных сценариев — разделы «Обязательные проверки финального этапа» в [PNG](review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md) и [доставке](review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md). Сохранять только обезличенные команды, exit codes, SHA, условия и агрегаты. Секреты, `.env`, credentials, session tokens/cookies, реальные сообщения, дампы и signed URLs в evidence не входят. Существующие сырые измерения в отчётной фазе неизменны. diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0fe665a --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +# Финальная validation ЛР5 + +Измерен HEAD `b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef`; runtime совпадает с прошедшим review `42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91`. Изменяются только документы и evidence. Полные три повтора трека 2 не запускались заново: применимость и первичные хеши проверены в [аудите](../load-validation.md), [audit.json](audit.json) и [historical-hashes.json](historical-hashes.json). + +## Условия + +Дата каталога — 2026-11-07 Europe/Moscow; сырые UTC-метки начинаются 2026-11-06T21:15. Darwin arm64, Docker 28.3.2, Linux VM 16 CPU / 8 217 190 400 байт RAM. Основной project `mtusi2026lab5` изолирован собственными сетями и четырьмя сохранёнными volumes. HTTP 18085, stats 25085, broker UI 25086, только loopback. Чужие контейнеры не запускались и не останавливались. + +Сборка и начальные функциональные проверки частично совпали по времени с собственным `make student-test` (его одноразовые контейнеры отражены в `postgres-outage*.json`). Перед HTTP PNG и проверками памяти student-test завершился, посторонних работающих Docker-контейнеров нет. Нагрузка хоста фиксируется срезами, непрерывного контроля CPU нет; RPS, p95 и новые SLO не заявляются. + +Точные лимиты, image IDs и volumes — [runtime-containers.json](runtime-containers.json). Worker 2 CPU / 1 GiB, render 448 MiB / 30 с, concurrency=2; API ×2 по 1 CPU / 512 MiB. Реальные версии и хеш установленного images.py — [image-runtime.txt](image-runtime.txt). Конфигурация запуска — [env.sh](env.sh), без секретов. Fault-suite использует штатный `infra/compose.faults.yaml` и восстанавливает настройки. + +## Выполнено + +Все `.txt` содержат команду, исходный SHA, UTC и exit code. Команды выполняются из корня после `source evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh`. + +| Команда / файл | Наблюдение | +| --- | --- | +| `make check validate lint`, [checks.txt](checks.txt) | PASS | +| `make student-test PYTEST_ARGS='-q --tb=short'`, [student-test.txt](student-test.txt) | 980 passed, 1 Linux-only skip, 19 stack deselected; real-broker тесты включены | +| `openspec validate --all --strict`; `openspec list --json`, [openspec.txt](openspec.txt), [active-changes.txt](active-changes.txt) | 22 PASS, активных changes нет; новый change не создаётся для docs/evidence | +| `docker compose build`; `docker compose up -d --wait`, [build.txt](build.txt), [up.txt](up.txt) | PASS; сохранённые volumes, без удаления очередей/данных | +| `make test`, [smoke.txt](smoke.txt) | Публичный HTTP smoke PASS | +| `rabbitmqctl list_policies/list_queues`, [policy.txt](policy.txt), [queues.txt](queues.txt) | Эффективная policy `delivery-limit=-1` на существующей quorum queue; исходная DLQ=15 | +| `.venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py postgres-outage-retry`, [команда](postgres-outage-retry.txt), [результат](postgres-outage-retry.json), [сырые requeue](postgres-outage-worker.log) | PASS: настоящий PostgreSQL exited, 12 `job.requeued`, затем ready без replay; job_id и attempt=1 сохранены, три варианта, DLQ=15; 8 инвариантов PASS | +| `targeted.py png-http`, [команда](png-http.txt), [результат](png-http.json) | 8 PNG × v1/v2 × 3 варианта = 48 побайтных сравнений с независимым белым эталоном PASS; оригиналы неизменны, metadata/hash/геометрия, удаление EXIF, stale/duplicate noop; 8 инвариантов PASS | +| `pipeline_suite.py --only …`, [команда](delivery-targeted.txt), [результат](delivery-targeted.json) | 12 адресных сценариев и 8 инвариантов PASS; 11 ID, 47 S3-объектов. DLQ 15 → 16 только от ожидаемого malformed message | +| `targeted.py png-limits`, [команда](png-limits.txt), [результат](png-limits.json) | Четыре FAIL для 40 Мп tRNS при штатных пределах; принудительные timeout/memory и последующее обычное задание PASS. Не переименовывать весь запуск в PASS | + +PNG HTTP включает grayscale 1/2/4/8/16, RGB8/16, точного непрозрачного соседа 12346 и RGB16 с Adam7/filter=4/EXIF=6. Новые синтетические 40 Мп fixtures сохранены в [fixtures](fixtures); генератор — `large_png` в [targeted.py](targeted.py). + +Policy сверена через Context7 `/rabbitmq/rabbitmq-website`; точная семантика 4.1 дополнительно проверена по [RabbitMQ 4.1](https://www.rabbitmq.com/docs/4.1/quorum-queues#poison-message-handling). Динамическое доказательство относится именно к RabbitMQ 4.1.8, а не к изменённой семантике nack в 4.3. + +## Непригодные промежуточные проверки + +Первый [postgres-outage.txt](postgres-outage.txt) имеет exit 1: `docker compose start worker` запустил зависимости, включая PostgreSQL, поэтому 12 ошибок не возникли. Это ошибка новой проверочной обвязки, а не дефект приложения. Исходная обвязка сохранена в [targeted-initial.py](targeted-initial.py). Повторён только этот сценарий с `docker start` точного ID своего worker; никаких старых пригодных серий не повторялось. + +В `png-limits.json` проверка `no_orphans` выполнена до очередного штатного sweep: после последнего ready ещё оставался staging. Остальные семь инвариантов PASS. Read-only [cleanup-recheck](cleanup-recheck.txt) после sweep подтвердил отсутствие pending outbox/staging/nonterminal/дублей и точное совпадение 10 объектов S3 с БД для семи ID. Тяжёлые PNG не повторялись; исходный `no_orphans FAIL` не переписан. + +## Незавершённая квалификация + +Четыре валидных PNG 8000×5000 с tRNS приняты с 202, но дали failed/processing_failed на первой попытке. Worker жив, последующая обычная загрузка ready. **Major: не выполнен объявленный сценарий «Изображение на пределе пикселей» [OpenSpec](../../openspec/specs/lab5-image-variants/spec.md): PNG 8000×5000 при штатных пределах должен дать ready.** Это вывод о конкретном граничном сценарии, не заявление о потере данных или падении сервиса. Полное подтверждение «5» и готовность к публикации блокируются до отдельного fix/re-review. Реализация не менялась. + +Пять прежних minor и документационная неточность `201` в openspec/config.yaml сохраняются в REPORT. Публикация и Telegram не выполнялись. + + +[resource-probe-worker.txt](resource-probe-worker.txt) воспроизводит `MemoryError` при 448 MiB и загруженных модулях worker: grayscale 2/4 — `flatten` при выделении белого RGB-фона, grayscale16 — преобразование `I → L`, RGB16 — маски/повторное декодирование в `apply_png_transparency`. Без tRNS gray2/gray4/RGB16 обрабатываются, gray16 всё ещё превышает предел. В облегчённом процессе без импортов worker [resource-probe-retry.txt](resource-probe-retry.txt) проходит grayscale, но падает RGB16: такой изолированный результат не заменяет HTTP-проверку реального worker. RSS пробника — наблюдение процесса, а ограничение — виртуальное адресное пространство RLIMIT_AS. + +При штатном HTTP-прогоне peak контейнера составил 640 196 608 байт < 1 GiB; `MemoryError` возникает внутри ограниченного дочернего процесса. Увеличение лимита без учёта concurrency=2 и памяти worker не считается готовым решением. После исправления нужны ресурсная проверка новых PNG, отсутствие поломки точного tRNS и целевые регрессии. Полную принятую track2-матрицу повторять без нового основания не требуется. + +Первая попытка скопировать диагностические fixtures через `docker compose cp` отклонена read-only rootfs (`probe-copy-*.txt`), последующий запуск отсутствующего файла завершился exit 2 (`resource-probe.txt`). Затем [invoke-probe.py](invoke-probe.py) передал только синтетические fixtures и код через stdin, записал их в разрешённый tmpfs `/tmp` и выполнил пробник. Эти ошибки обвязки не скрыты и не названы тестовыми PASS. + +## Завершение и передача + +Итог — **1 major, 6 сохранённых minor**, [findings.json](findings.json). Фаза validation заблокирована граничной обработкой PNG; назначенный агент должен исправить реализацию через OpenSpec и пройти review. В этой фазе новых изменений реализации/конфигурации/OpenSpec нет. Check/validate/lint, полный student-test и остальные адресные результаты сохраняются для аудита применимости, не становятся автоматически недействительными после документационного коммита. + +`make down` без `-v` выполнен: [down.txt](down.txt), [stopped-containers.txt](stopped-containers.txt); контейнеров своего project нет. Четыре постоянных volume сохранены — [retained-volumes.txt](retained-volumes.txt). Итоговый список работающих Docker-контейнеров пуст — [running-containers-after.txt](running-containers-after.txt). Фоновых агентов и процессов этап не оставил. Push и Telegram не выполнялись. + + +Финальные `make check validate lint` — PASS ([checks-final.txt](checks-final.txt)); новый код evidence разобран Python AST. Проверены локальные ссылки и совпадение runtime с review, нормативных файлов со skeleton ([final-doc-audit.json](final-doc-audit.json)). Проверка tracked файлов и новых evidence по восьми шаблонам секретов не обнаружила реальных credentials; семь совпадений проверены как skeleton placeholders/тестовые значения ([secret-scan.json](secret-scan.json)). Это проверка содержимого, без чтения `.env` и `secrets/`. Концевые пробелы в новых текстовых логах нормализованы; результаты/значения не изменены, историческое сырьё не редактировалось. diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/active-changes.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/active-changes.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f15821d --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/active-changes.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:15:54Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {} +$ openspec list --json +{ + "changes": [], + "root": { + "path": "", + "source": "nearest" + } +} +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.794 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d57aecc --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json @@ -0,0 +1,142 @@ +{ + "head": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "review_runtime_equal": true, + "runtime_diff_from_D": [ + "infra/rabbitmq/definitions.json", + "src/messenger/attachments/infrastructure/images.py" + ], + "platform": "macOS-15.1-arm64-arm-64bit-Mach-O", + "host_load": [ + 3.61962890625, + 2.6328125, + 2.22509765625 + ], + "docker": "28.3.2 16 8217190400", + "retained_volumes": [ + "mtusi2026lab5_broker-data", + "mtusi2026lab5_pgdata", + "mtusi2026lab5_s3data", + "mtusi2026lab5_valkeydata" + ], + "series": [ + { + "name": "level4", + "source_sha": "0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc", + "scenarios": 17, + "invariants": 8, + "accepted": 33, + "config": { + "base_url": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", + "level": 4, + "only": "", + "expect_variants": "thumbnail,crop,optimized", + "max_attempts": 5, + "stall_seconds": 15.0, + "compose": "docker compose", + "compose_faults": "docker compose -f compose.yaml -f infra/compose.faults.yaml" + } + }, + { + "name": "track-run1", + "source_sha": "0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc", + "scenarios": 13, + "invariants": 8, + "accepted": 13, + "config": { + "base_url": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", + "level": 5, + "only": "smoke_pipeline,duplicate_after_ready,crash_commit_publish,crash_publish_confirm,crash_after_s3_before_commit,crash_after_commit_before_ack,lease_expiry_fencing,crash_before_side_effect,worker_kill_mid_task,duplicate_in_flight,reorder_attempts,reorder_versions,stale_after_new_version", + "expect_variants": "thumbnail,crop,optimized", + "max_attempts": 5, + "stall_seconds": 15.0, + "compose": "docker compose", + "compose_faults": "docker compose -f compose.yaml -f infra/compose.faults.yaml" + } + }, + { + "name": "track-run2", + "source_sha": "0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc", + "scenarios": 13, + "invariants": 8, + "accepted": 13, + "config": { + "base_url": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", + "level": 5, + "only": "smoke_pipeline,duplicate_after_ready,crash_commit_publish,crash_publish_confirm,crash_after_s3_before_commit,crash_after_commit_before_ack,lease_expiry_fencing,crash_before_side_effect,worker_kill_mid_task,duplicate_in_flight,reorder_attempts,reorder_versions,stale_after_new_version", + "expect_variants": "thumbnail,crop,optimized", + "max_attempts": 5, + "stall_seconds": 15.0, + "compose": "docker compose", + "compose_faults": "docker compose -f compose.yaml -f infra/compose.faults.yaml" + } + }, + { + "name": "track-run3", + "source_sha": "0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc", + "scenarios": 13, + "invariants": 8, + "accepted": 13, + "config": { + "base_url": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", + "level": 5, + "only": "smoke_pipeline,duplicate_after_ready,crash_commit_publish,crash_publish_confirm,crash_after_s3_before_commit,crash_after_commit_before_ack,lease_expiry_fencing,crash_before_side_effect,worker_kill_mid_task,duplicate_in_flight,reorder_attempts,reorder_versions,stale_after_new_version", + "expect_variants": "thumbnail,crop,optimized", + "max_attempts": 5, + "stall_seconds": 15.0, + "compose": "docker compose", + "compose_faults": "docker compose -f compose.yaml -f infra/compose.faults.yaml" + } + } + ], + "evidence_sha256": { + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/upload-negative.txt": "6cb7ad695b0715a2865e81d113bff729bf98d106a29c419e2ff16f7ee067c4b8", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/baseline.txt": "f6520adb750693e1c7ad31cdad2d1de327a302d15a17a763a035f35ea5b759f5", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/student-test.txt": "2976f98e550a14ee2c385f8a1b34a37626fdc602dfc6f848fbf81b0f105834fc", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/summary.json": "406cea849c5a294a7a744e18056ed54a554cccdf3f5b1133d580ea67cdc1a57f", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.json": "5e90e87bcbf43115df39a37b95f50141772d92e3005f445e1a0c9b5d04050ad0", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/baseline-regressions.txt": "b0525cea37ce47958dc95e02866c1f014239a6cc8500cf76bf448d2b4f1423c9", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-level4-middle.json": "677c0e3499a45daf06cc5bc6f46338ceb873f4203ae137b8cb1c9606f13538eb", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/lint-runtime.txt": "5e3c5752c468b6f747e4dbafd91954660f8b80f820b63ff34704641e7d5db970", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/final-containers.txt": "e2ea3d831281e9cc6cc9b03ea1f00172e4eda23fb7244b8d9b60f7d211b5ec64", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/down.txt": "9dbe77c3dc7b1a17798bd117fd1c8b4cb9ab01a6122376ca5ab38d147ac7b9ff", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/stopped-containers.txt": "f7ac8e8c29b18a83193a089a2dd75aa0dfc103e54173e2421b853c00a0113338", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/unit-regressions.txt": "26d5cf96bdf415c5b17fe2a596b9228834995418b1b33a83c146f59617debc5a", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.txt": "7966b1f45232223055f58b0031a6eeee987d42d5789798ec17df711f40c207ac", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.txt": "4b8254db242784c6db3a0db7a8e363269a1aa486a1b26caaee254100f1ab0a52", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/source-inventory.json": "8977c7883b08b4a2ce7385ddf1c8da11bb4344e586dc71ba637118fcf9d8f506", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-stopped.json": "5ed4cc9e6c6969cd16b699a24ac747c7b4ee4c8b189be2f57cd610622891f00d", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/forward-audit.json": "675a9fcf1fb817bb043c8bcde35079617294da9c7832a529c4d7bfa2adc8f52d", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-before.json": "4ef9320729dc38a49b7e8dc3338a862fd69946ceaf64b4aed004bc6ac23ab1cc", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.txt": "1ff4b753ab5627ee5393977203d5dc83f59d4c9e990e7171fc63a06061ceecb3", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4-command.txt": "2b9e49afc9e9ec0e8a8f2a3c491906b72c7439b4a2e30ff6ed0a96d9be4c73ed", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json": "904e2c40a6737947b1867c9051a36920c007f49ad59de057a168c1dcc345d87c", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/archive.txt": "54bc70e53d69969580bd0c88f373778f2a029e2329bbccac7844ff16055deceb", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-after1.json": "65e7d5a4652e102e6ad8ecbf74356b1c468e2d5ddaee492af21432d646aa4bdf", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/up.txt": "0baaa49727722eaf24ac4d8b3e083c09bbb53e278e557e42551221d0c59e5856", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/checks-before-commit.txt": "1b8bd42a69e070cffb07e12449ec749066ec92407fa5d94bd8ad766f40d93dff", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/checks-final.txt": "d0d3a9f7a24914365c772eabceb4ad2238c5922e30c866a26c5274f8fb570e81", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/failover.txt": "fcd1b67b77aa7936f9f0ae1c48982e9e4ad9f2e8b9705d2b856ff8cf360fdaa9", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence-containers.txt": "229bf4c9809cf0e6a1d9cfd162949b413d7f990f57a30fbcd5f9c5b6e3f81e92", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-start.json": "64e99f2110c3ccf029fba7fe30bd1c9f01615cb5b43ffd77fe4a0f09e7030245", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/final-smoke.txt": "eec6f2507465824cd920fe78bf876dfbf8b905e84ebcd7b9d51e80d16d4c064b", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/findings.json": "2f0db619bebbc615dc33f78599210201e1d9441139adb33687dea7a46fc1f15b", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/network-regressions.txt": "30f0735c6d0bd2370cf39ac6855c06750ba18b282b978dcf6dddcf293145e02b", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-after2.json": "fa3a1808cc215afb3a422fe582c2d4cae5cf480411f4150977be30f9e24bf462", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-after3.json": "1054464f5526ee719579fbda81b9e7605a97a660fec9bdfc52f6e68ce94cfad1", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/specs-validation.txt": "79fe9fdb0bb258d6d7788a79d96587b748233001e97f2acd38bf9bfe0376d515", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/cache-outage.txt": "fbe1eb591256b35a93a8fd3f4fb299caf22f57159f0b68c984f7c75e5e8be9fc", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/failover-containers.txt": "4468a88f349073027fb07b2c81406e480e1b503b64fb828e58ecee688d7b2091", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/clock-observation.json": "d7ae11b8c7970cc71775f46fa0a1474e113da4cae9229d8f28bf85312dd8acc4", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-level4-start.json": "0cb8a9314b3afd4704c762b1b611f80beb9f30795475642ad2a22452f87993c0", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/images.txt": "adb50435b1c24cc0deb913c49ed19e3fdd4287b73719d418accad013ebb7489d", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/retained-volumes.txt": "ef4b62f79ed1cd0dc1e7313d65873c6a6ab35ff933bd8673a3431d3df5691449", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/openspec-final.txt": "a34016edea7844300b98aaf38e713df8b4b217924b515881b33a599cd1603b24", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.json": "d190b7a1b4962c520d46931dc63601ed2655f1b4063bc7fea01b78b049a0bede", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/source-name-status.txt": "81abf426ff31f0253a5ced9ae43fdbbf2a56460afe7b5d299a32c6f664196b93", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/haproxy-errors.txt": "bf3b0b33f997fefc542860389e8a0fcc1856bbb17cd25b6103911610e87806a3", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence.txt": "06574967e1dab9742841d54cabb7b0109aa063316e08c8db5525234f084f92de", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/smoke.txt": "709ddeeb3aa1c4e0b516d4b66038b0421929ee519665d79feccc907cc7bc89ac", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/restore.txt": "96805ba0f8cba25cb90f385809d0a0a6c75b468a25f87006d729fedc51759c7d", + "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.json": "16fe12bd42f958a0d4962182da65bd4ee69e4b896fbce47daea724b0a1c618e8" + } +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cb0c4ea --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt @@ -0,0 +1,90 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:16:11Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose build +#1 [internal] load local bake definitions +#1 reading from stdin 434B done +#1 DONE 0.0s + +#2 [internal] load build definition from Dockerfile +#2 transferring dockerfile: 1.65kB done +#2 DONE 0.0s + +#3 [internal] load metadata for ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:0.9.7@sha256:ba4857bf2a068e9bc0e64eed8563b065908a4cd6bfb66b531a9c424c8e25e142 +#3 DONE 0.0s + +#4 [internal] load metadata for docker.io/library/python:3.14-slim-trixie@sha256:51dafde81dbdb6ebde285137a295cf18a47ca95234fe388a343719cb97305b3d +#4 DONE 1.7s + +#5 [internal] load .dockerignore +#5 transferring context: 453B done +#5 DONE 0.0s + +#6 FROM ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:0.9.7@sha256:ba4857bf2a068e9bc0e64eed8563b065908a4cd6bfb66b531a9c424c8e25e142 +#6 resolve ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:0.9.7@sha256:ba4857bf2a068e9bc0e64eed8563b065908a4cd6bfb66b531a9c424c8e25e142 0.0s done +#6 DONE 0.0s + +#7 [builder 1/7] FROM docker.io/library/python:3.14-slim-trixie@sha256:51dafde81dbdb6ebde285137a295cf18a47ca95234fe388a343719cb97305b3d +#7 resolve docker.io/library/python:3.14-slim-trixie@sha256:51dafde81dbdb6ebde285137a295cf18a47ca95234fe388a343719cb97305b3d 0.0s done +#7 DONE 0.0s + +#8 [internal] load build context +#8 transferring context: 51.62kB 0.0s done +#8 DONE 0.0s + +#9 [builder 2/7] COPY --from=ghcr.io/astral-sh/uv:0.9.7@sha256:ba4857bf2a068e9bc0e64eed8563b065908a4cd6bfb66b531a9c424c8e25e142 /uv /usr/local/bin/uv +#9 CACHED + +#10 [builder 4/7] COPY pyproject.toml uv.lock README.md ./ +#10 CACHED + +#11 [builder 3/7] WORKDIR /build +#11 CACHED + +#12 [builder 5/7] RUN uv sync --locked --no-dev --no-install-project --no-editable +#12 CACHED + +#13 [builder 6/7] COPY src ./src +#13 DONE 0.1s + +#14 [builder 7/7] RUN uv sync --locked --no-dev --no-editable +#14 0.280 Resolved 84 packages in 12ms +#14 0.309 Building mtusi-messenger @ file:///build +#14 1.851 Built mtusi-messenger @ file:///build +#14 1.855 Prepared 1 package in 1.54s +#14 1.859 Installed 1 package in 3ms +#14 2.080 Bytecode compiled 2301 files in 221ms +#14 2.080 + mtusi-messenger==1.5.0 (from file:///build) +#14 DONE 2.1s + +#15 [runtime 2/6] RUN groupadd --system --gid 10001 messenger && useradd --system --uid 10001 --gid messenger --no-create-home --shell /usr/sbin/nologin messenger +#15 CACHED + +#16 [runtime 3/6] COPY --from=builder --chown=root:root /opt/venv /opt/venv +#16 DONE 0.4s + +#17 [runtime 4/6] WORKDIR /app +#17 DONE 0.0s + +#18 [runtime 5/6] COPY --chown=root:root alembic.ini ./ +#18 DONE 0.0s + +#19 [runtime 6/6] COPY --chown=root:root alembic ./alembic +#19 DONE 0.0s + +#20 exporting to image +#20 exporting layers +#20 exporting layers 3.0s done +#20 exporting manifest sha256:5fa47645c125c166f4f83308eeda33e4679510f9548cae36141b4bcff1bec3cb +#20 exporting manifest sha256:5fa47645c125c166f4f83308eeda33e4679510f9548cae36141b4bcff1bec3cb done +#20 exporting config sha256:34e5f914cd69e5cff0b7745f9730b4d63d0a62480ef53de7b18914787a51c828 done +#20 exporting attestation manifest sha256:043b67091fa616197172d98abd054f1cd803a4b540ceb0bc4a8e30232d37359d done +#20 exporting manifest list sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2 done +#20 naming to docker.io/library/mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation done +#20 unpacking to docker.io/library/mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation +#20 unpacking to docker.io/library/mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation 0.6s done +#20 DONE 3.6s + +#21 resolving provenance for metadata file +#21 DONE 0.0s + api Built +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 9.093 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks-final.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks-final.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..620fc51 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks-final.txt @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:29:59Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {} +$ make check validate lint +python3 scripts/check_contract.py +PASS: offline skeleton structure, local refs and Python syntax; application NOT tested. +.venv/bin/python scripts/validate_openapi.py +PASS: full OpenAPI 3.1 and JSON Schema validation; application NOT tested. +.venv/bin/ruff check src student-tests scripts/capture_evidence.py alembic scripts/scaling.py tools scripts/probe.py scripts/limits.py scripts/lab4_scenarios.py scripts/lab4_seed.py scripts/upload_memory.py scripts/reconcile_check.py scripts/reconcile_track.py scripts/make_images.py scripts/pipeline_suite.py scripts/pipeline_evidence.py +All checks passed! +.venv/bin/ruff format --check src student-tests scripts/capture_evidence.py alembic scripts/scaling.py tools scripts/probe.py scripts/limits.py scripts/lab4_scenarios.py scripts/lab4_seed.py scripts/upload_memory.py scripts/reconcile_check.py scripts/reconcile_track.py scripts/make_images.py scripts/pipeline_suite.py scripts/pipeline_evidence.py +197 files already formatted +.venv/bin/ty check src student-tests alembic +All checks passed! +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.535 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..30f31ed --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:15:52Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {} +$ make check validate lint +python3 scripts/check_contract.py +PASS: offline skeleton structure, local refs and Python syntax; application NOT tested. +.venv/bin/python scripts/validate_openapi.py +PASS: full OpenAPI 3.1 and JSON Schema validation; application NOT tested. +.venv/bin/ruff check src student-tests scripts/capture_evidence.py alembic scripts/scaling.py tools scripts/probe.py scripts/limits.py scripts/lab4_scenarios.py scripts/lab4_seed.py scripts/upload_memory.py scripts/reconcile_check.py scripts/reconcile_track.py scripts/make_images.py scripts/pipeline_suite.py scripts/pipeline_evidence.py +All checks passed! +.venv/bin/ruff format --check src student-tests scripts/capture_evidence.py alembic scripts/scaling.py tools scripts/probe.py scripts/limits.py scripts/lab4_scenarios.py scripts/lab4_seed.py scripts/upload_memory.py scripts/reconcile_check.py scripts/reconcile_track.py scripts/make_images.py scripts/pipeline_suite.py scripts/pipeline_evidence.py +197 files already formatted +.venv/bin/ty check src student-tests alembic +All checks passed! +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.580 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f7ea877 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +{ + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "at": "2026-11-06T21:26:03.661679Z", + "result": "PASS", + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db", + "01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d", + "01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab", + "01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de", + "01a1b2bc-f161-7119-986f-bc7c8fd99bf0", + "01a1b2bd-0192-70e7-a174-3275ca516e11", + "01a1b2bd-13b0-712a-9275-1d3cdd2eb49a" + ], + "rows": { + "pending_outbox": [], + "staging_left": [], + "nonterminal": [], + "duplicate_effects": [] + }, + "s3_objects": 10, + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 16, + 0 + ] + }, + "reason": "Read-only recheck after scheduled staging sweep; no scenario rerun. Initial no_orphans ran before the sweep." +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f0007fd --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.txt @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:25:54Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ .venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py +{ + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "at": "2026-11-06T21:26:03.661679Z", + "result": "PASS", + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db", + "01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d", + "01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab", + "01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de", + "01a1b2bc-f161-7119-986f-bc7c8fd99bf0", + "01a1b2bd-0192-70e7-a174-3275ca516e11", + "01a1b2bd-13b0-712a-9275-1d3cdd2eb49a" + ], + "rows": { + "pending_outbox": [], + "staging_left": [], + "nonterminal": [], + "duplicate_effects": [] + }, + "s3_objects": 10, + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 16, + 0 + ] + }, + "reason": "Read-only recheck after scheduled staging sweep; no scenario rerun. Initial no_orphans ran before the sweep." +} +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 9.044 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..114a9e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json @@ -0,0 +1,896 @@ +{ + "suite": "lab5-pipeline-idempotency", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:22:22.429392Z", + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "config": { + "base_url": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", + "level": 5, + "only": "duplicate_after_ready,retry_exhausted,crash_commit_publish,crash_after_s3_before_commit,crash_after_commit_before_ack,lease_expiry_fencing,replay_failed,malformed_message_dead_lettered,duplicate_in_flight,reorder_attempts,reorder_versions,stale_after_new_version", + "expect_variants": "thumbnail,crop,optimized", + "max_attempts": 5, + "stall_seconds": 15.0, + "compose": "docker compose", + "compose_faults": "docker compose -f compose.yaml -f infra/compose.faults.yaml" + }, + "invariants": [ + { + "id": "terminal", + "statement": "every 202 reaches its expected terminal state", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 11 + } + }, + { + "id": "single_effect", + "statement": "one variant set per (attachment_id, pipeline_version, variant)", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_ready_rollback", + "statement": "ready never returns to queued or processing", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "traced": 11 + } + }, + { + "id": "monotonic_publication", + "statement": "published_version only moves forward", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "sampled": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "bytes_match_metadata", + "statement": "sha256, size and real dimensions match served bytes", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "verified": 10 + } + }, + { + "id": "bounded_attempts", + "statement": "attempt <= JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_orphans", + "statement": "no pending outbox, messages, dead letters, staging, objects", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 16, + 0 + ] + }, + "s3_objects": 47, + "scoped_attachments": 11 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_lost_202", + "statement": "every 202 is present in PostgreSQL and the API", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 11 + } + } + ], + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bd-dee8-7491-a9c1-90e56c2bb9e4", + "01a1b2bd-fe45-77cf-b9ef-53b5e01c32ac", + "01a1b2be-4b72-71c4-99f1-b93ee6662a6b", + "01a1b2be-6f6f-7200-a261-63dd237e9ec8", + "01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af", + "01a1b2be-c7f7-7326-b272-a341993c5bf9", + "01a1b2bf-47a0-77e8-97ed-907199a6caa7", + "01a1b2bf-b3a8-7754-af89-7d174f4540d1", + "01a1b2bf-ed3f-721d-ae2a-dd55e7ab970d", + "01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5", + "01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d" + ], + "scenarios": [ + { + "name": "duplicate_after_ready", + "level": 3, + "window": "redelivery of a finished job", + "seconds": 4.4, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bd-dee8-7491-a9c1-90e56c2bb9e4", + "events": [ + { + "kind": "enqueued", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "done", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "duplicate_noop", + "attempt": 1 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "retry_exhausted", + "level": 3, + "window": "transient error until JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "seconds": 19.6, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bd-fe45-77cf-b9ef-53b5e01c32ac", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bd-fe54-7252-944d-9d5a09b3019d", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "failed", + "attempt": 5 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "crash_commit_publish", + "level": 4, + "window": "after COMMIT, before publish", + "seconds": 9.2, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2be-4b72-71c4-99f1-b93ee6662a6b", + "exit_code": 137, + "after_crash": { + "outbox_published": false, + "status": "queued", + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 ee568583263a exited Exited (137) 1 second ago" + ] + }, + "variants": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-4b72-71c4-99f1-b93ee6662a6b/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-4b72-71c4-99f1-b93ee6662a6b/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-4b72-71c4-99f1-b93ee6662a6b/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "crash_after_s3_before_commit", + "level": 4, + "window": "after S3 write, before COMMIT", + "seconds": 12.4, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2be-6f6f-7200-a261-63dd237e9ec8", + "exit_code": 137, + "after_crash": { + "status": "processing", + "variant_rows": 0, + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 b9de1e78db3d exited Exited (137) Less than a second ago" + ] + }, + "variants": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-6f6f-7200-a261-63dd237e9ec8/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-6f6f-7200-a261-63dd237e9ec8/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-6f6f-7200-a261-63dd237e9ec8/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "crash_after_commit_before_ack", + "level": 4, + "window": "after COMMIT, before ack", + "seconds": 10.3, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af", + "exit_code": 137, + "after_crash": { + "status": "ready", + "variants": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ], + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 b78cddfd65c9 exited Exited (137) 1 second ago" + ] + }, + "variants": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2be-a1dc-76f3-9861-667de097c2af/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "lease_expiry_fencing", + "level": 4, + "window": "stalled worker, lease expiry", + "seconds": 32.7, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2be-c7f7-7326-b272-a341993c5bf9", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2be-c805-75f5-95ab-9aabfea704fb", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "done", + "attempt": 2 + } + ], + "events": [ + { + "kind": "enqueued", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "lease_expired", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "done", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "fenced", + "attempt": 1 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "replay_failed", + "level": 4, + "window": "operator replay", + "seconds": 24.6, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bf-47a0-77e8-97ed-907199a6caa7", + "replay": { + "result": "replayed", + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bf-47a0-77e8-97ed-907199a6caa7", + "operator": "cli" + }, + "replay_of_ready": { + "result": "noop", + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bf-47a0-77e8-97ed-907199a6caa7", + "operator": "cli" + }, + "events": [ + { + "kind": "enqueued", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "retry_scheduled", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "retry_scheduled", + "attempt": 3 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 3 + }, + { + "kind": "retry_scheduled", + "attempt": 4 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 4 + }, + { + "kind": "retry_scheduled", + "attempt": 5 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 5 + }, + { + "kind": "failed", + "attempt": 5 + }, + { + "kind": "replayed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "done", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "replay_noop", + "attempt": 1 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "malformed_message_dead_lettered", + "level": 4, + "window": "message that is not a job goes to the DLQ", + "seconds": 6.5, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "dead_letters": 1 + } + }, + { + "name": "duplicate_in_flight", + "level": 5, + "window": "two copies of one job in flight", + "seconds": 14.7, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bf-b3a8-7754-af89-7d174f4540d1", + "variants": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2bf-b3a8-7754-af89-7d174f4540d1/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2bf-b3a8-7754-af89-7d174f4540d1/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2bf-b3a8-7754-af89-7d174f4540d1/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ], + "events": [ + { + "kind": "enqueued", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "duplicate_noop", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "done", + "attempt": 1 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "reorder_attempts", + "level": 5, + "window": "attempt 2 delivered before attempt 1", + "seconds": 15.1, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bf-ed3f-721d-ae2a-dd55e7ab970d", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bf-ed46-71ef-85b7-54e89e3b1eec", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "done", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "events": [ + { + "kind": "enqueued", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "claimed", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "kind": "duplicate_noop", + "attempt": 2 + }, + { + "kind": "done", + "attempt": 1 + } + ] + } + }, + { + "name": "reorder_versions", + "level": 5, + "window": "v2 delivered before v1", + "seconds": 11.6, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2c0-2874-74f6-b880-6970766e70ee", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "superseded", + "attempt": 1 + }, + { + "job_id": "01a1b2c0-2bd0-748f-9b84-334656652efc", + "pipeline_version": 2, + "status": "done", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "v2_before_v1": { + "status": "ready", + "public": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "width": 128, + "height": 128, + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4" + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "content_type": "image/webp", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "width": 320, + "height": 200, + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957" + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "width": 256, + "height": 160, + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308" + } + ], + "rows": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/crop-5b6fb2a66216f8ca.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/optimized-fe520c978bd45fc8.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/thumbnail-fa0db661078d4da9.jpg" + } + ], + "published": 2 + }, + "after_v1": { + "status": "ready", + "public": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "width": 128, + "height": 128, + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4" + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "content_type": "image/webp", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "width": 320, + "height": 200, + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957" + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "width": 256, + "height": 160, + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308" + } + ], + "rows": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/crop-5b6fb2a66216f8ca.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/optimized-fe520c978bd45fc8.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-286d-77c5-8019-58526f2e09c5/2/thumbnail-fa0db661078d4da9.jpg" + } + ], + "published": 2 + } + } + }, + { + "name": "stale_after_new_version", + "level": 5, + "window": "v1 job after v2 is published", + "seconds": 4.7, + "result": "PASS", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d", + "published_version": 2, + "v1": { + "status": "ready", + "public": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "width": 128, + "height": 128, + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143" + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "content_type": "image/webp", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "width": 320, + "height": 200, + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb" + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "width": 256, + "height": 160, + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594" + } + ], + "rows": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + } + ], + "published": 1 + }, + "v2_before_stale": { + "status": "ready", + "public": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "width": 128, + "height": 128, + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4" + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "content_type": "image/webp", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "width": 320, + "height": 200, + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957" + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "width": 256, + "height": 160, + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308" + } + ], + "rows": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/crop-5b6fb2a66216f8ca.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/optimized-fe520c978bd45fc8.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/thumbnail-fa0db661078d4da9.jpg" + } + ], + "published": 2 + }, + "v2_after_stale": { + "status": "ready", + "public": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "width": 128, + "height": 128, + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4" + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "content_type": "image/webp", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "width": 320, + "height": 200, + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957" + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "content_type": "image/jpeg", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "width": 256, + "height": 160, + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308" + } + ], + "rows": [ + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "97bf1400b30a28c19420a30161c944f57b5e7d613533b76afe6ab2531cba0143", + "size_bytes": 1820, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/crop-97bf1400b30a28c1.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "1090d84ed8411226010ae498b08e1b9e6d81c8eee02ee77143a0dc327b894beb", + "size_bytes": 2462, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/optimized-1090d84ed8411226.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 1, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "7bc40bf315c8e18e907889b23514d978be213a44223d64b737290188ee808594", + "size_bytes": 4679, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/1/thumbnail-7bc40bf315c8e18e.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "5b6fb2a66216f8ca038542acdd8482fca9d1ad79193d60ae74de3989048ec0a4", + "size_bytes": 2142, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/crop-5b6fb2a66216f8ca.jpg" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fe520c978bd45fc8f1b85863dc9dc6fc98954b45d7fe803e8e4c6b681ddc1957", + "size_bytes": 2790, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/optimized-fe520c978bd45fc8.webp" + }, + { + "pipeline_version": 2, + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "fa0db661078d4da91b241edc8b416de7755db9c9c79ae704a620ca7ad534e308", + "size_bytes": 5628, + "object_key": "variants/01a1b2c0-5422-77cd-88f8-cd2c123fe78d/2/thumbnail-fa0db661078d4da9.jpg" + } + ], + "published": 2 + } + } + } + ], + "result": "PASS", + "finished_at": "2026-11-06T21:25:34.062079Z" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c8d4d2a --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:22:22Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ python3 scripts/pipeline_suite.py --only duplicate_after_ready,retry_exhausted,crash_commit_publish,crash_after_s3_before_commit,crash_after_commit_before_ack,lease_expiry_fencing,replay_failed,malformed_message_dead_lettered,duplicate_in_flight,reorder_attempts,reorder_versions,stale_after_new_version --output evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json +RUN duplicate_after_ready +PASS duplicate_after_ready +RUN retry_exhausted +PASS retry_exhausted +RUN crash_commit_publish +PASS crash_commit_publish +RUN crash_after_s3_before_commit +PASS crash_after_s3_before_commit +RUN crash_after_commit_before_ack +PASS crash_after_commit_before_ack +RUN lease_expiry_fencing +PASS lease_expiry_fencing +RUN replay_failed +PASS replay_failed +RUN malformed_message_dead_lettered +PASS malformed_message_dead_lettered +RUN duplicate_in_flight +PASS duplicate_in_flight +RUN reorder_attempts +PASS reorder_attempts +RUN reorder_versions +PASS reorder_versions +RUN stale_after_new_version +PASS stale_after_new_version +PASS: lab5 pipeline suite, report evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 191.693 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..56c02b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt @@ -0,0 +1,53 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:26:59Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ make down +docker compose --profile bench --profile tools --profile reconcile down + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Stopping + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Stopped + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Removing + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Removed + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Removed + Network mtusi2026lab5_backend Removing + Network mtusi2026lab5_edge Removing + Network mtusi2026lab5_backend Removed + Network mtusi2026lab5_edge Removed +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 3.346 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ef863e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +export COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME=mtusi2026lab5 +export COMPOSE_FILE=compose.yaml +export API_IMAGE=mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation +export LB_HTTP_PORT=18085 +export LB_STATS_PORT=25085 +export BROKER_MANAGEMENT_PORT=25086 +export BASE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:18085 +export NO_PROXY=localhost,127.0.0.1,::1 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-containers.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-containers.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cbe315a --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-containers.txt @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:26:59Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose ps -a --format '{{.Name}} {{.ID}} {{.State}} {{.Status}} {{.Ports}}' +mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 10 minutes (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 10 minutes (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 10 minutes (healthy) 127.0.0.1:25086->15672/tcp +mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 10 minutes (healthy) 127.0.0.1:18085->8080/tcp, 127.0.0.1:25085->8404/tcp +mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) 8 minutes ago +mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b running Up 6 minutes (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 297a45d2724b running Up About a minute (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 10 minutes (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) 8 minutes ago +mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 10 minutes (healthy) +mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 c708d0d22a5e running Up About a minute (healthy) +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.136 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-doc-audit.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-doc-audit.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c55342f --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-doc-audit.json @@ -0,0 +1,701 @@ +{ + "runtime_review_equal": true, + "normative_files_equal_skeleton": true, + "new_python_syntax": "PASS", + "allowed_changed_files": 56, + "local_markdown_links": 173, + "links": [ + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/README.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-port.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "uv.lock" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/track2/qualified/runtime.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "compose.yaml" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "src/messenger/shared/infrastructure/postgres.py" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "alembic/env.py" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "alembic/versions" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/report-audit-2026-11-07.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/report-audit-2026-11-07.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/final-smoke.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/failover.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/failover-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/restore.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/queues.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/consumers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/permissions.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4-command.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/network-regressions.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/upload-negative.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/cache-outage.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/haproxy-errors.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/down.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/stopped-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/retained-volumes.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/summary.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-before.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-start.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/clock-observation.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/track2/qualified/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/limits.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/student-test.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/load-validation.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/image-runtime.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "openspec/specs/lab5-image-variants/spec.md" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "REPORT.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "AGENTS.md", + "target": "evidence/README.md" + }, + { + "from": "AGENTS.md", + "target": "REPORT.md" + }, + { + "from": "AGENTS.md", + "target": "evidence/load-validation.md" + }, + { + "from": "AGENTS.md", + "target": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "../REPORT.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "load-validation.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "load-validation.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "report-audit-2026-11-07.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-port.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/source-inventory.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/forward-audit.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/NOTES.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade4/NOTES.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/track2/NOTES.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/track2/qualified/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/level4-command.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/level4.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run1.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run2.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/track-run3.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/summary.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/final-smoke.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/failover.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/persistence-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/failover-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/restore.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/student-test.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/offline-tests.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/boundaries.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-before.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/conditions-track-start.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/down.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/stopped-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/retained-volumes.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/limits.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/clock-observation.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/README.md", + "target": "review-fixes-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/load-validation.md", + "target": "forward-final-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/load-validation.md", + "target": "final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/load-validation.md", + "target": "final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "../load-validation.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "audit.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "historical-hashes.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "runtime-containers.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "image-runtime.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "env.sh" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "checks.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "student-test.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "openspec.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "active-changes.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "build.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "up.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "smoke.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "policy.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "queues.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "postgres-outage-retry.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "postgres-outage-retry.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "postgres-outage-worker.log" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "png-http.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "png-http.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "delivery-targeted.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "delivery-targeted.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "png-limits.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "png-limits.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "fixtures" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "targeted.py" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "postgres-outage.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "targeted-initial.py" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "cleanup-recheck.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "../../openspec/specs/lab5-image-variants/spec.md" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "resource-probe-worker.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "resource-probe-retry.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "invoke-probe.py" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "findings.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "down.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "stopped-containers.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "retained-volumes.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "running-containers-after.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "checks-final.txt" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "final-doc-audit.json" + }, + { + "from": "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md", + "target": "secret-scan.json" + } + ] +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6f81594 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +[ + { + "severity": "major", + "file": "src/messenger/attachments/infrastructure/images.py:95", + "problem": "Не проходит объявленный обязательный сценарий openspec/specs/lab5-image-variants/spec.md:48: PNG 8000×5000 со штатными пределами должен стать ready. Через LB четыре валидных tRNS PNG (grayscale 2/4/16 и RGB16, 35 759–385 445 байт) получают 202, затем failed/processing_failed на attempt=1 при RENDER_MEMORY_MB=448 и timeout=30. Linux-пробник с импортами worker воспроизводит MemoryError в rgb_mask/apply_png_transparency и flatten; без tRNS gray2/gray4/RGB16 проходят, gray16 требует памяти и без tRNS. Worker остаётся жив; потери данных/падение сервиса не заявляются. Доказательства: evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json, resource-probe-worker.txt, fixtures/*.png. Нужен отдельный fix, review и повтор только затронутых PNG/ресурсных проверок." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "src/messenger/attachments/application/pipeline.py:230", + "problem": "Сохранено из ревью 544b9c78d39d0e9dd07f841894c390895896605a: after_publish_before_confirm вызывается после publish(), уже проверившего Basic.Ack. crash_publish_confirm доказывает сбой после confirm до COMMIT outbox, а не потерю подтверждения." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "scripts/limits.py:10", + "problem": "Сохранено из первого ревью: S3_CLIENT_SECRETS не отсортирован, сравнение с sorted(secrets) даёт ложные FAIL. evidence/sqlalchemy-2026-11-06/grade3/limits.txt содержит exit_code=1; этот запуск нельзя обозначать PASS." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "scripts/reconcile_track.py:396", + "problem": "Сохранено из первого ревью: демонстратор ожидает upload 201 и attachments/, поэтому непригоден для квалификации ЛР5 с 202 queued. Текущие pipeline evidence его не используют." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "src/messenger/attachments/application/pipeline.py:333", + "problem": "Сохранено из первого ревью: failed upgrade v2 при опубликованной ready v1 нельзя отдельно повторить через replay/reprocess. V1 остаётся доступной; подтверждение исходного ревью — test_failed_new_version_keeps_ready_original." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "evidence/forward-final-2026-11-06/clock-observation.json", + "problem": "Сохранено из первого ревью: в повторах 2/3 UTC-интервалы расходятся с elapsed (1161.195/186.458 с и 571.513/180.259 с). Причина не установлена; длительности исключены из выводов о производительности." + }, + { + "severity": "minor", + "file": "openspec/config.yaml:130", + "problem": "Сохранена документационная неточность: design требует upload 201 вместо нормативного 202 ЛР5; конфиг вне scope validation." + } +] diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray16-40mp.png b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray16-40mp.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fe7a42f26b87075638bdde4ee95bb363300eec99 GIT binary patch literal 103565 zcmeI5T}WGJ7{{OZQHjKlH5THAmKO2rVjSJo+9_6|TT0MXWmhXCq_CTTgGt?_!NV5B zmC#ZmEEl6ni-q3Eyy`%(p&9CEp*qHNcwxu3Hmr&=t+dv)drxvqgyyoz*!nv+#-x&P zs^|B-&+q@d=d1TS-YqJ8y--AoT<Fes~*52Np|1>I= zk#?8!M9*j6tS+A@ifHovx2=En|5ozxv9e#HjltRn&Bo8EBjUFt9_XQhbBRat_{(>G z%}qRRxvLkO&xUIDUXPW}n?L0FD^Oy-+?0FFeB{2oVZJ=}QA_SA{HY{H+%jYU=b{WMX+dM(ed=GJ4fAON4szR=p zp|?$M`^Db2ki8YMw`6b0-jcl~drS6~>@C?_vbV{bXM#nr2o}L2SOkk;5iF*;JNL`! zs`*wfxKzZ_G4!Or>Draf;h?(DI9&!nkLA_UP1q7y_X zh)xil`7GwM0wwXX2P{eiEP_R_2o}L2SOkk>xrxF6EV36fn@%#AOJg(}jnSb0c(p~u z4xv1BJhy++3AbdWA>w0%iys(1MnCg!((_1kKu7Pd92WbFBE(sz7SuC zFT@w(3-N{cLVO{<5MPKdG<>1s=~;JtzCx}iEogg|v^h6L{ zT@snkVm=Ejf<>?h7QrG|JkY0#0^2EDqGc1QHWSOdv6V!~_x(NK7EH^>!Aw z-uA36H&|5(64jnh%=Tv2jbY94JN7sEP_R_2o}L2SOkk;Q7=x^1@bCmQJ?Icty1T~7Tuky>|UsG zw$~YFr3J%};m7b}_%Zw#ehfc`AH$E~$M7q|A3vBtVgiW?BqorUKw<)k2_zt zhW}PUVqpRn!Qwnv1dCu1EP_R_IB(1)s{<@%9*aLuSA^85)@+;W1Marb((>{6sn7fy z$KQs=D2-7XqclbteWEeS3Xl~bD?nC&|KbYpjUVfNy8Xd}jlYfJ)YaDEoM`oY@ejlH BU`GG| literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray2-40mp.png b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray2-40mp.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6a277d93e31585b1cb7c2bd22d3fe1e718baf6e3 GIT binary patch literal 35759 zcmeI)&nv@m9LMqZ*J{(+_j^%dZE-)!~8m^p|&AKISPv$ z#By+OA=!nCeN!A%8BoR1U_6i8H$RLHasv`F-i^vD1LNP-}tWGER*hLWLV zC>ctIlA&ZM8A^tdp=2l-N`{i5WGER*hLWLVC>ctIlA&ZM8A^tdp=2o8zgM!O{B@mL z%(a|(zS5lmuhBX@9oK9(DdofA*7kyy_e!6uH(|}yN4*D{Y7XW```ymXta*RxYtT1R znVB&o)*MV&o=jmOFNZIOzk{uV?UA#C^O53#0*UI83YqqS7K#3m9vMIYNf0EI3?)O! zP%@MZB}2(jGL#G@L&;Dwlnf<9$xt$s3?)O!P%@MZB}2(jGL#G@L&;Dwlnf<9$$lx> z_OWkA5z#9i?;2}MZTrb3Vkl&E$RQEZBEd#Vj|d|%O){+HbO|vN)F#DFQlBvfjA~$x z1+zLBWP*~RWGER*hLWLVC>ctIlA&ZM8A^tdp=2l-N`{i5WPeJ@PGqEDJinFqMT?V) NCEOYbrCa)EzX5zj#l8Rl literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray4-40mp.png b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray4-40mp.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5cc88fe582290582de924630b1a0fff766c63a67 GIT binary patch literal 46441 zcmeI*ze|--9LMqR?bf|uUQsGAOR`#`$p|8pz-u>B2oZ~@AW#|_YA{i#mTqcbPC^b6 zBK`qo4%V6_K|`QZ8U#568QNe(4bhK>#wM384X@=sa5>ZAJm-ABpU>xcpS$gCCv#;r zWf75UZ7Fm_>}iVFHnchUBi>&7IG8*(^>(zKj#O&&$5h1QeXWK3nd{?gi}|YA`k0&U zsJ^qFJzsg_{r!9GOCQoP@hu(mjh`kXdj9-mY9liQkHc6+bS*90|OsGbLGuk2fl!8n|=OeIE zxJe8(o+4Y7v&>wVFX%A^|7r@l-#ofhlSE(!yMA8W-#;)obMQ%Dd&IGUipajsr{YU_ zL+n16-4Y9jSE9SKc6&6GtEM;FwisE zJR2X8xpa-)S{z!g+xu`hCt*~g zgb@S;1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G1Ox;G z1Ox;G1O$VYLF=v+*Uh+0XG53iw0!S7m5wOZzj}J5&^m+l}|HCt$8^^9^#y_c2 zZ)QC9o##H!dCz&yIq!Gv7oYvPk9_z?KD@KD^O4=lmp;3*^P?Acc7FH|9{7V-ipMCWQ|Mio9bYbV=fBKc(OP~7X-~Qu&`^S&}(BE9#`GLRu z-lyOC{8xW|=l8$z_22osUw!lwFMj<`zV}=I`^nYr-Vy(M!s7eBLl`^Y!8`rOkmZT0@2I(zl# z_y4gcw|f8IIeYDyBj5k-6OV26{$IFu>BiB&=A&n}djGFo+UjF^Xsh@C-1)6OrY~>x z{?Tmchh`!C6KFPQh-Qha9}~?64Tt8$&(-G~nuCViY~ttct8%kJPW*aoV_$?*C z1dWH40GqQ_rMZD({X(S~G#DD2__<B%$S_|kX3{k3mC{!sqHux_O&E*gsBprI&EMA}mn4;qT%$V5>* z#L(q0F%-o`Ls1+w6vYV|y8KDb6~&c_F8`pRD6UL&`3DVM{+uSd{6mZtLu2CSdQe%H zf4ITWn4rPXh)ft7LkxySiNVk)8Yj`vxcZy_{?fWF^m||U`~Ug#-~Gc!9{c#Y{6r{Difx}puv==OspOZ8cc~KT}+7~#=6?Fda&UJQ(^2;8bO1h5t*2>$Z5jRh)ft7l?g**&|qj(CJc>1<5UDi`UZlh)x(zx80JaPFw8T= zuwfKp9E)L|+inbPJ~&gX8z|N<9DIX@Db|IeJ*p}Bp(lb3H%ze(F^Ir~(f(e@gefuHaA;1@ z(Eg50w7-WK+TSIH_IJ_H{tgnRdhEdSaFiOzSFiHx_$*)W_j0O$9S!MFVwM#b=L-MUb%%JrG7K7Fy zj6v&gLvEI!Avdc`?$Mz2(Hleai8%NoRW0lxhP%Q-3=N|Y!(CyC;cJ<=_GFa8$scZT z@*6a)d)PA7ZRji$O!RSee|TYBB%Boa66)(J)WIar0s5VVEajN(m5|>?r{T z4JANiVwh)$VVI}HPy!SUB|y+n0widBuwkBqH-;vuV@ee2$5wCWKL@477d4C`Rn=m+ zp<0Y&RErClXc!GQRErZdREv>`YH^66S}ZYCi$z1V7&KIi2^t@)S`4Z;|4uXuAZUhW zL1403k7Fn-?g|SU2CXX-8%Bc$->fomSJ0KQiIu4>36TB?c$IXmIj_1}8s3gOi_x zmXlwZaPkKYPJU&=$saWMW;snb`9lo8S%|?m3o-7@$)Ce$@mHZ4niYY*zKw5o>&DRh zplUH%Q!NfLc2$dsy{g5^M720*s1_>|)#9L`TFhypS{!0X<3kM9Vu+zyoP+h|Fw$qX zy4CsVmtKFlj5_eODT~5#n`$wCObHNeDgmNRcZEeJN`T5l2{33V0V)%Bg$)`eU~`(t z&4w6CfDl6oP-5Ku3D~VShURT(7=@o2Mnen@qY%T*(jms4YB6Z27NOv&JdtfeC?~%%(J&e`9zApR>hNT~9x1KAC^ri-afP6NaK^ON#lnY()bWV8ed`@k;d=iCN~RcaUUOeV4EIrl7`se~py57>$V9_vPUKyyACZZM z(LyHfqZn>T<0oiH<0BIm>kwnzS9Kr7aKl>e#7`D$Wx`?&8VrrdgrPC98 zQx=Jz>m~h*=dYA12fvn^1vI%?NTU6n*m7KQvqLwA=7VEOjG~zm;V@HTh{2R7G0c4x z4F_M)I4%cY-qL$2-k+4HsBe93CO?>He@~jES`0B%iy?;gcZ03=chE4!+MuD*95hs# zk%>xkh@sLfF;tpGL!}usRGJAI+TTgYwZAKq*Dh_<*L&#NGx@1dE5Lfhd?7l?G&^uz zi1!uR^S&Z{s~-`*Nr}qDU15U;?`t6ws~;0Wd0&-@N0AO1`jQD6#tVlSysr?$>PLvN z$NLHzyst?!Tz(#6Sp5hwtbX(~VQ2&mhDL&hyDSnk7#a(iFf@i642=mIr)ijHi;bbp zFRo#OBj6Ah!`hWsi)!?5%a!^34l3=fwnF$_x=4Gp89;XaCF z8iu74LN$yk6OUsUG*0pq>&@SSlOLIL@`ugb2n6el&Oj#^s!uy&K%KNHJtmO_G42=X0hQ<(sp%G#*G(rr9#vH5+jS|CJ zZqZ<91dS7JXxzFk#FWVS$doA6nG%BrQ(_?#ro`k`Nv#+LufUVP7&zalvL}Vl=Tb@o^O!gQWg9bw*GGS;8F;1wVaqGs=e7**9ay~L8h8U(;LkxF?g&0hUo(QH` zgNA{e1PxOb2^vg^%EVgkpuv<_$i$SzgixkLWnwLN(6E-9pmEBkSm#sD@8~h63s@YQ z;RYwa+;C_P8l3#dgp)tSIH68{K20-Y`83UpP0{qe?AdKMhK6_=MuA$xXo#U<6k=!? zg&6NEA|1=o48zikXzZeZ;fB6sf`(z~A%^F7hZvsU9b&A# zqld0N(};TTYq?oKbBR+(VrDF{#mrb`A~zc})Y#fOYWgv*IQuXjU`~O9u_Z(g_-d zd6L2z=7~&9SyU#^oxgq|;N)B34^tu#$<0aXf;cQ{@cc5VJP4WkVd>lbJ?XlNK!FNS%7hGCwO ziH1>#vC=RK8tmE1#4yjG!8fZ+G>is~_vxE$wJ|hhl!!DMbXVB0ZqFr7A%=$0M2z(X z;Lo4iY6_PrF%(iQCbp;+hZw5G5JR;XVz|e(hmP^WprKk!&~S-Uf`;6zGI5F1pkd0Q zGBIT_Xqd9dX`=l-#L)f@G2CTQV%V1~8Vrq~;Vz3wx{i;baoEPt=7V$aZJ=1cF!wcR znEPrPz{w994!)5ICqKkEJ_lbupm)w?(QNTCojH3o=}Nzq*DThsh{YPhSY(S#Sge%^ zi*?Xou`Xm{k!?b#O0zOCGd5_bG!rybnnMhgW{9EE3^B}%&B3}d&tI9C84DT=jrW4a zf$Ku3f+|5E=L_#E=L_#EB;kEkCcLjfgZH(N3GZt{DDSH>;e8Dnysrce-q#R=_Z4FB zzCsM%*Bq?8uM)#u7Da>i6*L$c2^tKIoUIIv%7mdYXfQMuGGS;;2t7@P#*rICqX-S7 zC_;WU#Bf(wh_RAi1r7OCWg@>CG~`zcnaHnBXMQz=&&U1F7nu_Ci90mQ6NhHdc-5gf zXgD+zMcrjF#Bi5Ih~W~a62m1PAZ{?4nS&&4t5Jnnbnee^_ z4Qc#BCcLi+p}eokL>fP6JQ!)bLvudyUEbFO#`WsNmoME2IQdpi6T>`($gp(Kc*3ys zpkbINLBlZ55W|%zA%?zWh_NR(3mS5>Bw%v01Py)3$mAIGC2zkmG#?x%KZ@q$4>25k zAqG<-#9&G^)I0c!1}A^eu$J4P!O0IArYuG#)^bA(PJW1CEw?EsCqHO#@)I;T`3V{f zjmqSOYg@IC&z!xQp9-}C>>ip04Kxd3_-2uehEZi=0(Q{QFj~mO1nh*+@0)LS%f?XN zgVm4Wr@L5(7)*(Y;k!(U5W`(z6EXHY@pd7T(|Q+cKXLn#3p5;>iH$BW4>!!@CpL2O zBNI-3W#Z5rG+3;a2`7KhV6o;jF_S;UFq#-*tS5L`tiz4(o5eaGff8U&bH3S7am6!RO#B0(pJk4!*pH%648$;{y>V ze~2NPg&5NK5aa%(@%=;&d@Y&<7SSxE)t5}BsxMiY+%Hoi?;%9Z$0V8sBGD`)5zQhK z(X28N%?1rq7L|!9i$TMbMNX3kcgo^68$%m>P-O$f%3Wb|xa=9o2{8=h%;BApweROKro#<}M!3Py7-F1UL*uY@Ap<#~x`CWh-J?hc4W>k8VjySG zU`k9G?op%@F?KzXEyOToF%iR*MTud`Vu6M!iwU7ji3Sa(M9^SLj7(0hDe>M1s{NfK zK&2U(Ykx=PD$UA7`+LyP{;o{4zXuKN@0=#u-$RVFzqi>Knjh3K3ZpcPh8S+w2{GKR z6JoesXHvEGzTxxdu3sos4t&k~DlELOpuzh}Y;likVvF1?GLf5ACWd(i4Hj!X;mVXbSZ~g}d4|y_#W2rsgQ3x&!O#dA42_Y=@fqehY-4Ei z!Rak-pm6X7iZz)Xe4}UwU%BDn3mOi-k;(Bn`0@e0`}Rb$`Itnr(nB;08lu_AL^KOA z+=(7KQf?h%(Xe(1Do^&`Zv`jHdaU161pG(KoNxDW3O2>WqE8lRwHys!+B#t$0$ zl99=3i!^=>9gB7NBR4C5Sgb)qZdRGFSO*Qc*+M2P*8Qa21Z;@m;W863*09LU!VNQH z;fA{`CVrY33o%Z}%-E3|LnC|*qfp&_6hjQAM2NwZ2r)E_dLl3-f`*1sf(BC}K|{kR zGO?Dskcqjk;RaJ8L4zqV#IVQ~VlX8_j1yu?^y6E;*8a|?X~QVFf%bQlqSCBPw7&-p zmF7Yw+TRmGjV4wm4|t_{(8ds|3<9V!2qdDKlqf7riJ)OpBGJQBKN2)N^`kQJ)Q>^K zltpFYsUL#|?<=PX?`w$RsUIPRr+$POp87EdtIN+z467eS!&+|9Fl7-m7#azo42@(O z42{Typ;4JIGzN{6ZfM-HF7)F}i4i_iA}0bk-626A+}00#87F57;8hu>c?bCRzHRt zD$NEBm1fXTX^u>8xn$t>8$+8Pw86cBV&$%|h|67JA%=$0BqwW`*x(*+*x*jkkj4)& zG>k$F7nqkA)^dx6G(Ko(7$wutFiHs3Fse*6j0O!2qsqht?4V%+Hm8ZcMDx@|*e3#)Q0RC0q{N`1TC7Y| zi-U%0F{g>#Y=|K@3o%@K5@M(p=U{d1Nr~awlcHhDqG*_a4H^uMgiwY?G7W}CWWvy> zOc)x221BDVVQ35*$I;L@WL?O?=imzh!(mgbg~i-g&~WfoCJw$q<2W9C?0_(@#N zUEu`{xnv*=@fg#J z&LsnbhW2-4;^xC4h9`!U7%qS+8V_3gdz+1+!AHX=Y1o5Cm7zgE*#9DnHRp?lQ5d3O zw6BphLs+bl35&HdaZ$jaVJ){Z@kF*kgZGuwg!eVXu=){VtUD2&$Tr-t`Vnqe{TO2K zzCsN5xP}-eU?&@2nHj507#cx?p^>1$&`8iQGZvYgI78!*jiJrwYanL>#h$sZ#6WXj zAqG<-F_0-ynHb0^8cd0xVag&Q)RaX+s40ue#C;Tl22-LkvB)-PFeP%DFeQc<7TH1! zi)M*Wn%k#(6IfzkjYbLuO6(RL2P~H$di}f%un@Od2OCQNTOK?!_bIK z_81z2#?sI@YGY{hB_a)mR%;V#REr^oyTT@7tTc=kGI3Yfa6`42pdpPPVwhqLG4v%v z3{$KEYUw0gWj!8TE=OF~o4~ zNr>UvlMqA0XwF}YY$b-=tZ2y1iUw06XfP!bLS1{3Ov55uWMTrgGI3?fpkd0QGGS;8 z8Vrq`CJc=s216snU}%IG$Jx;M&OiLsPk(4T?@#>L(|>#JrPp7cbFjZf zUTYW?A`PQKgDDZ2xLs$6;dY%8!=yyfU`hlHrbL3q6HJLggDFv&FeL^JrbKE_ro<3~ zDG_2YB|?njY)U+T?)rtk)dOFvGz*LNchJ!Oo}^Kw8Dbo-nf$&n(X42QWXDs7%~P5j0F$G-#Nz7&KIik%=jb zA%-c75`*_uH127&*nenV>q{on)0Z4#C;>tYB|wOwFWJ*v2~aeY0E31Spg}{!C}?OH zjZBmPA;w*4fB*VhAAMxKF!bb^Z+z*y-~QS+AAe{+lM#^?P`fK^pBPMu5<^5P8cd0x zVfCX2x7Ck9!<0p3V)bLtV6je`Vaj46#?6}pFP^^=aE3FBFRB&;n!Ccn4Y^q)BR8u| m 1 else 'resource-probe.py')).read_text(), 'fixtures': {p.name: base64.b64encode(p.read_bytes()).decode() for p in (folder / 'fixtures').glob('*.png')}} +result = subprocess.run(['docker', 'compose', 'exec', '-T', 'worker', 'python', '-c', bootstrap], input=json.dumps(payload), text=True, check=False) +raise SystemExit(result.returncode) diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9629019 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:15:53Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {} +$ openspec validate --all --strict +- Validating... +✓ spec/lab1-event-publication +✓ spec/lab1-messenger-chats +✓ spec/lab1-messenger-history +✓ spec/lab1-messenger-identity +✓ spec/lab1-service-operability +✓ spec/lab2-auth-sessions +✓ spec/lab2-dependency-failures +✓ spec/lab2-history-index +✓ spec/lab2-persistent-storage +✓ spec/lab2-session-cache +✓ spec/lab3-failover-operations +✓ spec/lab3-idempotent-messages +✓ spec/lab3-load-balancing +✓ spec/lab4-attachments +✓ spec/lab4-object-storage +✓ spec/lab4-storage-reconciler +✓ spec/lab4-upload-resilience +✓ spec/lab5-attachment-pipeline +✓ spec/lab5-image-variants +✓ spec/lab5-job-delivery +✓ spec/lab5-job-recovery +✓ spec/lab5-versioned-pipeline +Totals: 22 passed, 0 failed (22 items) +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.889 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..933a5ad --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json @@ -0,0 +1,742 @@ +{ + "mode": "png-http", + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:30.802260Z", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "gray2", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:31.867669Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-107e-76d1-b857-f8a847a893d8", + "input_sha256": "80754a3aa0c8a6014dc7a282b2009d49d064a5c02ed48e634d05d01c0aa3df6b", + "input_bytes": 189, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "def030bc04042aa23362c895a36b18d1d9748360df045decaf68eaeb0aa68deb", + "bytes": 1324, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fd49dc2d33e7b7963cd8f8f6ef0f0b80117e2c4a7dfb4fd2ee79285e47ff789a", + "bytes": 98, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "1b6f714677aa69673da7ed9eefba73376b8df42eae70a3d91002d2aab7272d9e", + "bytes": 332, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "d14b6cc6fe415bd8c4fef55402a4fb196bc4f39d493ee505d536594b28841697", + "bytes": 1489, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "c8f23e1adbf1add646f23531e270dc25d5108453d50947dec3e73700b0d6741f", + "bytes": 96, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "93107a3ba1a8aba475f8993dfb0d03658cef12a416c08a230653370921dcc00b", + "bytes": 335, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.952 + }, + { + "name": "gray4", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:36.820264Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-23d7-7757-bd08-e78831dce1a6", + "input_sha256": "d0ed5b64b3b875be881dd286bedb7948fd06570f9ef1d2cfe41b665a838e426b", + "input_bytes": 263, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "43323e552e3c79e1a1688478d72c2ce370c21e55f1560958f9f6a225bc32f909", + "bytes": 1034, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "dbc0ec3736c18df42f26b8f396b2eb243a18c6a0f5b6bbef8bf4ff7e563032c3", + "bytes": 90, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "d594ebb80ca7939643379ba54392070444eb900ca40bec9c6beee75175fd81ab", + "bytes": 330, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "16e27d4c1df7aac7185381a1f4c8c9cceb05647e98f941c41e38f4dfe4c5ec75", + "bytes": 1197, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "cd31de25056767d9050108c4475d4b72ccd1ab3c36c1c96159b104019e4e3493", + "bytes": 92, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "86afdaf8b40f77c2426ebf10c8d603535d75caa4fc720462be9acc43e39d4fbd", + "bytes": 330, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.607 + }, + { + "name": "rgb16", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:41.427922Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-35d8-7442-a3b7-1cd166d552cc", + "input_sha256": "e8e5f64cf3a0312b17549aed29f062e3cb03d0c1bf327396c6a25c4b88dec89f", + "input_bytes": 724, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "6386114c3d0b89c4df88745eec318b5db1a779d488e1b08f34ac34138c7feb99", + "bytes": 671, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "fed7e1bf230e91296a5ea9a85b51d190152639bb2963b661f872029d852cc4ad", + "bytes": 94, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "af0a65a6596a0905a79403a9a6ef32a1301671a98ae3c8b5c3d6ced2d20a1009", + "bytes": 332, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "dedcbac123226e3012a4dbd178b7aae7a7aba4f2c44c91be274c86804238b208", + "bytes": 696, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "bc09a1696563daae4385190d2c52afac8230e18fff4b5eba701a42f0facde043", + "bytes": 94, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "218bc7fd6fa995a3c4cf725016714408073699d13f39d0d364ffe3595856d272", + "bytes": 333, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.02 + }, + { + "name": "gray1", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:45.448396Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-458d-73f1-9c76-b2f5f360400e", + "input_sha256": "1bf59ee41fbd12bf572ac294e0505cc00b904363dd479d643b43062199dd67e3", + "input_bytes": 154, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "1b88218fd7e3ff00d6fa3e4bb732411617126591b2b6837aecdcaef426327eda", + "bytes": 380, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "315ce3f53ac2012226bbeb906c7d37997a7f6fabb3d0ede23a797e66fe4b51ee", + "bytes": 66, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "c5745603d7848377a38bb5228f7817f5d4d4f5af26dadd7d3b2fb97b6a598a8e", + "bytes": 308, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "45eac1bd54dba273142a01a3f01a1530787db5a9fe04aa2483862256dbf16132", + "bytes": 380, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "8c5e7cc56874d00f7d5731a6a89461b264ef4e3b450899b63f4608231180b5aa", + "bytes": 66, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "19305cfd18dc8f3e504d6ef5667ddd7be788836e16317dba5b2c6f590b6a2667", + "bytes": 308, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 3.992 + }, + { + "name": "gray8", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:49.441526Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-5527-75fa-ace8-6f2de9678922", + "input_sha256": "31cb54aacd9e1c324b14e38377f83a21d4084dc134aa3d3e1e5c40e3d9c5dd2f", + "input_bytes": 286, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "14a6e4afbe7e4cf766330007adda1c14168f16957f9409f402a8699a0e5de62f", + "bytes": 621, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "d35d7d59302099ea5fea9e91a405f4ebf8823aae1f53a59f88a09015619136fa", + "bytes": 74, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "d8fac3c82defab08dbb276681b1a7fb2545d883830dae5f965349474897373c7", + "bytes": 324, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "dba34622f93edcd2d3449e217eb9605b1fac739c7c873a875af5d88d8e76bf2e", + "bytes": 637, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "3d4823a2da9971a444b16cf060be5f0b2b7a16bf50a26e7343283d48b562d105", + "bytes": 76, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "d9d4ed6ef383acdf227745e511acaffddf6e90c4f100d0f6ea117f5783581d29", + "bytes": 324, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.022 + }, + { + "name": "gray16", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:53.463983Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-64df-7694-8365-6ba2803fa169", + "input_sha256": "f7fbc2506997045f18891037f3cde42cf1e3b55461948f790779817317574f77", + "input_bytes": 344, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "e49a69181bafd0ebb4348db7030ad2cbf632b296a65f0ba05fe984b3d2b1ccdc", + "bytes": 632, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "751dc647784804af94b6cda23248840f73cab0cfe03227c4568b75195c00603a", + "bytes": 80, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "1bc87b25d02a179dc0cf5a883fb624fda094ba042ed9476c883ae1c12da6f1b6", + "bytes": 322, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "a94faef9b08b5ab6ab239b6618c0e92b0ab92abca889acd714d6d9179dde90ef", + "bytes": 662, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "b22468814595a3ae63a9b326ed55fefb9a833a0e621be5f366b113ad6cf18a12", + "bytes": 72, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "d2267d9adb990db045e8c186737a4bdf66aa4e8d82d785c0bb3d8e87c34c5072", + "bytes": 323, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 3.952 + }, + { + "name": "rgb8", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:57.416228Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-7451-70a2-83ed-869d99c81f3f", + "input_sha256": "8c27c74500758b1a24ccc96261334265e304d55530780aefc7ef4a1109c11852", + "input_bytes": 385, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "c36bf54d185cfcf7abddd219a5e586e11b0c4d10007df5db55978f74ddcad2d0", + "bytes": 1069, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "7b78675ebd18218e82922e75072a801eea74b4d5f26cde2b5810407c86509b88", + "bytes": 116, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "f6e37a29401efe000eb8deb1490975d745f621f2ab229f4d85162945189e1791", + "bytes": 385, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "fd82664e5924528cd7916b3b9e30b71517fa13c2763a8705e750fd4293f3027c", + "bytes": 1184, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "a05ef5a9f1305b2941cc99ab594eb3671bb87babe35d28ac97127791881137bb", + "bytes": 120, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "3cac9f1ca274bcac1dc05cf186cd88eb622fd947fb1a7958a1175e77623a96d6", + "bytes": 392, + "dimensions": [ + 64, + 64 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.545 + }, + { + "name": "rgb16-adam7-filter4-exif6", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:01.962099Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-8615-7763-b117-c00aacaebeb6", + "input_sha256": "b9c1cb1e309024e4578d1f17bf6bb0f0645aad4d8973e16098b65c54cfd4930a", + "input_bytes": 1297, + "versions": [ + { + "version": 1, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "f257bf8fa4f30f0e4df6672de140799375cebd2bf735a656432cf702663414a1", + "bytes": 601, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "cb92af5a047068048eba212d944513edb2c454f64e124339820d46c24e69ea45", + "bytes": 112, + "dimensions": [ + 63, + 65 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "110cf7571f07d2db04821e8ef1861f74b5a16978851a4b0082ca60aedc1d29e4", + "bytes": 419, + "dimensions": [ + 63, + 65 + ] + } + ] + }, + { + "version": 2, + "variants": [ + { + "name": "crop", + "sha256": "0a7fea5640c5877026100e65e39848e7b15ee5eebb93897ebbeb95d441e8d652", + "bytes": 675, + "dimensions": [ + 128, + 128 + ] + }, + { + "name": "optimized", + "sha256": "9d4b7431a72adfc10284e4443c4e56b4cd19a67c0729979041fc8b0bc2c6ca34", + "bytes": 116, + "dimensions": [ + 63, + 65 + ] + }, + { + "name": "thumbnail", + "sha256": "529ceb55a8675e5ed870ed7917d7f1a5753c898b689f3e431e403b9b3682a732", + "bytes": 440, + "dimensions": [ + 63, + 65 + ] + } + ] + } + ], + "stale_and_duplicate_noop": true + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.577 + } + ], + "conditions": { + "host_load": [ + 5.10693359375, + 3.61181640625, + 2.75048828125 + ], + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) 2 minutes ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b running Up 11 seconds (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) 2 minutes ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c running Up 24 seconds (healthy)" + ], + "running": "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-api-2 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Up 24 seconds (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Up 11 seconds (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\n", + "worker_limits": "448\n30\n2\n" + }, + "invariants": [ + { + "id": "terminal", + "statement": "every 202 reaches its expected terminal state", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "single_effect", + "statement": "one variant set per (attachment_id, pipeline_version, variant)", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_ready_rollback", + "statement": "ready never returns to queued or processing", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "traced": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "monotonic_publication", + "statement": "published_version only moves forward", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "sampled": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "bytes_match_metadata", + "statement": "sha256, size and real dimensions match served bytes", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "verified": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "bounded_attempts", + "statement": "attempt <= JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_orphans", + "statement": "no pending outbox, messages, dead letters, staging, objects", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "s3_objects": 56, + "scoped_attachments": 8 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_lost_202", + "statement": "every 202 is present in PostgreSQL and the API", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 8 + } + } + ], + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bc-107e-76d1-b857-f8a847a893d8", + "01a1b2bc-23d7-7757-bd08-e78831dce1a6", + "01a1b2bc-35d8-7442-a3b7-1cd166d552cc", + "01a1b2bc-458d-73f1-9c76-b2f5f360400e", + "01a1b2bc-5527-75fa-ace8-6f2de9678922", + "01a1b2bc-64df-7694-8365-6ba2803fa169", + "01a1b2bc-7451-70a2-83ed-869d99c81f3f", + "01a1b2bc-8615-7763-b117-c00aacaebeb6" + ], + "finished_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:18.474212Z", + "result": "PASS" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..908483b --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:20:30Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ .venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py png-http +gray2 PASS +gray4 PASS +rgb16 PASS +gray1 PASS +gray8 PASS +gray16 PASS +rgb8 PASS +rgb16-adam7-filter4-exif6 PASS +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 47.846 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bf4e8ef --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json @@ -0,0 +1,242 @@ +{ + "mode": "png-limits", + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:18.724252Z", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "gray2-40mp", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:20.277013Z", + "result": "FAIL", + "error": "{\"attachment_id\": \"01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db\", \"input_bytes\": 35759, \"input_sha256\": \"e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6\", \"pixels\": 40000000, \"status\": \"failed\", \"error_code\": \"processing_failed\", \"jobs\": [{\"job_id\": \"01a1b2bc-cdc9-7157-b245-f357f81b4d6c\", \"pipeline_version\": 1, \"status\": \"failed\", \"attempt\": 1}], \"memory_peak\": \"541655040\", \"memory_max\": \"1073741824\"}", + "elapsed_seconds": 1.066 + }, + { + "name": "gray4-40mp", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:21.343296Z", + "result": "FAIL", + "error": "{\"attachment_id\": \"01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d\", \"input_bytes\": 46441, \"input_sha256\": \"64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd\", \"pixels\": 40000000, \"status\": \"failed\", \"error_code\": \"processing_failed\", \"jobs\": [{\"job_id\": \"01a1b2bc-d21b-72a6-b463-0fa58bd353a2\", \"pipeline_version\": 1, \"status\": \"failed\", \"attempt\": 1}], \"memory_peak\": \"541655040\", \"memory_max\": \"1073741824\"}", + "elapsed_seconds": 1.168 + }, + { + "name": "gray16-40mp", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:22.511903Z", + "result": "FAIL", + "error": "{\"attachment_id\": \"01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab\", \"input_bytes\": 103565, \"input_sha256\": \"b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800\", \"pixels\": 40000000, \"status\": \"failed\", \"error_code\": \"processing_failed\", \"jobs\": [{\"job_id\": \"01a1b2bc-d74e-7582-a9f8-fa827d36c9fe\", \"pipeline_version\": 1, \"status\": \"failed\", \"attempt\": 1}], \"memory_peak\": \"638119936\", \"memory_max\": \"1073741824\"}", + "elapsed_seconds": 0.955 + }, + { + "name": "rgb16-40mp", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:23.467422Z", + "result": "FAIL", + "error": "{\"attachment_id\": \"01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de\", \"input_bytes\": 385445, \"input_sha256\": \"3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7\", \"pixels\": 40000000, \"status\": \"failed\", \"error_code\": \"processing_failed\", \"jobs\": [{\"job_id\": \"01a1b2bc-dc3f-7724-a737-43ad5584c8c7\", \"pipeline_version\": 1, \"status\": \"failed\", \"attempt\": 1}], \"memory_peak\": \"640196608\", \"memory_max\": \"1073741824\"}", + "elapsed_seconds": 2.242 + }, + { + "name": "forced-timeout", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:26.091820Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-f161-7119-986f-bc7c8fd99bf0", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "worker": "running" + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.233 + }, + { + "name": "forced-memory", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:30.325405Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bd-0192-70e7-a174-3275ca516e11", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "worker": "running" + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 4.766 + }, + { + "name": "normal-after-limits", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:38.218266Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bd-13b0-712a-9275-1d3cdd2eb49a", + "variants": [ + "crop", + "optimized", + "thumbnail" + ] + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 1.618 + } + ], + "conditions": { + "host_load": [ + 4.66455078125, + 3.70458984375, + 2.83203125 + ], + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) 3 minutes ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b running Up 59 seconds (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) 3 minutes ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 4 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c running Up About a minute (healthy)" + ], + "running": "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-api-2 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Up 59 seconds (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Up 4 minutes (healthy)\n", + "worker_limits": "448\n30\n2\n" + }, + "large_observations": [ + { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db", + "input_bytes": 35759, + "input_sha256": "e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6", + "pixels": 40000000, + "status": "failed", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bc-cdc9-7157-b245-f357f81b4d6c", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "failed", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "memory_peak": "541655040", + "memory_max": "1073741824" + }, + { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d", + "input_bytes": 46441, + "input_sha256": "64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd", + "pixels": 40000000, + "status": "failed", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bc-d21b-72a6-b463-0fa58bd353a2", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "failed", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "memory_peak": "541655040", + "memory_max": "1073741824" + }, + { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab", + "input_bytes": 103565, + "input_sha256": "b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800", + "pixels": 40000000, + "status": "failed", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bc-d74e-7582-a9f8-fa827d36c9fe", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "failed", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "memory_peak": "638119936", + "memory_max": "1073741824" + }, + { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de", + "input_bytes": 385445, + "input_sha256": "3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7", + "pixels": 40000000, + "status": "failed", + "error_code": "processing_failed", + "jobs": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bc-dc3f-7724-a737-43ad5584c8c7", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "failed", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "memory_peak": "640196608", + "memory_max": "1073741824" + } + ], + "invariants": [ + { + "id": "terminal", + "statement": "every 202 reaches its expected terminal state", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 7 + } + }, + { + "id": "single_effect", + "statement": "one variant set per (attachment_id, pipeline_version, variant)", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_ready_rollback", + "statement": "ready never returns to queued or processing", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "traced": 7 + } + }, + { + "id": "monotonic_publication", + "statement": "published_version only moves forward", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "sampled": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "bytes_match_metadata", + "statement": "sha256, size and real dimensions match served bytes", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "verified": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "bounded_attempts", + "statement": "attempt <= JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_orphans", + "statement": "no pending outbox, messages, dead letters, staging, objects", + "result": "FAIL", + "details": "staging kept after ready: [{'id': '01a1b2bd-13b0-712a-9275-1d3cdd2eb49a'}]" + }, + { + "id": "no_lost_202", + "statement": "every 202 is present in PostgreSQL and the API", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 7 + } + } + ], + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db", + "01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d", + "01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab", + "01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de", + "01a1b2bc-f161-7119-986f-bc7c8fd99bf0", + "01a1b2bd-0192-70e7-a174-3275ca516e11", + "01a1b2bd-13b0-712a-9275-1d3cdd2eb49a" + ], + "finished_at": "2026-11-06T21:21:42.105495Z", + "result": "FAIL" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e2eabb6 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:21:18Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ .venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py png-limits +gray2-40mp FAIL {"attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-cdc1-7315-82e0-39f3e53d87db", "input_bytes": 35759, "input_sha256": "e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6", "pixels": 40000000, "status": "failed", "error_code": "processing_failed", "jobs": [{"job_id": "01a1b2bc-cdc9-7157-b245-f357f81b4d6c", "pipeline_version": 1, "status": "failed", "attempt": 1}], "memory_peak": "541655040", "memory_max": "1073741824"} +gray4-40mp FAIL {"attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-d211-7337-bd57-0ca1f3e33a0d", "input_bytes": 46441, "input_sha256": "64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd", "pixels": 40000000, "status": "failed", "error_code": "processing_failed", "jobs": [{"job_id": "01a1b2bc-d21b-72a6-b463-0fa58bd353a2", "pipeline_version": 1, "status": "failed", "attempt": 1}], "memory_peak": "541655040", "memory_max": "1073741824"} +gray16-40mp FAIL {"attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-d744-77c1-8352-989f80848cab", "input_bytes": 103565, "input_sha256": "b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800", "pixels": 40000000, "status": "failed", "error_code": "processing_failed", "jobs": [{"job_id": "01a1b2bc-d74e-7582-a9f8-fa827d36c9fe", "pipeline_version": 1, "status": "failed", "attempt": 1}], "memory_peak": "638119936", "memory_max": "1073741824"} +rgb16-40mp FAIL {"attachment_id": "01a1b2bc-dc37-7249-b7c3-f8901fb298de", "input_bytes": 385445, "input_sha256": "3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7", "pixels": 40000000, "status": "failed", "error_code": "processing_failed", "jobs": [{"job_id": "01a1b2bc-dc3f-7724-a737-43ad5584c8c7", "pipeline_version": 1, "status": "failed", "attempt": 1}], "memory_peak": "640196608", "memory_max": "1073741824"} +forced-timeout PASS +forced-memory PASS +normal-after-limits PASS +exit_code: 1 elapsed_seconds: 23.549 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..13a4444 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:17:55Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose exec -T broker rabbitmqctl -q list_policies -p messenger +vhost name pattern apply-to definition priority +messenger attachments-process ^attachments\.process$ queues {"dead-letter-exchange":"attachments.dlx","dead-letter-strategy":"at-least-once","delivery-limit":-1,"overflow":"reject-publish"} 10 +messenger attachments-dlq ^attachments\.process\.dlq$ queues {"max-length":100000,"overflow":"reject-publish"} 10 +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.598 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..faef9a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json @@ -0,0 +1,199 @@ +{ + "mode": "postgres-outage-retry", + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:02.998079Z", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "published_outbox_database_outage", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:04.036200Z", + "observed": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bb-aa23-72ec-98b1-63582184109f", + "jobs_before": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bb-aa2a-72d3-ad8b-623a79fcbed4", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "queued", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "jobs_after": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bb-aa2a-72d3-ad8b-623a79fcbed4", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "done", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "requeues": 12, + "queues_during": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 1 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "queues_after": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "replay": false, + "stopped_containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b exited Exited (0) Less than a second ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c exited Exited (0) 1 second ago" + ] + }, + "result": "PASS", + "elapsed_seconds": 21.815 + } + ], + "conditions": { + "host_load": [ + 3.986328125, + 3.29931640625, + 2.619140625 + ], + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c running Up About a minute (healthy)" + ], + "running": "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-api-2 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Up 3 minutes (healthy)\n", + "worker_limits": "448\n30\n2\n" + }, + "outage_checkpoint": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2bb-aa23-72ec-98b1-63582184109f", + "jobs_before": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2bb-aa2a-72d3-ad8b-623a79fcbed4", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "queued", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "dlq_before": [ + 15, + 0 + ], + "stopped_containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b exited Exited (0) Less than a second ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up 3 minutes (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c exited Exited (0) 1 second ago" + ] + }, + "invariants": [ + { + "id": "terminal", + "statement": "every 202 reaches its expected terminal state", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "single_effect", + "statement": "one variant set per (attachment_id, pipeline_version, variant)", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_ready_rollback", + "statement": "ready never returns to queued or processing", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "traced": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "monotonic_publication", + "statement": "published_version only moves forward", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "sampled": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "bytes_match_metadata", + "statement": "sha256, size and real dimensions match served bytes", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "verified": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "bounded_attempts", + "statement": "attempt <= JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_orphans", + "statement": "no pending outbox, messages, dead letters, staging, objects", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "s3_objects": 4, + "scoped_attachments": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_lost_202", + "statement": "every 202 is present in PostgreSQL and the API", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 1 + } + } + ], + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2bb-aa23-72ec-98b1-63582184109f" + ], + "finished_at": "2026-11-06T21:20:30.164434Z", + "result": "PASS" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f91fb10 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:20:02Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ .venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py postgres-outage-retry +published_outbox_database_outage PASS +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 27.330 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8ddcdbe --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.json @@ -0,0 +1,146 @@ +{ + "mode": "postgres-outage", + "source_sha": "b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:18:09.131834Z", + "cases": [ + { + "name": "published_outbox_database_outage", + "started_at": "2026-11-06T21:18:10.870080Z", + "result": "FAIL", + "error": "timeout 90s waiting for 12 real database failures", + "elapsed_seconds": 97.081 + } + ], + "conditions": { + "host_load": [ + 3.3544921875, + 3.0048828125, + 2.4365234375 + ], + "containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c running Up About a minute (healthy)" + ], + "running": "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-api-2 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Up About a minute (healthy)\nmtusi-lab5-test-valkey-a93cc36b Up About a minute\nmtusi-lab5-test-1de81872 Up About a minute\nmtusi-lab5-test-rustfs-62f3a9c3 Up About a minute\nmtusi-lab5-test-rabbitmq-675a32e8 Up 2 minutes\n", + "worker_limits": "448\n30\n2\n" + }, + "outage_checkpoint": { + "attachment_id": "01a1b2b9-f033-76be-ba05-897b08873abd", + "jobs_before": [ + { + "job_id": "01a1b2b9-f043-72e8-970c-647fc4a1f2e3", + "pipeline_version": 1, + "status": "queued", + "attempt": 1 + } + ], + "dlq_before": [ + 15, + 0 + ], + "stopped_containers": [ + "mtusi2026lab5-api-1 fc7d65385119 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-api-2 a5411e55f06d running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 a38bbcf03870 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 f0d01200b1f8 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 feca425ac0ae exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 9f62ea9d176b exited Exited (0) Less than a second ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 4153c8488753 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 9a7684ef147a running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 e5825f3eeafb exited Exited (0) About a minute ago", + "mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 e37f783f9d50 running Up About a minute (healthy)", + "mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 ee8f9d678c2c exited Exited (0) 1 second ago" + ] + }, + "invariants": [ + { + "id": "terminal", + "statement": "every 202 reaches its expected terminal state", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "single_effect", + "statement": "one variant set per (attachment_id, pipeline_version, variant)", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_ready_rollback", + "statement": "ready never returns to queued or processing", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "traced": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "monotonic_publication", + "statement": "published_version only moves forward", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "sampled": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "bytes_match_metadata", + "statement": "sha256, size and real dimensions match served bytes", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "verified": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "bounded_attempts", + "statement": "attempt <= JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "rows": 0 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_orphans", + "statement": "no pending outbox, messages, dead letters, staging, objects", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "queues": { + "attachments.process": [ + 0, + 0 + ], + "attachments.process.dlq": [ + 15, + 0 + ] + }, + "s3_objects": 4, + "scoped_attachments": 1 + } + }, + { + "id": "no_lost_202", + "statement": "every 202 is present in PostgreSQL and the API", + "result": "PASS", + "details": { + "accepted": 1 + } + } + ], + "accepted_ids": [ + "01a1b2b9-f033-76be-ba05-897b08873abd" + ], + "finished_at": "2026-11-06T21:19:52.189137Z", + "result": "FAIL" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..50ce316 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.txt @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:18:08Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ .venv/bin/python evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py postgres-outage +published_outbox_database_outage FAIL timeout 90s waiting for 12 real database failures +exit_code: 1 elapsed_seconds: 103.241 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-fixtures.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-fixtures.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6e8d2d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-fixtures.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:25:54Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose cp evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures worker:/tmp/validation-fixtures + mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 copy evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures to mtusi2026lab5-worker-1:/tmp/validation-fixtures Copying +Error response from daemon: container rootfs is marked read-only +exit_code: 1 elapsed_seconds: 0.081 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-script.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-script.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2b63302 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-script.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:25:54Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose cp evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py worker:/tmp/resource-probe.py + mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 copy evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py to mtusi2026lab5-worker-1:/tmp/resource-probe.py Copying +Error response from daemon: container rootfs is marked read-only +exit_code: 1 elapsed_seconds: 0.073 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6f3b27d --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:17:55Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose exec -T broker rabbitmqctl -q list_queues -p messenger name type durable policy effective_policy_definition messages_ready messages_unacknowledged +name type durable policy effective_policy_definition messages_ready messages_unacknowledged +attachments.process quorum true attachments-process [{<<"dead-letter-exchange">>, attachments.dlx}, {<<"dead-letter-strategy">>, at-least-once}, {<<"delivery-limit">>, -1}, {<<"overflow">>, reject-publish}] 0 0 +attachments.process.dlq quorum true attachments-dlq [{<<"max-length">>, 100000}, {<<"overflow">>, reject-publish}] 15 0 +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.578 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1bf4311 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +import json +import sys +from pathlib import Path + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] +sys.path.insert(0, str(ROOT / 'scripts')) +import pipeline_suite as ps + +stack = ps.Stack(ps.arguments()) +report = json.loads(Path(__file__).with_name('png-limits.json').read_text()) +ids = report['accepted_ids'] +array = '{' + ','.join(ids) + '}' +rows = {name: stack.sql(name, ids=array) for name in ('pending_outbox', 'staging_left', 'nonterminal', 'duplicate_effects', 'object_keys')} +keys = {row['key'] for row in rows.pop('object_keys')} +objects = stack.objects(ids) +assert not any(rows.values()), rows +assert objects == keys, {'extra': sorted(objects - keys), 'missing': sorted(keys - objects)} +queues = stack.queues() +assert queues[ps.QUEUE] == (0, 0), queues +result = {'source_sha': ps.run(['git', 'rev-parse', 'HEAD']).strip(), 'at': ps.now(), 'result': 'PASS', 'accepted_ids': ids, 'rows': rows, 's3_objects': len(objects), 'queues': queues, 'reason': 'Read-only recheck after scheduled staging sweep; no scenario rerun. Initial no_orphans ran before the sweep.'} +Path(__file__).with_name('cleanup-recheck.json').write_text(json.dumps(result, indent=2) + '\n') +print(json.dumps(result, indent=2)) diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-retry.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-retry.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..39aa9c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-retry.txt @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:26:09Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ python3 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/invoke-probe.py +{"file": "gray16-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 424820} +{"file": "gray16-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "e3f239d818da5f02cd7b5d1cc4a2c542ed4fc4a7fbc604598500e7810e246e2f", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 429016} +{"file": "gray2-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 429148} +{"file": "gray2-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "05c65f9a86b01f05b914b6f3f15fcfaf93b2ee4383bef3c3a60c19df1f5b5135", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 429148} +{"file": "gray4-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 429148} +{"file": "gray4-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "ff963c27cc6fdff1757fc9fa135b7b24ec2af67e042582024ebb88f2066ffaf5", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 429148} +{"file": "rgb16-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 26}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 154}, {"function": "apply_png_transparency", "file": "images.py", "line": 111}, {"function": "rgb_mask", "file": "images.py", "line": 95}, {"function": "getchannel", "file": "Image.py", "line": 2823}], "max_rss_kib": 433500} +{"file": "rgb16-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "f8082d24114c279ab0f9cab2a743e87147a322b7ad50eb402e689640b0761501", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 433500} +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 2.774 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a9f7514 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.py @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +import hashlib +import json +import resource +import traceback +import gc +import struct +from pathlib import Path + +from messenger.attachments.infrastructure.images import RenderLimits, render_variants + +import messenger.worker + +resource.setrlimit(resource.RLIMIT_AS, (448 << 20, 448 << 20)) +def without_trns(data): + result = data[:8] + offset = 8 + while offset < len(data): + size = struct.unpack('>I', data[offset:offset + 4])[0] + 12 + if data[offset + 4:offset + 8] != b'tRNS': + result += data[offset:offset + size] + offset += size + return result + + +def probe(path, data, transparency): + row = {'file': path.name, 'transparency': transparency, 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'limit_bytes': 448 << 20} + try: + row['variants'] = [r.name for r in render_variants(data, RenderLimits(10485760, 40000000))] + row['result'] = 'ready' + except Exception as error: + row['error_type'] = type(error).__name__ + row['frames'] = [{'function': f.name, 'file': Path(f.filename).name, 'line': f.lineno} for f in traceback.extract_tb(error.__traceback__)] + row['max_rss_kib'] = resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_SELF).ru_maxrss + print(json.dumps(row), flush=True) + + +for path in sorted(Path('/tmp/validation-fixtures').glob('*.png')): + data = path.read_bytes() + probe(path, data, True) + gc.collect() + probe(path, without_trns(data), False) + gc.collect() diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2d2235e --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:26:40Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ python3 evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/invoke-probe.py resource-probe-worker.py +{"file": "gray16-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 28}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 160}, {"function": "flatten", "file": "images.py", "line": 124}, {"function": "point", "file": "Image.py", "line": 2038}], "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "gray16-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "e3f239d818da5f02cd7b5d1cc4a2c542ed4fc4a7fbc604598500e7810e246e2f", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 28}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 160}, {"function": "flatten", "file": "images.py", "line": 124}, {"function": "point", "file": "Image.py", "line": 2038}], "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "gray2-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 28}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 160}, {"function": "flatten", "file": "images.py", "line": 128}, {"function": "new", "file": "Image.py", "line": 3254}], "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "gray2-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "05c65f9a86b01f05b914b6f3f15fcfaf93b2ee4383bef3c3a60c19df1f5b5135", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "gray4-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 28}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 160}, {"function": "flatten", "file": "images.py", "line": 128}, {"function": "new", "file": "Image.py", "line": 3254}], "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "gray4-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "ff963c27cc6fdff1757fc9fa135b7b24ec2af67e042582024ebb88f2066ffaf5", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "rgb16-40mp.png", "transparency": true, "input_sha256": "3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "error_type": "MemoryError", "frames": [{"function": "probe", "file": "resource-probe.py", "line": 28}, {"function": "render_variants", "file": "images.py", "line": 172}, {"function": "decoded", "file": "images.py", "line": 154}, {"function": "apply_png_transparency", "file": "images.py", "line": 111}, {"function": "rgb_mask", "file": "images.py", "line": 95}, {"function": "getchannel", "file": "Image.py", "line": 2814}, {"function": "load", "file": "ImageFile.py", "line": 370}, {"function": "load_prepare", "file": "PngImagePlugin.py", "line": 1010}, {"function": "load_prepare", "file": "ImageFile.py", "line": 451}], "max_rss_kib": 426640} +{"file": "rgb16-40mp.png", "transparency": false, "input_sha256": "f8082d24114c279ab0f9cab2a743e87147a322b7ad50eb402e689640b0761501", "limit_bytes": 469762048, "variants": ["thumbnail", "crop", "optimized"], "result": "ready", "max_rss_kib": 426640} +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 2.418 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4be3d56 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +import hashlib +import json +import resource +import traceback +import gc +import struct +from pathlib import Path + +from messenger.attachments.infrastructure.images import RenderLimits, render_variants + +resource.setrlimit(resource.RLIMIT_AS, (448 << 20, 448 << 20)) +def without_trns(data): + result = data[:8] + offset = 8 + while offset < len(data): + size = struct.unpack('>I', data[offset:offset + 4])[0] + 12 + if data[offset + 4:offset + 8] != b'tRNS': + result += data[offset:offset + size] + offset += size + return result + + +def probe(path, data, transparency): + row = {'file': path.name, 'transparency': transparency, 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'limit_bytes': 448 << 20} + try: + row['variants'] = [r.name for r in render_variants(data, RenderLimits(10485760, 40000000))] + row['result'] = 'ready' + except Exception as error: + row['error_type'] = type(error).__name__ + row['frames'] = [{'function': f.name, 'file': Path(f.filename).name, 'line': f.lineno} for f in traceback.extract_tb(error.__traceback__)] + row['max_rss_kib'] = resource.getrusage(resource.RUSAGE_SELF).ru_maxrss + print(json.dumps(row), flush=True) + + +for path in sorted(Path('/tmp/validation-fixtures').glob('*.png')): + data = path.read_bytes() + probe(path, data, True) + gc.collect() + probe(path, without_trns(data), False) + gc.collect() diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c04c5ac --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.txt @@ -0,0 +1,5 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:25:54Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose exec -T worker python /tmp/resource-probe.py +python: can't open file '/tmp/resource-probe.py': [Errno 2] No such file or directory +exit_code: 2 elapsed_seconds: 0.107 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0353e8a --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:27:03Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker volume ls --filter label=com.docker.compose.project=mtusi2026lab5 --format '{{.Name}}' +mtusi2026lab5_broker-data +mtusi2026lab5_pgdata +mtusi2026lab5_s3data +mtusi2026lab5_valkeydata +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.017 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/running-containers-after.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/running-containers-after.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..64aab80 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/running-containers-after.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:27:03Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker ps --format '{{.Names}} {{.Status}}' +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.018 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/runtime-containers.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/runtime-containers.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..332e542 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/runtime-containers.json @@ -0,0 +1,167 @@ +[ + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-api-1", + "id": "fc7d65385119449e1e81f5158ddcb2970a4d15a8f0dcc592b7f4cc5d975b4a94", + "image": "sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 536870912, + "NanoCpus": 1000000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-relay-1", + "id": "4153c8488753a4557fdd65b30243cfe772d1d0cc89abfd443a7f92de2f62d183", + "image": "sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 201326592, + "NanoCpus": 500000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-api-2", + "id": "a5411e55f06d7b51a6570392751f230afb401748d8da638d2e374d30d70efbe5", + "image": "sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 536870912, + "NanoCpus": 1000000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-worker-1", + "id": "ee8f9d678c2c7e910adef08271f9327710a82050e22358b802a3fa5c207f4453", + "image": "sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 1073741824, + "NanoCpus": 2000000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1", + "id": "feca425ac0ae5529007e3cb975c873bef4f882ad5aa71abdb1e198397f403e50", + "image": "sha256:9293b3138e99506510e947ba0cfc77ed4301f96344dd937d51d03e8c258121f2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 268435456, + "NanoCpus": 500000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1", + "id": "e5825f3eeafb6c2412d36cde84cfdbf2d69ff02649403e5978557239f854c36c", + "image": "sha256:ab024bfebee49a750ce886b4c70963ccd9ddaa03f491704a90710641d7a26699", + "limits": { + "Memory": 67108864, + "NanoCpus": 500000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-broker-1", + "id": "a38bbcf038702b1a8063120379ca2341868f0982f70d62f3113046aab641d209", + "image": "sha256:54ef5ff505352c1beef05a97ee9bd6ab95b3559a76629ba0119b1d63d8d6e4b2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 536870912, + "NanoCpus": 1000000000, + "PortBindings": { + "15672/tcp": [ + { + "HostIp": "127.0.0.1", + "HostPort": "25086" + } + ] + } + }, + "mounts": [ + { + "name": "mtusi2026lab5_broker-data", + "type": "volume", + "destination": "/var/lib/rabbitmq" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1", + "id": "9f62ea9d176b033a9a2218fe15bda597484114af3dc26bc7fdc576b4094d79bd", + "image": "sha256:266d3c257594e195b309ae9d1805e54c788f1d7b375f56bf6c367aac6c917e7b", + "limits": { + "Memory": 1073741824, + "NanoCpus": 2000000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [ + { + "name": "mtusi2026lab5_pgdata", + "type": "volume", + "destination": "/var/lib/postgresql/data" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-lb-1", + "id": "f0d01200b1f88a204c983e37cc078fcc08e54fda9151ca82a3630cd714b2d6f9", + "image": "sha256:5893840576071e6217cd52ebdcc14f454c6f7a631056fa6f4e0f40d3cac4215b", + "limits": { + "Memory": 134217728, + "NanoCpus": 1000000000, + "PortBindings": { + "8080/tcp": [ + { + "HostIp": "127.0.0.1", + "HostPort": "18085" + } + ], + "8404/tcp": [ + { + "HostIp": "127.0.0.1", + "HostPort": "25085" + } + ] + } + }, + "mounts": [] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-s3-1", + "id": "9a7684ef147aace715f79446f6e490b40df0c105f1f4d529f5aef9270540aedb", + "image": "sha256:ed9210d6411d77ffceb70d94b964a3cb7d225983368bc25bebe01e995293dcc2", + "limits": { + "Memory": 536870912, + "NanoCpus": 1000000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [ + { + "name": "mtusi2026lab5_s3data", + "type": "volume", + "destination": "/data" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "/mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1", + "id": "e37f783f9d5014b4f9d96260df10abf1faa26d6373fb6b2487f15340715e9a64", + "image": "sha256:2602ace2be6569bc2bbb06f873776516ab9089821525be34f4305c67eb9db02a", + "limits": { + "Memory": 134217728, + "NanoCpus": 500000000, + "PortBindings": {} + }, + "mounts": [ + { + "name": "mtusi2026lab5_valkeydata", + "type": "volume", + "destination": "/data" + } + ] + } +] diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/scan-secrets.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/scan-secrets.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..43d2014 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/scan-secrets.py @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +import json +import re +import subprocess +from pathlib import Path + +ROOT = Path.cwd() +files = set(subprocess.check_output(['git', 'ls-files', '-z']).decode().split('\0')) - {''} +files.update(str(p) for p in Path('evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07').rglob('*') if p.is_file()) +patterns = { + 'private_key': r'-----BEGIN (?:RSA |EC |OPENSSH )?PRIVATE KEY-----', + 'github_token': r'\b(?:gh[pousr]_[A-Za-z0-9]{30,}|github_pat_[A-Za-z0-9_]{50,})\b', + 'openai_token': r'\bsk-(?:proj-)?[A-Za-z0-9_-]{35,}\b', + 'aws_key': r'\b(?:AKIA|ASIA)[A-Z0-9]{16}\b', + 'telegram_token': r'\b[0-9]{8,12}:[A-Za-z0-9_-]{35}\b', + 'bearer_literal': r'Bearer [A-Za-z0-9_-]{24,}', + 'credential_url': r'\b(?:amqps?|postgres(?:ql)?|redis|https?)://[^\s\"\'{}$<>:/]+:[^\s\"\'{}$<>@/]+@', + 'secret_literal': r'''["'](?:password|secret|token|access_token|secret_access_key)["']\s*:\s*["'][A-Za-z0-9_+/=-]{24,}["']''', +} +allow = { + ('contracts/examples.json', 5, 'secret_literal'): 'unchanged skeleton example placeholder', + ('contracts/openapi.json', 3096, 'secret_literal'): 'unchanged skeleton example placeholder', + ('examples/requests.http', 20, 'secret_literal'): 'unchanged skeleton example placeholder', + ('scripts/broker-secrets.sh', 17, 'credential_url'): 'printf format; no credential literal', + ('student-tests/api/test_operability.py', 131, 'credential_url'): 'synthetic unavailable endpoint u:p', + ('student-tests/api/test_operability.py', 143, 'credential_url'): 'synthetic unavailable endpoint u:p', + ('student-tests/conftest.py', 141, 'credential_url'): 'ephemeral test database literal', +} +findings = [] +for name in sorted(files): + if re.search(r'(^|/)(?:\.env|secrets|volumes)(?:/|$)', name): + findings.append({'file': name, 'rule': 'forbidden_path'}) + try: + text = Path(name).read_text() + except (UnicodeDecodeError, OSError): + continue + for rule, pattern in patterns.items(): + for match in re.finditer(pattern, text): + line = text.count('\n', 0, match.start()) + 1 + item = {'file': name, 'line': line, 'rule': rule} + if (name, line, rule) in allow: + item['reviewed_non_secret'] = allow[name, line, rule] + findings.append(item) +report = {'files_scanned': len(files), 'patterns': list(patterns), 'candidates': findings, 'unresolved': sum('reviewed_non_secret' not in f for f in findings)} +Path('evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json').write_text(json.dumps(report, indent=2) + '\n') +print(json.dumps(report, indent=2)) +raise SystemExit(bool(report['unresolved'])) diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ca2bc84 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +{ + "files_scanned": 739, + "patterns": [ + "private_key", + "github_token", + "openai_token", + "aws_key", + "telegram_token", + "bearer_literal", + "credential_url", + "secret_literal" + ], + "candidates": [ + { + "file": "contracts/examples.json", + "line": 5, + "rule": "secret_literal", + "reviewed_non_secret": "unchanged skeleton example placeholder" + }, + { + "file": "contracts/openapi.json", + "line": 3096, + "rule": "secret_literal", + "reviewed_non_secret": "unchanged skeleton example placeholder" + }, + { + "file": "examples/requests.http", + "line": 20, + "rule": "secret_literal", + "reviewed_non_secret": "unchanged skeleton example placeholder" + }, + { + "file": "scripts/broker-secrets.sh", + "line": 17, + "rule": "credential_url", + "reviewed_non_secret": "printf format; no credential literal" + }, + { + "file": "student-tests/api/test_operability.py", + "line": 131, + "rule": "credential_url", + "reviewed_non_secret": "synthetic unavailable endpoint u:p" + }, + { + "file": "student-tests/api/test_operability.py", + "line": 143, + "rule": "credential_url", + "reviewed_non_secret": "synthetic unavailable endpoint u:p" + }, + { + "file": "student-tests/conftest.py", + "line": 141, + "rule": "credential_url", + "reviewed_non_secret": "ephemeral test database literal" + } + ], + "unresolved": 0 +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/sha256.json b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/sha256.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..12b4f2f --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/sha256.json @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +{ + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py": "0ef9974190761b0226f0c87ba3196f360fa0cb7f9761da14790da0747200b871", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt": "299662f32cd80c0c69e1b4f281b97a38c9d81c44be2501dda6a3be02df692ab8", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted-initial.py": "5ccd725d3d07f82d53b8ee2f7f3614cd22f354891b6c220cb5572f8eb94b64dc", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/audit.json": "6f1202bc4c225513a3cf65f4661f57dff02fa03eb1d3b30e15221096e31b4344", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-containers.txt": "eca334ad0581d40039451984bbd5a294adb3367a605f75366b8dddd946006be4", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/down.txt": "994c14a80ffafc46a7a51b16af856cbfdfe4bc518ade4b0d85a1809ed4cf446f", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt": "5e32c5318af95dd450c8bd7420c8cd87e7c63a54cfef0e87d1e62aeef4b73771", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.py": "e0fd41c717ef20143f9b7433197ec4007c23bcb047a20d6f884eda7ba47735f8", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.json": "6ef2b1a692692d073d5095e308633a57b3f8b77c907ef2a005c3de7405bd03b2", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/recheck-cleanup.py": "d976b607d40be26b2fc9d2ed1a330bc517b099ffce10eff0756629f85ab30a44", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.txt": "ec52bf98f582f1db46a573ab2c8f9097108adb55ec8c5ebab653fb22a45ad216", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage.txt": "03ae2413b4d24ca545fe7118dfbca42e19c787df082085be09b57881e8c6ef3b", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-retry.txt": "d2ce23c775e6b460c16ef30fb9ade683508c05a5cfbf700cb2f8f2b5f30ded47", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-worker.log": "860a8f2c3a41efa2068cd2c0f614c02e605af50b12f13118c0b4f8bba5d0949d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/final-doc-audit.json": "ed0950f9a15a0a42ae8c2165d6189a158561949e7f1347d4ced82fd2ccf4d72b", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/invoke-probe.py": "fb4a472315b5b08fa8b312868241902cb3ca827ca4af8fdaf7aabac57722476d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/runtime-containers.json": "85da009405a52ea1654d6cb396ef9b7a16cd50c37a09888f3ff9c3a358255b4b", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.txt": "bf399ba45062574f2c7295dfb5255cde84065b2c621d34e91c0682c96ce88c8f", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/build.txt": "12dd0f1dcb5aab6a5ef66aa8aa88466f35ed5d4e6b46c01c4048ef269d260d1f", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt": "8089a2eacd964d323f040fabee30988d68287b86bffdfb107b7a231b63b4b914", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-fixtures.txt": "f0e163372b70e3550047572dc5d293c73fb971fcb22e84570983a98d41c21297", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/policy.txt": "f47b54dd4b522870ddd464d62a0076bd4fdd7793506834af83167af4d75738b2", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/running-containers-after.txt": "aea44e7b644394fe4dffc8d50afe64ae3189f9c0d1221530e6320e095ee9bd1b", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.json": "dc6162f26b2aa3ec219c2a323bd38fecb7700e10fc1ac26db3b73c6df56c8442", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks-final.txt": "c3c7720032cb1ddd357056fb5ceffd481d5b918ca2c618570fef2276341713c4", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/probe-copy-script.txt": "b41b5bbc44740bf143c6a7b3ecd0a11b5278be0c7949085c329c124837a1dc31", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.txt": "48191931290985ab5ee3a4f606f5871e751af74d92262d9a95375f845a8e528b", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-limits.json": "ead7292827f5da0bf87e7d2209c5db26738361b61332b5ae2dd1855a3220f89f", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.json": "087921045c843d5ef6b9519ad23ccc4e35fbafa8d0b526fd17b57f2dcc89f2b8", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/delivery-targeted.txt": "ab62360225b4cff3cd99f51abbccd637101699070c4237d672cb198b77a5f9f0", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json": "1bee1d38c4975c2a5b282131de001a7406751e2373ce29908ad49baf64754f83", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md": "4d918715650d58f320e0884b17c1d9e32276f07c741d515f2c10ee5f18c583cc", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/secret-scan.json": "c2ffa9e63666c64f1d2e11fc0058c462636a65db0d4466fcce56750b569cbae9", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/scan-secrets.py": "de87d9de67d0d8addab791b45725b8afe96dfb3bf84fa1d6bec46b7850494e79", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/cleanup-recheck.txt": "238e1c1d2eb739b105f621198c1cce3614d1cbf5f7a01ebaf30a9edbfc84fa93", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/retained-volumes.txt": "dfa358841d4bd6258e01a9d19756596ccfafcc64338a2f1336be41db557ea1ff", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/env.sh": "06cc16c51f3ea5fe5bc703a1c4c44901a1c079a452c4df57e723f0f30f7b666a", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/queues.txt": "269a2934d5b03d25c1028b1677dc7a57b7444bba646ffbb46d374473858cde9e", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe-worker.txt": "d3e1e5cfef280cbaddbd915ffee91a109ddf2e19e7fc4771333b79826b95e587", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.txt": "5c4dc9697e8bbfcfd897375ec346c48ade105bdabc4a068406785eac89056df0", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/historical-hashes.json": "865452375e881103a36f9991388a33ae20ca957718222e474f50778bedca53b7", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/openspec.txt": "87a9b001f1780bca8d822372eb43d8b1b6225b66380a235c573a8c12f235f033", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/checks.txt": "f04184507396267b800955824155b4adc52fc561ca7c4427b195b0a28ef0a78d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/active-changes.txt": "f75e218e916653ad195abc458a187238930ee0cb74b3dff3bceff633f63b3a2f", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/postgres-outage-retry.json": "efd5a60a6d8ac1f0b927f8e4dae35183444c887b12bbc76efc589d4b60b3b608", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt": "f667f89d95ccfc52ac942cae11c2cdd6bfc8d1a192eb9cdf1b24f3ba02a8888d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/image-runtime.txt": "89b07842b945ac8873e6077a51782be7642b9f36e3fc45bacf5e2811ef1bd90d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/resource-probe.py": "5ac1b3087a22ce8c9b0d3e988b78a8c5ae385436ef5b8cdf2ccb57fe1a0a0359", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/png-http.json": "8871e5adc7c030edaf8357807597e8f38045d24ca6e20825e73864392451596d", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/rgb16-40mp.png": "3c4418a6f6a7676298b30b70ebbde9d12929f1345152f4fae979caf5ba1cb3f7", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray4-40mp.png": "64e665928c08ac3721324af4f8e2e9d2e98230dc1be389dde7bbf365650b08cd", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray2-40mp.png": "e1238de6a5be9dbce36abee904f7233f8ff7be59e405b528671940630cce11f6", + "evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/fixtures/gray16-40mp.png": "b59784ae916d50b41b15afa4bdd474a8699f099da55efd53580d3f97180f3800" +} diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5811fcf --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/smoke.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:17:56Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ make test +python3 tests/smoke.py --base-url "http://127.0.0.1:18085" +PASS: lab5 public API scenario; infrastructure and grading evidence remain separate. +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 1.723 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bc486ec --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/stopped-containers.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:27:02Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker ps -a --filter label=com.docker.compose.project=mtusi2026lab5 --format '{{.Names}} {{.Status}}' +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 0.020 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..16c9329 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/student-test.txt @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:15:34Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ make student-test 'PYTEST_ARGS=-q --tb=short' +.venv/bin/pytest -q --tb=short +........................................................................ [ 7%] +........................................................................ [ 14%] +........................................................................ [ 22%] +........................................................................ [ 29%] +........................................................................ [ 36%] +........................................................................ [ 44%] +........................................................................ [ 51%] +........................................................................ [ 58%] +........................................................................ [ 66%] +........................................................................ [ 73%] +........................................................................ [ 80%] +........................................................................ [ 88%] +.................................................................s...... [ 95%] +............................................. [100%] +980 passed, 1 skipped, 19 deselected in 180.75s (0:03:00) +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 182.490 diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted-initial.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted-initial.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bec906c --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted-initial.py @@ -0,0 +1,177 @@ +import hashlib +import json +import os +import struct +import sys +import time +import zlib +from io import BytesIO +from pathlib import Path + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] +sys.path[:0] = [str(ROOT / 'scripts'), str(ROOT / 'student-tests')] +import pipeline_suite as ps +from PIL import Image +from messenger.attachments.infrastructure.images import RenderLimits, render_variants +from pictures import SIGNATURE, chunk +from png_trns_fixtures import png_with_trns + +MODE = sys.argv.pop(1) +OUT = Path(__file__).parent / (MODE + '.json') +if OUT.exists(): + raise SystemExit('Result exists; do not repeat completed evidence') +SUITE = ps.Suite(ps.arguments()) +STACK = SUITE.stack +REPORT = {'mode': MODE, 'source_sha': ps.run(['git', 'rev-parse', 'HEAD']).strip(), 'started_at': ps.now(), 'cases': []} +LIMITS = RenderLimits(10485760, 40000000) + + +def save(): + OUT.write_text(json.dumps(REPORT, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + '\n') + + +def case(name, function): + row = {'name': name, 'started_at': ps.now()} + REPORT['cases'].append(row) + save() + began = time.monotonic() + try: + row['observed'] = function() + row['result'] = 'PASS' + except Exception as error: + row.update(result='FAIL', error=str(error)) + row['elapsed_seconds'] = round(time.monotonic() - began, 3) + save() + print(name, row['result'], row.get('error', ''), flush=True) + + +def containers(): + return STACK.dc('ps', '-a', '--format', '{{.Name}} {{.ID}} {{.State}} {{.Status}}').splitlines() + + +def outage(): + SUITE.drained() + before_dlq = STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ] + STACK.stop('worker') + att = SUITE.api.fixture() + ident = att['id'] + ps.poll(lambda: all(r['published'] for r in STACK.sql('outbox', id=ident)), 30, 'published outbox') + jobs = STACK.sql('jobs', id=ident) + REPORT['outage_checkpoint'] = {'attachment_id': ident, 'jobs_before': jobs, 'dlq_before': before_dlq} + save() + STACK.stop('postgres') + REPORT['outage_checkpoint']['stopped_containers'] = containers() + save() + since = ps.now() + STACK.dc('start', 'worker') + def requeues(): + logs = STACK.dc('logs', '--no-color', '--since', since, 'worker') + rows = [line for line in logs.splitlines() if 'job.requeued' in line and jobs[0]['job_id'] in line] + return rows if len(rows) >= 12 else None + try: + lines = ps.poll(requeues, 90, '12 real database failures', 1) + Path(__file__).with_name('postgres-outage-worker.log').write_text('\n'.join(lines) + '\n') + during = STACK.queues() + finally: + STACK.up('postgres') + ps.poll(lambda: ps.http_ready(SUITE.args.base_url), 30, 'API after PostgreSQL') + ready = SUITE.api.wait(ident) + SUITE.verify(ready) + SUITE.drained() + after = STACK.sql('jobs', id=ident) + assert after[0]['job_id'] == jobs[0]['job_id'] and after[0]['attempt'] == jobs[0]['attempt'] == 1 + assert after[0]['status'] == 'done' + assert STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ] == before_dlq + assert len(STACK.sql('variants', id=ident)) == 3 + return {'attachment_id': ident, 'jobs_before': jobs, 'jobs_after': after, 'requeues': len(lines), 'queues_during': during, 'queues_after': STACK.queues(), 'replay': False, 'stopped_containers': REPORT['outage_checkpoint']['stopped_containers']} + + +def png(name, data, reference): + att = SUITE.api.upload(data, name=name + '.png') + ident = att['id'] + results = [] + for version in (1, 2): + if version == 2: + STACK.admin('reprocess', '--attachment-id', ident, '--pipeline-version', '2') + ps.poll(lambda: SUITE.record(ident)['published_version'] == 2, 90, 'published v2') + ready = SUITE.api.wait(ident) + SUITE.verify(ready) + assert SUITE.api.content(ident)['bytes'] == data + expected = {r.name: r for r in render_variants(reference, LIMITS, version)} + variants = [] + for variant in ready['variants']: + content = SUITE.api.content(ident, variant['name'])['bytes'] + assert content == expected[variant['name']].data, variant['name'] + ' differs from independent white reference' + with Image.open(BytesIO(content)) as image: + assert not image.getexif() + assert not any(key in image.info for key in ('icc_profile', 'xmp', 'transparency')) + variants.append({'name': variant['name'], 'sha256': hashlib.sha256(content).hexdigest(), 'bytes': len(content), 'dimensions': [variant['width'], variant['height']]}) + results.append({'version': version, 'variants': variants}) + before = SUITE.snapshot(ident) + STACK.publish(SUITE.payload(ident, 1)) + STACK.publish(SUITE.payload(ident, 2)) + SUITE.drained() + assert SUITE.snapshot(ident) == before + assert len(STACK.sql('variants', id=ident)) == 6 + return {'attachment_id': ident, 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'input_bytes': len(data), 'versions': results, 'stale_and_duplicate_noop': True} + + +def large_png(depth, rgb): + transparent = (12345, 23456, 34567) if rgb else (1 if depth < 16 else 12345,) + neighbor = (transparent[0] + 1, *transparent[1:]) + def block(pixel): + if depth < 8: + value = sum(pixel[0] << shift for shift in range(0, 8, depth)) + return bytes([value]) * (4000 * depth // 8) + return b''.join(v.to_bytes(depth // 8, 'big') for v in pixel) * 4000 + row = b'\0' + block(transparent) + block(neighbor) + compressor = zlib.compressobj() + compressed = b''.join(compressor.compress(row) for _ in range(5000)) + compressor.flush() + return SIGNATURE + chunk(b'IHDR', struct.pack('>IIBBBBB', 8000, 5000, depth, 2 if rgb else 0, 0, 0, 0)) + chunk(b'tRNS', b''.join(v.to_bytes(2, 'big') for v in transparent)) + chunk(b'IDAT', compressed) + chunk(b'IEND', b'') + + +def large(name, data): + assert len(data) < LIMITS.max_bytes + att = SUITE.api.upload(data, name=name + '.png', final=('ready', 'failed')) + ready = SUITE.api.wait(att['id'], ('ready', 'failed')) + row = {'attachment_id': att['id'], 'input_bytes': len(data), 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'pixels': 40000000, 'status': ready['status'], 'error_code': ready['error_code'], 'jobs': STACK.sql('jobs', id=att['id']), 'memory_peak': STACK.cgroup('worker', 'memory.peak'), 'memory_max': STACK.cgroup('worker', 'memory.max')} + REPORT['large_observations'] = REPORT.get('large_observations', []) + [row] + save() + assert ready['status'] == 'ready', json.dumps(row) + SUITE.verify(ready) + assert int(row['memory_peak']) < int(row['memory_max']) + return row + + +try: + SUITE.detect_api() + SUITE.api = ps.Api(SUITE.args) + dead_before = STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ][0] + REPORT['conditions'] = {'host_load': os.getloadavg(), 'containers': containers(), 'running': ps.run(['docker', 'ps', '--format', '{{.Names}} {{.Status}}']), 'worker_limits': STACK.dc('exec', '-T', 'worker', 'printenv', 'RENDER_MEMORY_MB', 'RENDER_TIMEOUT_SECONDS', 'WORKER_CONCURRENCY')} + save() + if MODE == 'postgres-outage': + case('published_outbox_database_outage', outage) + elif MODE == 'png-http': + folder = ROOT / 'evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/fixtures' + for name in ('gray2', 'gray4', 'rgb16'): + case(name, lambda name=name: png(name, (folder / (name + '.png')).read_bytes(), (folder / (name + '-white.png')).read_bytes())) + for name, depth, color in [('gray1', 1, (0,)), ('gray8', 8, (85,)), ('gray16', 16, (12345,)), ('rgb8', 8, (255, 0, 0))]: + case(name, lambda name=name, depth=depth, color=color: png(name, *png_with_trns(depth, color))) + case('rgb16-adam7-filter4-exif6', lambda: png('adam7', *png_with_trns(16, (12345, 23456, 34567), size=(65, 63), interlace=1, filtering=4, orientation=6))) + elif MODE == 'png-limits': + for name, depth, rgb in [('gray2-40mp', 2, False), ('gray4-40mp', 4, False), ('gray16-40mp', 16, False), ('rgb16-40mp', 16, True)]: + case(name, lambda name=name, depth=depth, rgb=rgb: large(name, large_png(depth, rgb))) + data = large_png(16, True) + case('forced-timeout', lambda: SUITE.limited(data, FAULT_RENDER_TIMEOUT_SECONDS='0.01')) + case('forced-memory', lambda: SUITE.limited(data, FAULT_RENDER_MEMORY_MB='200')) + STACK.restore() + case('normal-after-limits', SUITE.smoke_pipeline) + REPORT['invariants'] = SUITE.invariants(dead_before) +finally: + STACK.up('postgres') + STACK.restore() + REPORT['accepted_ids'] = SUITE.api.accepted if SUITE.api else [] + REPORT['finished_at'] = ps.now() + REPORT['result'] = 'PASS' if REPORT['cases'] and all(x.get('result') == 'PASS' for x in REPORT['cases'] + REPORT.get('invariants', [])) else 'FAIL' + save() +raise SystemExit(0 if REPORT['result'] == 'PASS' else 1) diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000..970081a --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/targeted.py @@ -0,0 +1,179 @@ +import hashlib +import json +import os +import struct +import sys +import time +import zlib +from io import BytesIO +from pathlib import Path + +ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2] +sys.path[:0] = [str(ROOT / 'scripts'), str(ROOT / 'student-tests')] +import pipeline_suite as ps +from PIL import Image +from messenger.attachments.infrastructure.images import RenderLimits, render_variants +from pictures import SIGNATURE, chunk +from png_trns_fixtures import png_with_trns + +MODE = sys.argv.pop(1) +OUT = Path(__file__).parent / (MODE + '.json') +if OUT.exists(): + raise SystemExit('Result exists; do not repeat completed evidence') +SUITE = ps.Suite(ps.arguments()) +STACK = SUITE.stack +REPORT = {'mode': MODE, 'source_sha': ps.run(['git', 'rev-parse', 'HEAD']).strip(), 'started_at': ps.now(), 'cases': []} +LIMITS = RenderLimits(10485760, 40000000) + + +def save(): + OUT.write_text(json.dumps(REPORT, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + '\n') + + +def case(name, function): + row = {'name': name, 'started_at': ps.now()} + REPORT['cases'].append(row) + save() + began = time.monotonic() + try: + row['observed'] = function() + row['result'] = 'PASS' + except Exception as error: + row.update(result='FAIL', error=str(error)) + row['elapsed_seconds'] = round(time.monotonic() - began, 3) + save() + print(name, row['result'], row.get('error', ''), flush=True) + + +def containers(): + return STACK.dc('ps', '-a', '--format', '{{.Name}} {{.ID}} {{.State}} {{.Status}}').splitlines() + + +def outage(): + SUITE.drained() + before_dlq = STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ] + STACK.stop('worker') + att = SUITE.api.fixture() + ident = att['id'] + ps.poll(lambda: all(r['published'] for r in STACK.sql('outbox', id=ident)), 30, 'published outbox') + jobs = STACK.sql('jobs', id=ident) + REPORT['outage_checkpoint'] = {'attachment_id': ident, 'jobs_before': jobs, 'dlq_before': before_dlq} + save() + STACK.stop('postgres') + REPORT['outage_checkpoint']['stopped_containers'] = containers() + save() + since = ps.now() + worker_id = STACK.dc('ps', '-aq', 'worker').strip() + assert worker_id + ps.run(['docker', 'start', worker_id]) + def requeues(): + logs = STACK.dc('logs', '--no-color', '--since', since, 'worker') + rows = [line for line in logs.splitlines() if 'job.requeued' in line and jobs[0]['job_id'] in line] + return rows if len(rows) >= 12 else None + try: + lines = ps.poll(requeues, 90, '12 real database failures', 1) + Path(__file__).with_name('postgres-outage-worker.log').write_text('\n'.join(lines) + '\n') + during = STACK.queues() + finally: + STACK.up('postgres') + ps.poll(lambda: ps.http_ready(SUITE.args.base_url), 30, 'API after PostgreSQL') + ready = SUITE.api.wait(ident) + SUITE.verify(ready) + SUITE.drained() + after = STACK.sql('jobs', id=ident) + assert after[0]['job_id'] == jobs[0]['job_id'] and after[0]['attempt'] == jobs[0]['attempt'] == 1 + assert after[0]['status'] == 'done' + assert STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ] == before_dlq + assert len(STACK.sql('variants', id=ident)) == 3 + return {'attachment_id': ident, 'jobs_before': jobs, 'jobs_after': after, 'requeues': len(lines), 'queues_during': during, 'queues_after': STACK.queues(), 'replay': False, 'stopped_containers': REPORT['outage_checkpoint']['stopped_containers']} + + +def png(name, data, reference): + att = SUITE.api.upload(data, name=name + '.png') + ident = att['id'] + results = [] + for version in (1, 2): + if version == 2: + STACK.admin('reprocess', '--attachment-id', ident, '--pipeline-version', '2') + ps.poll(lambda: SUITE.record(ident)['published_version'] == 2, 90, 'published v2') + ready = SUITE.api.wait(ident) + SUITE.verify(ready) + assert SUITE.api.content(ident)['bytes'] == data + expected = {r.name: r for r in render_variants(reference, LIMITS, version)} + variants = [] + for variant in ready['variants']: + content = SUITE.api.content(ident, variant['name'])['bytes'] + assert content == expected[variant['name']].data, variant['name'] + ' differs from independent white reference' + with Image.open(BytesIO(content)) as image: + assert not image.getexif() + assert not any(key in image.info for key in ('icc_profile', 'xmp', 'transparency')) + variants.append({'name': variant['name'], 'sha256': hashlib.sha256(content).hexdigest(), 'bytes': len(content), 'dimensions': [variant['width'], variant['height']]}) + results.append({'version': version, 'variants': variants}) + before = SUITE.snapshot(ident) + STACK.publish(SUITE.payload(ident, 1)) + STACK.publish(SUITE.payload(ident, 2)) + SUITE.drained() + assert SUITE.snapshot(ident) == before + assert len(STACK.sql('variants', id=ident)) == 6 + return {'attachment_id': ident, 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'input_bytes': len(data), 'versions': results, 'stale_and_duplicate_noop': True} + + +def large_png(depth, rgb): + transparent = (12345, 23456, 34567) if rgb else (1 if depth < 16 else 12345,) + neighbor = (transparent[0] + 1, *transparent[1:]) + def block(pixel): + if depth < 8: + value = sum(pixel[0] << shift for shift in range(0, 8, depth)) + return bytes([value]) * (4000 * depth // 8) + return b''.join(v.to_bytes(depth // 8, 'big') for v in pixel) * 4000 + row = b'\0' + block(transparent) + block(neighbor) + compressor = zlib.compressobj() + compressed = b''.join(compressor.compress(row) for _ in range(5000)) + compressor.flush() + return SIGNATURE + chunk(b'IHDR', struct.pack('>IIBBBBB', 8000, 5000, depth, 2 if rgb else 0, 0, 0, 0)) + chunk(b'tRNS', b''.join(v.to_bytes(2, 'big') for v in transparent)) + chunk(b'IDAT', compressed) + chunk(b'IEND', b'') + + +def large(name, data): + assert len(data) < LIMITS.max_bytes + att = SUITE.api.upload(data, name=name + '.png', final=('ready', 'failed')) + ready = SUITE.api.wait(att['id'], ('ready', 'failed')) + row = {'attachment_id': att['id'], 'input_bytes': len(data), 'input_sha256': hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest(), 'pixels': 40000000, 'status': ready['status'], 'error_code': ready['error_code'], 'jobs': STACK.sql('jobs', id=att['id']), 'memory_peak': STACK.cgroup('worker', 'memory.peak'), 'memory_max': STACK.cgroup('worker', 'memory.max')} + REPORT['large_observations'] = REPORT.get('large_observations', []) + [row] + save() + assert ready['status'] == 'ready', json.dumps(row) + SUITE.verify(ready) + assert int(row['memory_peak']) < int(row['memory_max']) + return row + + +try: + SUITE.detect_api() + SUITE.api = ps.Api(SUITE.args) + dead_before = STACK.queues()[ps.DLQ][0] + REPORT['conditions'] = {'host_load': os.getloadavg(), 'containers': containers(), 'running': ps.run(['docker', 'ps', '--format', '{{.Names}} {{.Status}}']), 'worker_limits': STACK.dc('exec', '-T', 'worker', 'printenv', 'RENDER_MEMORY_MB', 'RENDER_TIMEOUT_SECONDS', 'WORKER_CONCURRENCY')} + save() + if MODE.startswith('postgres-outage'): + case('published_outbox_database_outage', outage) + elif MODE == 'png-http': + folder = ROOT / 'evidence/review-trns-depth-2026-11-06/fixtures' + for name in ('gray2', 'gray4', 'rgb16'): + case(name, lambda name=name: png(name, (folder / (name + '.png')).read_bytes(), (folder / (name + '-white.png')).read_bytes())) + for name, depth, color in [('gray1', 1, (0,)), ('gray8', 8, (85,)), ('gray16', 16, (12345,)), ('rgb8', 8, (255, 0, 0))]: + case(name, lambda name=name, depth=depth, color=color: png(name, *png_with_trns(depth, color))) + case('rgb16-adam7-filter4-exif6', lambda: png('adam7', *png_with_trns(16, (12345, 23456, 34567), size=(65, 63), interlace=1, filtering=4, orientation=6))) + elif MODE == 'png-limits': + for name, depth, rgb in [('gray2-40mp', 2, False), ('gray4-40mp', 4, False), ('gray16-40mp', 16, False), ('rgb16-40mp', 16, True)]: + case(name, lambda name=name, depth=depth, rgb=rgb: large(name, large_png(depth, rgb))) + data = large_png(16, True) + case('forced-timeout', lambda: SUITE.limited(data, FAULT_RENDER_TIMEOUT_SECONDS='0.01')) + case('forced-memory', lambda: SUITE.limited(data, FAULT_RENDER_MEMORY_MB='200')) + STACK.restore() + case('normal-after-limits', SUITE.smoke_pipeline) + REPORT['invariants'] = SUITE.invariants(dead_before) +finally: + STACK.up('postgres') + STACK.restore() + REPORT['accepted_ids'] = SUITE.api.accepted if SUITE.api else [] + REPORT['finished_at'] = ps.now() + REPORT['result'] = 'PASS' if REPORT['cases'] and all(x.get('result') == 'PASS' for x in REPORT['cases'] + REPORT.get('invariants', [])) else 'FAIL' + save() +raise SystemExit(0 if REPORT['result'] == 'PASS' else 1) diff --git a/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bf99f14 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/final-validation-2026-11-07/up.txt @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +date: 2026-11-06T21:16:39Z commit: b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef +environment: {"COMPOSE_PROJECT_NAME": "mtusi2026lab5", "COMPOSE_FILE": "compose.yaml", "LB_HTTP_PORT": "18085", "LB_STATS_PORT": "25085", "BASE_URL": "http://127.0.0.1:18085", "NO_PROXY": "localhost,127.0.0.1,::1", "API_IMAGE": "mtusi-messenger:lab5-validation"} +$ docker compose up -d --wait + Network mtusi2026lab5_backend Creating + Network mtusi2026lab5_backend Created + Network mtusi2026lab5_edge Creating + Network mtusi2026lab5_edge Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Creating + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Created + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Starting + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Started + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Waiting + Container mtusi2026lab5-valkey-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-migrate-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-init-1 Exited + Container mtusi2026lab5-postgres-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-s3-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-broker-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-api-2 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-worker-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-relay-1 Healthy + Container mtusi2026lab5-lb-1 Healthy +exit_code: 0 elapsed_seconds: 10.322 diff --git a/evidence/load-validation.md b/evidence/load-validation.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..67d7b22 --- /dev/null +++ b/evidence/load-validation.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +# Аудит применимости измерений ЛР5 + +Фаза validation, 2026-11-07. Исходный HEAD `b30e2f6a84419d1ca64525ffb40df92183cccaef`, runtime прошёл review на `42575281b352d35bda17ee7601bae5548a996e91` (R). Diff R → HEAD содержит только REPORT, AGENTS и два документа evidence. Реализация в этой фазе не меняется; push запрещён. + +Выбран трек 2 README — идемпотентность pipeline. Матрица throughput/prefetch и SLO относятся к невыбранному треку 1; новые SLO не вводятся. + +## Принятые серии + +Основная база D: `0e921116610d289716af0a40ec823376eb8bbcbc`, каталог [forward-final-2026-11-06](forward-final-2026-11-06/RESULTS.md). + +| Серия | Решение и основание | +| --- | --- | +| Track run1/2/3: по 13 сценариев, 8 инвариантов, 13 ID, 58 объектов | Принимаются функциональные результаты всех трёх повторов. Все обязательные повторы уже выполнены. SQL/outbox/lease/fencing/versioning не изменены. Старый sample PNG входит в побайтную проверку совместимости renderer. Влияние новой policy проверяется адресно. Полный track2 повторно не запускается. | +| Level4: 17 сценариев, 8 инвариантов, 33 ID, 116 объектов | Принимаются незатронутые результаты; адресно дополняются delivery/ack/retry и новые PNG. | +| Smoke/persistence/failover | Принимаются сохранность данных, сессий и отказ реплики: их реализация и конфигурация не менялись. Новый smoke служит проверкой собранного стенда. Полные persistence/failover повторно не запускаются. | +| Network regressions, upload-negative, cache-outage, HAProxy errors | Принимаются: входная валидация, кэш и LB не менялись. | +| 819 student tests / 1 skip | Исторический результат D. Полный набор запускается на R для новых регрессий и real-broker тестов. | +| 430 offline + 20 boundaries, 114 идентичных вариантов | Принимаются для R; не заменяют HTTP/Linux и реальный отказ PostgreSQL. | + +Условия D: Darwin arm64, Docker 28.3.2, 16 CPU / 8 217 190 400 байт VM RAM; основной изолированный project `mtusi2026lab5`, API 18085, stats/UI 25085/25086. Compose, Dockerfile и uv.lock не изменены. API ×2 по 1 CPU/512 MiB; worker 2 CPU/1 GiB, concurrency/prefetch=2, renderer 448 MiB/30 с. Fault override: lease 5 с, stall 15 с, backoff 1 с, poll 0.5 с. Синтетический dataset: sample 320×200, матрица 26 изображений, 40 Мп fixture. Volumes сохранялись. Срезы условий не показывают других работающих проектов, но непрерывного контроля нагрузки хоста нет. + +Run2/3 имеют несогласованные UTC/elapsed: функциональный результат сохранён, время исключено из performance-выводов. Повторять корректные сценарии из-за неприменимого времени не требуется. Старые корневые evidence до SQLAlchemy, промежуточные FAIL и прерванные серии не используются как PASS. + +## Недостающие и затронутые проверки + +1. RabbitMQ 4.1.8: применение policy на сохранённом volume; настоящий отказ PostgreSQL после опубликованного outbox, >10 nack, ready без replay, неизменные job/attempt/DLQ. +2. HTTP tRNS grayscale/RGB разных глубин, точный сосед RGB16, Adam7/filter/EXIF, v1/v2 и повтор старой job. Linux 40 Мп, штатные и принудительные лимиты, последующее обычное задание. +3. Адресная suite: duplicate/reorder/fencing, COMMIT/ack, malformed/DLQ, retry-exhaustion/replay. Причина — изменённая policy доставки; весь baseline и три track2 повтора не повторяются. +4. Текущие check/validate/lint/student-test, OpenSpec, SHA и отсутствие секретов в tracked файлах. + +Результаты и команды этой фазы сохраняются в `final-validation-2026-11-07/`. Завершённые результаты не перезаписываются. Итог: **validation blocked, 1 major** — четыре 40 Мп PNG tRNS не достигают ready при штатном лимите памяти. Подробности и завершённые проверки — [RESULTS](final-validation-2026-11-07/RESULTS.md), [findings](final-validation-2026-11-07/findings.json). Runtime не изменён, публикация запрещена. Повторять после fix только ресурсные/tRNS проверки и сценарии, которые затронет фактический diff. + + +## Итог адресной квалификации + +- Реальный PostgreSQL outage: 12 nack/requeue, восстановление без replay, job/attempt/DLQ сохранены; 8 инвариантов PASS. +- HTTP PNG: 8 fixtures, 48 сравнений вариантов v1/v2 с независимым эталоном, stale/duplicate noop; 8 инвариантов PASS. +- Delivery subset: 12 сценариев, 8 инвариантов, 11 ID / 47 объектов PASS. Одна новая запись DLQ ожидаема от malformed message. +- Linux 40 Мп tRNS: 4 FAIL (processing_failed); принудительные лимиты и последующая обычная работа PASS. MemoryError подтверждён отдельным пробником. Эти результаты не заменяют PASS старого обычного PNG 40 Мп и не позволяют обещать готовность новых путей на границе. +- Check/validate/lint PASS; student-test 980 passed / 1 Linux-only skip; OpenSpec 22 PASS, changes=[]; 64 исторических хеша сверены. Код и нормативные файлы неизменны. + +Сохранены также непригодный первый outage (обвязка автоматически запустила БД), неуспешный docker cp диагностических файлов и ранний no_orphans до sweep. Повторён только неверно выполненный outage, перенос пробника и read-only проверка cleanup; результаты успешных серий не перезаписывались. Диагностика памяти повторяет только выявленные неуспешные пути, чтобы установить причину.